• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Base Sonic MFTL-MFTL+ speed upgrade

I don't have much to say even if I want this to go through but...I wouldn't put much stock into the Advance 3 feat since it's an outlier for Eggman.
Possibly? Vs wiki seems to put Eggman's technology at MFTL for keeping up with Super Sonic (Non-Aggression Zone, Sonic Unleashed opening had the two persuing each other, and using Sonic Runners feat of Sonic being MFTL+ in Base would also imply that Eggman's moving at MFTL+ speeds in the boss fights. Thus you could argue that Eggman's pretty consistently MFTL to MFTL+.
 
Possibly? Vs wiki seems to put Eggman's technology at MFTL for keeping up with Super Sonic (Non-Aggression Zone, Sonic Unleashed opening had the two persuing each other, and using Sonic Runners feat of Sonic being MFTL+ in Base would also imply that Eggman's moving at MFTL+ speeds in the boss fights. Thus you could argue that Eggman's pretty consistently MFTL to MFTL+.
While there isn’t a Calc that I see There’s also the Egg Mobile Traveling to the Moon in a few Seconds which could yield something

plus, Since Sonic keeps getting stronger, it could make sense how In Unleashed The Egg Mobile can go past Super Sonic but then Base Sonic after Getting up from a defeat can keep up with the Egg Mobile, which is pretty much the same thing that happened in Forces

he also Pushed the Button on before Super Sonic can react, Though arguably that could be just Sonic’s cockiness, but that’s a rare sight in Super Form
 
I don't have much to say even if I want this to go through but...I wouldn't put much stock into the Advance 3 feat since it's an outlier for Eggman.
Eggman kept up with Super Sonic in Nonagression, since he fought alongside the same against Gemerl.

Tho the Egg Mobile has like 2 diferent scalings to that ig, and the Eggmobile being capable of traveling those kind of distances isn't something so uncommon iirc.
 
While there isn’t a Calc that I see There’s also the Egg Mobile Traveling to the Moon in a few Seconds which could yield something

plus, Since Sonic keeps getting stronger, it could make sense how In Unleashed The Egg Mobile can go past Super Sonic but then Base Sonic after Getting up from a defeat can keep up with the Egg Mobile, which is pretty much the same thing that happened in Forces
Reaching the moon in a few seconds would be relativistic. The moon is like 1.3 light seconds away from Earth. So reaching it in a few seconds would immediately be slower than light. Still impressive regardless.

I agree with the Sonic keeps getting stronger thing. I did mention it in my initial post after all.
 
Reaching the moon in a few seconds would be relativistic. The moon is like 1.3 light seconds away from Earth. So reaching it in a few seconds would immediately be slower than light. Still impressive regardless.
Well yeah but the feat in question does have a little more, he seems to Cross the Earth First before getting to the Moon
image0.png

He Gets from this platform, so far away from earth you can See stars, and gets to the moon
 
I'm not sure how to tell you this but Sonic scaling to his Super Form from previous occasions it's also not accepted.

This is straight up debunked in Generations with Classic Super Sonic being stronger than Modern Base Sonic.
 
I'm not sure how to tell you this but Sonic scaling to his Super Form from previous occasions it's also not accepted.

This is straight up debunked in Generations with Classic Super Sonic being stronger than Modern Base Sonic.
I mean, Stronger doesn’t Mean Faster, Technically in gameplay Modern Super Sonic is doing all the Speed with the boost button (hell arguably Modern Sonic stages in general probably go on faster then Classic Sonic Stages with Super)
 
I'm not sure how to tell you this but Sonic scaling to his Super Form from previous occasions it's also not accepted.

This is straight up debunked in Generations with Classic Super Sonic being stronger than Modern Base Sonic.
I don't know if vs wiki goes by this. But I believe Classic Sonic from Generations to not be the Classic Sonic from the 90's. Was he supposed to be? Yes, of course. However, due to the events of Sonic Generations interrupting the events of Sonic 1 (He was in Greenhill Zone before Time Eater erased the Universe IIRC). Thus the Classic Sonic we see in the game shouldn't scale to 90's Sonic. Especially since his feats are significantly greater than what we see from the actual 90's classic era.
Plus, Classic Super Sonic in gameplay from what I remember hearing actually isn't any faster than Base. If you're referring to the Final Boss you can also argue they weren't going any faster than the speeds they were in Base. You just assume that since they transformed that they're faster than before which I guess is a fair assumption doesn't automatically mean Classic Super Sonic > Modern Sonic in speeed.
 
