Rule Violation Reports (New forum)

[MSahla]

This guy uploaded another CRT again..
https://vsbattles.com/threads/i-bel...-should-be-added-to-columbina-profile.191599/

He've been warned by @TWILIGHT-OP twice and @ActuallySpaceMan42 on his message wall, and he still didn't listen at all. This is like his 5th CRT he made even though there are currently 3 active genshin CRTs.

At this point, just ban him. Already warned 3 times, still didn't listen and keep uploading 5 Genshin CRTs in short timeframe, god knows if he aware that there are 3 active CRTs.

I suppose that we will likely have to give them a temporary warning ban then.

Yeah, I suppose there's not much choice if they literally won't listen otherwise.

What do our staff members here think? Should we lock all of their recent threads and give them a final warning, or apply a ban, and if so, how long should it be? 1 month or more?

Sorry for bumping this, But I think the staffs should do something about this immediately, to prevent them from doing the same thing again. Since no one has answered Ant's question yet, so it seems the penalty hasn't been implemented yet.

Sorry if this sounds unpleasant.

 

[Mr. Bambu]

Sorry for bumping this, But I think the staffs should do something about this immediately, to prevent them from doing the same thing again. Since no one has answered Ant's question yet, so it seems the penalty hasn't been implemented yet.

Sorry if this sounds unpleasant.

I'll apply a one month warning ban for you. I think Ant's proposal is fine, I just thought it was resolved.

 

[Antvasima]

Thank you for helping out.

 

[Makai641001]

You were the first one to be aggressive, in the way you're reporting Cursed for ("Honestly this is such an ass debunk, I can't believe you'd waste time writing it"). You are a staff member, and no matter how widely agreed upon something is, it falls to you to make an even greater effort to follow the rules. To me, it reads like you really didn't make an effort at all, here. You took every opportunity to denigrate and accuse the supporters of this verse. Even though I agree with the sentiments of your OP (without looking through the evidence too much), I think your behavior in this thread was demonstrably worse than either of the two you've reported. Being right cannot allow users to be rude. It simply cannot be.

Insofar as the toxicity end of this report goes, I do think action is warranted against Makai (posts like this really suck and shouldn't be tolerated), but I think you, M3X, behaved the worst on the thread, and started it. I'm neutral on action with Cursed, he definitely did say the "low IQ debunk" thing but given it was parroting one of the very first posts by M3X, and I think the worst post from the user (maybe calling M3X 13 years old and lacking reading comprehension is comparable, but eh), I find it hard to pursue hard action when the ball was already rolling several pages before they got there.

Regarding stonewalling: Makai posted here that they were going to sleep, at 1:13, and by 1:30, had sent a further 11 messages. However, it's not like he was the only one posting a ton at the time. In the same timeframe, DaReaperMan (who is not being accused here, for the record, I'm just using him by way of random example) posted 4, and this certainly isn't his own verse. Arkenis posted 5 times. I'm saying this to say that I think there is a realistic case to be made that Makai was stonewalling, but I think the more likely explanation is that he just believes what he's saying and was arguing on many fronts at the same time. A lot of users need to learn to reply to multiple people in one reply, but. It is what it is. I'd be in favor of a warning to just try to do so in the future, so that threads do not become clogged up. I don't find Cursed's actions to strongly resemble stonewalling.

End of the day, I think tensions rose unnecessarily high and everyone involved needs to take a break. Nothing on this site is this serious or worth getting upset over. It's a silly little website for talking about fictional characters, nothing more. Be good, have fun, etc.

Actual admins said they didn’t understand why my point wasn’t adressed, the thread wants to nuke a rating by focusing on one thing but completely leaving aside the justification for Chaos Arthur (Cath) being tier 4

I have an extra few hours of my own sleep in order to entertain something for the sake of it being completely out of point.

 

[StarShooter80]

CohesiveAlbatross244 has made several vandalisms you can see in the report thread from here and in the following messages, this is blatantly a troll account so they should to be banned.

 

[Antvasima]

CohesiveAlbatross244 has made several vandalisms you can see in the report thread from here and in the following messages, this is blatantly a troll account so they should to be banned.

I banned them, and reverted their remaining edits.

 

[FinePoint]

(posts like this really suck and shouldn't be tolerated)

Are you talking about the uwuspeak or the condescension?

Overall, I agree that both parties are sort of at fault for the general toxicity in this thread, and in recognition of that I don't think we necessarily have to hand out any punishments to anyone specific involved so long as it doesn't continue.

