• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Jujutsu Kaisen Calculations - Attack Potency...

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're basically saying I don't know what I'm talking about despite being a former staff member, insulting my ability to come to a conclusion.
I never said you don’t know what you’re talking about in general. I said you’re not up to date on the forum’s current standards, which is a completely different thing. Staff status from the past doesn’t automatically reflect current accepted methodology, especially on a wiki that revises its rules regularly.

Not that this matters since this thing about earthquakes is actually old.
 
Is this rage bait? Since when has CONCRETE blown up from FIRE alone???? I feel like not even a physics buff would know that's not even true and I would love for you to prove that to be the case

Dude thinks I make threads with information pulled out of my booty hole.
I never said combustion is an explosion, I said fire doesn't blow up concrete without a medium because concrete isn't a combustible material. Example:
You implied it in your reply.
If the wind is a shockwave in that fictional setting, it is what it is.
It just... Isn't, that goes against our principles.
 
Can we get some interaction in the earthquake thread?
Yeah I have my problems with the jogo earthquake but this isnt really one of them

Uruame, mechamaru and jogo's ash calc (since that one one isnt even accepted as a feat) and gojo earthquake should be removed from this thread since nobody is talking about it or have already been downgraded and not applied yet

Main discussion is the jogo earthquake and sukuna thermobaric
 
Also.. Thermobaric explosions happen when... Well, it doesn't happen with concrete dust thats for sure. So, this is flowery language.
I brought this up before but didn't the calc use different dust? The calc just shouldn't be done through dust since it requires ignoring the primary used material. Alternatively though the metal within the area should be used instead which is 411618212 kg steel.
 
I brought this up before but didn't the calc use different dust? The calc just shouldn't be done through dust since it requires ignoring the primary used material. Alternatively though the metal within the area should be used instead which is 411618212 kg steel.
It uses coal dust because its directly stated sukuna changes the particles into thermobaric fuel.
 

Dude thinks I make threads with information pulled out of my booty hole.
The link you presented shows it occurring from explosive spalling from 600 degrees where the water inside the concrete turns into steam. The steam expands so much that the volume of the concrete cannot contain it and it effectively "blows up" because it literally cannot fit. It's like filling a balloon with so much water that it explodes on it's own. That doesn't mean the concrete explodes from fire, that's a secondary effect from water that is not even close to what Fuga has shown here.

Not only that, the spalling would never occur within an entire building which my example of a burning building presents (otherwise it woulda exploded from spalling entirely), so you wouldn't even be applying your psuedo-physics correctly here.
building-ablaze-night-stockcake.jpg


And finally the explosion straight up vapourised the area even. Meaning whatever water that was in the area was effectively GONE and thus there would not be able to be any spalling in the first place.
think-choso-death-was-probably-the-most-heartbreaking-v0-bmyvb4tn967f1.jpeg


Thus again, there would be no basis for your claim that concrete explodes, especially so violently, from fire alone; which I told you explicitly here. You're positing headcanon here.
Concrete dust does not explode with a fire attack alone (which Fuga is) because concrete is not combustible on it's own. You need a fuel for that, which the narrative explains which exact type it was. Unless you have another plausible explanation as to how concrete blows up an entire town so violently, you have no basis for what you would be saying and claiming it's "flowery language" severely misunderstands how that claim is even made in the first place.
You implied it in your reply.
No, you just strawmanned me. Please read what I'm saying next time.
It just... Isn't, that goes against our principles.
Which principles? Not even cgm and staff, who establish these principles for calcing in the first place, are agreeing with you lmfao
 
its directly stated sukuna changes the particles into thermobaric fuel.
Yeah, quoting chapter 259, pages 2-5:
Ryōmen Sukuna can only open the Furnace doors after first preparing his ingredients, Cleave and Dismantle.

Despite their absurd firepower, the flames within the Furnace lack both speed and range. To amend this, Sukuna undertook another Binding Vow.

"Outside of his Domain, Furnace cannot be used against multiple targets." This Binding Vow enabled Sukuna to not only reduce all within the Malevolent Shrine's range to dust, but ensure that all the resulting particles were matted in the explosive Cursed Energy akin to Furnace.

On top of this, Sukuna deftly altered the functionality of the Domain, to one that only allowed entry to living beings, maintaining the Shrines' output whilst sealing it airtight.

Thermobaric explosives and the transformed particle matter danced, raining down on every inch of the Domain.

The heat of Furnace spread the detonations immediately, birthing scalding, instantly compressing and decompressing shockwaves, ensuring the death of all living beings within the Domain.
An attack capable of instantly obliterating Makora back in Shibuya. This is Ryōmen Sukuna's ultimate move.
 
