Amy vs Rouge Rematch

[Peptocoptr27]

Last time this matchup happened here was in 2020. A LOT has changed since then. Not to mention some arguments in the original thread were kind of flawed in my opinion.

---

Spoiler: My thoughts on the last thread's arguments

The funniest argument to deconstruct is the one that Rouge's emphatic manipulation would make Amy fall in love with her. This is a stretch to say the least. Neither Rouge or Amy have any evidence of bisexuality, which I honestly do think makes Rouge even less likely to use it in-character, even if only to win a fight (she only ever used it once in a side mission anyway), and Amy isn't garanteed to be affected by it, since her obession for Sonic is unlikely to be overcome by charm that's only ever been shown to work on male-coded robots. Also, I just realized Rouge is 18 while Amy is 12, so even if Rouge beats Amy this way, she won't be beating Chris Hansen afterwards.

The second argument is that Rouge scales to Knuckles' skill, has better mobillity via flight, and easily defeated Amy and Emerl in Sonic Battle. This is still valid, but less so now that Amy has aquired more experience and skills. Her poison parry, cyloop and mobillity options granted to her in Frontiers help her make up for this disadvantage.

---

---

Anyway, standard battle assumptions
Modern versions used
Battle takes place in Station Square

Amy Rose:
Rouge The Bat:
Incon:

 

[SJG13673]

Amy wins instantly by using Amy Flash which leaves Rouge to her mercy for whole 20 seconds which is longer than Rouge's 10, tho she will likely not use it right of the bat and i'm honestly not sure if she even remembers she can do that, so she will go in melee with hammer where she will likely be outclassed, tho Frontiers moves might get the thing more even, pretty even to me