I'm not sure how to word this in a way that doesn't set a bad precedent, but actual substantive debate continued alongside the passive-aggressiveness, and in addition to the partial apologies which followed here, I at least think that this was just a debate which got far too heated as opposed to some form of bullying or intentional toxicity, if that makes sense.

I do think that a staff member should go in and comment on the thread itself if they haven't already, encourage civil discussion going forward, etc.

And just to recognize a bit of bias, I do think that if we push for warnings in relation to this incident we'd then need to get HR involved, and I don't think most people want to deal with that kind of hassle if we could civilly move on instead.

 

[Cursed_Copycat]

You were the first one to be aggressive, in the way you're reporting Cursed for ("Honestly this is such an ass debunk, I can't believe you'd waste time writing it"). You are a staff member, and no matter how widely agreed upon something is, it falls to you to make an even greater effort to follow the rules. To me, it reads like you really didn't make an effort at all, here. You took every opportunity to denigrate and accuse the supporters of this verse. Even though I agree with the sentiments of your OP (without looking through the evidence too much), I think your behavior in this thread was demonstrably worse than either of the two you've reported. Being right cannot allow users to be rude. It simply cannot be.

Insofar as the toxicity end of this report goes, I do think action is warranted against Makai (posts like this really suck and shouldn't be tolerated), but I think you, M3X, behaved the worst on the thread, and started it. I'm neutral on action with Cursed, he definitely did say the "low IQ debunk" thing but given it was parroting one of the very first posts by M3X, and I think the worst post from the user (maybe calling M3X 13 years old and lacking reading comprehension is comparable, but eh), I find it hard to pursue hard action when the ball was already rolling several pages before they got there.

Regarding stonewalling: Makai posted here that they were going to sleep, at 1:13, and by 1:30, had sent a further 11 messages. However, it's not like he was the only one posting a ton at the time. In the same timeframe, DaReaperMan (who is not being accused here, for the record, I'm just using him by way of random example) posted 4, and this certainly isn't his own verse. Arkenis posted 5 times. I'm saying this to say that I think there is a realistic case to be made that Makai was stonewalling, but I think the more likely explanation is that he just believes what he's saying and was arguing on many fronts at the same time. A lot of users need to learn to reply to multiple people in one reply, but. It is what it is. I'd be in favor of a warning to just try to do so in the future, so that threads do not become clogged up. I don't find Cursed's actions to strongly resemble stonewalling.

End of the day, I think tensions rose unnecessarily high and everyone involved needs to take a break. Nothing on this site is this serious or worth getting upset over. It's a silly little website for talking about fictional characters, nothing more. Be good, have fun, etc.

I appreciate this message, thank you. And I apologize for any comments I did make, as well as not really replying to multiple people per message. I gave up trying to do that because this site is unstable and constantly reloads, deleting replies I try to type So I try to keep them brief.

 

[Cursed_Copycat]

This I disagree with, I think you’re exaggerating since I did not attack the person but the argument, might still be unnecessary sure, but not worse than them. But I don’t mind that to dispute it, actions were taken in the end of the day, and the thread is now under control, even though it’s not the outcome I wanted (which is being staff only).

And this I think it’s just giving them an excuse for their behavior. When was Cursed’s first comment? Like page 5? 6? He didn’t even quote my rather ignorant comment, he quoted a regular comment of mine and said “low iq debunk”, he actually started that.

But as I said, I don’t mind the outcome, and actions were taken, anyway.

I simply read through the entire thread and responded when appropriate. Most of it were other’s counter arguments, some were mentioning your, imo, childish behavior, as you created the thread. We should be held to as high a standard as reasonably possible regardless of how irrelevant the topic because these arguments still reflect us as people and how we think/act.

 

[Okstrike]

Hello!

So on this thread, a group of people against the CRT randomly came along at around the 5th page and began derailing the thread with irrelevant comments which don't contribute to the CRT at all and also clowned on the supports of the CRT quite a few times. They've been doing this for about 3 pages and show no signs of slowing down even after multiple requests to stop, i would greatly apricate if staff could delete any derailing comments and maybe even give a warning if necessary

 

[ExcelsisBerny]

Hello!

So on this thread, a group of people against the CRT randomly came along at around the 5th page and began derailing the thread with irrelevant comments which don't contribute to the CRT at all and also clowned on the supports of the CRT quite a few times. They've been doing this for about 3 pages and show no signs of slowing down even after multiple requests to stop, i would greatly apricate if staff could delete any derailing comments and maybe even give a warning if necessary

You are the one who started with passive aggressive comments. If everyone then makes fun of you because of your attitude, that is your problem. No one is going to stay quiet

 

[Okstrike]

You are the one who started with passive aggressive comments. If everyone then makes fun of you because of your attitude, that is your problem. No one is going to stay quiet

My friend, what are you talking about? The derailment began with Nova telling his friend to ratio @Kebabbaro.1 after he told Nova to address his points or stop commenting meaningless things like a "" emoji in response to his comments, why do you bother twisting the story if all the evidence is there on the thread for staff to see themselves?

