This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
I don't see what that has to do with us not seeing the actual punch. Do you think that Georg is throwing the punch as he is talking? If not can you show in which panel we see him punching?
That's a fist being prepared for an attack - but Selene smashes him into the ground seemingly before he can do anything more than that. Like how you or I can ball up our hands into a fist and draw back our arm to get ready to throw a punch - but then someone who's faster can sucker-punch us in...
How so? I don't see any indication of that from the pages of the manga.
The point that I raised is that we never see Georg start his attack. So we have no confirmation that he "lunged first".
Correct me if I'm wrong but Floxy's post that you replied to there didn't say she raised her arm while he was still speaking. Just that she did it before he could unleash his attack.
So it'd be a situation where they didn't attack at the same time, but she attacked first.
How much time does he need for him to have been able to react and dodge out of the way?
Also, I don't think I said anything about her lifting her arms up before he finished talking.
I mean, she let him speak in the first place. I don't think anyone insinuated that she waited an unusually long time after he finished speaking. To me it seems that the moment he finished speaking, she unleashed her attack, and we don't see him do his attack at all.
Likewise I don't see how the interpetation that they made simultaneous attacks is an ironclad assumption either.
In the case of equal interpretation, the calc could be accepted as "possibly" rating if we're unable to find a better solution or if we don't get more input from other Calc Group...
I need to see more evidence for Accelerated Development for Garra as opposed to this just being development. Rasa stating Gaara's sand has gotten stronger can just mean that Gaara is trying harder than before if there's no other context.
Not to be an automatic nay-sayer but looking at the feat here, and analyzing this explanation regarding the assumptions of the calc:
I don't see anything in that page that shows that he actually started throwing a punch in the first place before Selene flattened him into the ground.
Well, we'd need a CRT anyway to determine any changes to justifications/ratings, etc. A Calc Group thread like this should just be about which version of a calc should be used, and whether a calc should be removed; not about altering the profiles themselves.
I think we're waiting for Chariot's proposed method to be put in a blog and evaluated, then we'll a better list of choices to pick from for evaluating the feat.
The Kaido calc will be removed but best handled in a separate CRT once this whole thread is finished.
@MonkeyOfLife I'm still not sure about your explanation, but one thing I have to note is that your explanation doesn't line up with the original calc. This is the description from the original calc that KT's Marco calc is based on:
"Moved horizontally in a 180 degree spin", essentially.
Not...
I'm not denying that there's more to Marco's movement in order for him to have gotten out of the way; but it doesn't look like a 180 degree rotation around any point is the correct method for calcing Marco's movements here.
@CloverDragon03 I guess it's down to how you interpret "other instances" here but to me Marco dodging out of the way of Queen's laser and King attacking Marco are two different instances.
If you calc a character's speed when he dodges a bullet during a fight, and then another guy shows up and...
Issue with Marco's Calc
I'll start by addressing what I believe to be a flaw in the original calc for Marco.
Essentially the calc is for the movement of the tips of Marco's wings as he rotates to dodge Queen's laser; if you think of Marco's wingspan (8.6516666666667 m) as being the diameter...
I initially wasn't going to comment on this but I've been looking into the calcs and I think there seems to be a problem here, so I'll prepare an analysis to address this and see what other people think.
(And in case anyone is wondering, the issue isn't possible calc stacking)
EDIT: Will have...
It's still very generously assuming a travel in a completely straight line with only 4 hours of rest per day.
I don't think it's worth changing the size of the Naruto planet over this.
We all already know this. A fictional world doesn't have to be literally Earth to be assumed to have Earth-like qualities as the default.
There is no indication that this is caused by or related to the size of the planet.
Not sure what relevance this has.
The tallest mountains on Earth can...