Do we have proof they are actually stars in the first place? If your entire line of logic is this, the maximum you can get out of this is the moons being real. Why would Columbina, who’s fighting on par with Dottore (they are equal opponents), have any narrative reason to create a realm which requires her to actually output solar system levels of strength to create stars? That has no narrative sense.
And that’s not a legible point. Who said we should abide by a textbook appeal to ignorance? The entire basis is “no reason to deny this is provided, therefore this should be accepted”.
Characters can sustain domains with energy without actually requiring star levels of energy. Domain expansions in JJK are very much textbook examples of this.
I think Puppet or Woomy should know about this.
the dimension dissapears after he decides to enter real world to kill columbina and others
Apologies, but I don't care about other verses. I care about whether Genshin fits the standard.
The reason is simple. We literally see stars. It is what it is.
Mind you, that realm was in Nefer's chessboard. So yeah, unlucky brother.would this mean rerir has 5-A scaling due to having pocket dimension with a moon inside
The standard is based off the normal, and the normal is defined as “not just genshin”. That’s just a disingenuous claim.
Morax never fought a sovereing man...
No, we saw small glowing dots. Nothing suggests they have mass as potent as stars or any other properties. You know very well that this is a terrible argument that has absolutely no basis whatsoever.
Azhdaha is the Geo Sovereign. Come on now. He and Apep have equal evidences of being a Sovereign.
I would agree if it was Columbina getting knocked out. The fight ends with Dottore being knocked out though and then she dispels the dimension itself, which doesn't have to lead to her own energy physically keeping it up and running in the first place. In the second video, we don't even see her exert energy at all when summoning it, but we do see her make a special move in the first one so it seems inconsistent to determine her energy values from it.
that doesnt matter since pocket dimensions can be large even if they are inside something else
There's no confirmation that realm was Rerir's realm either.that doesnt matter since pocket dimensions can be large even if they are inside something else
I mean you have realm of space inside teyvat yet u argue its 4-A dimension so
cuz he creates it
similarly how columnina supposedly does lol
Ei 5-C coming because she can sustain a Moon in her pocket dimensionwould this mean rerir has 5-A scaling due to having pocket dimension with a moon inside
Whataboutism isn't an acceptable argument. Each verse has their own circumstances and should be judge on their own. Last thing I will say on the matter.
Give me the exact statement where it says he created it.cuz he creates it
That's a fair conclusion, honestly. I give more stock to the fighting overall tho. Still, I wouldn't fight it if other staff agreed more with this.
brother columbina had 0 statements abt creating realm she did and why would rerir need to? why you being hypocrite rn do you see how ridicilous that is anyway i just wanted to know if its valid or not but ig it may be valid
Azhdaha is just vaguely mention as Geo King Dragon in CN, Apep at least tells u "yeah i was there with Nibelung chilling" unless they actually show Adzhada in a Sovereign cutscene/animation im not gonna agree with it
Why would it be Nefer's chessboard when he litterally got out of it? and then suddenly we are in a pocket dimension.
What does this mean? Wasn't it Columbina who created that dimension? We even saw how easy it was for her to create it when she showed it to Traveler, but when fighting, Columbina needs more effort to create an attack.
Apparently I f*cked up and forgot to finish my last argument. I also meant to ask why are we assuming she created a dimension and not just the moon
Because it could also just be hax. They are absolutely right to point out the fact the second vid kinda does point to the other direction.
Actually, just slow down the clip linked in the OP lmao, it just shows the particles that are used as “stars” moving and dissipating
.
I believed so because the second vid she did it again and it was the exact same (with Paimon seemingly referencing that "that's the place they talked about before" that she didn't get to see)
Didn't I mention several times that this verse is promiscuous regarding the feats of celestial bodies? That should be the circumstance of the verse and how such feats are judged. But instead you turn all my arguments into a straw man
He doesnt
What do you mean, the creation was just a hax? Or was it during the fight with Dottore?
I acknowledged that. I simply don't agree to group them all by default without true reason.
Columbina possesses the Authority over Space. It is likely that he was simply teleporting, but the power of the Three Moons allows him to do both at the same time (Dottore, who possessed the Authority of the Three Moons, was able to create his own dimension and teleport there with the cast of Nod-Krai).
Ah, yeah that makes sense then.
We have absolutely no idea. The conclusion OP derived from what we see is just as much as an assumption as what you're suggesting here as there's nothing explicit about the logistics of the feat in the first place, there's no statement about her creating it or sustaining it with energy at all
Agreed, yeah.
that space never existed before columbina became trilune goddess
Can you prove that?