If you're taking about the overall tone of the thread being toxic, it's been like that since the very beginning and both sides we're, though technically Nova did start it by insulting us and calling us "suffocatingly obtuse"

But regardless on who actually started it, it does not in anyway justify organizing mass derailment of a thread

Also, a lot of the derailment was just completely irrelevant stuff, like, you guys we're on about Neoplatonism and LOTM at one point, so trying to paint it as a response to my "passive aggressiveness" is already disingenuous since most of it had no correlation with that

 

[ShinMaximillion]

Since I'm someone who's actively participated in that thread from the beginning.

I'd mostly point out how the derailment went on both sides for the mods. Primarily, though, I'd like to point out how crude language such as this

I'm going to be real with you chief, you genuinely like a 12 year old saying this; Toxic and his lapdogs just be calling ANYTHING they don't like "wank" without ever engaging open mindedly🫩

Calling a set of specific people, including those unrelated, such as I, Mgq and so forth, who didn't take part in any of the banter from the last few pages, equivalent to dogs and whatnot, despite the thread users' being lightly warned by @GrathOfLux before. It just doesn't sit right with me over such comments aimed at me or my friends, especially Toxic himself, who hates such notions, so I'll just report it here.

Anyway, the messages relating to the derailment of the very same user who's reporting this, starting on page 5

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7755091 (Here he talks about how it's always two to three mindless people liking the comments, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7755111 (Here, he just quotes something in a blank message for no reason, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7755249 (Here he posts some meme in response to a message of mine asking for more order and decorum, and more rebuttals rather than complaints and derailment, unrelated to the thread or my response)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756066 (Here he again brings up the irrelevant point of people liking the opposition's messages instead of him, once again, instead of making a response breaking down things for East like he said he would, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756092 (Here he posts some memey post about being jealous of PSW users getting more likes or whatever, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756267 (Here he posts a link to a Korean song on YouTube, and brings up some irrelevant drama of PSW offsite that I'm not particularly aware of, insisting that he'd ping the staff to delete the derailment messages while derailing himself, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756306 (Lashes out at people derailing the thread instead of pinging the mods like he said he would, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756332 (Says he has screenshots to prove some dumb drama offsite relating to PSW, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756339 (Repeats his point about having screenshots to prove dumb drama offsite relating to PSW, unrelated to the thread, and just clogging down the important messages)

Both sides of the "opposition" and supporters are responsible for the derailment; I'm not pointing out one group in specific. I'm not sure why okstrike kept bringing up PSW, Toxic and existent/non-existent drama irrelevant to the thread.

But I just thought it'd be nice to point out that the derailment wasn't particularly shown by one side, contrary to the same person dropping in the report over derailment. That being said, I'd appreciate it if the mods delete the messages, save for the important ones. I was thinking about asking the mods to delete the derailed messages anyway, since I wouldn't want the responses I, Nova, and others made to be clogged down.

 

[Mr. Bambu]

Hello!

So on this thread, a group of people against the CRT randomly came along at around the 5th page and began derailing the thread with irrelevant comments which don't contribute to the CRT at all and also clowned on the supports of the CRT quite a few times. They've been doing this for about 3 pages and show no signs of slowing down even after multiple requests to stop, i would greatly apricate if staff could delete any derailing comments and maybe even give a warning if necessary

I would say this comment was the first domino, even if it isn't so bad.

Some responses seem too quick to fly off the rip (here), but I'm willing to gloss over that seeing as they did not start it. I don't think they should have carried on, like so, but SuperNova555 also carried on and did so with less substance of actual debate. ExcelsisBerny's comments (starting about here) also really suck and also shouldn't be tolerated. It's just personal insults. Even if a CRT truly sucks (not saying this one does or does not, I don't care to look into it), you can't just farm it for likes by being a dick. If their points are awful, counter them and be done.

I'm not going to say that OkStrike (et al) aren't also doing it, but again, I find it really hard to judge it as harshly when they are being aggressed upon by lots and lots of other random users trying to farm likes. I can't fault them too much when they are being dogpiled like that.

