• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Punishing: Gray Raven Tier 1 CRT

Status
Not open for further replies.

AlipheeseXIV

He/Him
Messages
3,296
Reaction score
1,803
This CRT will be split into 2 parts, and is not a continuation per se but directly related to this previous CRT. As the title implies, this CRT will be me making an argument for why Punishing: Gray Raven should be tier 1. This CRT will be my first second ever tier 1 CRT so please bear with me. Now that the PGR verse has been made, with the profile of Rosetta down the next step is the implementation of verse specific abilities, with those being Construct Physiology & Punishing Virus respectively. Construct Physiology should be quite simple and easy, that is until we get to the Omega Frames, originally I had thought to just release the page in the state it had previously been in. However, with the ramifications that the higher dimensionality of the virus has on the verse it gets a bit hectic. Since the Omega Frames are capable of cleansing the virus even in areas such as the Hetero Tower where the concentration of the virus is at an all time high. From this a few things need to be made to properly flesh out all these pages as they piggy back off each other, but I will separate these threads. If you want the link to check out the verse specific abilities & UES based things, please click here. Without further ado I will now begin.

The general scaling is as follows, Ishmael is the current peak of the verse. Being a Higher Dimensional entity above Lee Hyperreal. With Lee having transcended beyond time and dimensions. Making him a higher dimensional being capable of freely manipulating "all universe's" while also granting him travel across the spacetime-continuum. As it is stated time has a "boundless array of possibilities", with Lee having experienced countless sunrises and sunsets as well as all versions of himself throughout all universe's being in "an infinite loop" and there being "infinite futures".

Once Lee passes the initial trial and manages to reach the gate, he's pulled into a completely different world, a distorted dimension. Where "the concepts of beginning and end do not exist". And another following statement about "beings who dwell in a higher dimension" is made. With the Watcher (Ishmael) even needing to transform this space into something Lee can comprehend, which is important because "the summit" is in fact a gateway to a higher dimension. One already above this Lee, who at this point should be at least L1C for transcending beyond time and dimensions as I showed earlier, as well as being able to reach this summit which is later confirmed to be the true test hidden by the towers "rules and logic" as he was previously unable to even interact with or enter this space until he passed all the trials. Which just supports the summit being higher D (I will touch up more on that later).

As he's above all the universes and dimensions up until this point, this would mean that the watchers would scale an entire higher dimension above both him and the summit naturally. As they are literally what created the tower in the first place, to test humanity and the virus. If for some odd reason you're still skeptical this far in, there is yet another scan confirming that Ishmael is beyond the dimensions as she requires a literal avatar that can travel in lower dimensions to even interact with Lee who's at the summit. Having "projections who can travel in lower dimensions" is also noted to be an extremely rare ability that only a small portion of Watchers possess. She then states their true goal is to watch and witness "the real future among all possibilities".

Lee then defeats the primal projection, which is the watcher's projection. Now, while the primal projection is naturally not as powerful as Ishmael's true form (as it has already been stated to be a lower dimensional projection of herself), we can at least confirm that it is comparable if not superior to Lee, as he's died countless times to it and only managed to defeat it after millions of years if not more, only defeating it through the use of Acausality Type 3 granted to him by the tower. Finally, after beating the projection and being qualified by Ishmael herself as someone worthy she gives him an option to "pass through the gate" stating that if he doesn't do so and decides to reject godhood he will forget everything that happened, lose all his powers and all that transpired would be erased from history.

This then circles back to my earlier statement about the summit being even higher in dimensionality to Lee who was already L1C prior to reaching this summit. As it's clearly stated by Ishmael, that if he were to go through the gate he would be qualified to step into "the wider world" and "choose his perfect world" as shown in the scan above. It also implies that merely by entering the summit he had already become a higher dimensional being incapable of traveling to lower dimensions, as he needed Ishmael's help to return to the proper world. Which ties in perfectly with the previous scan mentioned here stating that only an extremely small portion of Watchers are capable of creating projections who can travel to these lower dimensions.

