• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Damage3245
Reaction score
34,956

Profile posts Latest activity Postings About

  • Hi, could you evaluate this thread please? 🙏

    Hi, can you help evaluate this crt, this crt has been a long time, but still needed staff vote. Please 🙏
    Could you take a look at this CRT?
    Sorry to disturb u. I accidentally posted a thread twice. This maybe considered as spam so I hope u can close the one that is not in content revision. Also could u check if the thread makes worth arguments or not
    Hello, would it be possible for you to evaluate this 1-A Type Moon CRT? There haven't been any staff votes/evaluations so far, and it needs evaluation/staff votes in general

    Yo, Damage. Can you take a look at this for a while?


    Currently in this thread, there's 2 mods: Vietthai and Theglassman. Both of them had different view.

    Shortly: Vietthai prefer Immortality type 5 over the Resistances, while Theglassman has the opposite view. So, i think we need at least one or two more staffs to decide which one we'll take. After that, i can immediately apply the accepted one.

    Well, theres Twilight over there actually, but he hasn't comeback yet since his first comment.

    It'll be very helpful if you go there and give your thoughts.
    Could you evaluate this thread? i believe it's important withing calc member staff? please and thank you in advance

    Mind taking a look?
    Vzearr
    Vzearr
    Has it been 24 hours? Potential bump since it says yesterday.
    Can you help here?
    Thank you.
    Hey can you give one more vote? Mr. Bambu has gave his share of wisdom to my rework
    “Again, that's really far-fetched.

    The map of Alabasta clearly shows a big river, but it's nowhere near as big as you describe it. It was described as "taking a day to float across", which isn't really that unbelievable, considering floating is damn slow.

    My guess would be it's around the same size as Iceland, but nowhere near the size of Australia. (It's actually a little bit larger than that)

    Also, in chapter 214 you can see the route took to escape Alabasta. They covered that distance within a day, which would be impossible if it was the size of Australia.

    Actually, let's look at another example, Crocodile mentioned it would take the rebel army 8 hours to make it to Alubarna from Nanohana. Let's say they average out at around 30 km/h (Fairly realistic for long distance horse travel). That would mean they had covered 240 kilometers within that timespan. Based on the map from chapter 214, that's around 1000 km from shore to shore on the long side. Which is around the size of Indonesia's largest island.

    Overall it's fairly inconsistent on Oda's part. The Straw Hats covered atleast 1000km within 12-15 hours or so on a ship, where the rebels only covered 240km in 8 hours”

    I find this from a old Reddit Post



    I can’t completely vouch for this post regarding Alabasta’s size at least since the links are unfortunately to online piracy sites except this one.


    Here is the map for Alabasta
    Stefano4444
    Stefano4444
    Actually the Rebel Army use camels not horses, and when travelling for longer distances at a faster clip they can maintain a steady pace of around 40 km/h.

    Meaning if they took 8 hours to arrive at steady pace then the distance between the two locations would be of 320 km.

    Also that map linked below isn't on fully scale so i don't think he can be used, beside giving us the overall ideas where Alubarna and Nanohana are suppost to be.

    Better if you keep using this, as in the 3rd panel (the one where we see the river) if you look closely you may notice what could be Alubarna as its in the center of the image.
    Hello. If you have a free time, please give us your input here. It's a CRT to fix the values, and since you're a CGM, i think it's good time for you to see. Thank you!
    Hello. Could you take a look at this? We need a knowledgeable staffs regarding CM to evaluate. Thank you 🙏
    Hello! Could you please take a look at my CRT? 🙏

    Yo check this tier 1 jjk upgrade

    Can you evaluate this crt please?
    Hey, mind dropping a comment here?
    Could you take a look at this?
    Hello, can you look at this downgrade thread? Supporters and another CGM agrees with calcs 1, 2, and 5 being removed, but Calcs 3 and 4 seem to have minor contention. Just needs 1 more evaluation!
    Huh could you comment on the staff thread I told u about in DMs

    Post in thread 'One Piece Blue Planet Calc Revisions'
    https://vsbattles.com/threads/one-piece-blue-planet-calc-revisions.189096/post-7605254

    To avoid cluttering the thread, I did notice your response to KingTempest’s counter argument’s having some scans refusing to register on Imgur.

    “I don't think it is the case that the individual island's micro-climates will necessarily be visible from the perspective of the panel in question. For example, in these panels we can see that there are clouds directly over Alabasta, yet from the further-zoomed out panel we can't see those clouds at all and only see the ones closer to the perspective of the panel. It shows that details that are visible from a zoomed-in perspective won't necessarily be included in a zoomed-out perspective. Like the city visible here not being visible anywhere here.”

    Some links are broken here.

    Also due to issues with Igmur, there was attempts to find more reliable options in the event of Igmur acting up in this thread here:

    Damage3245
    Damage3245
    Thanks. It's frustrating Imgur is having so many issues. I'll re-upload those soon.
    HammerStrikes219
    HammerStrikes219
    You are welcome.

    Edit: Remove the recommendation since it is redundant
    Hello,

    Could i get a staff opinion about this thread? Its about applying accepted calculations, but its a niche verse so I dont think im getting any staff votes unless i keep proactively asking

    I've already got one so hopefully one more should allow it to be passed?
    Thank you
    Hey, can you please review and put your input my crt regarding a verse's downgrade? This thread is essentially about trying to remove some speed calcs by showing how dangerous guns and bullet-speed is in the verse. While the presentation (and words) aren't the prettiest i, i agree but i tried my best to make concrete arguements, I think it has some good points, so please evaluate this crt if possible..



    Here it is: https://vsbattles.com/threads/downgrading-the-best-mhs-verse-killer-peter.188800/page-2#post-7592165



    This thread needs a few mod aprovals
  • Loading…
  • Loading…
  • Loading…
Back
Top