I mean, Stronger doesn’t Mean Faster, Technically in gameplay Modern Super Sonic is doing all the Speed with the boost button (hell arguably Modern Sonic stages in general probably go on faster then Classic Sonic Stages with Super)
An example of that, but with durability, is how Base Sonic on Archie can tank attacks from a duplicated Super Form, despite his base being much inferior to it's power in regardings.
 
I don't know if vs wiki goes by this. But I believe Classic Sonic from Generations to not be the Classic Sonic from the 90's. Was he supposed to be? Yes, of course. However, due to the events of Sonic Generations interrupting the events of Sonic 1 (He was in Greenhill Zone before Time Eater erased the Universe IIRC). Thus the Classic Sonic we see in the game shouldn't scale to 90's Sonic. Especially since his feats are significantly greater than what we see from the actual 90's classic era.
Plus, Classic Super Sonic in gameplay from what I remember hearing actually isn't any faster than Base. If you're referring to the Final Boss you can also argue they weren't going any faster than the speeds they were in Base. You just assume that since they transformed that they're faster than before which I guess is a fair assumption doesn't automatically mean Classic Super Sonic > Modern Sonic in speeed.
Actually Sonic Generations takes place between Sonic 2, since at that time Classic Sonic did already know Tails's existence, and Sonic CD since Classic Sonic recognizes Amy's existence and has fought Metal to attain a Chaos Emerald from his defeat.
 
Actually Sonic Generations takes place between Sonic 2, since at that time Classic Sonic did already know Tails's existence, and Sonic CD since Classic Sonic recognizes Amy's existence and has fought Metal to attain a Chaos Emerald from his defeat.
Couldn't you just say he knows Metal Sonic via knowing Tails and Amy already and thus he must have went through the events of CD already? Saying he got a Chaos Emerald from him the Generations storyline wouldn't be solid evidence. Seeing as he did that in the empty white space and not in the normal timeline.
Either way, Mania and Forces further cement my idea that Classic Sonic from Generations is from Another Dimension. Tails straight-up STATES Classic Sonic is from another Dimension. Some may use the argument that "He's referring to 2D, it's a joke" as an excuse, but it makes no sense within the context. Plus in the Japanese Sub he states Classic Sonic's from another World, not Dimension. Which debunks the notion of it being a pun/joke.

I really think Classic Sonic from Generations, Mania, and Forces shouldn't be used to scale to Classic Sonic's speeds. He has significantly better feats and scales relatively close to the current Modern Sonic who I place at a far higher level than vs wiki places him (Multi-Solar at least via Ultimate Emerl scaling). 90's Classic Sonic's significantly inferior in both Attack Potency and Speed in terms of feats and scaling. Knuckles knocked OG Classic Super Sonic out of his Super Form for Pete's sake. He certainly wouldn't pull that off against Modern Sonic.
 
It’s also not exactly unheard off For Sonic to give Speed to partners, there’s whole Sections about that in Forces and in Advance 3 Characters can only go into Super Speed Mode if Sonic is there Partner
 
Couldn't you just say he knows Metal Sonic via knowing Tails and Amy already and thus he must have went through the events of CD already? Saying he got a Chaos Emerald from him the Generations storyline wouldn't be solid evidence. Seeing as he did that in the empty white space and not in the normal timeline.
Oh my mistake anyway, but I could say the explanation is that after the Time Eater messed up with the original classic timeline the events kinda diverged, since the Classic timeline is what it leads to the Modern era, but the events diverged after Generations, hence the reason of why Sonic Mania supposedly happens and why in recent sources Classic is stated to be from another world, aka another timeline, despite in Generations them being called the past and present versions of each other more than twice.
 
I’d also want to Note the Wiki itself has no real feats listed for Classic Super Sonic, just saying that since he has the same Power Source as Modern Super Sonic they should be similar speeds, Which isn’t shared across all users of the 7 Chaos Emeralds like Emerl and Perfect Chaos, and the Super forms are already rated as being variable in power anyway, then it says the Time Eater feat, in which Classic Super Sonic is visibly Slower then Modern Super Sonic, and it could be argued it’s Modern Giving his Classic Self some speed which Has been done before
 
Oh my mistake anyway, but I could say the explanation is that after the Time Eater messed up with the original classic timeline the events kinda diverged, since the Classic timeline is what it leads to the Modern era, but the events diverged after Generations, hence the reason of why Sonic Mania supposedly happens and why in recent sources Classic is stated to be from another world, aka another timeline, despite in Generations them being called the past and present versions of each other more than twice.
Agreed. That's exactly my thoughts. Someone even mapped this out:

images


Ignore the non-canon things like IDW (and possibly Mania Adventures). I'd say the timeline works out quite well structured that way.

