• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Billy and Stu vs Bob and Buck | 2-2-0

HorrorHistory

HorrorHistory

Messages
779
Reaction score
261
Billy and Stu were stealthily scavenging around the woods, chasing after a runaway victim. They stumble upon an old museum and wrongly conclude their victim has entered inside. They break in through the roof, where once inside, they stumble upon the twins Bob and Buck to deal with.

The Rules:
  • Billy and Stu have their Buck 120 knives, Bob and Buck have their Mallet & Electric Baton.
  • Each team starts about 15 meters away with a line of sight.
  • The Twins will be on Extreme Mode, giving them their better perks.
  • Speed is equalized.
  • Billy and Stu are 9-C of around 4.1KJ while Bob and Buck upscale from baseline 10-A and 9-C durability of around 3.9KJ via Granny.

Win Conditions:
  • Billy and Stu wins by incapacitating The Twins, though they can't permanently kill Bob and Bob due to their resurrection & immortality but they can still disable them.
  • Bob and Buck win by incapacitating or killing the highschool duo and feeding them to their Giant Hercules Beetle.

Billy and Stu: Ar1216789, PlutoValid (2)

Bob and Buck: Frieza_force_soldier_100, AThe1412 (2)

Inconclusive:
 
Last edited:
Billy and Stu can just speed blitz, no? Also, weakness makes them an easy target for Stu and Billy. I'm inclined to vote for Billy and Stu due to this.

Weaknesses: They somewhat lack self awareness and can be tricked, with Bob usually being the more gulliable of the two. Potentially lack healthy eyesight due to their tendency to walk into Granny's beartraps and their own laser traps and their inability to see through the Slendrina mask.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
HorrorHistory said:
Billy and Stu were stealthily scavenging around the woods, chasing after a runaway victim. They stumble upon an old museum and wrongly conclude their victim has entered inside. They break in through the roof, where once inside, they stumble upon the twins Bob and Buck to deal with.

The Rules:
  • Billy and Stu have their Buck 120 knives, Bob and Buck have their Mallet & Electric Baton.
  • Each team starts about 15 meters away with a line of sight.
  • The Twins will be on Extreme Mode, giving them their better perks.
  • Billy and Stu are 9-C of around 4.1KJ while Bob and Buck upscale from baseline 10-A and 9-C durability of around 3.9KJ via Granny.

Win Conditions:
  • Billy and Stu wins by incapacitating The Twins, though they can't permanently kill Bob and Bob due to their resurrection & immortality but they can still disable them.
  • Bob and Buck win by incapacitating or killing the highschool duo and feeding them to their Giant Hercules Beetle.

Billy and Stu:

Bob and Buck:

Inconclusive:
Click to expand...
due to my recent content revsion getting accepted billy and stu would be atleast 9kj and should just speed blitz them. voting billy and stu
 
Ar1216789 said:
Billy and Stu can just speed blitz, no? Also, weakness makes them an easy target for Stu and Billy. I'm inclined to vote for Billy and Stu due to this.
Click to expand...
Forgot to equalize speed, my bad on that.
PlutoValid said:
due to my recent content revsion getting accepted billy and stu would be atleast 9kj and should just speed blitz them.
Click to expand...
Bob and Buck's AP scale to about 1 Megajoule via their weapons which is enough to one-shot Billy & Stu, so they'd have to use their stealth to their advantage or try to disarm them which would be hard given the Twin's enhanced hearing and higher physical strength.
 
Well, Billy and Stu have the better stamina and teamwork (Buck is physically abusive to Bob), as well as likely having more common sense. However, Bob and Buck have much more AP, hearing, and lifting strength than them.

Overall, I'd give it to the Twins for their greater physicals and their hearing making it harder for Billy and Stu to sneak up on them.
 
Frieza_force_soldier_100 said:
Well, Billy and Stu have the better stamina and teamwork (Buck is physically abusive to Bob), as well as likely having more common sense. However, Bob and Buck have much more AP, hearing, and lifting strength than them.

Overall, I'd give it to the Twins for their greater physicals and their hearing making it harder for Billy and Stu to sneak up on them.
Click to expand...
counted
 
You can ask users from other Granny and Scream threads for opinions. I may do that later, but right now, I am kind of focused on making another match of my own. I suppose I can try to help with yours in-between.
 
B&B FRA. The odds of the Ghostfaces figuring out that their opponents can't die and must instead be incapacitated before they get oneshotted is rather low.
 
Billy and Stu are much smarter than Bob, but Buck is a different story. Also, while Billy and Stu are physically superior, B&B have the more powerful weapons. Just something to consider.
 
