• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Removing Acheron + izumos history EE that's been promised 3000 years ago

Status
Not open for further replies.
Zanesucksatlife said:
Ok then history wasn't erased.
If the fact theirs still documents + logs of said place then it's not EE.
+ Everything in the CRT addresses everything you're arguing against.
I planned this out thoroughly , was lowk expecting these arguments
Izumo's history is all but lost in the modern day.
Word: Lost not erased
History EE is erasure on all 3 points,
No one in HSR (as of right now) has HGR and can erase from history EE.

More over, what you're saying is already addressed in the CRT.
Click to expand...
Genuinely what are you talking about? I am LITERALLY ARGUING against ALL of your "evidence" in my own CRT. This is really annoying.
 
All you did was copy paste mbpoop's points from his own CRT and applied them here when my own thread is arguing against them 😭😭😭
 
Also, as for the relic set AGAIN, those things are extrapolated and simulated in the SU. This set is literally a coalesence of data gathered from all the historical records left in order to reconstruct it. It proves nothing. It's pretty much a highly educated guess.
 
Nighting4l33yes said:
Acheron survived which is why she is resistant to it and she became acausal due to it.
Click to expand...
Acheron is not acausal. But thats not the point of this crt (btw type 4 doesnt save you from history EE)
Nighting4l33yes said:
The records 1) Aren't mentioned to BE from Izumo 2) The records could have been created by History Fictionologists afterwards 3) The records could have just survived. 4) The records could be mystical in nature and thus survive.
Click to expand...
1. The records are from izumo why wouldnt they be about izumo?

2. Parts 2-4 present uncertainty. You yourself dont know where these documents are from or how they survived izumo’s erasure. So i ask, why do we even index it?
There is more evidence suggesting that these scrolls and observations are from Izumo than them Being fake.

Also how do you “just survive” if your history is being erased from the point of origin?

Nothing hints at these documents being mystical in nature either.
 
Nighting4l33yes said:
Genuinely what are you talking about? I am LITERALLY ARGUING against ALL of your "evidence" in my own CRT. This is really annoying
Click to expand...
Ok
And the evidence in the CRT speaks for itself. It's not history EE
Nighting4l33yes said:
All you did was copy paste mbpoop's points from his own CRT and applied them here when my own thread is arguing against them 😭😭😭
Click to expand...
Lmao???
That's a new one that's never getting proved either way
Nighting4l33yes said:
Also, as for the relic set AGAIN, those things are extrapolated and simulated in the SU. This set is literally a coalesence of data gathered from all the historical records left in order to reconstruct it. It proves nothing. It's pretty much a highly educated guess.
Click to expand...
It proves nothing and is a highly educated guess.
Ok so prove that it's proving nothing and it's them guessing,
Relic sets in star rail have hidden lore which is canon, why it's hidden
 
Mbpoops said:
Acheron is not acausal. But thats not the point of this crt (btw type 4 doesnt save you from history EE)
Click to expand...
She is. I am aware its why she has history EE res.
Mbpoops said:
1. The records are from izumo why wouldnt they be about izumo?

2. Parts 2-4 present uncertainty. You yourself dont know where these documents are from or how they survived izumo’s erasure. So i ask, why do we even index it?
There is more evidence suggesting that these scrolls and observations are from Izumo than them Being fake.

Also how do you “just survive” if your history is being erased from the point of origin?

Nothing hints at these documents being mystical in nature either.
Click to expand...
1. Why are there xianzhou files in herta space station? Idk ppl travel and wanna learn about shit? You okay?
2. Obviously? We can't know anything for sure when enigmata is involved?

You survive by having causality manip resistance.
 
Nighting4l33yes said:
She is. I am aware its why she has history EE res.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Now what about this has anything to do with acausality?
Nighting4l33yes said:
1. Why are there xianzhou files in herta space station? Idk ppl travel and wanna learn about shit? You okay?
Click to expand...
? This doesnt tackle my point
Nighting4l33yes said:
2. Obviously? We can't know anything for sure when enigmata is involved?
Click to expand...
Ok so we dont know and my question still hasnt been answered, why do we index it?