Anyways, my point would be that Classic Sonic from any of the late 2000's game should scale above Classic Sonic from the 90's. Generations clearly caused a divergence. Some may ask "Well just because the Timeline was separated doesn't mean that Classic Sonic should be much stronger" and you're right. But it doesn't need to make sense. It's just what happened. You can come up with a list of a plethora of reasons of why Classic Sonic randomly got insanely stronger. But at the end of the day it's a different Classic Sonic who's shown to be significantly greater. The burden of proof would be on whoever claims OG Classic Sonic scales to Generations Classic Sonic without the, 'he originated from the 90's timeline before being split from it'. Because again, the problem with that is you can easily make up many excuses as to why Classic Sonic was more powerful. Splitting Timelines could make you significantly stronger, being confronted with a greatly stronger foe could increase Sonic's rate of growth for all we know.
It's unexplained because SEGA couldn't care less about scaling and making sense. It's pretty inconsistent as we all know.
 
It’s also not exactly unheard off For Sonic to give Speed to partners, there’s whole Sections about that in Forces and in Advance 3 Characters can only go into Super Speed Mode if Sonic is there Partner
Another thing to regard is that the only thing the Eggmobile actually scales in comparison to Super Sonic is his speed, since when he fought Gemerl alongside the same he was directly amped by Super Sonic's chaos energy to directly damage Gemerl in a single blast, since the Eggmobile isn't directly capable of damaging Gemerl through conventional means unless Sonic charges up a chaos power attack with him envolved.
I’d also want to Note the Wiki itself has no real feats listed for Classic Super Sonic, just saying that since he has the same Power Source as Modern Super Sonic they should be similar speeds, Which isn’t shared across all users of the 7 Chaos Emeralds like Emerl and Perfect Chaos, and the Super forms are already rated as being variable in power anyway
Perfect Chaos uses like negative power from the Emeralds, which according to the wiki doesn't scale to the positive energy feats, like the Chaos Emeralds's power surpassing the Final Egg Blaster and so on.
 
I’d also want to Note the Wiki itself has no real feats listed for Classic Super Sonic, just saying that since he has the same Power Source as Modern Super Sonic they should be similar speeds, Which isn’t shared across all users of the 7 Chaos Emeralds like Emerl and Perfect Chaos, and the Super forms are already rated as being variable in power anyway, then it says the Time Eater feat, in which Classic Super Sonic is visibly Slower then Modern Super Sonic, and it could be argued it’s Modern Giving his Classic Self some speed which Has been done before
Yea, that kinda bugged me. Just because A and B are using the same power sources doesn't mean they have the same benefits. They seem to use the 'they use the Chaos Emeralds and thus must be at this level or that level'. But the Chaos Emeralds are shown to grant variable levels of power. In cases where the Chaos Emerald is just used to fuel a machine, the power of the machine should just be what it was programmed to be with the Chaos Emeralds merely serving as a battery. Whilst if something is shown to straight-up channel the energy of the Chaos Emeralds itself that's a different story.
 
Another thing to regard is that the only thing the Eggmobile actually scales in comparison to Super Sonic is his speed, since when he fought Gemerl alongside the same he was directly amped by Super Sonic's chaos energy to directly damage Gemerl in a single blast, since the Eggmobile isn't directly capable of damaging Gemerl through conventional means unless Sonic charges up a chaos power attack with him envolved.

Perfect Chaos uses like negative power from the Emeralds, which according to the wiki doesn't scale to the positive energy feats, like the Chaos Emeralds's power surpassing the Final Egg Blaster and so on.
“Negative Chaos Energy” users have been rated as MFTL before, FinalHazard and Ultimate Gemerl besides, Perfect Chaos is going through a scaling revision soon
 
“Negative Chaos Energy” users have been rated as MFTL before, FinalHazard and Ultimate Gemerl besides, Perfect Chaos is going through a scaling revision soon
This negative energy and positive chaos energy thing always bothered me. Sonic Adventure seemed to imply that unless someone is specifically stated to tap into the individual energies that they were just naturally tapping into both energies or something neutral. Otherwise the positive energy thing wouldn't have been such a surprise to Sonic. Plus the positive energy from the Chaos Emeralds made Sonic powerful enough to fight Perfect Chaos who absorbed the negative energy. The implication being that both are comparable in power despite using two different forms of the same energy. I really don't see a reason to consistently separate positive and negative energy from each other when regarding using the Chaos Emerald's power.
 
