- 5,206
- 2,721
Charlotte Katakuri VS Onoki
- Starting Distance: 25 Meters
- Fight Location: Whole Cake Island
- Katakuri at 7-A
- Both in character
- Equalized speed
Onoki:
Inconclusive:
Last edited:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Would that be a compliment? lolWow, that's a match up I would've never thought of in a million years lol.
Yeah lol, you're definitely creative.Would that be a compliment? lol
I don't think I'm overlooking Onoki, rather as I said he literally cannot overcome Katakuri's future sight which negs anything he can do, if this wasn't a factor, then it would be much closer.I feel like Onoki is being seriously overlooked here, so I guess I'll have to argue for him.
First off, and this might be Onoki's biggest advantage here, he severely outranges Kata. Not only can he freely fly out of the range of Kata's attacks, but he can also attack him from much farther away. Onoki's Jinton can easily cover hundreds of meters almost instantly, so it's not going to be the easiest thing to dodge, even with Future Sight, given speed is equalized.
Onoki can also pin Katakuri in place from a distance, which can then be followed by Jinton.
He can create Rock Golems for distractions and to occupy the opponent while he sets up his attacks. He can also create Rock clones to test the waters.
Obviously Katakuri doesn't really have a way of one shotting here either because their APs are almost identical, so that gives Onoki even more options.
I'm not going to vote yet until I hear more arguments, but I definitely had to put this out there because Onoki was severely overlooked here.
He doesn't need to neg his future sight when he can abuse his range advantage.I don't think I'm overlooking Onoki, rather as I said he literally cannot overcome Katakuri's future sight which negs anything he can do, if this wasn't a factor, then it would be much closer.
It's speed doesn't matter, sure, but its AOE definitely does.Attack speed also gets equalized in speed equalization, so Jinton's speed doesn't matter.
Luffy didn't have the luxury of large AOE or unrestricted flight either. Onoki isn't going to engage in h2h here, let's be real.The reason I think Onoki can't overcome the future sight is solely because Luffy could only match it whilst being faster than Katakuri and having pseudo future sight of his own, Onoki doesn't have either of these luxuries.
How will he avoid it though? Onoki just pinned down 25 Susano'o at once from meters away. It's not like he can outrun hax.Onoki is never pinning Katakuri with that, I think you're seriously underestimating how much of a factor Katakuri's future sight is here, he would see that happening several seconds ahead and avoid it effortlessly, and even if by some miracle he was caught in it, he can just escape by turning into Mochi, it's not as if the stone fist is airtight.
He can fight for hours during the war, it's not like he'll gas out after 5 minutes.You're right about the AP thing, but Katakuri's stamina is far higher than Onoki's, so Onoki doesn't even have the choice of outlasting Katakuri and rather, given Onoki's age, the longer the battle lasts the weaker he's probably going to be.
This strategy would only be useful if they're in an enclosed space, which is not the case here afaik. The OP just says "Wholecake Island", so Onoki can still just fly out of range.Doesn't Onoki have to mold chakra and do handsigns while Katakuri can just spawn Mochi fists next to Onoki's face?
It's in his range.
Katakuri can suffocate him via mochi.
Nah, cause they have huge ass buildings and Whole Cake Cheatau which can be turned into a giant mochi thingyThis strategy would only be useful if they're in an enclosed space, which is not the case here afaik. The OP just says "Wholecake Island", so Onoki can still just fly out of range.
Also I've literally never seen Onoki wave a handsign. He just extends his hands and fires off his stuff.
The further away he fires Jinton from the easier it is for Katakuri to evade it, it's a projectile, and given his future sight, it's already easy enough. Him abusing range doesn't help him at all, because again, he doesn't even have the choice of flying high and trying to outlast given his inferior stamina.He doesn't need to neg his future sight when he can abuse his range advantage.
It's speed doesn't matter, sure, but its AOE definitely does.
Luffy didn't have the luxury of large AOE or unrestricted flight either. Onoki isn't going to engage in h2h here, let's be real.
How will he avoid it though? Onoki just pinned down 25 Susano'o at once from meters away. It's not like he can outrun hax.
He can fight for hours during the war, it's not like he'll gas out after 5 minutes.
This strategy would only be useful if they're in an enclosed space, which is not the case here afaik. The OP just says "Wholecake Island", so Onoki can still just fly out of range.
Also I've literally never seen Onoki wave a handsign. He just extends his hands and fires off his stuff.
How far will those buildings go, realistically? Onoki can fly Kilometers into the air.Nah, cause they have huge ass buildings and Whole Cake Cheatau which can be turned into a giant mochi thingy
So he just claps his hands together, it's not like he goes into an hour long ritual to prep his attacks lol. Also, I can pull numerous examples where he just fires it off willy nilly.
