• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

DC Heralds rescaling thread

Didn't you already have several suggestions for his tiering? Would you mind placing them here?

Sure. Lemme copy paste it:

Attack Potency: Varies (Conner has a strong no-Kill rule and holds back.[65][20][18] In addition, his powers require his force of will[37]) Usually Moon level (Was designed to be as close to Pre-Death Superman as possible[4], his Tactile Telekinesis derived stats are stated to be "Superman-Level[66]" Hurts Martian Manhunter possessed by Despero, and again[67], hurts Pre-Circle of Fire Kyle Rayner through his shield[68], Stronger than Cassie Sandsmark Wonder Girl, as per Harm[69], Stalemates M'onel[70] who was stated to be stronger than Pre-Death Superman[71][72], hurts Knockout[73][18][74][35], who is stronger than him[73][75] [18]), Low Multiverse level at peak (Fought and hurt Black Zero[76] who could overpower Pre-Crisis Krypto[77] and Superboy[76]. Rips down a door built to restrain Doomsday[78]) || Varies (Has gained Kryptonian powers and is stronger than before[79][80][81][45][39][40][66][41][39][82] Superboy holds back[83][84][56],) Usually Galaxy level ( Oneshots full Kryptonians and overpowers and defeats a bloodlusted Alura In-Zee, Supergirl's mother[85], Fought Kingdom Come Superman, though he eventually loses after being convinced to lose[86], Had the advantage on Match[54] who defeated Ultraman[50], Drew blood from Superman[87] Fought Gog, who hurt Superman, and even hurt him[88], staggered Brainac with his blows[89]) Low Multiverse level at his peak (Stalemates Orion[90] Hurts a young Darkseid[91], In the second fight with Superboy-Prime A motivated Conner draws blood from him and trades blows with him[92]. In their third battle, Conner fights near-equally with Prime[93]. A brainwashed Conner broke out of the hold of and overpowered Power Girl and Supergirl.[94], Blows up Black Lantern Kal-L[82] Conner is stated to be able to “do everything Superman can do”[39])

Speed: MFTL+ (Dodged an attack from an Imperiex Probe[95], Kept pace with Impulse[96]) || MFTL+: (Kept up with Supergirl[97], Kept up with Bart Allen in a race[98], could react to Kingdom Come Flash[46], Claims to be as fast as Impulse[99] Likely is as fast as any Kryptonian since he can "do everything Superman can do")

Lifting Strength: varies, up to Class G (lifted a large palace[100]) | Varies up to Stellar at peak (Scales to other kryptonians, who are comparable to Lobo)

Striking Strength: Varies Usually Moon level, Low Multiverse level at peak (could hurt M'onel, Pre-Circle of Fire Kyle Rayner, Knockout and Martian Manhunter with his strikes, at his peak he can hurt Black Zero) | Varies, usually Galaxy level, Low Multiverse level at Peak (Can oneshot Kryptonians, fought Kingdom Come Superman and hurt him, drew blood from a holding back Superman, hurt Brainiac with his strikes. At his peak, he can fight and hurt Superboy-Prime, Orion, and Darkseid)

Durability: Varies from Moon level (Can take blows from people in his tier. Aquaman can’t hurt him and had to drown and weaken him later in the same comic to effect him, with Superboy getting right back up[101], Took hits from Match[102], took hits from Despero possessing Martian Manhunter[67], ) Up to Low Multiverse level (Takes a beating from Cyborg Superman directly after witnessing him murder a blimp of people with Cyborg Superman being impressed with his durability[103] takes a beating from Pre-Crisis/Pocket Universe Superboy[104] || Varies from Galaxy level (took hits from Brainiac[89], took hits from Kingdom Come Superman and Kingdom Come Flash[86],) to Low Multiverse level at peak Takes an extended beating from Gog[88] A depressed Conner takes a beating from the Eradicator [105], (A depressed Conner is beaten nearly to death by Superboy-Prime[106][107], but in his rematches,[92] takes his attacks far better.[93], took hits from Black Lantern Kal-L[87][82])
 
Sure. Lemme copy paste it:

