• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Reinhard vs Acheron

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm not really sure where exactly it was accepted that HSR characters get Type Moon smurf hax. I just kept seeing it said it was accepted a while ago. It was never shown where or why it isn't on their profiles now. I'm not saying it's wrong. I just feel like we actually need this explained to make a judgement.

"Its also stated by Servant Otti to lancer that something replaced magical energy entirely, allowing miracles to be created through the grail."

Miracles=Mystery btw
 
Ngl thats just unfair if real

Honkai leeching of Nasu is on brand tho
Our gift to them is an 11D pinball
image.png
 
So basically, from what i can see there are a couple issues with this

She insta timestops which he can't resist due to verse equalization not being applicable + BFR being instant death
image.png


She can selectively target who to affect (the video she wasn't aiming towards the citizens, rather she was aiming at a god's power that spanned the entire 2 million light years).
8a6da06adbbd.png

We do visibly see humans being sent flying, so it cannot be definitively argued that she intentionally excluded them from the attack. For ordinary civilians in New York, being launched like that would realistically be fatal.


Dreamscape also allows individuals to exit when placed in danger, not exclusively upon death, so escaping it does not inherently prove they actually died.
6ccb48c36170.png

Again, she was freely able to use her powers because of this
Acheron starts off transformed. Transformed Acheron doesn't engage in sword combat and immediately goes for hax and BFR

Now, because of this, she would not realistically engage in that type of attack while they are around.

CQC is generally the option that makes the most sense for her in that scenario.

Also, the activation method for her BFR requires a slash, which gives Reinhard enough time to immediately go for the kill, especially since the starting distance is only 10 meters, which is well within his range.

She is also a victim to the fact that there is no gap between thought and action for Reinhard, so basically in any given scenario he would always be the one to act first
 
This is how it would go:

Reinhard instinctive action exploiting the gap between thought and execution->Acheron decides to slash->Reinhard has already finished his slash
 
We do visibly see humans being sent flying, so it cannot be definitively argued that she intentionally excluded them from the attack. For ordinary civilians in New York, being launched like that would realistically be fatal.


Dreamscape also allows individuals to exit when placed in danger, not exclusively upon death, so escaping it does not inherently prove they actually died.
Ok but they're still in the Dreamscape. The fact they're inside still means that the attack was purposely made to not endanger them.

Again, she was freely able to use her powers because of this
The "freely use her powers" would work if they all woke up in reality. None of them were teleported back to reality because she made it not dangerous for them so this doesn't work.

Now, because of this, she would not realistically engage in that type of attack while they are around.

CQC is generally the option that makes the most sense for her in that scenario.
BFR? Why would she not BFR. She isn't dumb.

Also, the activation method for her BFR requires a slash, which gives Reinhard enough time to immediately go for the kill, especially since the starting distance is only 10 meters, which is well within his range.
This has never been the activation method at all, and she doesn't even need the sword to BFR. She BFR'd us to the Horizon of Existence without using her sword and slashing us.

We even see another clip of her using the BFR without slashing


She is also a victim to the fact that there is no gap between thought and action for Reinhard, so basically in any given scenario he would always be the one to act first
Timestop + BFR
 

"Its also stated by Servant Otti to lancer that something replaced magical energy entirely, allowing miracles to be created through the grail."

Miracles=Mystery btw
Yeah, okay, this is a stomp. This can be closed.
 
Ok but they're still in the Dreamscape. The fact they're inside still means that the attack was purposely made to not endanger them.


The "freely use her powers" would work if they all woke up in reality. None of them were teleported back to reality because she made it not dangerous for them so this doesn't work.


BFR? Why would she not BFR. She isn't dumb.


This has never been the activation method at all, and she doesn't even need the sword to BFR. She BFR'd us to the Horizon of Existence without using her sword and slashing us.

We even see another clip of her using the BFR without slashing



Timestop + BFR

Welp, i tried, this is a stomp in that case
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top