I think SuperNova555 has a point to make, but they choose to act childish at every opportunity while making it. I would be in favor of at least a warning for their behavior, I find it pointlessly instigatory, even if they were otherwise engaging in debate (sometimes). ExcelsisBerry also should receive a warning for how significant their contributions to the discussion were. I would also issue a broad warning to everyone else involved (including Okstrike, and other CM supporters) to just knock it off. It's a CRT. It is not meant to bicker over. In theory it is meant for staff to evaluate. Bickering makes it even less likely that any staff will interact. Presuming all parties have the ideals of the wiki in mind, and are arguing in good faith, this means bickering is only ever a lose-lose.

 

[Okstrike]

Calling a set of specific people, including those unrelated, such as I, Mgq and so forth, who didn't take part in any of the banter from the last few pages, equivalent to dogs and whatnot, despite the thread users' being lightly warned by @GrathOfLux before. It just doesn't sit right with me over such comments aimed at me or my friends, especially Toxic himself, who hates such notions, so I'll just report it here.

One, i apologies for the lapdog message, but this isn't towards you or Mgq, why do you assume such when it's obviously meant towards the people who called the thread "power wank" and insulted it out of nowhere (Eg, Bern) without engaging with it at all?

Two, lapdog is a common metaphor for a lackey or yes-men, don't twist it's meaning to make it seem like i called them animals

Three, Grath wared everyone in general, so trying to report me over toxicity in response to your mates toxicity doesn't help your case

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7755091 (Here he talks about how it's always two to three mindless people liking the comments, unrelated to the thread)

this is in response to Nova derailing the thread by asking for people to like him, so i jokingly mention that its always the same people

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7755111 (Here, he just quotes something in a blank message for no reason, unrelated to the thread)

I quoted an earlier message where i called Nova out for insulted me instead of engaging with the thread, which is very relevant since it did this during the aforementioned derailment, essentially restating what i said earlier

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7755249 (Here he posts some meme in response to a message of mine asking for more order and decorum, and more rebuttals rather than complaints and derailment, unrelated to the thread or my response)

An obvious joke, and i was more or less asking what you where saying since i didn't seem clear, though it did seem like you where trying to satirize us telling people to respond instead of derailing the thread further

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756066 (Here he again brings up the irrelevant point of people liking the opposition's messages instead of him, once again, instead of making a response breaking down things for East like he said he would, unrelated to the thread)

Not irrelevant, East said he'll enjoy ratioing me when i respond to his points, so i said that inventible when you tell your friends to mass upvote yourself

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756092 (Here he posts some memey post about being jealous of PSW users getting more likes or whatever, unrelated to the thread)

Satirizing another guys comment about me allegedly being jealous that you guys were telling your friends to mass upvote yourselfs

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756267 (Here he posts a link to a Korean song on YouTube, and brings up some irrelevant drama of PSW offsite that I'm not particularly aware of, insisting that he'd ping the staff to delete the derailment messages while derailing himself, unrelated to the thread)

First part was a joke, second part i didn't bring up, i was responding to someone who did bring it up

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756332 (Says he has screenshots to prove some dumb drama offsite relating to PSW, unrelated to the thread)

https://vsbattles.com/threads/cthulhu-mythos-revision-the-big-one.189941/post-7756339 (Repeats his point about having screenshots to prove dumb drama offsite relating to PSW, unrelated to the thread, and just clogging down the important messages)

It seemed that Bern was calling me out for bullshit or something about PSW staff stalking harassing me off site, so i said i have of proof of it but don't want to further reinsituate the drama from months ago

 

[SuperNova55555]

Apologies for writing here, but I feel it is necessary since my name was brought up.

Hello!

So on this thread, a group of people against the CRT randomly came along at around the 5th page and began derailing the thread with irrelevant comments which don't contribute to the CRT at all and also clowned on the supports of the CRT quite a few times. They've been doing this for about 3 pages and show no signs of slowing down even after multiple requests to stop, i would greatly apricate if staff could delete any derailing comments and maybe even give a warning if necessary

Might I remind you that before all this debacle happened, this was the first thing said to me after rhetorically commenting about a contradiction in the oppositions argumentation:

Never ask a PSWiki user how to read a scan

Let's also not forget that you were awfully condescending when I said that I wasn't gonna engage with the topic any further and didn't wanna bloat it because I knew it was fruitless and a waste of my time:

Is it really because it's "no longer worth responding to," or are you just masking the fact that you haven't addressed the argument at all?