Attack Potency: Varies (Conner has a strong no-Kill rule and holds back.[65][20][18] In addition, his powers require his force of will[37]) Usually Moon level (Was designed to be as close to Pre-Death Superman as possible[4], his Tactile Telekinesis derived stats are stated to be "Superman-Level[66]" Hurts Martian Manhunter possessed by Despero, and again[67], hurts Pre-Circle of Fire Kyle Rayner through his shield[68], Stronger than Cassie Sandsmark Wonder Girl, as per Harm[69], Stalemates M'onel[70] who was stated to be stronger than Pre-Death Superman[71][72], hurts Knockout[73][18][74][35], who is stronger than him[73][75] [18]), Low Multiverse level at peak (Fought and hurt Black Zero[76] who could overpower Pre-Crisis Krypto[77] and Superboy[76]. Rips down a door built to restrain Doomsday[78]) || Varies (Has gained Kryptonian powers and is stronger than before[79][80][81][45][39][40][66][41][39][82] Superboy holds back[83][84][56],) Usually Galaxy level ( Oneshots full Kryptonians and overpowers and defeats a bloodlusted Alura In-Zee, Supergirl's mother[85], Fought Kingdom Come Superman, though he eventually loses after being convinced to lose[86], Had the advantage on Match[54] who defeated Ultraman[50], Drew blood from Superman[87] Fought Gog, who hurt Superman, and even hurt him[88], staggered Brainac with his blows[89]) Low Multiverse level at his peak (Stalemates Orion[90] Hurts a young Darkseid[91], In the second fight with Superboy-Prime A motivated Conner draws blood from him and trades blows with him[92]. In their third battle, Conner fights near-equally with Prime[93]. A brainwashed Conner broke out of the hold of and overpowered Power Girl and Supergirl.[94], Blows up Black Lantern Kal-L[82] Conner is stated to be able to “do everything Superman can do”[39])

Speed: MFTL+ (Dodged an attack from an Imperiex Probe[95], Kept pace with Impulse[96]) || MFTL+: (Kept up with Supergirl[97], Kept up with Bart Allen in a race[98], could react to Kingdom Come Flash[46], Claims to be as fast as Impulse[99] Likely is as fast as any Kryptonian since he can "do everything Superman can do")

Lifting Strength: varies, up to Class G (lifted a large palace[100]) | Varies up to Stellar at peak (Scales to other kryptonians, who are comparable to Lobo)

Striking Strength: Varies Usually Moon level, Low Multiverse level at peak (could hurt M'onel, Pre-Circle of Fire Kyle Rayner, Knockout and Martian Manhunter with his strikes, at his peak he can hurt Black Zero) | Varies, usually Galaxy level, Low Multiverse level at Peak (Can oneshot Kryptonians, fought Kingdom Come Superman and hurt him, drew blood from a holding back Superman, hurt Brainiac with his strikes. At his peak, he can fight and hurt Superboy-Prime, Orion, and Darkseid)

Durability: Varies from Moon level (Can take blows from people in his tier. Aquaman can’t hurt him and had to drown and weaken him later in the same comic to effect him, with Superboy getting right back up[101], Took hits from Match[102], took hits from Despero possessing Martian Manhunter[67], ) Up to Low Multiverse level (Takes a beating from Cyborg Superman directly after witnessing him murder a blimp of people with Cyborg Superman being impressed with his durability[103] takes a beating from Pre-Crisis/Pocket Universe Superboy[104] || Varies from Galaxy level (took hits from Brainiac[89], took hits from Kingdom Come Superman and Kingdom Come Flash[86],) to Low Multiverse level at peak Takes an extended beating from Gog[88] A depressed Conner takes a beating from the Eradicator [105], (A depressed Conner is beaten nearly to death by Superboy-Prime[106][107], but in his rematches,[92] takes his attacks far better.[93], took hits from Black Lantern Kal-L[87][82])
Aside from some minor formatting things, the only complaint I have is that holding back stuff doesn’t belong in the AP section, it goes in either Notes or Standard Tactics.
 
Sure. Lemme copy paste it:

Attack Potency: Varies (Conner has a strong no-Kill rule and holds back.[65][20][18] In addition, his powers require his force of will[37]) Usually Moon level (Was designed to be as close to Pre-Death Superman as possible[4], his Tactile Telekinesis derived stats are stated to be "Superman-Level[66]" Hurts Martian Manhunter possessed by Despero, and again[67], hurts Pre-Circle of Fire Kyle Rayner through his shield[68], Stronger than Cassie Sandsmark Wonder Girl, as per Harm[69], Stalemates M'onel[70] who was stated to be stronger than Pre-Death Superman[71][72], hurts Knockout[73][18][74][35], who is stronger than him[73][75] [18]), Low Multiverse level at peak (Fought and hurt Black Zero[76] who could overpower Pre-Crisis Krypto[77] and Superboy[76]. Rips down a door built to restrain Doomsday[78]) || Varies (Has gained Kryptonian powers and is stronger than before[79][80][81][45][39][40][66][41][39][82] Superboy holds back[83][84][56],) Usually Galaxy level ( Oneshots full Kryptonians and overpowers and defeats a bloodlusted Alura In-Zee, Supergirl's mother[85], Fought Kingdom Come Superman, though he eventually loses after being convinced to lose[86], Had the advantage on Match[54] who defeated Ultraman[50], Drew blood from Superman[87] Fought Gog, who hurt Superman, and even hurt him[88], staggered Brainac with his blows[89]) Low Multiverse level at his peak (Stalemates Orion[90] Hurts a young Darkseid[91], In the second fight with Superboy-Prime A motivated Conner draws blood from him and trades blows with him[92]. In their third battle, Conner fights near-equally with Prime[93]. A brainwashed Conner broke out of the hold of and overpowered Power Girl and Supergirl.[94], Blows up Black Lantern Kal-L[82] Conner is stated to be able to “do everything Superman can do”[39])

Speed: MFTL+ (Dodged an attack from an Imperiex Probe[95], Kept pace with Impulse[96]) || MFTL+: (Kept up with Supergirl[97], Kept up with Bart Allen in a race[98], could react to Kingdom Come Flash[46], Claims to be as fast as Impulse[99] Likely is as fast as any Kryptonian since he can "do everything Superman can do")

Lifting Strength: varies, up to Class G (lifted a large palace[100]) | Varies up to Stellar at peak (Scales to other kryptonians, who are comparable to Lobo)

Striking Strength: Varies Usually Moon level, Low Multiverse level at peak (could hurt M'onel, Pre-Circle of Fire Kyle Rayner, Knockout and Martian Manhunter with his strikes, at his peak he can hurt Black Zero) | Varies, usually Galaxy level, Low Multiverse level at Peak (Can oneshot Kryptonians, fought Kingdom Come Superman and hurt him, drew blood from a holding back Superman, hurt Brainiac with his strikes. At his peak, he can fight and hurt Superboy-Prime, Orion, and Darkseid)

Durability: Varies from Moon level (Can take blows from people in his tier. Aquaman can’t hurt him and had to drown and weaken him later in the same comic to effect him, with Superboy getting right back up[101], Took hits from Match[102], took hits from Despero possessing Martian Manhunter[67], ) Up to Low Multiverse level (Takes a beating from Cyborg Superman directly after witnessing him murder a blimp of people with Cyborg Superman being impressed with his durability[103] takes a beating from Pre-Crisis/Pocket Universe Superboy[104] || Varies from Galaxy level (took hits from Brainiac[89], took hits from Kingdom Come Superman and Kingdom Come Flash[86],) to Low Multiverse level at peak Takes an extended beating from Gog[88] A depressed Conner takes a beating from the Eradicator [105], (A depressed Conner is beaten nearly to death by Superboy-Prime[106][107], but in his rematches,[92] takes his attacks far better.[93], took hits from Black Lantern Kal-L[87][82])
Few notes

  • Considering we're likely putting MMH at 2-C, the MMH justification should probably be 2-C.
  • I'd say remove the KC Flash parts, he doesn't have a profile nor any scaling on the wiki rn. Not like Superboy needs him anyway.
  • Not entirely sure about the KC Superman and Gog parts yet as I'm kinda unsure on whether he scales to 3-C or 2-C.
  • I feel it should be mentioned Connor blew up BL Kal L with his TK powers.
  • Also him being able to do everything Superman can is a little sus but I'll look into that a bit more later on.

Good job.
 
Few notes

  • Considering we're likely putting MMH at 2-C, the MMH justification should probably be 2-C.
  • I'd say remove the KC Flash parts, he doesn't have a profile nor any scaling on the wiki rn. Not like Superboy needs him anyway.
  • Not entirely sure about the KC Superman and Gog parts yet as I'm kinda unsure on whether he scales to 3-C or 2-C.
  • I feel it should be mentioned Connor blew up BL Kal L with his TK powers.
  • Also him being able to do everything Superman can is a little sus but I'll look into that a bit more later on.

Good job.

Working on the rest, but the idea of Conner being able to do Everything Superman can comes from Adventure Comics vol 2 #7.