Of course im just being a bit of a jackass, we do know because the relic set is literally about izumo and these files are canon in lore so yes we do know they are connected to izumo.
Nighting4l33yes said:
You survive by having causality manip resistance.
Click to expand...
So you admit its just causality manip resistant and no acausality ok though this isnt important to this thread so i wont respond to any more acausality slop
 
I kinda understand why Nighting seems frustrated, except for the matter of whether this CRT should've been posted or not, which I am neutral on, I agree with the CRT, it does make sense although I'm not knowledgeable on the verse
 
genuinely what are u talking about.
Mbpoops said:
So you admit its just causality manip resistant and no acausality ok though this isnt important to this thread so i wont respond to any more acausality slop
Click to expand...
how do you think you become acausal. like actually.
 
SuperNova55555 said:
On that note, you can put me up for agreeing with partial erasure of Izumo’s history. Whether that qualifies as full-on EE or not via the standards I’m not sure.
Click to expand...
According to vietthai the current standards say it has to be full erasure from past present and future to qualify. Im personally not against partial erasure but standards and such

Based on our wiki standard, history erasure entails the erasure of all points in time, across the past, the present and the future, it is default assumption unless show otherwise
Click to expand...
 
Yeah, you will find that I do not have Clairvoyance. I'm reviewing this thread cause I was asked and know it exists.
 
The wiki is paraphrasing. Acheron's character story doesn't mention the Armed Archeologists coming across Izumo's remains or them exploring anything (there was literally nothing when they arrived), and its history being lost wasn't framed as consequence of how sudden it erasure was. The presence of Enigmata was also specific: a melody recounting how the world was destroyed by Acheron.
Unfortunately, the world has long vanished from the astral charts. The truth of history eludes us, and the Remembrance no longer exists. When the Armed Archaeologists arrived, the galaxy resounded solely with the melody of the Enigmata: Dark Sun's tears, rain's boundless outpour. Beneath faint curtain, the survivor departs from her shore. Her homeland, once saved by her, now by her hands erased... Invisible shadows ahead, her vision encased.
Click to expand...

Also, her character story directly mentions the Remembrance of Izumo no longer existing (which was changed from more ambiguous "no longer holds its place" that's in the OP's image) and based on Herta and Cyrene's account of the remembrance's role, I don't see how its not some form of history erasure when Remembrance is the very mechanism that holds the past and is a path that's fundamental to existence.

Herta: But if things continue that way, the branches grow endlessly, the leaves multiply, and one day the tree collapses under its own weight.
Herta: That is why there is a concept in biology called "lignification." Soft sprigs form a hardened shell and fuse with the trunk.
Herta: For the universe, that process is what we call "memory."
Herta: Under Fuli's record-keeping, the "past" becomes "memory." In the corners THEY forget, even the events of the "present" become fruit without roots.
Cyrene: So it is the opposite of the Erudition... One calculates what is to come, and the other holds on to what came before.
Click to expand...

Also, how is Izumo just having planar disprove the history EE just by having lore when the lore in question is this?

Izumo's history should have been a long flowing river, but it was severed in one cut, and all its past and future voided on emptiness' other shore. Did it never exist, and was it no more than a fabricated story? Did its histories never occur, and it ran aground on the beach of reverse causation? Was it yet another appalling experiment by Dr. Primitive, or was it a sign of the Voracity returning from the end of the Cosmos?

Only that pitch-black great sun knows the answer, yet THEY remain silent, never speaking.
Click to expand...
It being questioned if it ever existed at all and if its history ever occurred doesn't sound like it disproves disproves history EE, and such a thing wouldn't be asked if the information we the player know was just available in universe.

Granted I'm not terribly familiar with VS's standards, so if physical written records are a hard disqualifier in spite of the clearly more metaphysical stuff going on then so be it I guess. Also hope this wasn't too bad for a first post.
 
Cassette95 said:
Also hope this wasn't too bad for a first post.
Click to expand...
Everyone starts from somewhere.