The ramifications of this are not made clear until much later in the story when Ishmael becomes a playable character with her own story chapter, however since it's still untranslated and likely will not be out for months it wouldn't work as evidence. I do however, hope I was able to convey why Lee, the Hetero Tower & The Primal Projection should be at least 1C with Ishmael being higher. To summarize in an easy to understand manner;
Tower (5D)
Gate (6D)
Ishmael (7D)

Agree:
Neutral:
Disagree:
 
Last edited:
The general scaling is as follows, Ishmael is the current peak of the verse. Being a Higher Dimensional entity above Lee Hyperreal. With Lee having transcended beyond time and dimensions. Making him a higher dimensional being capable of freely manipulating "all universe's" while also granting him travel across the spacetime-continuum. As it is stated time has a "boundless array of possibilities", with Lee having experienced countless sunrises and sunsets as well as all versions of himself throughout all universe's being in "an infinite loop" and there being "infinite futures".
I don't think Lee meets the bar here. Being "beyond time and space" means nothing; it could easily refer to characters who can manipulate time at will or even time travelers.
Once Lee passes the initial trial and manages to reach the gate, he's pulled into a completely different world, a distorted dimension. Where "the concepts of beginning and end do not exist". And another following statement about "beings who dwell in a higher dimension" is made. With the Watcher (Ishmael) even needing to transform this space into something Lee can comprehend, which is important because "the summit" is in fact a gateway to a higher dimension. One already above this Lee, who at this point should be at least L1C for transcending beyond time and dimensions as I showed earlier, as well as being able to reach this summit which is later confirmed to be the true test hidden by the towers "rules and logic" as he was previously unable to even interact with or enter this space until he passed all the trials. Which just supports the summit being higher D (I will touch up more on that later).
Ismael being HDE is fine by me, given the statement that he is a higher-dimensional entity who interacts with lower dimensions using projections and cannot be comprehended by lower-dimensional beings. Tho, Lee again do not have enough evidences of being hde, Ishmael clearly say this is "dimensional border humans can reach" and also that Watcher transformed this space just so Lee can comprehend it. So it clearly doesn't hint towards Lee having anything like hde.

I can see Ishmael being 5D, but that's about it. Also, just having HDE doesn’t grant Tier 1. Let me know if I missed something, as I’m not familiar with the verse.
 
The general scaling is as follows, Ishmael is the current peak of the verse. Being a Higher Dimensional entity above Lee Hyperreal. With Lee having transcended beyond time and dimensions. Making him a higher dimensional being capable of freely manipulating "all universe's" while also granting him travel across the spacetime-continuum. As it is stated time has a "boundless array of possibilities", with Lee having experienced countless sunrises and sunsets as well as all versions of himself throughout all universe's being in "an infinite loop" and there being "infinite futures".
The only thing from this portion that I could say kinda gives the argument for 5d is the transcend time and dimensions statement but I'd say you'd need more there because otherwise this sounds like Solid 2-A to me

Otherwise Reiner kinda sniped me mid typing stuff but yeah the Gate and Ishmael being 5d I do personally feel could have some grounds to stand on for maybe a possibly 5d rating if we do believe this just goes beyond just having HDE alone since Ishmael clearly does scale above him beating the Lee guy countless times with his avatar and being someone who could allow others to ascend to having HDE as well but that could just be power bestowal as well hence why I say maybe possibly works
 
I don't think Lee meets the bar here. Being "beyond time and space" means nothing; it could easily refer to characters who can manipulate time at will or even time travelers.
That's true, but with the context being used it should be taken as literal. To further support my point though, the Tower which Lee uses comes from the same dimension as Ishmael, and is itself also a projection. Lee transcending the spacetime continuum through the Tower should make him at least 5D (6D post Gate since the Gate is essentially the peak of the projected Tower).

Here are some statements saying things such as there being "a boundless array of possibilities" with these possibilities also transcending the confines of his world. As well as another statement of him experiencing "countless sunrises and sunsets" and the other statements of there being infinite futures and stuff I already went over at the start of the thread. I do understand, and 100% agree simply being beyond time and space doesn't mean much without further support or evidence, but I do think due to these example and the nature of the Tower itself that taking the statement as literal should be adequate.

Tho, Lee again do not have enough evidences of being hde, Ishmael clearly say this is "dimensional border humans can reach" and also that Watcher transformed this space just so Lee can comprehend it. So it clearly doesn't hint towards Lee having anything like hde.
Yeah, I can understand how you would come to this conclusion. Lee's evidence of HDE primarily comes from the Tower itself, as once again it does have HDE and transcends the spacetime-continuum, with him becoming the owner of the Tower, it would simply give it to him by extension. Thus, as the Tower naturally exists dimensionally above the worldline, that would at bare minimum make it 6D (as stated in this scan here)
I can see Ishmael being 5D, but that's about it. Also, just having HDE doesn’t grant Tier 1. Let me know if I missed something, as I’m not familiar with the verse.
For further clarification since I know not just you, but many people on the wiki aren't familiar with the verse.

