• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Champion of Midgard: The Thor Odinson MegaCRT

Messages
990
Reaction score
1,253
After nearly a year in the works, my Thor readthrough is completed, indexed, and processed. I'm hoping that this exhaustive, comprehensive readthrough will serve as the standard for the character's profile for the foreseeable future, as it takes into account thousands of scans of feats, antifeats, statements, and variability mechanics that I gathered over a nine-month reading period and organized across a month and a half of analysis. It's not at all practical to do this for every character on the wiki, but here it is for Thor!

BLOGS THAT MUST BE READ IN ORDER FOR THIS CRT TO MAKE SENSE​

Google Doc version (click at your own risk but it's far better formatted) https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Bkyc6GvDLXGewGVXCnMBm8f3reLu01sXdH9ggQFihX8/edit?tab=t.0

Thor variability (all versions): User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Thor Variability and Stats

  • TLDR: Thor holds back immensely in the vast majority of his fights, and limits himself both subconsciously and consciously unless fighting against beings he perceives as able to handle his true godly power. He also never uses his full power when civilians are in the area. No character should scale to him unless it's abundantly clear that Thor is actually going all-out in their fight.
Worthy Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Thor Stats...and Statistics

Unworthy Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Unworthy Thor Stats and Statistics

Incomplete All-Father Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Allfather Thor: Incomplete vs Complete Allpower

Complete Allfather Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Allfather Thor: Incomplete vs Complete Allpower

The keys would be split as follows: Unworthy Thor | Worthy Thor | Incomplete All-Father | Herald of None Thor | Rune King Thor | Complete All-Father

Edit: Herald of None Thor should also be 1-A, given how he's an amped version of the same Incomplete Allfather Thor that took hits from an amped Galactus and overpowered that same Galactus in a beam struggle.

 
Last edited:
Disagree with everything because it’s shorter then I was expecting

I think that she hulk’s is just cold resistance via gamma heat since she was explicitly stated to be warm and started glowing, other then that I agree with everything
This is why I linked all the blogs so it the CRT itself would actually be readable on its own lol. Also good point about She Hulk. That's probably just cold resistance
 
Thor variability (all versions): User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Thor Variability and Stats

  • TLDR: Thor holds back immensely in the vast majority of his fights, and limits himself both subconsciously and consciously unless fighting against beings he perceives as able to handle his true godly power. He also never uses his full power when civilians are in the area. No character should scale to him unless it's abundantly clear that Thor is actually going all-out in their fight.
The evidence looks good here, but I have a question. The conclusion of the blog is that "nobody should scale to base Thor unless it is made explicitly clear that Thor a) is not weakened; b) is using his full power; and c) is morally focused, as that directly influences his power level." Must all 3 be explicitly stated at the same time, or is it enough to have a statement for Thor going all-out or being unrestrained?
Worthy Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Thor Stats...and Statistics

  • Nobody should have 5-B or 3-C for battling Thor, and both the 3-C and High 3-A keys should be removed from his profile. As demonstrated in the above blog, it is not statistically consistent for Thor to actually struggle with opponents in those tiers when he's using his full power (Durability success rates are 87% for 5-B and 92% for High 3-A, with Attack Potency success rates at 98.3% for 5-B and 96% for High 3-A). Such instances should either be ignored as serious outliers or give those characters a "Low 1-A at peak" key if Thor consistently struggles with them when he is known not to be holding back.
The overall indexing of the feats and the conclusion look fine. I have several contentions with some parts, but they aren't included with the actual justifications, so it doesn't matter.
  • Worthy Thor's tiering should be "Low 1-A normally, 1-A with God Blast, Phoenix Force, and at peak". If you read (at least the summary of) the blog, you'll notice that base Thor has a 96% success-of-damaging rate against opponents in the Low 1-A bracket, and 100% in the 1-A bracket. Across those three tiers alone, he has 359 fights and/or explicit feats spread between Attack Power and Durability.
Agree with this proposal.
No issues here.
This may require multiple detailed individual evaluations. Are you proposing Skyfather level upgrades for all of them, or simply re-evaluations? And do you have the scans here for them fulfilling your requirements for scaling to Thor's Low 1-A baseline, or are they on the profiles already? Regardless, just to name some potential contentions, the Cosmic Cube Beyonder was explicitly an infinite-dimensional being, and Angela's notes explain why she doesn't scale to Thor based on her current encounters with him.
Unworthy Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Unworthy Thor Stats and Statistics