Earlier in the same comic, he stated he had developed almost all full Kryptonian abilities, save Ice Breath.

Then he uses Ice Breath for the first time, and Cass refers to him as "a guy who can do everything Superman can"

This is supported by the Secret Files 2005 saying he has powers nearly identical to Superman.
 
Is there any progress here? Lots of characters still need to be updated from tier 4:
This profiles don't need to be updated, either because they are already updated or that this are mostly Post-Flashpoint characters which for what i remember where not include since the upgraded was only reserved to Post-Crisis and Rebirth characters.
 
As far as I can tell, the only characters left to be updated are those that weren’t given new justifications in the OP.

At this point, for the remaining characters, I would say to just change the tiers according to their current justifications. Otherwise, the thread will just be stuck here.
 
As far as I can tell, the only characters left to be updated are those that weren’t given new justifications in the OP.

At this point, for the remaining characters, I would say to just change the tiers according to their current justifications. Otherwise, the thread will just be stuck here.
And which ones are they?
 
As far as I can tell, the only characters left to be updated are those that weren’t given new justifications in the OP.

At this point, for the remaining characters, I would say to just change the tiers according to their current justifications. Otherwise, the thread will just be stuck here.
I second this, it would take an ETERNITY to come up with new justifications for all the 4-B (and some of the 5-A) characters, granted it’ll get done eventually but this thread has lost some steam and momentum.
 
I'm working Martian Manhunter rn. I wanna get to at least the core characters for scaling before moving on.

Also, Tracer, you done with Wonder Woman yet? iirc, I think we approved of her already, you can place hers now.
 
Also, Tracer, you done with Wonder Woman yet?
Her first key is more-or-less done, and her Post-Clayface key can just be scaled to Supergirl and Power Girl (both of whom already have good justifications and just need their tiers changed) until I finish my proper revision for Wonder Woman.
 
Thanks, I'll update MMH in a bit.

Can someone unlock this page btw? @Maverick_Zero_X

 
Thanks, I'll update MMH in a bit.

Can someone unlock this page btw? @Maverick_Zero_X

Unlocked.
 
Is all that needs to be done just replacing the tiers because the justifications are good enough? If so, I could handle it in minutes with a script.
 
Is all that needs to be done just replacing the tiers because the justifications are good enough? If so, I could handle it in minutes with a script.
Some of the justifications need slight alterations to remove details that are unnecessary now (i.e. Supergirl’s durability justification mentioning her being able to survive an exploding star is useless for a Tier 2 character) or to just fix formatting.

But Bizzaro, Solomon Grundy, Ursa and the Parademon Alien can safely have their 4-B ratings changed to 2-C.
 
Also in the Superboy thread, 5-C should be updated to Low 5-B as Pre death Superman scales to Superboy, and Captain Atom in turn scales to Pre death Superman. Could someone unlock these two?


 
In terms of character importance, the only ones left are KC Superman, Supergirl, Powergirl, MMH and Aquaman

Aquaman is probably gonna be like, Low 5-B iirc lmfao
 
Also in the Superboy thread, 5-C should be updated to Low 5-B as Pre death Superman scales to Superboy, and Captain Atom in turn scales to Pre death Superman. Could someone unlock these two?


Opened.

Edit: Also unlocked Supergirl.
 
So I'm done with MMH's page "update", should I place that here for eval or just make another thread?
 
So I'm done with MMH's page "update", should I place that here for eval or just make another thread?
I'd like to see the Eval, especially with how weird his scaling is (he's occasionally treated as in the Same Tier as Superman and other times below them, to the point in OWAW, he wasn't even top 4 material)
 
I'd like to see the Eval, especially with how weird his scaling is (he's occasionally treated as in the Same Tier as Superman and other times below them, to the point in OWAW, he wasn't even top 4 material)
MMH kinda has a lot of anti-feats that kinda prevents from being around Superman's level proper

Red King (JLA: Classified #36).
Red King was off guard and MMH never really posed a threat to him for the rest of the arc.

Superboy Prime (Infinite Crisis #6)
SPB was kinda just messing around for a bit and likely wasn't even that serious, not to mention in that same sequence he stomps Black Adam, who's superior to MMH easily. And later on, we see SBP stomp MMH.

I think the SBP could be added, but probably not Red King. I don't think he's infinitely weaker than either but not on the same level either.
 

Can ya'll hop onto here real quick?
 
Back
Top