The Universe = 4D (I think this is pretty clear cut and simple)
The Worldline = 5D (I also think this is pretty simple)
The Tower = 6D (as it is dimensionally above the Worldline at least it's projections would be this high, which directly scales to Lee as his feats are all a result of the Tower)
Ishmael = 7D (As she is above the aforementioned Tower)

I hope that was able to put things further into perspective, as I didn't properly go into too much detail at the start of the thread. I'm discussing it some more with the rest of the supporters on the discord but currently everyone but myself is busy. I'm not the most knowledgeable person on dimensional tiering, so I am awaiting some more feedback. However, that is more or less the conclusion we have reached with the nature of the series thus far.
 
The only thing from this portion that I could say kinda gives the argument for 5d is the transcend time and dimensions statement but I'd say you'd need more there because otherwise this sounds like Solid 2-A to me

Otherwise Reiner kinda sniped me mid typing stuff but yeah the Gate and Ishmael being 5d I do personally feel could have some grounds to stand on for maybe a possibly 5d rating if we do believe this just goes beyond just having HDE alone since Ishmael clearly does scale above him beating the Lee guy countless times with his avatar and being someone who could allow others to ascend to having HDE as well but that could just be power bestowal as well hence why I say maybe possibly works
I see, it seems you guys misunderstood the transcending time and dimensions statement as my base argument. It was just a supporting statement, not the actual core of my reasoning. I will elaborate more on this tomorrow, since like I said previously. All the other supporters are currently busy (and I myself have to sleep early) due to having some things I need to take care of in the morning. So, I will leave this until then
 
Lee transcending the spacetime continuum through the Tower should make him at least 5D (6D post Gate since the Gate is essentially the peak of the projected Tower).
Can you elaborate on this part? In what way he uses the tower? And if possible, can you provide as many scans as possible related to the "nature" of tower?
 
Can you elaborate on this part? In what way he uses the tower? And if possible, can you provide as many scans as possible related to the "nature" of tower?
Yup! I'm working on it rn with the people from the discord, we're gathering scans I'll send them and a reply shortly (sorry for not sending them last night I was pretty tired lol)
 
Ok, I had to do a fair bit of research in order to get a greater understanding of spatial and temporal dimensions, as well as see some other examples of how various verse's got into tier 1, sorry for the wait. I will start off by explaining and proving a few points. But before that, allow me to also apologize for my explanation on worldlines, turns out worldlines in the series function a bit differently and are higher than what I had previously stated, that's not something that'll be relevant in this discussion (at least, currently)

1. Proving the universe has infinite/boundless possibilities
This is simple, and I've already proven it in this scan here. Where it verbatim states that the Tower manifests the spacetime continuum and that the "possibilities" Lee can encounter transcend the confines of his world, as well as it stating that the possibilities encountered are boundless. (Sorry for repeating myself ik I've said this like twice already lol)

2. Timelines are infinite in amount
This is technically already proven in the previous point but can also be proven by this scan, where it states that Lee can utilize the computing power of "himself" in all universe's. As well as this scan, where it states there are infinite futures, this would naturally confirm that each individual version of himself, is from another universe, and as previously stated proves timelines are thus infinite and/or boundless with the previous scan for some extra support.

3. How the Tower and more accurately, how Lee fits into these feats
This can be proven through a few ways, no matter which angle we tackle this from every single feat displayed comes first and foremost from the Tower. Officially labeled the Hetero-Tower, and utilizing it's attributes is what allows Lee to do all this bonkers stuff in the first place. No Tower, means no feats for Lee. This Tower was as I previously said created by the higher dimensional beings known as Watchers (such as Ishmael). This is immensely important, because it means the Tower itself would scale to their general dimensionality.

As the Tower itself not only manifests the spacetime continuum, but would naturally have to exist above it as passing through the Gate would allow Lee to become a Watcher himself. As stated here in this scan, where Ishmael states Lee is now qualified to step into the wider world and choose his perfect world. It also functions as more proof that these feats are more a direct result of the Tower, rather than Lee as she clearly states that once he leaves he will lose his ability to interfere with time.