 

[Okstrike]

Might I remind you that before all this debacle happened, this was the first thing said to me after rhetorically commenting about a contradiction in the oppositions argumentation:

You were the first to act that way actually, you made lots of comments about us not having reading comprehension and holistic reading

Let's also not forget that you were awfully condescending when I said that I wasn't gonna engage with the topic any further and didn't wanna bloat it because I knew it was fruitless and a waste of my time:

As i mentioned, you insulted us and called us mentally slow (twice) before this, and you had already engaged with the thread when i said this, you can't just come on a thread to insult the OP, leave due to the fact you think the CRT is beneath you because you think it's bad, and then expect me not to call you out for it

 

[ShinMaximillion]

One, i apologies for the lapdog message, but this isn't towards you or Mgq, why do you assume such when it's obviously meant towards the people who called the thread "power wank" and insulted it out of nowhere (Eg, Bern) without engaging with it at all?

My statement in itself says, "It just doesn't sit right with me over such comments aimed at me or my friends, especially Toxic himself, who hates such notions, so I'll just report it here."

It doesn't really matter if your comment wasn't directed at me or MGQ, which is weird given your incessant targeting of PSW users and PSW staff, which you have a well-known history of. Supposing you don't mean me or MGQ, why would one assume that the people involved are Toxic's (PSW founder) lapdogs, hmm? Someone who has nothing to do with any of this? I see it as unproductive to bring him up over such matters.

Three, Grath wared everyone in general, so trying to report me over toxicity in response to your mates toxicity doesn't help your case

I never implied otherwise, "despite the thread users' being lightly warned by Grath before" thread users constitute all of us. The issue lay elsewhere.

this is in response to Nova derailing the thread by asking for people to like him, so i jokingly mention that its always the same people

I quoted an earlier message where i called Nova out for insulted me instead of engaging with the thread, which is very relevant since it did this during the aforementioned derailment, essentially restating what i said earlier

An obvious joke, and i was more or less asking what you where saying since i didn't seem clear, though it did seem like you where trying to satirize us telling people to respond instead of derailing the thread further

Not irrelevant, East said he'll enjoy ratioing me when i respond to his points, so i said that inventible when you tell your friends to mass upvote yourself

Satirizing another guys comment about me allegedly being jealous that you guys were telling your friends to mass upvote yourselfs

First part was a joke, second part i didn't bring up, i was responding to someone who did bring it up


It seemed that Bern was calling me out for bullshit or something about PSW staff stalking harassing me off site, so i said i have of proof of it but don't want to further reinsituate the drama from months ago

I don't really care about any of this, nor your reasoning as to why the derailment on your side occurred above; they're all derailments in my eyes and things unrelated to the thread, which you could've stopped anytime and not partake in. I also don't know what's with your insistence on them apparently "telling others to mass upvote their respective comments" or whatever, those who support will like the comments pertaining to the supporters and those who don't will like the comments of the opposition. But I don't really care about this either.

I have nothing to say beyond this, as I don't want to drag this out in RVR over the more important matters and have this turn into a bickering contest over me simply pointing out derailment on both sides. Either way, Bambu put out his thoughts on the matter, and I'm fine and agree with what he said.

 

[SuperNova55555]

As i mentioned, you insulted us and called us mentally slow (twice) before this, and you had already engaged with the thread when i said this, you can't just come on a thread insult the OP, and leave due to the fact you think the CRT is beneath you because you think it's bad, and then expect me not to call you out for it

No, I didn't call you mentally slow. I called you obtuse, which I'm using as a light way of implying that you're being frustrating to talk to, since you're intentionally unwilling to see to any points. I.e a subtle way of telling you that you're wanking, likely intentionally so.

unwilling to understand something <- a definition of obtuse, if you will

And I'm also confused what engaging with the thread previously has anything to do with it. The entire reason is that I entered the thread, debated it for a bit, ya'll began saying stuff like "you should've actually read the blog lol", and realized that it was very pointless in my end and decided to end it right there rather than dragging it, since I knew that the judgment of the thread completely depended on whatever Ultima thought of it anyways. And voila, look how it ended up.

And I won't be responding any further here, I'm very aware you're not supposed to be debating stuff on RVR, so I'll just accept whatever the mods deem fit. That is all.

 

[Okstrike]

My statement in itself says, "It just doesn't sit right with me over such comments aimed at me or my friends, especially Toxic himself, who hates such notions, so I'll just report it here."

I was specifically referring to the parts where you accused this of being a general statement towards your friends, you went our of your way to mention multiple people who i have no issue with and clamed i was insulting them too

It doesn't really matter if your comment wasn't directed at me or MGQ,

It very much does matter, you specifically claimed i was insulting them, which i wasn't, this was literally my whole contention with what you said

which is weird given your incessant targeting of PSW users and PSW staff, which you have a well-known history of.