The blog for the speed of thought isn't included with this CRT. Everything else is fine.
  • Who scales to peak/bloodlusted Unworthy Thor who doesn't already:
    • Amadeus Cho at peak (overpowered a bloodlusted Unworthy Thor, although they were fairly relative, and was unharmed by Jarnbjorn)
    • Devil Hulk (shocked Unworthy Thor with his power, although it's unlikely that Thor was bloodlusted here. Thoughts on whether this is usable or not?)
    • He was once overpowered by an amped Namor, although they only fought once and I don't know if Namor retained his amp after that issue. Additionally, Thor didn't appear to be bloodlusted here. I recommend that it be ignored due to uncertainty.
    • Savage She-Hulk (potentially, for withstanding Ymir's cold that Unworthy Thor couldn't. This might also just be Cold Resistance)
    • Potentially Juggernaut at peak, although this could potentially create some circular scaling issues by changing one of Unworthy Thor's High 3-A justifications to Low 1-A
    • Angela (fought evenly with Unworthy Thor when both were bloodlusted)
    • Summary: Angela and peak Amadeus (morals off) scale. I'm happy to hear your thoughts on Devil Hulk, She-Hulk, and Juggernaut.
Fine with everything besides Angela. I don't see any fighting evenly here, Thor lands two strikes on her, then they make a truce.
Incomplete Allfather Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Allfather Thor: Incomplete vs Complete Allpower

Looks good.
Complete Allfather Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Allfather Thor: Incomplete vs Complete Allpower

No significant issues here, but matching "Nyx at night" (as in, on earth) should be part of the Outerverse level justifications.
The keys would be split as follows: Unworthy Thor | Worthy Thor | Incomplete Allfather | Herald of None Thor | Rune King Thor | Complete Allfather

Looks great, fantastic job all around!
 
The evidence looks good here, but I have a question. The conclusion of the blog is that "nobody should scale to base Thor unless it is made explicitly clear that Thor a) is not weakened; b) is using his full power; and c) is morally focused, as that directly influences his power level." Must all 3 be explicitly stated at the same time, or is it enough to have a statement for Thor going all-out or being unrestrained?

The overall indexing of the feats and the conclusion look fine. I have several contentions with some parts, but they aren't included with the actual justifications, so it doesn't matter.

Agree with this proposal.

No issues here.

This may require multiple detailed individual evaluations. Are you proposing Skyfather level upgrades for all of them, or simply re-evaluations? And do you have the scans here for them fulfilling your requirements for scaling to Thor's Low 1-A baseline, or are they on the profiles already? Regardless, just to name some potential contentions, the Cosmic Cube Beyonder was explicitly an infinite-dimensional being, and Angela's notes explain why she doesn't scale to Thor based on her current encounters with him.

The blog for the speed of thought isn't included with this CRT. Everything else is fine.

Fine with everything besides Angela. I don't see any fighting evenly here, Thor lands two strikes on her, then they make a truce.

Looks good.

No significant issues here, but matching "Nyx at night" (as in, on earth) should be part of the Outerverse level justifications.

Looks great, fantastic job all around!
Awesome thoughts, thank you! For the first question, a statement of Thor going all out is probably sufficient, unless it's a version of Thor that either isn't fully in control of himself ( mind control etc) or is otherwise morally compromised, as the Variability blog discusses how his power directly correlates to his worthiness even in his Allfather keys.

