• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Kagurabachi General Discussion Thread

I feel like Sword Saint Von being released would be similar to 15 (16 actually) finger Sukuna being let out by Jogo.
lmfao 🥷🏽 said sword saint von. i actually think it might be worse. when sukuna came out he was mostly just ******* around, and didn’t need to actually do anything that he did. when this mf comes out he’s likely going to wanna destroy japan for keeping him captive, which is what’s implied by the hishaku leader
 
lmfao 🥷🏽 said sword saint von. i actually think it might be worse. when sukuna came out he was mostly just ******* around, and didn’t need to actually do anything that he did. when this mf comes out he’s likely going to wanna destroy japan for keeping him captive, which is what’s implied by the hishaku leader
And I want to see it, I feel like seeing the Sword Saint actually destroy Japan (also helps powerscalers) shows the true power of these Nuke Swords.
 
do you guys think we’re in the “everything goes to shit arc” (for example, shibuya incident arc, paranormal liberation war arc, etc.) of the series? the hishaku have already launched a full scale attack on the kamunabi.
Definitely feels like a Shibuya Arc to me, several concurrent small events leading up to a major disastrous one with everyone having their own fights here and there

Hakuri and Uruha vs Traitors
Chihiro vs Samura
Azami vs Samurai Hishaku
Yura's whereabouts are still unknown but he's likely also sneaking his way towards Hakuri and the Shinuchi
 
Someone gonna make an update for this verse or what.
You can help, currently there's no Hiyuki or Azami sandbox
These should be pretty easy to make

Take a look at what we're cooking for Chihiro, so you know we're definitely cooking
 
did Nishiki enhance his senses I thought it just strengthened his inner ear? Since when did Banquet affect memories?

Honestly I don’t think that scene correlated to much in terms of resistances to supernatural powers, if it was somehow not as simple as strengthening the inner ear (meaning it’s just, based on weird disruptions of that particular body part) then Chihiro wouldn’t have done it and it wouldn’t have worked. More of a specific counter than a generalised resistance. Chihiro did power through that early chapter mind manipulator and Iori did power through the memory manipulation but I just think those are limitations of those powers more than anything else. You can use it to scale to willpower I suppose.

Also I think immortality type 2 is a bit of a stretch that’s like giving Luffy immortality type 2.


Also wait he can’t actually normally emit electricity lmao I don’t think you can just give him that.
 
Last edited:
You can help, currently there's no Hiyuki or Azami sandbox
These should be pretty easy to make

Take a look at what we're cooking for Chihiro, so you know we're definitely cooking
Oh, another point, how are you handling Owl being confirmed as a very physical phenomena given it changed the weather across Japan? Samuea’s speed is also in question since evidently the scattering of Owl worked the same as Crow given how quickly he teleported and we know people on Samura’s level can somewhat react to Crow, so that would give a speed scaling to rushing across Japan.
 
did Nishiki enhance his senses I thought it just strengthened his inner ear
Banquet effects a lot of things and nishki does allow him to resist its effects and maintain equilibrium
Oh, another point, how are you handling Owl being confirmed as a very physical phenomena given it changed the weather across Japan? Samuea’s speed is also in question since evidently the scattering of Owl worked the same as Crow given how quickly he teleported and we know people on Samura’s level can somewhat react to Crow, so that would give a speed scaling to rushing across Japan.
The owl is not an AP feat, blocking tbe sun for several days made it colder thereby changing the weather that's all, and no owls range is the whole country so it dropping feathers where he senses the blades is not a speed feat
 
Last edited:
Oh, another point, how are you handling Owl being confirmed as a very physical phenomena given it changed the weather across Japan? Samuea’s speed is also in question since evidently the scattering of Owl worked the same as Crow given how quickly he teleported and we know people on Samura’s level can somewhat react to Crow, so that would give a speed scaling to rushing across Japan.
Limited Forcefield Creation for Owl doing that, maybe, just maybe some LS for holding back the weather, ik Dale's gonna shut this down