4. Giving proof for the general scaling
This is where the research I had to do came in handy, I only managed to study it a bit so do let me know if I make any mistakes or have any misconceptions. The universe itself would be 4D, as it has 3 spatial + 1 temporal dimension. Pretty simple, this doesn't need any actual scans I believe. The next thing is the Tower, which would be 5D, as it has an additional spatial dimension that cannot be ordinarily accessed without direct influence from the Tower itself. Which, apart from using Lee's previous feats of traveling throughout the spacetime continuum. There are other characters who have managed to get into the Tower, that being Luna and another character by the name of Selene, wherein there is another statement made saying one more step, and she can leap into another timeline.

This is pretty important, as it proves that the Tower's ability to do this is special and the only actual means of accomplishing this throughout the story (outside of being a Watcher). As, Selene is a being who is the physical embodiment of the Punishing Virus. How is this relevant you might ask? Well, it's relevant because Selene can actually already observe and analyze different timelines, but...is unable to actually travel between them. Which is incredibly consistent as the Virus has repeatedly shown the ability to perceive these timelines and change the past and in fact has a 4th dimension to it. And yet, despite this the Virus itself still needs to rely on the Tower for actual physical travel throughout these timelines.

Time within the Tower also does flow differently, which might give it an extra temporal dimension? I am not entirely sure, however from the research I conducted it seems that having extra temporal dimensions is inferior to having extra spatial dimensions when proving higher dimensional feats, so I will ignore it for now. Regardless, using the previously stated point of the Virus having a 4th dimension, and the Tower existing as a higher dimensional entity in comparison that should thus make it 5D.

As for the Gate, the only argument I have with it being higher dimensional to everything previously shown is the statement of Ishmael transforming it into something Lee can comprehend as well as her manipulating it freely, and not only being away from reality (which would be even further away than the lower levels of the Tower, as for context this scene happens after Lee starts messing around with the spacetime continuum), but him being able to see all past and future versions of himself being laid out clearly within this dimension. Which I will admit is not much, so if you guys disagree with that general line of thinking, totally fine. That means the Tower & Lee would just be 5D with Ishmael being 6D, at least in accordance to my argument. Otherwise if you guys do agree then that would simply make the Gate 6D and Ishmael 7D.

Hope that was able to give a bit more info on things, and sorry for the wait I had some errands to run.
 
Last edited:
Ok, I had to do a fair bit of research in order to get a greater understanding of spatial and temporal dimensions, as well as see some other examples of how various verse's got into tier 1, sorry for the wait. I will start off by explaining and proving a few points. But before that, allow me to also apologize for my explanation on worldlines, turns out worldlines in the series function a bit differently and are higher than what I had previously stated, that's not something that'll be relevant in this discussion (at least, currently)

1. Proving the universe has infinite/boundless possibilities
This is simple, and I've already proven it in this scan here. Where it verbatim states that the Tower manifests the spacetime continuum and that the "possibilities" Lee can encounter transcend the confines of his world, as well as it stating that the possibilities encountered are boundless. (Sorry for repeating myself ik I've said this like twice already lol)

2. Timelines are infinite in amount
This is technically already proven in the previous point but can also be proven by this scan, where it states that Lee can utilize the computing power of "himself" in all universe's. As well as this scan, where it states there are infinite futures, this would naturally confirm that each individual version of himself, is from another universe, and as previously stated proves timelines are thus infinite and/or boundless with the previous scan for some extra support.

3. How the Tower and more accurately, how Lee fits into these feats
This can be proven through a few ways, no matter which angle we tackle this from every single feat displayed comes first and foremost from the Tower. Officially labeled the Hetero-Tower, and utilizing it's attributes is what allows Lee to do all this bonkers stuff in the first place. No Tower, means no feats for Lee. This Tower was as I previously said created by the higher dimensional beings known as Watchers (such as Ishmael). This is immensely important, because it means the Tower itself would scale to their general dimensionality.

As the Tower itself not only manifests the spacetime continuum, but would naturally have to exist above it as passing through the Gate would allow Lee to become a Watcher himself. As stated here in this scan, where Ishmael states Lee is now qualified to step into the wider world and choose his perfect world. It also functions as more proof that these feats are more a direct result of the Tower, rather than Lee as she clearly states that once he leaves he will lose his ability to interfere with time.