For the proposed Low 1-A scaling, I'd suggest Skyfather tiers for all of them (except perhaps Angela as you mentioned, and Juggernaut's forcefield scales far above his physicals so he'd only get a "up to Low 1-A with forcefields). Thanos, Ego, Sentry, true adamantium Ultron, the Destroyer and Mangog all require Thor to go all out to match them in the majority of their encounters. I'm on mobile right now so I don't have the scans for it at the moment but I can add them for those who don't currently have it (I believe they're all already on their profiles, though, so only the tiering would change).

I'll edit the Nyx on Earth to be part of 1-A 👍
 
Can you provide like, a list of all characters currently scaled to Thor if possible? It's okay if you can't, I'll try to make it myself.

Just y'know, impact assessment n all
 
Can you provide like, a list of all characters currently scaled to Thor if possible? It's okay if you can't, I'll try to make it myself.

Just y'know, impact assessment n all
I'm not sure about the 5-B characters, unfortunately--I'm just not familiar with those pages on the wiki. I can try to look for them tonight. Some off the top of my head are Graviton and Count Nefaria, which will likely require more in-depth analysis to decide if they should scale or not. Is there a function on the wiki that lets you check which characters are cross-scaled to another?

Beta Ray Bill will be getting his own near-total redo of his page by me fairly soon. Silver Surfer's tier will likely be going up soon as well independent of base Thor scaling and I expect will end up with Low 1-A at peak. I'm also planning a total Jane Foster redo for both her Thor and Valkyrie keys. The Phoenix Force hosts from the AvX storyline are currently scaled to him but I'm not sure they should since Thor was injured and weakened for almost the entire arc given he fought the Phoenix itself towards its beginning.

Legion's dragon form has a KO against Thor but I don't believe that's on his profile.

Death Seed Sentry should scale.

Kurse should also scale.

I don't believe we have profiles for the Builders, but if we did they would scale.
 
I agree. Extremely well researched and justified. I have no issues with the scaling (except for the fact that the Low 1-A characters absolutely should be 1-A, but that can be handled later as OP said). I also agree with everyone who is listed as scaling to Thor here.

Two very minor nitpicks: when the profile is updated, it should be formatted as "All-Father," not "Allfather." I would also prefer to have "Complete All-Father" be before Herald and Rune King keys. But yeah, other than that this looks pretty incredible.
 
Can you provide like, a list of all characters currently scaled to Thor if possible? It's okay if you can't, I'll try to make it myself.

Just y'know, impact assessment n all
Most of these characters have scaling other then scaling to Thor btw, Air walker, Angela, apocalypse, awesome android, beta Ray bill, bi beast, blue marvel, captain America’s shield, cosmic ghost rider, count nefaria, the destroyer, ego, executioner, firelord, galactus, ghost rider(Robbie), gladiator, Godzilla, gorr, graviton, Hela, Hercules, hulk, multiple hyperions, iceman, Ikaris, some of iron man’s armors, Jane foster, jormungand, juggernaut, kang’s forcefields, knull, kurse, Loki, mangog, mindless ones, pheonix force(namor, colossus, cyclops, Emma frost, Magik), Odin, Pluto, Proxima midnight, radioactive man’s forcefields, ragnarok, scarlet witch, sentry, Seth, she hulk, silver surfer, starbrand, Surtur, Terrax, Thanos, tyr odinson, ultron, wolverine, wonder man, and I think that’s all of them
 
Last edited:
I agree. Extremely well researched and justified. I have no issues with the scaling (except for the fact that the Low 1-A characters absolutely should be 1-A, but that can be handled later as OP said). I also agree with everyone who is listed as scaling to Thor here.