As for Crow, Crow is Instant Teleportation, wdym react to crow?
Owl allows him to drops feathers over what it surveys there's no speed scaling for him popping up anywhere in Japan

Samura would scale so so to first arc Chihiro's peak speed
 
ik Dale's gonna shut this down
Yup because he didn't hold the weather back, he just blocked sunlight out for several days causing it to get colder then suddenly removed owl causing a change in weather (nothing seperating hot and cold fronts which cause our weather)
 
Banquet effects a lot of things and nishki does allow him to resist its effects and maintain equilibrium
Yeah but it’s a specific counter it wouldn’t work on somebody’s whose abilities just had nothing to do with the inner ear. Chihiro knew this specific counter because of his expertise with the blades. Also it didn’t enhance his senses exactly did it?


The owl is not an AP feat, blocking tbe sun for several days made it colder thereby changing the weathee that's all, and no owls range is the whole country so it dropping feathers where he senses the blades is not a speed feat
It would have also had to have blocked raindrops for that scene to make sense. The process wouldn’t have happened fast enough and just because it comes from the sun doesn’t mean heat is only transferred through radiation, there had to be a physical object getting hit by heated particles but having its temperature not change much. He did just kinda have to create physical enough feathers to spread across the whole country and also reached incredibly high.


As for the speed, my point is:
P1)Owl spread across the entire country very fast.
P2)This form of Owl also spreads Crow feathers, i.e feathers that can be teleported to.
P3)People are capable of reacting to Crow.
C)People scale to the spreading of Owl.


Remember Crow’s feathers originate from Samura himself, wherever he can teleport is a testament to how fast those feathers move.
 
Yeah but it’s a specific counter it wouldn’t work on somebody’s whose abilities just had nothing to do with the inner ear. Chihiro knew this specific counter because of his expertise with the blades. Also it didn’t enhance his senses exactly did it?



It would have also had to have blocked raindrops for that scene to make sense. The process wouldn’t have happened fast enough. He did just kinda create physical enough feathers that spread across the whole country and also reached incredibly high.


My point is:
P1)Owl spread across the entire country very fast.
P2)This form of Owl also spreads Crow feathers, i.e feathers that can be teleported to.
P3)People are capable of reacting to Crow.
C)People scale to the spreading of Owl.

did Nishiki enhance his senses I thought it just strengthened his inner ear? Since when did Banquet affect memories?
Banquet affects Visual perception(gave the illusion of Samura killing Toto and Hiruhiko+appearance of warping the surroundings , Balance(the victims found it hard to keep balance) , The senses(these are all part of perception anyway Samura states it replicates the sensation of cutting when he thought he killed hiruhiko and Toto), memories (Samura fell back into a memory of when he feared, iori had killed herself in her Room)

Chihiro resists it entirely also we literally see Chihiro amplify his perception to combat Samura what even is this question gang
Honestly I don’t think that scene correlated to much in terms of resistances to supernatural powers, if it was somehow not as simple as strengthening the inner ear (meaning it’s just, based on weird disruptions of that particular body part) then Chihiro wouldn’t have done it and it wouldn’t have worked. More of a specific counter than a generalised resistance. Chihiro did power through that early chapter mind manipulator and Iori did power through the memory manipulation but I just think those are limitations of those powers more than anything else. You can use it to scale to willpower I suppose.
Except it's not willpower related and it's something he needs to use Nishiki buffs to deal with, Hiruhiko verbatim states Banquet is useless on Chihiro, it has a plethora of effects, Chihiro emphasised his inner ear because of balance, that doesn't mean it was the only thing he was strengthening
Also I think immortality type 2 is a bit of a stretch that’s like giving Luffy immortality type 2.
Huh? Did you read the justification
Also wait he can’t actually normally emit electricity lmao I don’t think you can just give him that.
Give him what, Electricity Manipulation?
That's currently on his profile, it'll be removed for Power Absorption, Damage Reduction, Reflection, Mimicry(?) and Modification with Aka
 
It would have also had to have blocked raindrops for that scene to make sense. The process wouldn’t have happened fast enough and just because it comes from the sun doesn’t mean heat is only transferred through radiation, there had to be a physical object getting hit by heated particles but having its temperature not change much. He did just kinda have to create physical enough feathers to spread across the whole country and also reached incredibly high.