This negative energy and positive chaos energy thing always bothered me. Sonic Adventure seemed to imply that unless someone is specifically stated to tap into the individual energies that they were just naturally tapping into both energies or something neutral. Otherwise the positive energy thing wouldn't have been such a surprise to Sonic. Plus the positive energy from the Chaos Emeralds made Sonic powerful enough to fight Perfect Chaos who absorbed the negative energy. The implication being that both are comparable in power despite using two different forms of the same energy. I really don't see a reason to consistently separate positive and negative energy from each other when regarding using the Chaos Emerald's power.
There’s also just the fact the Japanese version of Sonic Adventure doesn’t even have an explicit statement “Negative Chaos Energy” is weaker then Positive, just that Sonic knows how to use The Chaos Emeralds “The Real Way”



EbmnKrOXQAAYDwf
 
“Negative Chaos Energy” users have been rated as MFTL before, FinalHazard and Ultimate Gemerl besides, Perfect Chaos is going through a scaling revision soon
Perfect Chaos is supposedly meant to scale to the Eclipse Cannon's attack speed normally, something quite funny to take out.
 
There’s also just the fact the Japanese version of Sonic Adventure doesn’t even have an explicit statement “Negative Chaos Energy” is weaker then Positive, just that Sonic knows how to use The Chaos Emeralds “The Real Way”



EbmnKrOXQAAYDwf

Exactly. Wouldn't you say that just implies that Sonic knows how to use the Chaos Emeralds better than Perfect Chaos or has better mastery over it? Mastery of Chaos Energy has been a prevalent thing in Sonic. It's quite consistent too. Super Shadow was exhausted and dropped out of Super whilst Sonic was fine. Why could this be? Because it's Shadow's first time. Every subsequent time after he handles it far better without issue. Silver kind of gets a pass as Sonic lent energy to Silver to go Super as opposed to using the Chaos Emerald himself (As well as Shadow).
 
I have some arguments for tier 4 Base Sonic btw, but this is out of question for now, the focus here is speed IIRC.
We could discuss that somewhere else. I personally have my own tier 4 Sonic as a bare minimum for Sonic. On other websites, I actually place him at 2-C (Base alone). Although my opinion on that could change.
But yea, let's keep it on speed.

So far more confusion has seemed to be cleared up. Since I'm kind of new to this site I don't quite know how it works. Do we have to wait for an admin or something to view this thread and approve it or does the majority have to decide what seems right?
 
So far more confusion has seemed to be cleared up. Since I'm kind of new to this site I don't quite know how it works. Do we have to wait for an admin or something to view this thread and approve it or does the majority have to decide what seems right?
It needs some staff approval btw, this site has some restrictions to pass a CRT here, at any case you can look up at the site rules to be more sure.
 
It sounds crazy, but it has to do with some scaling shenanigans involving Erazor Djinn, Time Eater, and Infinite. Merlina used to be part of the rhetoric but I've changed my views on her. Albeit I doubt the site will really agree with the meta.
 
It needs some staff approval btw, this site has some restrictions to pass a CRT here, at any case you can look up at the site rules to be more sure.
Does CRT stand for Content Revision Thread? I've seen it quite a bit and it's left me pretty confused.
In any case, how would I acquire staff approval?
 
Does CRT stand for Content Revision Thread? I've seen it quite a bit and it's left me pretty confused.
In any case, how would I acquire staff approval?
Yes, CRT stands for Content Revision Thread, and you have to contact a staff member or wait for a staff member to give some answers here, if such member disagrees or agrees with the proposal.
 
Yikes, is it bad that I use that on occasion? The feat is confusing. Doesn't running through time constitute as Immeasurable?
Actually Sonic being capable of ''fixing space'' with his speed is oftenly regarded as a spatial manip feat of his own, and that's a limited one.

Running through time can be performed via FTL travel, that's if, of course, said verse follows those kind of rules, which in the case of Sonic verse this is completely different.
 
I don’t think it’s important to discuss the Generations running through time thing, I think it would be best if someone summed up the feats and counter arguments again, maybe in a edit for the OP. since multiple things have been changed since the thread started
 
I don’t think it’s important to discuss the Generations running through time thing, I think it would be best if someone summed up the feats and counter arguments again, maybe in a edit for the OP. since multiple things have been changed since the thread started
Yikes, Imagine Sonic having infinite speed in base with just 5-A ratings, OOF!
 
Back
Top