This thread however is probably not passing anyway. It's a copy paste from another thread with repeated arguments and half-truths that I have already dispelled in my own thread that should take priority over this one and if it passes, gives this one no reason to exist.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, this isn't History EE, you need to full erase something from all point of time, not partially removing something past and future only, leaving the present intact. Also EE is existence erasure, history EE is that you erasw the history itself and the existence tied with it to make them disappear. Somehow Izumo still physicallg exist is an anti-feat against EE in the first place, let's alone History EE, unless you have proof that Izumo was already erased and somehow existing in a nonexistent state, but evidently it seem like it still exist normally and only its past and future was lost

At best i can see causality and fate erasure that almost do nothing in a match, decorative abilities
 
Vietthai96 said:
Yeah, this isn't History EE, you need to full erase something from all point of time, not partially removing something past and future only, leaving the present intact. Also EE is existence erasure, history EE is that you erasw the history itself and the existence tied with it to make them disappear. Somehow Izumo still physicallg exist is an anti-feat against EE in the first place, let's alone History EE, unless you have proof that Izumo was already erased and somehow existing in a nonexistent state, but evidently it seem like it still exist normally and only its past and future was lost

At best i can see causality and fate erasure that almost do nothing in a match, decorative abilities
Click to expand...
Before voting here, can you take a look at my thread that was made 3 days ago and tackles this issue already? Normally, making this thread shouldn't even be allowed since mine hasn't concluded.

vsbattles.com

Acheron's Acausality and Stuff

Before getting into the actual evidence, I want to clarify something regarding previous discussions around Acheron and Type 2 Acausality because a large portion of the disagreement stemmed from an extremely strict interpretation of Type 2 that even prior Acausality revision threads and many...
vsbattles.com vsbattles.com
and the tldr here and here
 
Vietthai96 said:
Yeah, this isn't History EE, you need to full erase something from all point of time, not partially removing something past and future only, leaving the present intact. Also EE is existence erasure, history EE is that you erasw the history itself and the existence tied with it to make them disappear. Somehow Izumo still physicallg exist is an anti-feat against EE in the first place, let's alone History EE, unless you have proof that Izumo was already erased and somehow existing in a nonexistent state, but evidently it seem like it still exist normally and only its past and future was lost

At best i can see causality and fate erasure that almost do nothing in a match, decorative abilities
Click to expand...
i promise I wont send you any more honkai crts for 2 months
 
Nighting4l33yes said:
Everyone starts from somewhere.
Click to expand...
Thanks.

Vietthai96 said:
Somehow Izumo still physicallg exist
Click to expand...
It doesn't though? Its completely gone without a trace.

Acheron says it the whole world was erased:
Acheron: Come to think of it, I didn't even get a chance to formally introduce myself...
Acheron: Simply put, I'm a Self-Annihilator who was cursed by the Nihility. My hometown was destroyed a long time ago, and the whole world was erased beneath THEIRIX, the Nihility shadow.
Click to expand...
The Izumo Planar:
The existence of the two planets instantly evaporated, disappearing into nothingness.
Click to expand...
Acheron's character story II:
Unfortunately, the world has long vanished from the astral charts.
Click to expand...

The mere fact that its questioned if it was eaten by voracity or if it ever existed at all should preclude a physical planet, even in ruins, being present. It doesn't exist in the present in any capacity.
 
Acheron: Simply put, I'm a Self-Annihilator who was cursed by the Nihility. My hometown was destroyed a long time ago, and the whole world was erased beneath THEIRIX, the Nihility shadow.
Click to expand...

The existence of the two planets instantly evaporated, disappearing into nothingness.
Click to expand...

Unfortunately, the world has long vanished from the astral charts.
Click to expand...

At most just is just normal EE, which would explain why they still have scrolls and historical records of the planet. this also is kinda a pointless topic because it has very little to do with type 4 acausality

Edit: im a dumbass this is a whole different thread. but yea this is just normal EE

Also welcome to the forum
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Mbpoops
  • Locked
Acheron does NOT have acausality type 2
5 6 7
Replies
255
Views
11K
Mbpoops
Mbpoops
Nighting4l33yes
Acheron's Acausality and Stuff (NEED STAFF VOTES PLEASE)
4 5 6
Replies
220
Views
13K
Nighting4l33yes
Nighting4l33yes
Nighting4l33yes
Self-Annihilator Additions
Replies
19
Views
1K
Nighting4l33yes
Nighting4l33yes
AlipheeseXIV
This was Promised 3000 years ago
2
Replies
61
Views
4K
AlipheeseXIV
AlipheeseXIV
Mbpoops
i lack space but i am space? what am i truely? IX NEP aspects removal
2
Replies
60
Views
3K
Emirp sumitpo
Emirp sumitpo
Back
Top