You should already know why i hate the vast majority (not all) of PSW users since i literally mentioned that in my previous comment (ie, staking and harassing me for weeks)

I see it as unproductive to bring him up over such matters.

Yes, it was unproductive, and i already apologized earlier for it

I never implied otherwise, "despite the thread users' being lightly warned by Grath before" thread users constitute all of us. The issue lay elsewhere.

So let me get this straight; your message implies you're trying to report me specially:

Calling a set of specific people, including those unrelated, such as I, Mgq and so forth, who didn't take part in any of the banter from the last few pages, equivalent to dogs and whatnot, despite the thread users' being lightly warned by @GrathOfLux before. It just doesn't sit right with me over such comments aimed at me or my friends, especially Toxic himself, who hates such notions, so I'll just report it here.

Yet here you are admitting that such a thing would be hypocritical?

I don't really care about any of this, nor your reasoning as to why the derailment on your side occurred above; they're all derailments in my eyes and things unrelated to the thread, which you could've stopped anytime and not partake in.

I never mentioned derailment until later on, and i only responded to East comment which actually tried to engage with the CRT, but then that somehow spiraled into people insulting me and trying reinsinuate old drama, so i defended myself since i'm not going to ignore big accusations like that

I also don't know what's with your insistence on them apparently "telling others to mass upvote their respective comments" or whatever, those who support will like the comments pertaining to the supporters and those who don't will like the comments of the opposition. But I don't really care about this either.

My guy, Nova literally asked for people to ratio our comments by mass upvoting them, this has nothing to do supporting or not supporting it, and these weren't substantial comments that had anything to do with the debate, they were derailing ones that came after Nova stopped leaving counter points

I have nothing to say beyond this, as I don't want to drag this out in RVR over the more important matters and have this turn into a bickering contest over me simply pointing out derailment on both sides. Either way, Bambu put out his thoughts on the matter, and I'm fine and agree with what he said.

Reasonable tbh, but if you drag it on, don't expect me to not defend myself, its not like i asked for the users to be punished, i literally just said that any derailing comments comments should be removed

 

[ShinMaximillion]

Not going to respond to any of the outbursts in particular. Wasn't going to respond at all.
But this bit in particular is troublesome.

I don't think you want me to mention what specifically since it could get you and others banned, it's something i really wanted report a bit ago out of spite but abstained since my friends warned me to not institute more drama

No. I've literally no clue what you're pertaining to. And it seems extremely counterproductive, performative and damning in front of everyone and the staff members of VSBW in the RVR thread when you come out with a vague nothingburger notion of a "100% ban report guarantee, only holding myself back for reasons"

All I'll say is, whether you choose to do it in Public or file a Private report, I encourage you not to hold yourself back. By all means and purposes, go ahead and report me or Nova or everyone else from PSW or whatever you're claiming to have a report so apprehensive it could get all of us banned.

I haven't done anything that warrants a single bit of apprehension on my end, so you're free to do whatever it is that you like.

That'll be my last message on the topic. Not clogging this thread up further too.

 

[Antvasima]

I would say this comment was the first domino, even if it isn't so bad.

Some responses seem too quick to fly off the rip (here), but I'm willing to gloss over that seeing as they did not start it. I don't think they should have carried on, like so, but SuperNova555 also carried on and did so with less substance of actual debate. ExcelsisBerny's comments (starting about here) also really suck and also shouldn't be tolerated. It's just personal insults. Even if a CRT truly sucks (not saying this one does or does not, I don't care to look into it), you can't just farm it for likes by being a dick. If their points are awful, counter them and be done.

I'm not going to say that OkStrike (et al) aren't also doing it, but again, I find it really hard to judge it as harshly when they are being aggressed upon by lots and lots of other random users trying to farm likes. I can't fault them too much when they are being dogpiled like that.

I think SuperNova555 has a point to make, but they choose to act childish at every opportunity while making it. I would be in favor of at least a warning for their behavior, I find it pointlessly instigatory, even if they were otherwise engaging in debate (sometimes). ExcelsisBerry also should receive a warning for how significant their contributions to the discussion were. I would also issue a broad warning to everyone else involved (including Okstrike, and other CM supporters) to just knock it off. It's a CRT. It is not meant to bicker over. In theory it is meant for staff to evaluate. Bickering makes it even less likely that any staff will interact. Presuming all parties have the ideals of the wiki in mind, and are arguing in good faith, this means bickering is only ever a lose-lose.

