- 3,607
- 538
you contradicted yourself with the link you sentWell, you’re absolutely right in the sense that it was implied it’d work, but it has no bearing on All Might. Because the limit isn’t physical—It’s “Life Power.” While there isn’t a cap on incapacitation, specifically, there is seemingly in the method of doing so. As ShigAFO notes. He even goes so fast as to say it might be possible, but less effective
You admit yourself that there's no cap when it comes to incapacitation, meaning incapacitation on All Might, who is comparable to if not slightly weaker than Incomplete Shiggy, will still work, except that the method of doing so might be less effective
However, if you look closely at what he's actually saying:
"Judging from the fact that she didn't say: 'If he touches the air within this set range, he dies', one assumes that the new rule can't arbitrarily involve things she hasn't touched, just through roundabout wording, or perhaps she could make such a rule, but it would be less effective"
What he's saying is that Star could potentially impose rules on something she HASN'T touched if they touch things she HAS touched, but it might be less effective
However, for the things she HAS touched, she can do whatever the f*ck she wants
Except you misinterpreted what he's saying againPoint being, Star has a limit in her ability to affect living things—New Order works specifically flawlessly on the non living, due to “her one sided understanding enforcing the rule.” As such, given it’s about an abstract thing and has only been applied abstractly, we can’t say for sure or against New Order. All we know is some limitation exists for her, and that should be accounted for. (More specifically, deliberating what would and wouldn’t breach into what would be in that limitation.)
You claim that New Order's rules for living and nonliving things are different, as nonliving things can be affected flawlessley while living things are harder to control, which is half true
It's true that nonliving things can be controlled flawlessly
But, according to Shiggy, and confirmed by the rest of the fight:
"The difference in efficacy between rules for living and nonliving things must have to do wit the process of naming the target. Her new rule for me didn't take hold because her understanding doesn't quite mesh with reality. When Ms. Star touched me, she believed me to be Tomura Shigaraki... but even my understanding of myself is hazy. Is my NAME Shigaraki? Or All For One? Or Shimura, even?"
"When calling the name of a target with a sense of self, Ms. Star's understanding of the Target's identity must align with its own.
For targets without a sense of self, her one-sided understanding is enough to enforce the new rule!"
This basically means if Star's understanding of her target's identity matches the target's understanding of their own identity, she can do whatever the f*ck she wants
Since All Might has a known name and a known Hero name, what this basically means is:
she can do whatever the f*ck she wants
and therefore, All Might is cooked