I think their weakness makes them easy targets for Billy & Stu. Billy & Stu have good teamwork and cooperation while Bob and Buck seem to lack that. They also seem to lack healthy vision and self-awareness, despite the AP difference they should take this in my opinion.
 
Ar1216789 said:
I think their weakness makes them easy targets for Billy & Stu. Billy & Stu have good teamwork and cooperation while Bob and Buck seem to lack that. They also seem to lack healthy vision and self-awareness, despite the AP difference they should take this in my opinion.
Click to expand...
That's your opinion and I will grant you that those are legitimate points. B&B lack good teamwork since Buck is abusive to Bob and Bob isn't afraid to hit back. Bob is also pretty dumb, and even Buck, despite his overall impressive intelligence, seems to lack self-awareness. If there are two solid advantages over the Twins that the Ghostfaces have, they are their better teamwork and self-awareness. Bob's low intelligence will be his biggest handicap in this fight.
 
Let us examine this closely:

Billy and Stu
  • Better stamina
  • Better teamwork
  • Both smarter than Bob
  • More self-aware
  • Better Striking Strength
Bob and Buck
  • Capable of one-shotting with their weapons
  • Better Lifting Strength
  • Buck is smarter than either Billy or Stu (albeit less self-aware)
  • Resurrection grants them a potential second chance if Billy and Stu kill them instead of simply incapacitating them at first.
If Bob and Buck didn't have those 9-B weapons, this would be a pretty easy match for the Ghostfaces considering their teamwork and better Striking Strength. The problem for them is that the Twins DO have those 9-B weapons, and considering their better Lifting Strength, it wouldn't be easy for Billy and Stu to just yank them out of their hands. If the match setup was different and the Ghostfaces had time to prepare, I'd probably vote for them since they would be able to outwit the Twins. In a random encounter like this though, I think the Twins would win out mainly because of their weapons and Lifting Strength.
 
Last edited:
Billy and Stu seem to be presumably smarter and a better duo compared to the twins. Although their stealth advantage won't be of much use when starting with a direct line of sight and the twins have enhanced senses, it is likely that they could only try to evade them, either in an attempt to deceive them and ambush them, which wouldn't be very difficult if the twins keep following one of the Ghostfaces while the other traps them.

I don't know how fast or effective the immortality of the twins is, but I believe a decent attack with the typical tactics of Ghostface could incapacitate them. Although the twins have a chance to shoot first and kill, I lean more towards voting for the common sense of Ghostface.
 
Pyro9278 said:
Billy and Stu seem to be presumably smarter and a better duo compared to the twins. Although their stealth advantage won't be of much use when starting with a direct line of sight and the twins have enhanced senses, it is likely that they could only try to evade them, either in an attempt to deceive them and ambush them, which wouldn't be very difficult if the twins keep following one of the Ghostfaces while the other traps them.

I don't know how fast or effective the immortality of the twins is, but I believe a decent attack with the typical tactics of Ghostface could incapacitate them. Although the twins have a chance to shoot first and kill, I lean more towards voting for the common sense of Ghostface.
Click to expand...
Their resurrective immortality allows them to come back 30 seconds after dying. Their bodies will disappear, and they will respawn out of thin air. They can still be incapacitated however. Tying them up or something should work. They could also be knocked out or wounded to the point of being unable to go on.
 
Frieza_force_soldier_100 said:
Their resurrective immortality allows them to come back 30 seconds after dying. Their bodies will disappear, and they will respawn out of thin air. They can still be incapacitated however. Tying them up or something should work. They could also be knocked out or wounded to the point of being unable to go on.
Click to expand...
Well, if Billy and Stu kill them for the first time, they will not only discover that they can resurrect, but they could also take the twins' weapons and use them back against them
 
Billy and Stu are way more agile than Bob and Buck. Using that to their advantage, they could maneuver around B&B's weapons and go in for the kill with their far superior striking strength. If B&B resurrect B&S could just kill them again. B&S can use their knowledge on horror movies and realize that B&B's resurrection is like a save a dollar Jason Voorhees and just incapacitate them by striking a nerve with their Buck 120's.
 
Pyro9278 said:
Well, if Billy and Stu kill them for the first time, they will not only discover that they can resurrect, but they could also take the twins' weapons and use them back against them
Click to expand...
I don't know if this can be dismissed as game mechanics, but when B &B are killed, their weapons vanish with them and reappear with them when they respawn. I'm not sure if Billy and Stu can take the weapons from them after killing them the first time. I actually had considered the possibility of them using the brothers' weapons against them, but trying to physically take them from the brothers could be difficult considering their superior lifting strength. The Ghostfaces may have better SS, but the twins have better LS. Trying to take Buck's taser from him in particular could be extra difficult since he could shock them with it when they went to try and take it from him. The twins and their weapons don't immediately vanish when they die. They take about 10 seconds to vanish, and another 20 to respawn. I suppose that would give the Ghostfaces a brief window to use one of the weapons on the other twin before they vanish.
 