Thanks a lot for helping out, Bambu.

And all regular members involved in this situation, please stop spamming, to make it easier for our staff members to evaluate it.

 

[FinePoint]

I think we should specifically give Excelsis and SuperNova a warning and grant leniency to everyone else (though leave a general comment on the thread).

It got heated on all sides, but Excelsis is the only one who forgoes debate and any point entirely to focus on insulting people and derailing the thread.

SuperNova to me has some of the same but far less severe, they were being kind of snarky, but not nearly to the same extent; their comments come off as partially joking. I think their warning should focus more on the derailing aspect for all the posts with no substance.

So, in short, I think Excelsis should get warnings for toxicity and derailing, and SuperNova just for derailing.
The entire thread should get a general instruction to calm down and stay on topic.

 

[Hecky2222]

SuperNova to me has some of the same but far less severe, they were being kind of snarky, but not nearly to the same extent; their comments come off as partially joking. I think their warning should focus more on the derailing aspect for all the posts with no substance.

So, in short, I think Excelsis should get warnings for toxicity and derailing, and SuperNova just for derailing.

Excuse me but wasn't it acknowledged both sides derailed already? From what I see toxicity happened when both sides started to go off topic. Now you are giving one side "warning" for toxicity while completely ignoring another side's toxicity. If anything I guess it would be better to let it go since both sides are equally guilty here. You can't say "One hand can clap alone", so I can't get exact reason of warning one side while ignoring another one.

I can't follow this logic.

 

[ExcelsisBerny]

It got heated on all sides, but Excelsis is the only one who forgoes debate and any point entirely to focus on insulting people and derailing the thread.

I did not insult anyone at any point. I just said that he got ragdolled in the discussion, which is an objective fact.

 

[BoastJr]

Your Honor, My Client @SuperNova55555 is not guilty

They both derailed and Okstrike has done some oopsie daisies in the past

 

[FinePoint]

I did not insult anyone at any point. I just said that he got ragdolled in the discussion, which is an objective fact.

You did insult them. You implied they had no reading comprehension. You implied their thread was embarrassing. You accused them of intentionally 'wanking' the verse.

Also, it is not objective.

I can't follow this logic.

The logic is that not all parties contributed equally, and that the specific degree of toxicity from some was worse than others.

Your Honor, My Client @SuperNova55555 is not guilty
They both derailed and Okstrike has done some oopsie daisies in the past

That is fair enough. In hindsight I think I was too harsh on SuperNova who was just making light of an already tense situation for the most part.
I'll retract my support for warning them specifically.

 

[FinePoint]

Please refrain from commenting unless you are either staff or have something substantial to add to the report.

 

[Mr. Bambu]

Your Honor, My Client @SuperNova55555 is not guilty

They both derailed and Okstrike has done some oopsie daisies in the past

Ignoring the unserious tone of your post, I do think this changes how I view it, but not in the same sense as FinePoint. Acknowledging now that Okstrike's comments against SuperNova (and vice versa) are part of a continued trend, I'd more support a direct warning to Okstrike as well. Neither of them should pursue this petty feud at the expense of a thread's ability to be resolved. I now interpret SuperNova's comments less as just farming likes to outright trying to pursue this feud, and Okstrike's comments as taking much the same opportunity.

 

[FinePoint]

Ignoring the unserious tone of your post, I do think this changes how I view it, but not in the same sense as FinePoint. Acknowledging now that Okstrike's comments against SuperNova (and vice versa) are part of a continued trend, I'd more support a direct warning to Okstrike as well.

I no longer felt comfortable advocating for warning SuperNova specifically in the conflict, but if we want to swing that conclusion the other way around and warn both of them I'd be fine with that too. I just don't want it to seem like we're picking sides in their drama.

There's been a troubling rise of passive-aggressive shitposting in the community, and while in some contexts could be waved off as playful joking, I do acknowledge that in many contexts it becomes just a way to bully someone or further fuel a tribalistic separation, especially since it often feels coordinated.

On a larger scale, we may need to make the topic a staff thread if we ever want any productive conclusion to it. The thread basically started hostile and continued that way for like weeks even after Grath warned everybody. The Cthulhu Mythos seems really controversial in general, just taking a peruse through the older threads as well.

 

[Antvasima]

There's been a troubling rise of passive-aggressive shitposting in the community, and while in some contexts could be waved off as playful joking, I do acknowledge that in many contexts it becomes just a way to bully someone or further fuel a tribalistic separation, especially since it often feels coordinated.