As for the speed, my point is:
P1)Owl spread across the entire country very fast.
P2)This form of Owl also spreads Crow feathers, i.e feathers that can be teleported to.
P3)People are capable of reacting to Crow.
C)People scale to the spreading of Owl.


Remember Crow’s feathers originate from Samura himself, wherever he can teleport is a testament to how fast those feathers move.
Yeah no you're assuming owl was blocking the weather when we're never told or shown that, it can cover sky above japan and still be above cloud layers something we infact are shown. The fact of the matter we're never given a single explicit height of how high it say above the sky but we are able to still see clouds sooo yeah.

Also no idea what you're talking about creating enough feathers to cover all of japan, thats something thats never stated even a single time ever. Idek where ya got that from
Remember Crow’s feathers originate from Samura himself, wherever he can teleport is a testament to how fast those feathers move.
Not really Owl literally just creates feathers and drops them where he finds the EBs its not a speed feat to spawn something an area you're already at
 
As for the speed, my point is:
P1)Owl spread across the entire country very fast.
P2)This form of Owl also spreads Crow feathers, i.e feathers that can be teleported to.
P3)People are capable of reacting to Crow.
Crow is a Teleportation move, there isn't anything like reacting to Crow
C)People scale to the spreading of Owl.
Genuinely how
Remember Crow’s feathers originate from Samura himself, wherever he can teleport is a testament to how fast those feathers move.
Owl comes from the blade, Owl can span the country, Owl can also drop feathers wherever it spans to, he only needs to toss the feathers down a few hundred meters from Owl or so pop in where he needs to be
 
Yeah no you're assuming owl was blocking the weather when we're never told or shown that, it can cover sky above japan and still be above cloud layers something we infact are shown. The fact of the matter we're never given a single explicit height of how high it say above the sky but we are able to still see clouds sooo yeah.
You’ve only responded to one argument and while I haven’t calculated the height based on reasonable assumptions of it ended up being so far in the sky no clouds would be blocked I always thought it would be pretty easy to interpret it as dragging up said clouds. Reply to the other part of the argument tho.


Also no idea what you're talking about creating enough feathers to cover all of japan, thats something thats never stated even a single time ever. Idek where ya got that from
No point in replying to this part because replying to the next part suffices.

Not really Owl literally just creates feathers and drops them where he finds the EBs its not a speed feat to spawn something an area you're already at
Okay, so you think Samura can control Owl to create feathers where he wants so he would never have had to spread them to teleport where he does like he would normally?
 
Crow is a Teleportation move, there isn't anything like reacting to Crow
I meant reacting to the feathers he disperses for crow.
Genuinely how
P means proposition C means conclusion (sorry for the midwit Aquinas bro speak I just like the neatness). It is objectively the case that if the Owl feathers and the Crow feathers are the same and people can react to the Crow feather spreading then they can react to the Owl feather spreading.

Owl comes from the blade, Owl can span the country, Owl can also drop feathers wherever it spans to, he only needs to toss the feathers down a few hundred meters from Owl or so pop in where he needs to be
So, to be clear, you think Owl is distinct from the feathers Samura uses elsewhere but just creates them where Samura desires?
 
You’ve only responded to one argument and while I haven’t calculated the height based on reasonable assumptions of it ended up being so far in the sky no clouds would be blocked I always thought it would be pretty easy to interpret it as dragging up said clouds. Reply to the other part of the argument tho.
There's no real frame of reference to measure how high up it is directly, we know its higher than clouds and mountains (one shot shows us mountains) as have multiple shots that show clouds below the owl.