Two very minor nitpicks: when the profile is updated, it should be formatted as "All-Father," not "Allfather." I would also prefer to have "Complete All-Father" be before Herald and Rune King keys. But yeah, other than that this looks pretty incredible.
I definitely agree that the Low 1-A should be 1-A (but as we discussed elsewhere that might be best to make its own CRT). I also like your idea of "All-Father" as that looks better.

I originally had Herald and RKT after Complete All-Father, but then I realized the possible High 1-A end for his Complete All-Father key and wasn't sure if that should go at the end, since it's higher than I believe RKT extends to. What are your thoughts on that? Thematically it makes more sense to have the All-Father keys next to each other, but there is the tradition of having the strongest ones at the end.
 
Most of these characters have scaling other then scaling to Thor btw, Air walker, Angela, apocalypse, awesome android, beta Ray bill, bi beast, blue marvel, captain America’s shield, cosmic ghost rider, count nefaria, the destroyer, ego, executioner, firelord, galactus, ghost rider(Robbie), gladiator, Godzilla, gorr, graviton, Hela, Hercules, hulk, multiple hyperions, iceman, Ikaris, some of iron man’s armors, Jane foster, jormungand, juggernaut, kang’s forcefields, hknull, kurse, Loki, mangog, mindless ones, pheonix force(namor, colossus, cyclops, Emma frost, Magik), Odin, Pluto, Proxima midnight, radioactive man’s forcefields, ragnarok, scarlet witch, sentry, Seth, she hulk, silver surfer, starbrand, Surtur, Terrax, Thanos, tyr odinson, ultron, wolverine, wonder man, and I think that’s all of them
Bless your soul for doing that. I'll add any more I can find as I encounter them
 
Intelligence: Genius (Despite his usual tendency to charge head-first into battle, Thor is a veteran warrior with thousands of years of experience and can match the universe's most skilled warriors. He can use portals in combat and carefully calculate trajectories of obstacles thrown by his enemies to protect innocents. His skill in battle is without equal in Asgard, allowing him to break through Man Beast's martial arts that were a million years more advanced than anything on Earth and defeat an Asgardian-demon hybrid that had never lost a fight. Thor can devise plans that can fool even his most cunning foes when the situation calls for it, such as Loki or Malekith the Accursed. He is also a highly skilled medical doctor and retains all of Donald Blake's knowledge, including the comprehension of how to create living beings from raw molecules. Thor speaks every language and dialect on Earth as well as countless alien languages, and knows every tree and pillar in the Nine Realms. He's also a decent cook)
I think all this could easily justify Extraordinary Genuis
 
Part of frustration for me right now is Ultron, Thanos and Juggernaut pages are kinda ******* terrible but anyways
  • Sentry's direct scaling to Thor is kinda reliant on the fact that we take HAMMER as this all-knowing entity when canonically it is a shittier S.H.I.E.L.D., so it knowing Thor's exact value to compare and contrast with Sentry is kinda wonky. I don't think SHIELD itself has a big chunk of the canon knowledge on what tier Thor is, since that requires there being very thorough investigation done for battles they straight up didn't witness. I guess he'd scale regardless for stalemating WWH, but y'know, that still has the wacky "guys hulk was totally holding back" caveat
  • Ultron is a genuinely terrible page, it composites so many keys, but regardless: Alot of his feats are set on earth itself, which as we know is a region where Thor holds back (and these are Avengers run so the collateral logic also checks out). This one also just, has the jank of Wanda amping his power reserves.
  • Thanos is another sucky page, but it straight up requires a rework. He'd likely end up Low 1-A still off of Silver Surfer or smth, but I would like to note Infinity #6 takes place on Earth, so that is something.
  • Ego till Hulk are probably fine
  • Juggernaut's file is straight up missing a scan for his forcefields and the supposed Low 1-A feat. So
The bad pages probably have good reason to scale, it's just ass keying and ass mechanics rep.
K
  • Savage She-Hulk (potentially, for withstanding Ymir's cold that Unworthy Thor couldn't. This might also just be Cold Resistance)
  • Potentially Juggernaut at peak, although this could potentially create some circular scaling issues by changing one of Unworthy Thor's High 3-A justifications to Low 1-A
  • Angela (fought evenly with Unworthy Thor when both were bloodlusted)
  • It's just better Cold Resist yeah
  • ...why?
  • K
ill read through the other scans in a bit
 