Agreed. The infighting really needs to stop. People in our community should make a greater effort to be nice to each other and get along. Picking "sides" in the context of that one fictional story should reach supremacy over another fictional story is pointless. We index statistics, yes, but the literary merit and enjoyability of a story is not measured by statistics, often quite the opposite.

 

[Okstrike]

Sorry i haven't been able respond, i've been busy over the last few days for personal reasons, and have had little time for the forum

But anyways, I didn’t really want this to be about the toxicity of the thread itself since i only came here so that any derailing messages could be delated, the toxicity was almost inevitable from the start due to our long standing history and hate of each others guts, but if staff deem it as something worth a warning, than i don’t believe one side should be favored over the other in anyway; both me and friends did say some bad things that we apologies for, and so did the other side

Since people mentioned it, yes, i did engage somewhat with the derailing comments, mostly just defending myself from insults and calling what Nova was doing dumb, and while it was annoying, i didn’t say anything about the derailment itself up to that point, that is, until one of Nova’s mates unpromptedly tried bringing up drama from months ago, at which point i decided enough was enough and told them to stop, they ignored me and kept going, and that is when i came here, so you can’t use that as an excuse to justify the derailment

 

[M3X_2.0]

I don't know what did I do this time, but @Demon_Lord18 is acting hella weird:

I’d like to see the mental gymnastics M3X will pull to try to invalidate the Behemoth calculation.

His arguments will revolve around things like: 'amplified attack destroying Britannia = Behemoth outlier hur dur', 'Behemoth superior to everything hur dur'. 'The magnitude is wrong because the houses were built on stilts, and Zeldris’s mention of world destruction is clearly hyperbolic, hur dur'. Or the worst possible argument — but the one I find most likely — 'him saying this is the demon world or that the Behemoth was only destroying that part'. That would be really funny.

It’s simply the truth. His arguments will revolve around that, unless he goes further and starts claiming that the demon world isn’t a planet — which I wouldn’t even doubt. Moreover, there would still be team members just spamming ‘agree,’ like an addict chasing methamphetamine.

I didn't even comment in the general discussion thread for days, and I have never spoken about Behemoth, he's making up imaginary claims and getting angry at things I never said. Also the bolded part is really bad.

 

[Demon_Lord18]

I didn't even comment in the general discussion thread for days, and I have never spoken about Behemoth, he's making up imaginary claims and getting angry at things I never said. Also the bolded part is really bad.

The bold part is what every blue name knows to be true, but doesn’t have the courage to say.

This happens in several verses on the wiki: some team members see the word downgrade and, like addicts to illicit substances, rush to agree — although they probably don’t even know what is actually being proposed.

I even went easy by saying methamphetamine; some seem addicted to Café Pilão in 2D.

 

[Makai641001]

Hello everyone, I would like to get perma banned I feel like the community is just full of super salty guys that can be real weirdos to others basically every single verse supporters but specifically the NNT community has turned really weird I wanted to wait for the end of series to make a thread but they honestly don’t deserve any attention/time from me.

 

[Damage3245]

As has been said numerous time on here, the Rule Violation Reports thread isn't the place to do this, the All-Purpose Request thread is more suited for it.

But I've handled it now.

 

[Vietthai96]

As has been said numerous time on here, the Rule Violation Reports thread isn't the place to do this, the All-Purpose Request thread is more suited for it.

Tbf, we are often ban people in this thread so the first thing that come to people mind when thinking about getting their account banned was this thread

 

[M3X_2.0]

I don't know what did I do this time, but @Demon_Lord18 is acting hella weird:



I didn't even comment in the general discussion thread for days, and I have never spoken about Behemoth, he's making up imaginary claims and getting angry at things I never said. Also the bolded part is really bad.

Bumping, plus his comment here was completely unnecessary, yet again.

https://vsbattles.com/threads/seven-deadly-sins-calc-issues.191759/post-7760313

 

[Demon_Lord18]

Bumping, plus his comment here was completely unnecessary, yet again.

https://vsbattles.com/threads/seven-deadly-sins-calc-issues.191759/post-7760313

The comment points out how you are wrong in your premise and that you should be familiar with the earthquake table, since you are a member with the authority to evaluate calculations. Not to mention the underestimation of the other feats, though that doesn’t matter as much.
Moreover, you are citing the atmosphere in calculations where it wasn’t even mentioned.

 

[M3X_2.0]

I swear I’m trying my best to not do anything that I shouldn’t do, but with the lack of action from staff and the way he’s targeting me for no reason it’s kinda getting hard to not tell him to **** off entirely.