This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
I don't really agree with scaling her to the NK, because at the end of the day it wasn't the stab wound itself that killed him, it was his body's reaction to the blade's material. NK's durability is probably at least building level normally anyways, considering his feat of tanking Drogon's...
I'm worried that Brienne relies too much on her physical strength in fights to be able to take on the Mountain, who definitely outclasses her in terms of strength. In terms of swordsmanship, she probably matches him, and with a Valyrian steel sword I'd say she has a shot at winning, but even...
Very hard to say.
While there isn't enough difference in their physical descriptions to determine strength or speed advantage, in my opinion Blackfyre has the most convincing feat as far as 1v1's are concerned; I'd put Gwayne Corbray (who was defeated by Daemon), being a knight of the...
Close one but Robert would do more damage to Gregor than vice versa. His warhammer is better suited against heavy armor than Gregor's greatsword. If it comes down to wrestling Gregor wins but Robert can get the upper hand before that happens. So voting Robert.
I don't think so. Robert's warhammer is supposed to be exceptionally large heavy as a testament to Robert's strength and there is no reason to equate it to a real life warhammer. ASOIAF doesn't exactly follow real life physics faithfully.
Are you talking about the fact that people carry it around for him?
That's just like squires carrying around swords for knights. It doesn't mean it's too heavy, it just means that the lord in question doesn't carry it around with him at all times, because he has servants for that.
Pretty sure this is a shitpost but anwyay, quotes of him being "unable to lift Robert's warhammer" are made in passing and irrelevant. Let's go by actual feats which puts Ned at 10-A.
This might be PIS or just a consequence of being hurt by Drogon but Viserion was quite clunky on the ground when he was blocking Jon from going to Bran. If Viserion wants to fight Geralt that's probably how he's going to have to do it, since Geralt is smart enough to stay behind cover when...
I did ask Matt about a Delphine profile long ago and got no answer. It should have been posted here earlier.
Also she literally has her magic in that profile and the same stats. Extreme downplay, quite the contrary.
So it's not just the bridge?
Then this makes it easier for Aela, she can use her stealth mastery and surprise the Sodden Knight as a werewolf, howling and turning him into prey.
It looks like Aela outskills while the Sodden Knight is more powerful. Since Aela doesn't get her range advantage nor a chance to transform, she definitely has reduced chances, but I still think she has a shot. She's very agile and can avoid his attacks, including the lightning attack if it's...
Not voting either but just going to say that I don't think J'zargo is going to start off with paralysis against Dumbledore. Any half decent mage can ward it off, it's a costly attack to perform as it screws you up if it fails, and J'zargo is going to tell Dumbledore is an experienced mage at...
The pages seem torn on whether it uses Book versions or Show versions, and several characters scale to 9-B entities like Sandor/Gregor and The Others in a way that creates serious unbalance (Beric is 9-B simply from fighting Sandor even though he died horribly to the one attack that actually...
Being the size of horses, able to sever a man's limbs easily and not even being afraid of mammoths in lore is well up there with real life wall level predators, so yeah. Sticking with Summer.
Gothren is Neloth's superior. Divayth is clearly more powerful than the other mages to such a ridiculous degree that scaling others to him is unfounded, you might as well scale Ulfric to Paarthurnax. Even in Dragonborn, Neloth's feats are laughable compared to Divayth's. He failed to replicate...