Part of frustration for me right now is Ultron, Thanos and Juggernaut pages are kinda ******* terrible but anyways
  • Sentry's direct scaling to Thor is kinda reliant on the fact that we take HAMMER as this all-knowing entity when canonically it is a shittier S.H.I.E.L.D., so it knowing Thor's exact value to compare and contrast with Sentry is kinda wonky. I don't think SHIELD itself has a big chunk of the canon knowledge on what tier Thor is, since that requires there being very thorough investigation done for battles they straight up didn't witness. I guess he'd scale regardless for stalemating WWH, but y'know, that still has the wacky "guys hulk was totally holding back" caveat
  • Ultron is a genuinely terrible page, it composites so many keys, but regardless: Alot of his feats are set on earth itself, which as we know is a region where Thor holds back (and these are Avengers run so the collateral logic also checks out). This one also just, has the jank of Wanda amping his power reserves.
  • Thanos is another sucky page, but it straight up requires a rework. He'd likely end up Low 1-A still off of Silver Surfer or smth, but I would like to note Infinity #6 takes place on Earth, so that is something.
  • Ego till Hulk are probably fine
  • Juggernaut's file is straight up missing a scan for his forcefields and the supposed Low 1-A feat. So
The bad pages probably have good reason to scale, it's just ass keying and ass mechanics rep.

K

  • It's just better Cold Resist yeah
  • ...why?
  • K
ill read through the other scans in a bit
Yeah, there are a lot of bad profiles that need to be fixed. I recall Thor stating he was going to use all the power at his disposal to fight Sentry during Siege, at which point he and bloodlusted Sentry fought on pretty even footing. I plan on heavily redoing all of the Asgard related profiles like Mangog and the Destroyer, so those will have strong justifications.
 
OH. ALSO.

There is a MASSIVE problem: The tier 3 feats are all done by Thor and Beta Ray Bill, as far as I recall.

So if they're getting upgraded everyone between 5-B and Low 1-A probably needs an entirely new set of feats. Ugh.

I guess that's an important thread to be made afterwards
Mmm, that could be an issue. I'll prioritize redoing Beta Ray Bill's page, because I strongly don't think he consistently scales to peak Thor. He might be able to act as a new scaling linchpin for heralds.
 
That'll probably have to be its own thread, yeah. I've mostly focused on tier 1 stuff lately so I don't have a ton of lower Herald feats but when that thread goes up I'll contribute what I can.
 
These are the characters I want you to address scaling for, ig:
  • Galactus Low-End
  • Iceman's 1-A
  • Iron Man Armors: Model 22 and 72
  • Kang's Forcefields
  • Knull
  • High end Mindless Ones
  • Seth
  • Pluto
 
I also think that these revisions seem very reasonable, except for Impress' points and that I am not sure if Genius, rather than Gifted, intelligence is warranted.

Is there any chance that you would be willing to expand on Thor's Marvel Comics Wiki's powers and abilities section as well? 🙏
 
After nearly a year in the works, my Thor readthrough is completed, indexed, and processed. I'm hoping that this exhaustive, comprehensive readthrough will serve as the standard for the character's profile for the foreseeable future, as it takes into account thousands of scans of feats, antifeats, statements, and variability mechanics that I gathered over a nine-month reading period and organized across a month and a half of analysis. It's not at all practical to do this for every character on the wiki, but here it is for Thor!