Not only that, the spalling would never occur within an entire building which my example of a burning building presents (otherwise it woulda exploded from spalling entirely), so you wouldn't even be applying your psuedo-physics correctly here.
Heat is uneven, some parts would explode whilst some wouldn't, because again, heat is inconsistent. This doesn't debunk what I've said.

Heat, i.e., fire creates the explosion.
And finally the explosion straight up vapourised the area even. Meaning whatever water that was in the area was effectively GONE and thus there would not be able to be any spalling in the first place.
Vaporised the area.

Then show's non-vaporisation.

Also that doesn't even make sense If the water was vaporised, that is the process that generates the steam pressure responsible for spalling. You’re removing the cause while describing the effect.
 
It uses coal dust because its directly stated sukuna changes the particles into thermobaric fuel.
Yeah ik, but I'm not sure if coal dust is the best for the calc. The metal dust is there, it is combustible, think it makes more sense the metal scattered combusted and caused the matted concrete to catch on fire.

Vaporised the area.

Then show's non-vaporisation.

Also that doesn't even make sense If the water was vaporised, that is the process that generates the steam pressure responsible for spalling. You’re removing the cause while describing the effect.
Where did all the steam come from then?
 
Can kinda just search it up and see for yourself.
Is this it?
Or this?
 
Is this it?
Or this?
Is this it?


Or this?
 
So when does JJK Take place? Cause those are not modern problems because people stopped making concrete like that for buildings and whatnot in the 1900s.

This is a knowledge check, cause hint: It is in modern timeframes.
bro what.
 
JJK takes place in 2018.

Tell me, Vzearr, what building built anywhere near this timeframe or is still standing during it has the problems you attempt to give out?
Literally any building that goes through extreme temperatures. Look at the photos in the links, they're clearly from the 2010's and 2020's.
 
Anyhoo, I guess that these calcs that are in legit contention are correct, so we're on the same page when it comes to that.
Self-evident.
Guesswork. If you do not know, and are merely guessing the timeframe, then it is guesswork.
 
Anyhoo, I guess that these calcs that are in legit contention are correct, so we're on the same page when it comes to that.

Guesswork. If you do not know, and are merely guessing the timeframe, then it is guesswork.
I'm going to crash out over a powerscaling online debate. Gonna re-evaluate my life and think "why?" then travel to India to answer my questions about morality and why I am getting so annoyed at someone repeating what he just said to me.
 
I'm going to crash out over a powerscaling online debate. Gonna re-evaluate my life and think "why?" then travel to India to answer my questions about morality and why I am getting so annoyed at someone repeating what he just said to me.
 
Heat is uneven, some parts would explode whilst some wouldn't, because again, heat is inconsistent. This doesn't debunk what I've said.

Heat, i.e., fire creates the explosion.
In this case, all of the buildings were f*cking gone after the attack lmfao. Plus you're making a circular reasoning here.

The process you're describing is a domino effect, which isn't true here because the explanation says that Fuga is the direct cause of the explosion after the CE explodes in everyone's faces
Vaporised the area.

Then show's non-vaporisation.
It's textbook vapourisation mec, at least according to the very principles you claim you appeal to.
Also that doesn't even make sense If the water was vaporised, that is the process that generates the steam pressure responsible for spalling. You’re removing the cause while describing the effect.
Did you forget the part where the centre of the vapourising attack (aka Fuga) sublimates concrete? There wouldn't be any solid for the steam to pop like popcorn at that point thus the way you posit concrete to explode wouldn't apply here. But it still explodes. Why? The scientist narrator explains why; you still didn't posit a plausible explanation for why the scientist would be wrong here (and the reason u said why was already debunked)
 
This thread was supposed to fail since the beginning.

Most of the arguments wouldn’t even exist in the first place if OP had read JJK beforehand. It gets even worse when OP says he can “debunk” without having read the series. I guess we found out you really can’t.

And the cherry on top: The arguments related to the calcs themselves are just nitpicks and I’m glad everyone in this thread either addressed them or just ignored.

As I said before, and I reiterate, I disagree with the thread.
 
Yo, debunk the thread first.
 
Yo, debunk the thread first.
You can't say debunk the thread when half of it is already being talked about in other threads, or have already been recalced (Uraume calc). The mech shit was killed last month and just won't be used. The verse page is ass rn so not your fault you didn't read five different threads going over some of this. The Sukuna shit is the only thing with some merit. Should make a thread tackling that in depth.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top