And yes the weather would infact have a huge shift very quickly if the entire area of japan which did not have sunlight for an entire week just about suddenly in a instant has the seen beaming in full swing. The moisture in the air would start rapidly condensing forming clouds and if intense enough precipitation which see since it was apparent cold enough that it snowed
 
Okay, so you think Samura can control Owl to create feathers where he wants so he would never have had to spread them to teleport where he does like he would normally
Its literally what they say he was doing owl is just to detect high spirit energy which we he does and he can just drop the feathers down via the owl and teleport to them
 
There's no real frame of reference to measure how high up it is directly, we know its higher than clouds and mountains (one shot shows us mountains) as have multiple shots that show clouds below the owl.
I think you narrow the range by obvious maximums and a minimum height that corresponds to presumably being able to clearly see the eyes at any point in Japan. I haven’t run through the numbers for this tho.


And yes the weather would infact have a huge shift very quickly if the entire area of japan which did not have sunlight for an entire week just about suddenly in a instant has the seen beaming in full swing. The moisture in the air would start rapidly condensing forming clouds and if intense enough precipitation which see since it was apparent cold enough that it snowed
Obviously light was blocked cause it was a visible object, but why didn’t heat above the owl and heat below the owl spread through convection? Also this all implies you think Owl was at least low enough for clouds which can drop rain to form above it (even at much higher temperatures than normal too seemingly).



Its literally what they say he was doing owl is just to detect high spirit energy which we he does and he can just drop the feathers down via the owl and teleport to them
So is Owl feathers themselves or does it just create them when Samura wants them to? Wanna make sure we’re super clear on this.
 
Banquet affects Visual perception(gave the illusion of Samura killing Toto and Hiruhiko+appearance of warping the surroundings , Balance(the victims found it hard to keep balance) , The senses(these are all part of perception anyway Samura states it replicates the sensation of cutting when he thought he killed hiruhiko and Toto), memories (Samura fell back into a memory of when he feared, iori had killed herself in her Room)

Chihiro resists it entirely also we literally see Chihiro amplify his perception to combat Samura what even is this question gang

Except it's not willpower related and it's something he needs to use Nishiki buffs to deal with, Hiruhiko verbatim states Banquet is useless on Chihiro, it has a plethora of effects, Chihiro emphasised his inner ear because of balance, that doesn't mean it was the only thing he was strengthening
The strengthening his inner ear thing doesn’t have to do with his senses it’s that the inner ear is responsible for balance. He’s not making it better at its job, he’s just making it more resistant to outside interference.

Anyway, it didn’t manipulate Samura’s memories it just showed him a vision of his memories, that’s a bit different. Maybe that’s counted as that on this wiki idk.

The larger issue here is Chihiro gave a specific counter that came from his knowledge of Kumeyuri, which doesn’t really have anything to do with a generalised resistance to these abilities. Somehow Kumeyuri does everything it does by ******* with the inner ear and so Chihiro could counter it by using Nishiki to protect that area of his body.

Yeah I don’t think resisting Banquet is a willpower thing, that was me speculating on what feats the rest of the abilities came from.

As for the rest of the post, yeah sorry I misunderstood the structure of the blog.
 
I think you narrow the range by obvious maximums and a minimum height that corresponds to presumably being able to clearly see the eyes at any point in Japan. I haven’t run through the numbers for this tho
Nah the range of it is just the entire country we literally do not need to calculate anything for it heightwise anyways because its not an AP feat and we already have its range stated.