Frieza_force_soldier_100 said:
I don't know if this can be dismissed as game mechanics, but when B &B are killed, their weapons vanish with them and reappear with them when they respawn. I'm not sure if Billy and Stu can take the weapons from them after killing them the first time. I actually had considered the possibility of them using the brothers' weapons against them, but trying to physically take them from the brothers could be difficult considering their superior lifting strength. The Ghostfaces may have better SS, but the twins have better LS. Trying to take Buck's taser from him in particular could be extra difficult since he could shock them with it when they went to try and take it from him. The twins and their weapons don't immediately vanish when they die. They take about 10 seconds to vanish, and another 20 to respawn. I suppose that would give the Ghostfaces a brief window to use one of the weapons on the other twin before they vanish.
Click to expand...
Wouldn't the Twins just get oneshotted by their own weapons and die then resurrect again?
 
AThe1412 said:
Wouldn't the Twins just get oneshotted by their own weapons and die then resurrect again?
Click to expand...
Not if Buck were attacked with Bob's mallet in spots like his limbs, as opposed to his head or the places his organs were. That would probably just break his limbs instead of killing him. You are probably right about Bob though, seeing as the electricity from Buck's taser would course through his entire body. Actually, fun fact, in two of the endings one of them attacks the other with their weapon.
 
Frieza_force_soldier_100 said:
I don't know if this can be dismissed as game mechanics, but when B &B are killed, their weapons vanish with them and reappear with them when they respawn. I'm not sure if Billy and Stu can take the weapons from them after killing them the first time. I actually had considered the possibility of them using the brothers' weapons against them, but trying to physically take them from the brothers could be difficult considering their superior lifting strength. The Ghostfaces may have better SS, but the twins have better LS. Trying to take Buck's taser from him in particular could be extra difficult since he could shock them with it when they went to try and take it from him. The twins and their weapons don't immediately vanish when they die. They take about 10 seconds to vanish, and another 20 to respawn. I suppose that would give the Ghostfaces a brief window to use one of the weapons on the other twin before they vanish.
Click to expand...
The point at which the Ghostface manage to trick and ambush the twins to kill them the first time and thus take their weapons without the need to struggle. This would be much easier than trying again with their SS. Also, I don't think the reappearance of the weapons counts for the twins; it’s probably a game mechanic since it doesn’t seem to have an apparent explanation, and the most logical thing is that it’s due to the game
 
Pyro9278 said:
The point at which the Ghostface manage to trick and ambush the twins to kill them the first time and thus take their weapons without the need to struggle. This would be much easier than trying again with their SS. Also, I don't think the reappearance of the weapons counts for the twins; it’s probably a game mechanic since it doesn’t seem to have an apparent explanation, and the most logical thing is that it’s due to the game
Click to expand...
I think that their weapons are supposed to immediately disappear with them when they die. If they're meant to last then why can't the Player pick them up and use them? It's the same situation with other characters in the series too like you not being able to pick up Granny's bat or Grandpa's cane after they're killed, though for Grandpa's case he can hold a key and a shotgun that the Player can use.
 
Since Horror isn't on here right now, I will update the votes:

B&B: Myself, AThe1412, noninho
B&S: Ar1216789, PlutoValid, Vyfourthaccount, EnnardTrap1987, Pyro9278, Narcissist12346946

Looks like we currently need but one more vote.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Peppersalt43
Ghostface vs RAT & CAT
Replies
35
Views
5K
Peppersalt43
Peppersalt43
ThePrimalHunter
Serial Killer Killer vs Guys Who Like Scary Movies (Thrillseeker vs Ghostface) (GRACE)
Replies
11
Views
2K
ThePrimalHunter
ThePrimalHunter
ShockingPsychic
Ghostface (1996) Vs. Ghostface (2011)
Replies
9
Views
3K
Jackythejack
Jackythejack
ShockingPsychic
Kevin McCallister Vs. Ghostface (Home Alone Vs. Scream)
Replies
18
Views
5K
CrackerVolley
CrackerVolley
ShockingPsychic
Ghostface In Hometown (Ghostface Vs. Kris and Susie)
Replies
21
Views
2K
ShockingPsychic
ShockingPsychic
Back
Top