I never said he'd try to outlast him, I said he has a range advantage, which he does. It being an advantage is a fact. It gives him better mobility options, and more evasive options. All of Katakuri's long ranged attacks are projectiles as well, which means Onoki can simply evade them by flying out of range.The further away he fires Jinton from the easier it is for Katakuri to evade it, it's a projectile, and given his future sight, it's already easy enough. Him abusing range doesn't help him at all, because again, he doesn't even have the choice of flying high and trying to outlast given his inferior stamina.
It's still a big pressure to have to constantly deal with. He'll have to constantly dodge something that's hundreds of meters across potentially.I guess? Katakuri can see how big its AOE is though, so it's not like he's going to be caught off guard by it.
Range isn't really a factor as I said above and neither is AOE.
It does not require that at all as far as I know. If you zoom into the picture I linked earlier, you will see that there are no hands present for the other 20 Susano'o he pinned down. The only hand he summoned was there to protect the incapacitated Raikage from the Susano'o's blows.The pin isn't instant, a hand comes out from the ground and traps you, Katakuri sees this happening in the future several seconds ahead and just casually moves out of the way?
I never said it would be a contest of stamina, all I'm saying is that Onoki can last for a long time. There's no reason to assume this fight will drag on forever, it may or may not last for hours, which Onoki will still be good for.Inferior One Piece characters to Katakuri can fight for several days and nights straight, if this is a contest of stamina, Onoki doesn't stand a chance.
The same could be said for most Naruto characters, sometimes they use signs, and sometimes they don't. It's not like it takes long anyway, so let's just drop this argument please. We're splitting hairs at this point.Onoki does use hand signs sometimes but othertimes he just forms the cube and fires it, so it's kinda inconsistent.
Like I said earlier, I don't think that is the case afaik. (If I'm wrong though, then I concede on this point)I think I misunderstood what you were going for with the pin argument, I thought you were trying to say Onoki would summon a rock hand and trap Katakuri in it.
Doesn't he have to touch something to weigh it down and pin it?
I know, but I'm just saying that outlasting isn't an option. It is an advantage, just not one that really affects the battle imo. Katakuri has future sight, Onoki doesn't, it's going to be much harder for Onoki to evade Katakuri's attacks than it would be for Katakuri to evade Onoki's.I never said he'd try to outlast him, I said he has a range advantage, which he does. It being an advantage is a fact. It gives him better mobility options, and more evasive options. All of Katakuri's long ranged attacks are projectiles as well, which means Onoki can simply evade them by flying out of range.
It's still a big pressure to have to constantly deal with. He'll have to constantly dodge something that's hundreds of meters across potentially.
Onoki isn't stupid, he will initially notice that Kata can anticipate and dodge all of his attacks, and then he'll realize that his only option is to expand his Jinton's range.
It does not require that at all as far as I know. If you zoom into the picture I linked earlier, you will see that there are no hands present for the other 20 Susano'o he pinned down. The only hand he summoned was there to protect the incapacitated Raikage from the Susano'o's blows.
I never said it would be a contest of stamina, all I'm saying is that Onoki can last for a long time. There's no reason to assume this fight will drag on forever, it may or may not last for hours, which Onoki will still be good for.
The same could be said for most Naruto characters, sometimes they use signs, and sometimes they don't. It's not like it takes long anyway, so let's just drop this argument please. We're splitting hairs at this point.
Like I said earlier, I don't think that is the case afaik. (If I'm wrong though, then I concede on this point)
I agree that Katakuri will be very hard to connect with due to FS, but I really don't think Onoki will be that easy to hit. FS is very powerful, yes, but it doesn't negate physical advantages like range. How will FS help him if Onoki simply evades out of range of his attacks or hits him with something that has a very large AOE.I know, but I'm just saying that outlasting isn't an option. It is an advantage, just not one that really affects the battle imo. Katakuri has future sight, Onoki doesn't, it's going to be much harder for Onoki to evade Katakuri's attacks than it would be for Katakuri to evade Onoki's.
Well, that's not really relevant because I sent another instance when he obliterated Madara's forest, unassisted by Tsunade. Also, the Tsunade thing was because he had no chakra left, but in any case it doesn't matter since I didn't even use that example.The only time Onoki created a Jinton that big was when Tsunade was giving him chakra, and we can safely assume he wouldn't be able to send out more than a handful of those.
Fair enough. Though I should've probably made myself more clear, so my apologies for that one.Yes I misunderstood what you were going for.
Fair enough.True, but under the rare case where the fight does last for an extended amount of time, Katakuri would have the advantage.
Yeah, that's fair. It's true that it's inconsistent.The hand sign thing wasn't my argument, I was just saying that it's kinda inconsistent regarding whether or not hand signs are required.
I'm going purely off of the example with the 25 Susano'o, so yeah.I'm not entirely sure either, but every other time we see him lighten or increase the weight of something, it required physical contact iirc.