-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
What the **** are these statements?
- Thread starter ShionAH
- Start date
Dragonite007
He/Him- 6,333
- 2,822
Maybe that say thats exist multiples timelines,
No idea
Maybe? Also we don't know how he came back, so If is High-Godly, will be Overtime
The Author erases flumptys immunity of plot and then erases him from the plot but Flumpty just kinda comes back. High-Godly? Idk.
- 9,145
- 9,508
What is the context for these statements?
- 9,145
- 9,508
Because they seem like discord convos and I wouldn't take those seriously at all.
- 9,145
- 9,508
Then yeah. Me personally I wouldn't take them seriously.
ShockingPsychic
He/Him- 2,962
- 1,071
I mean, it's basically just an interview done over Discord
- 9,145
- 9,508
Same. If this at least was done through a more official manner, then maybe I could entertain the idea. But as it stands, hard no from me.
- 9,145
- 9,508
Good for him!
- 8,931
- 10,126
No, that doesn't make any sense whatsoever and would definitely lead to the most slippery slope of all time. Just because a verse is comedic all of the time, doesn't mean that every single statement from the creator should be taken at face value. Literally why would an eldritch egg-shaped god randomly go to a strip club?
- 8,931
- 10,126
ShionAH
He/Him- 14,889
- 3,754
- Thread starter
- #18
Your point which is “Well maybe the creator was joking!” Ignoring the fact that those jokes are also canon since the verse is a literal joke. Anyways personal opinions dont really matter since theres no proof of him lying here
You're literally proving my point.
- 9,145
- 9,508
No. Already explained why.
You can ask the opinion from other staff. I will note, this entire revision requires at least 3.
Good luck. Unfollowing.
- 9,145
- 9,508
Abstractly_a_Protagonist
He/Him- 1,675
- 1,430
This is all kinda confusing, especially not knowing the context behind it all.
1. Canonly die but also canonically didn't die? Perhaps it implies that both outcomes are the possible canon ending for the said character (?)
2. Lack of context to give verdict.
3. Don't see how this could give a hax.
4. This one is interesting. As you say, author erases his immunity to the plot, thus letting Flumty died.
So basically "the plot demand" him to die, bypassing his immunity to the plot and thus die.
Author says he came back.
IMO, this is not High Godly since we don't know if his entire existence is erased.
To me, it only seems like a character who has lost its relevance to the plot and thus gets killed (losing immunity to the plot and dying to the plot), then came back.
I can see this as the resurrection (type 4 immortality).
1. Canonly die but also canonically didn't die? Perhaps it implies that both outcomes are the possible canon ending for the said character (?)
2. Lack of context to give verdict.
3. Don't see how this could give a hax.
4. This one is interesting. As you say, author erases his immunity to the plot, thus letting Flumty died.
So basically "the plot demand" him to die, bypassing his immunity to the plot and thus die.
Author says he came back.
IMO, this is not High Godly since we don't know if his entire existence is erased.
To me, it only seems like a character who has lost its relevance to the plot and thus gets killed (losing immunity to the plot and dying to the plot), then came back.
I can see this as the resurrection (type 4 immortality).
Abstractly_a_Protagonist
He/Him- 1,675
- 1,430
High Godly requires the erasure of body, mind, soul, and at least one fundamental aspect (could be concept, information, or plot).
What I got from the Flumpty grave is that he fell, his body cracked, and thus wasn't able to be put back.
To me, it reads like Flumpty just died normally. No mention of his soul and mind gets erased. His body is still left behind as well.
ShionAH
He/Him- 14,889
- 3,754
- Thread starter
- #26
"Such an aspect could be their place in the narrative, their history, their information (Type 2), their concept, et cetera"
Didn't the author literally use the plot manipulation to make his plot resistance and himself stop existing
- 9,319
- 3,300
We're kinda talking about the guy that gave a speech about the importance of life and then shot a guy in the face for no reason lol
- 9,319
- 3,300
These would probably be treated like those Twitter Questions, Friday Night Funkin' characters have a bunch of abilities due to Twitter asks (Like BF and GF's Mind Hax Resistance and Monster's Perception Manip), but I dunno what Staff actually think about that
- 9,319
- 3,300
Dimensional Travel into another universe is Interdimensional range
- 9,319
- 3,300
Yeah, that's interdimensional range
Low Multiversal Range is for like creating/nuking two universes and more
- 5,118
- 2,558
Disregarding either those can even be used or not:
1. Too vague for anything as we don't know how that worked at all, could mean a fake out death or some weird ressurection system, definitely not transduality lol, could even be immortality type 7 of being a undead counts as alive
2. Nothing, that just means flumpty is responsible for shenanigans.
3. Nothing, maybe acausality type 4 like equius, but that was done by equius status as a heir of void IIRC, in flumpty's case we are not sure if it is because of him or just how the system of causality works there, hell it could be a fancy way of saying that alternate timelines are canon.
4. He just died, he wasn't erased, him losing his immunity to plot means he could canonically die, which he did, by falling.
Immortality type 4 that takes a unknown time i guess
1. Too vague for anything as we don't know how that worked at all, could mean a fake out death or some weird ressurection system, definitely not transduality lol, could even be immortality type 7 of being a undead counts as alive
2. Nothing, that just means flumpty is responsible for shenanigans.
3. Nothing, maybe acausality type 4 like equius, but that was done by equius status as a heir of void IIRC, in flumpty's case we are not sure if it is because of him or just how the system of causality works there, hell it could be a fancy way of saying that alternate timelines are canon.
4. He just died, he wasn't erased, him losing his immunity to plot means he could canonically die, which he did, by falling.
Immortality type 4 that takes a unknown time i guess
- 4,357
- 2,346
Uhh... I dunno, the tone of the author makes this finicky as it is. It would be better to not tack these onto Flumpty so we don't wind up with members being confused over the nature of the statements.
- 4,357
- 2,346
Looney Tunes isn't logical either and back when we had it around, we made sure the showings and statements were legit and not bananas ridiculous. If we scrutinized that verse, we can scrutinize this one.
- 9,319
- 3,300
Flumpty already has Type 4 Acausality, so the third image could be used as support I guess
Abstractly_a_Protagonist
He/Him- 1,675
- 1,430
I agree with this notion.
Similar threads
