Demon Slayer Speed Overhaul

[KnyRaizn]

I'll agree too.

 

[Passersby]

This thing is still ongoing?

Been a while, saw the new segments, I agree

 

[Machmatej]

I agree with the scaling from Slasher, too.

 

[GarrixianXD]

Looks like there is a shit-load of discussion that occurred, and I was called out to evaluate this. Can someone give me a summary of arguments of both sides?

 

[Epyriel]

Looks like there is a shit-load of discussion that occurred, and I was called out to evaluate this. Can someone give me a summary of arguments of both sides?

The main point of discussion was for the section on Tanjiro’s Flowing Dance calc, which has since been rejected as an outlier and replaced.

Other than that, there was some brief discussion about a possible anti-feat from the emotion clones in SSV getting hit by Genya’s bullet sprays, in which one person argue that since Aizetsu was being told to hurry up and kill Genya by Sekido, the fact he then gets hit by a bullet spray should cap their speed.

The consensus was largely against this due to the fact that the emotion clones wanted to get hit in order to split into more clones, and would later casually block these bullet sprays in two other instances at close range. While Sekido may be impatient in line with his nature, Aizetsu clearly was not. Not to mention the fact that Genya’s gun could quite realistically shoot faster than mundane weaponry due to the fact he was explicitly prepared to go and hunt Kizuki to get promoted, and the Demon Slayer Crops has access to special gun power with special properties that can specifically hurt demons, while the gun itself was made out of the fictional material of scarlet iron.

One person had a rebuttal specifically on the point of the gun wouldn’t be able to use the special powder seen with Tengen because the explosions are too large, to which I responded that like all real world munitions there is the simple solution of reducing the amount of powder used, as the volume of powder reduces cubically with radius thus quickly shrinking its explosive power with a small reduction in capsule size.

Armorchompy had a concern specifically with the Tengen explosive calc, in which he maintains that the ignition time must first be taken into account. However I’m pretty sure he just misunderstood how the calculation was being performed as the ignition time is specifically what is actually being used as a timeframe. A full explanation for this can be found here.

 

[GarrixianXD]

The main point of discussion was for the section on Tanjiro’s Flowing Dance calc, which has since been rejected as an outlier and replaced.

Other than that, there was some brief discussion about a possible anti-feat from the emotion clones in SSV getting hit by Genya’s bullet sprays, in which one person argue that since Aizetsu was being told to hurry up and kill Genya by Sekido, the fact he then gets hit by a bullet spray should cap their speed.

The consensus was largely against this due to the fact that the emotion clones wanted to get hit in order to split into more clones, and would later casually block these bullet sprays in two other instances at close range. While Sekido may be impatient in line with his nature, Aizetsu clearly was not. Not to mention the fact that Genya’s gun could quite realistically shoot faster than mundane weaponry due to the fact he was explicitly prepared to go and hunt Kizuki to get promoted, and the Demon Slayer Crops has access to special gun power with special properties that can specifically hurt demons, while the gun itself was made out of the fictional material of scarlet iron.

One person had a rebuttal specifically on the point of the gun wouldn’t be able to use the special powder seen with Tengen because the explosions are too large, to which I responded that like all real world munitions there is the simple solution of reducing the amount of powder used, as the volume of powder reduces cubically with radius thus quickly shrinking its explosive power with a small reduction in capsule size.

Armorchompy had a concern specifically with the Tengen explosive calc, in which he maintains that the ignition time must first be taken into account. However I’m pretty sure he just misunderstood how the calculation was being performed as the ignition time is specifically what is actually being used as a timeframe. A full explanation for this can be found here.

I guess it's fine.

 

[Epyriel]

With now a second staff vote in favour of 3 of the 5 sections, I am going to go ahead and implement the changes for these parts.

Just one more vote needed for the remaining two sections to close out this thread.