4. Giving proof for the general scaling
This is where the research I had to do came in handy, I only managed to study it a bit so do let me know if I make any mistakes or have any misconceptions. The universe itself would be 4D, as it has 3 spatial + 1 temporal dimension. Pretty simple, this doesn't need any actual scans I believe. The next thing is the Tower, which would be 5D, as it has an additional spatial dimension that cannot be ordinarily accessed without direct influence from the Tower itself. Which, apart from using Lee's previous feats of traveling throughout the spacetime continuum. There are other characters who have managed to get into the Tower, that being Luna and another character by the name of Selene, wherein there is another statement made saying one more step, and she can leap into another timeline.

This is pretty important, as it proves that the Tower's ability to do this is special and the only actual means of accomplishing this throughout the story (outside of being a Watcher). As, Selene is a being who is the physical embodiment of the Punishing Virus. How is this relevant you might ask? Well, it's relevant because Selene can actually already observe and analyze different timelines, but...is unable to actually travel between them. Which is incredibly consistent as the Virus has repeatedly shown the ability to perceive these timelines and change the past and in fact has a 4th dimension to it. And yet, despite this the Virus itself still needs to rely on the Tower for actual physical travel throughout these timelines.

Time within the Tower also does flow differently, which might give it an extra temporal dimension? I am not entirely sure, however from the research I conducted it seems that having extra temporal dimensions is inferior to having extra spatial dimensions when proving higher dimensional feats, so I will ignore it for now. Regardless, using the previously stated point of the Virus having a 4th dimension, and the Tower existing as a higher dimensional entity in comparison that should thus make it 5D.

As for the Gate, the only argument I have with it being higher dimensional to everything previously shown is the statement of Ishmael transforming it into something Lee can comprehend as well as her manipulating it freely, and not only being away from reality (which would be even further away than the lower levels of the Tower, as for context this scene happens after Lee starts messing around with the spacetime continuum), but him being able to see all past and future versions of himself being laid out clearly within this dimension. Which I will admit is not much, so if you guys disagree with that general line of thinking, totally fine. That means the Tower & Lee would just be 5D with Ishmael being 6D, at least in accordance to my argument. Otherwise if you guys do agree then that would simply make the Gate 6D and Ishmael 7D.

Hope that was able to give a bit more info on things, and sorry for the wait I had some errands to run.
Alright. From the looks of it, I can see merit in Ishmael being 7D, considering that the multiverse is regarded as an insignificant 5D here per standards, and the Gate was said to be above everything previously shown. However, I have a few questions regarding the Tower and Lee, so I'll refrain from concluding anything about that until answered.

1. Does Tower contains this multiverse, timelines inside itself?
2. How Lee uses the Tower to travel around and transcend spacetime using it? If he's just being powered by the Tower and manipulate time and stuff then it wouldn't count as HDE. I should have been clear previously with my statement. "Beyond/transcends space-time" statements are meaningless from Dimensionality POV. Since it is common quote for characters who are capable of playing with time/timelines across several media. About gate, Ishmael himself said he has transformed the dimension into smth "earthlings" can comprehend. Which imposes further doubt over Lee being higher dimsional.
 
Alright. From the looks of it, I can see merit in Ishmael being 7D, considering that the multiverse is regarded as an insignificant 5D here per standards, and the Gate was said to be above everything previously shown. However, I have a few questions regarding the Tower and Lee, so I'll refrain from concluding anything about that until answered.
Gotcha, understood.
1. Does Tower contains this multiverse, timelines inside itself?
Yes it does, PGR treats higher dimensional constructs in a way wherein these things cannot actually descend to the lower dimensions and they require the use of avatars or more appropriately "projections" as Ishmael said in that 1 scan. The Tower itself does manifest the spacetime continuum (it's literally inside it) shown here on one of the games loading screens. There might be numerous folded spaces in it, which becomes more pronounced as as the tower rises until it peaks at the highest point. However, the Tower we see is actually just it's projection since again, it does come from the same dimension as Ishmael. Which is also why the loading screen scan above states that the optical observation might not be the reality.
2. How Lee uses the Tower to travel around and transcend spacetime using it? If he's just being powered by the Tower and manipulate time and stuff then it wouldn't count as HDE.
He is being powered by the Tower, but not in the conventional power bestowal sense. Yes, he is doing these things with the Tower's help directly but the Tower also allows someone to transcend along the spacetime. There is a scan about it here, though in typical gacha game writing fashion it is a tad bit dubious on it's own. Though I do believe since I've explained this much, it can be used as valid support and I'll even break it down a bit. Guided by an otherworldly force, he ascends along a web woven with the fabric of time and space. However, an invisible hand mercilessly yanks him down each time he nears the summit.