BLOGS THAT MUST BE READ IN ORDER FOR THIS CRT TO MAKE SENSE​

Thor variability (all versions): User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Thor Variability and Stats

  • TLDR: Thor holds back immensely in the vast majority of his fights, and limits himself both subconsciously and consciously unless fighting against beings he perceives as able to handle his true godly power. He also never uses his full power when civilians are in the area. No character should scale to him unless it's abundantly clear that Thor is actually going all-out in their fight.
Worthy Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Thor Stats...and Statistics

Agreed
Unworthy Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Unworthy Thor Stats and Statistics

Nice.
How consistent is this for Cho? Should be a case of outlier if it not.
Cold resistance. Nothing more.
    • Potentially Juggernaut at peak, although this could potentially create some circular scaling issues by changing one of Unworthy Thor's High 3-A justifications to Low 1-A
    • Angela (fought evenly with Unworthy Thor when both were bloodlusted)
    • Summary: Angela and peak Amadeus (morals off) scale. I'm happy to hear your thoughts on Devil Hulk, She-Hulk, and Juggernaut.
Incomplete Allfather Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Allfather Thor: Incomplete vs Complete Allpower

Incomplete All Father Thor should be straight up 1-A not possibly. No reason to add possibly since he should be stronger than his Unworthy self.
Complete Allfather Thor stats and statistics: User blog:NaturalDestroyer/Allfather Thor: Incomplete vs Complete Allpower

The keys would be split as follows: Unworthy Thor | Worthy Thor | Incomplete Allfather | Herald of None Thor | Rune King Thor | Complete Allfather

Other characters that will soon receive their own CRTs: Beta Ray Bill; Skurge; Amora (profile creation); Ymir (profile creation); Utgard-Loki (profile creation); Jane Foster Thor & Valkyrie; Yggdrasil; Desak (profile creation); Skyfathers going back to 1-A.
I want to point something out. Since Hulk is scaling to Thor's High 1-A and Hulk's vary mechanism, no need to scale him to Low 1-A or 1-A, He should just straight up High 1-A. Also, personas like Child-Like, Green Scar and Fractured Son (when he get his key) will scale since despite them having different base power (as in: some persona having a base power higher than the others), they all can reach same levels of peak power.


and also most people scaling to Thor would scale to his Low 1-A and we need to be careful about scaling anyone to Thor or we might end up in a messy scaling chain.


This is good. Proper restructuring of his profile. Great work


Looking at those scaling to Thor, we might get Low 1-A Heralds but that's a discussion for another time, not here.
 
Can somebody summarise the reasoning for High 1-A, and why other characters should scale to it, please? It seems too high from an intuitive perspective. 🙏
 
Can somebody summarise the reasoning for High 1-A, and why other characters should scale to it, please? It seems too high from an intuitive perspective. 🙏
scaling to full power Nyx, Hulk scales because he is on par with full power allfather Thor
 
scaling to full power Nyx, Hulk scales because he is on par with full power allfather Thor
How does allfather Thor scale to Nyx? I thought that Al Ewing described Zeus (and per extension, allfather Thor) as being a small firefly within her infinite darkness or somesuch within a rather recent Immortal Thor story. 🙏
 
How does allfather Thor scale to Nyx? I thought that Al Ewing described Zeus (and per extension, allfather Thor) as being a small firefly within her infinite darkness or somesuch within a rather recent Immortal Thor story. 🙏
Loki speaks of a greater danger, Zeus and Nyx fight for a while in the Dark Cold Room, but then she refers to Thor with Zeus's powers as a lighting bulb in an infinite universe. It's a bit contradictory, reason for it to be possibly High 1-A and not outiright High 1-A. If High 1-A is not accepted then they would scale to 1-A+ thanks to the Elder Gods creating a realm beyond the Far Shore
 
Is there any chance that you would be willing to expand on Thor's Marvel Comics Wiki's powers and abilities section as well? 🙏
He’s adding 3 abilities, he did say on discord that Thor’s P&A is surprisingly good so I think that’s why there’s not a whole lot of stuff being added to it
 
Back
Top