Genshin Impact Discussion Thread

[MSahla]

In Snezhnaya, those who brave the cruel cold follow their own laws of survival.
Every road guided by the light of the polestar will, in the end, lead to the same destination.

VA:
Paimon - Penelope Rawlins
Aether - Zach Aguilar
"The Jester" Pierro - Richard Tatum
"Childe" Tartaglia - Griffin Burns
"Marionette" Sandrone - Deneen Melody
"Regrator" Pantalone - J. Michael Tatum
"The Knave" Arlecchino - Erin Yvette
"The Rooster" Pulcinella - Dave B. Mitchell
Anastasya Feodorovna Snezhnaya - Lara Korba

 

[MSahla]

Anastasya/Tsaritsa's JP VA

 

[MSahla]

Anastasya/Tsaritsa's JP VA

WE FINALLY GOT KIRITO AND ASUNA IN GENSHIN

 

[Puppet43]

Livestream basically refuted the notion that moons as weapon refer to their authority rather than being actual weapons.

I mean, u can still damage by throwing a satelite to someone's face ngl

 

[Puppet43]

BTW FORTNITEVELER
THERE ONLY JOY AND HAPPINESS
BESIDE OF RANDOM TREE CLASHING WITH CRYO TRAVELER THEREFORE SCALING TO HIM

 

[Puppet43]

I mean, that's literally just Paimon who asked Nicole a help. Traveler on the other hand never ask anything nor want Paimon to ask Nicole to help them.

We are 6 years into the game... most of those 6 years statments were said by Paimon, so why only just now take her with precaution?

Clearly an outlier.

For it to be an outlier would need an already establish canon/lore
Think of something like if Sandrone actually could face god tiers with no explanation
Thats an outlier

A single showing that drastically exceeds a character's consistent portrayal requires corroborating evidence, not automatic acceptance.

Sahl, what "Consistent portrayal" has Mandragora beside Traveler post Nod Krai? Like tell me just one instance where my statment is false :

Mandragora has just faced Nod Krai Traveler

If u actually can find another instance of this plant, idk being low diffed by a Hilichurl then i would accept your vision of Mandragora not scaling to Traveler

If an Abyssal Herald can briefly contend with the Traveler, that only shows it can challenge the Traveler to some extent. It doesn't automatically prove equality. There's a thing called "Downscale." Many weaker opponents can delay, inconvenience, or pressure a stronger character without scaling 1:1 to them.

Dude, i never said Mandragora would scale 1:1, i just said same tier as in (Insert Attack Potency Tier Traveler would scale), like that was the plan, Downscaling Mandragora of Trav and Nicole not being equal who can extreme diff them

You're using the encounters themselves as corroboration, but that's circular reasoning.

Same could be said

Corroborating evidence would be additional feats, statements, or scaling from other characters showing Mandragora is genuinely at that level.

• Nicole being at aid, throwing her ult to a Mandragora?
• Traveler being concerned about Paimon's safety (Mind u the only time he got concerned of her safety was things such as Skofnungr, Gosoythoth)
• Paimon asking Nicole to lend help, as if she was worry about Traveler not being able to deal with it
• Their only feat be litterally fighting Traveler (This would be the same as seeing Arle low diffing Hydro Traveler and not accepting she is above him)

If the narrative says oh Mandragora monster is on this level so they can fight them, or Mandragora is strong enough to equally fight the Traveler, then I would accept that since it has a back up narrative to scale them to the Traveler.

The Mandragora has litterally the most straight foward scaling
X fights Y

Character A performs a feat of destroying a city and has City level durability. Character B lost a fight to Character A, yet still put up a considerable struggle, was able to harm Character A, and made Character A exert significant effort to defeat Character B. In this case, it's safe to assess that Character B also has City level Attack Potency and Durability.

Meanwhile, those things you mentioned(except that King and Queen and Oasis bug) have multiple independent lines of evidence supporting their scaling, whereas Mandragora's proposed scaling depends almost entirely on the very encounters you're trying to use as proof. That's precisely why they shouldn't be treated the same.

They dont, outside their boss fight they dont have any statments nor feats
Mandragora lvl statments

Wtf does "kill count" gotta do with them being major beings?

"5A Shade" when their biggest feat its terrorizing a town full of common visionless people

Not really.

Mmm, we gotta nerf Gosoythoth and all boss

Why are we even using values logic here instead of in-verse logic?

So again, why are they on same tier even do they are ligth work?

Okay? Does that mean Paimon's thinking = Traveler's thinking?

Yeah, Paimon doesnt know Traveler's power
At all, she is blind, deaf and mute she is ignorant to Traveler power lvl and she is just worriyng about a wall lvl opponent right? makes sense

 

[AsterReal]

I wonder where that lunar energy related to gravity comes from. I mean, it surely comes from the power of the Moon Goddesses. It’s probably the power that Aria used to control the tides.

 

[MSahla]

If something bad happen to Paimon in Snezhnaya, I would destroy my whole room. Dead ass serious.

 

[MSahla]

Now we just have to wait the Snezhnaya cast PV to drop. My prediction it would be next week's either Tuesday or Wednesday.

 

[MSahla]

Also, it was confirmed that the beams from Fagio (Sandrone's new robot) is a light beams. SoL Attack Speed Fagio.

 

[Natsuki012]

Also, it was confirmed that the beams from Fagio (Sandrone's new robot) is a light beams. SoL Attack Speed Fagio.

just being called a light beam is not enough to be SoL