Him "ascending along a web woven with the fabric of time and space" would be in reference to him ascending as he gets further and further within the Tower. Which fairly enough, can be seen as it just referring to ascension in terms of upward movement rather than literal ascension, though with the earlier feats I am more inclined to see it as literal ascension but again, it can also be argued it's just referring to him ascending the tower because he has to "go upwards" or "higher". The invisible hand mercilessly yanking him down each time he nears the summit is in reference to ofc, the projection of Ishmael stopping him every time he nears the Gate.
I should have been clear previously with my statement. "Beyond/transcends space-time" statements are meaningless from Dimensionality POV. Since it is common quote for characters who are capable of playing with time/timelines across several media. About gate, Ishmael himself said he has transformed the dimension into smth "earthlings" can comprehend. Which imposes further doubt over Lee being higher dimsional.
Gotcha, I understand what you're getting at. Ishmael transforming the dimension into smth Lee can comprehend is a little finicky, as we don't really have a confirmation as to what she specifically meant. Ishmael tends to talk like this very often when she's in serious mode lol, however using the context of the scene itself. I would personally surmise that she's referring to transforming the dimension into something easy for him to visualize across all of spacetime due to his special abilities, (namely his type 3 acausality) since in an earlier scene not even like 4 paragraphs before that. It is noted that after the dimension is transformed, all versions of himself throughout time are clearly laid out within the dimension.

This is likely due to her "testing" civilization, since the Watchers do have an actual rule where they essentially have to be very non partial. As excessive direct influence has caused 3 previous civilization to be destroyed. She also has helped out the cast on multiple occasions when it doesn't completely break these rules, however yeah I can admit your skepticism is completely understandable. Apart from my own personal opinion and understanding of the scene, I will admit there's nothing super concrete so...if the general opinion of Lee lacking HDE is still present that's fine. Maybe I'll do a bit more research and see if I can pull any other scans, but I doubt it.
 
He is being powered by the Tower, but not in the conventional power bestowal sense. Yes, he is doing these things with the Tower's help directly but the Tower also allows someone to transcend along the spacetime. There is a scan about it here, though in typical gacha game writing fashion it is a tad bit dubious on it's own. Though I do believe since I've explained this much, it can be used as valid support and I'll even break it down a bit. Guided by an otherworldly force, he ascends along a web woven with the fabric of time and space. However, an invisible hand mercilessly yanks him down each time he nears the summit.

Him "ascending along a web woven with the fabric of time and space" would be in reference to him ascending as he gets further and further within the Tower. Which fairly enough, can be seen as it just referring to ascension in terms of upward movement rather than literal ascension, though with the earlier feats I am more inclined to see it as literal ascension but again, it can also be argued it's just referring to him ascending the tower because he has to "go upwards" or "higher". The invisible hand mercilessly yanking him down each time he nears the summit is in reference to ofc, the projection of Ishmael stopping him every time he nears the Gate.
Alright. I am fine with Tower being 5D given that multiverse and crack btw spacetime resides in it.

However, I am still iffy about Lee being higher dimensional due to Ishmael statement about transforming the gate for ease of earthlings but I can also see how that dimension was clearly not mere 3D space due to this scan. So I will be neutral on Lee. I can't make up my mind to be on any side regarding his dimensionality.
 
Alright. I am fine with Tower being 5D given that multiverse and crack btw spacetime resides in it.

However, I am still iffy about Lee being higher dimensional due to Ishmael statement about transforming the gate for ease of earthlings but I can also see how that dimension was clearly not mere 3D space due to this scan. So I will be neutral on Lee. I can't make up my mind to be on any side regarding his dimensionality.
Okay, that's cool with me. I guess we'll wait wait for another staff to give this a look and see what they think, yeah it is def not a mere 3D space. Regardless I am completely fine with foregoing Lee's HDE if others are also against it despite the reasoning, so to clarify. You agree with the Tower being 5D, Gate being 6D and Ishmael being 7D? Or do you agree with the Tower and Gate both being 5D and Ishmael being only 6D?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top