Obviously light was blocked cause it was a visible object, but why didn’t heat above the owl and heat below the owl spread through convection?
Dawg sunlight is what provides the heat which means blocking the light also means blocking the heat. Hence there not being any connections in the actual qesther below and above owl.
Also this all implies you think Owl was at least low enough for clouds which can drop rain to form above it (even at much higher temperatures than normal too seemingly).
I mean ofc it ain't like tens or hundreds of kilometers high or anything but it is above lower cloud levels we literally see that much. Also why are you worried about rain we literally do not in nnow the forecast in the series when the sky was blocked we only see that it was sunny when the owl disappeared, legit rain has no bearing here you're overcomplicating this

So is Owl feathers themselves or does it just create them when Samura wants them to? Wanna make sure we’re super clear on this.
The latter
 
Nah the range of it is just the entire country we literally do not need to calculate anything for it heightwise anyways because it’s not an AP feat and we already have its range stated.
This doesn’t really matter



Dawg sunlight is what provides the heat which means blocking the light also means blocking the heat. Hence there not being any connections in the actual qesther below and above owl.
This just isn’t a genuine reply, the only way I can respond would just be repeating what I said in slightly different words, which I don’t see the point of.

The latter
So if Samura can spread out Owl faster than he can send out the feathers why does he a)send out the feathers to teleport when he could just create Owl and then drop feathers and b)channel owl through the feathers normally anyway lol.
 
Tbh you haven't said a single thing of substance here on it so I if you can't understand then well drop since there's nothing to discuss atp

So if Samura can spread out Owl faster than he can send out the feathers why does he a)send out the feathers to teleport when he could just create Owl and then drop feathers and b)channel owl through the feathers normally anyway lol.
He isn't spreading owl its already everywhere? Idk where you're getting this in your head that there was some big travel time involved in it, its quite instantly there and not
 
Tbh you haven't said a single thing of substance here on it so I if you can't understand then well drop since there's nothing to discuss atp
Cmon now. Cool off, take a moment, have a relaxing bath and reread my posts.

He isn't spreading owl its already everywhere? Idk where you're getting this in your head that there was some big travel time involved in it, its quite instantly there and not
Oh okay are you ESL? I can try explaining things again.
 
The strengthening his inner ear thing doesn’t have to do with his senses it’s that the inner ear is responsible for balance. He’s not making it better at its job, he’s just making it more resistant to outside interference.
I already said this vro
Anyway, it didn’t manipulate Samura’s memories it just showed him a vision of his memories, that’s a bit different. Maybe that’s counted as that on this wiki idk.
Forcefully putting someone in their memories IS Memory Manipulation
The larger issue here is Chihiro gave a specific counter that came from his knowledge of Kumeyuri, which doesn’t really have anything to do with a generalised resistance to these abilities. Somehow Kumeyuri does everything it does by ******* with the inner ear and so Chihiro could counter it by using Nishiki to protect that area of his body.
This isn't true at all, Nishiki was doing more than strengthening his inner ear, you literally see it over his eyes when banquets output increases at Samura's arrival and his perception starts to get ****** up(ch77pg6)
He wouldn't prioritise enhancing his inner ear normally because standardly his opponents don't **** with his balance and hiruhiko is not an opponent that requires he amps his speed, he was not only implied to but also stated to be holding back for the purpose of encountering Samura

Yeah I don’t think resisting Banquet is a willpower thing, that was me speculating on what feats the rest of the abilities came from.
It came from Banquets showings ?
Why are you acting like these aren't all in like 2-3 chapters which can easily be picked up on, just scan through chapter 75-76

Chihiro never says how Banquet works, he only says his way of countering it.
The inner ear deals with Balance, which asides from its stated Illusory Effects via Status inducement is the second most prominent effect Banquet gives its victims


ALSO are you going to help with profiles or not?
 
Last edited:
I already said this vro
What?


Forcefully putting someone in their memories IS Memory Manipulation
If that’s what you count it as that’s fine, idrc, just as long as it’s not used to say characters resist a kind of memory manipulation where memories themselves are actually affected.


This isn't true at all, Nishiki was doing more than strengthening his inner ear, you literally see it over his eyes when banquets output increases at Samura's arrival and his perception starts to get ****** up(ch77pg6)
He wouldn't prioritise enhancing his inner ear normally because standardly his opponents don't **** with his balance and hiruhiko is not an opponent that requires he amps his speed, he was not only implied to but also stated to be holding back for the purpose of encountering Samura
Two times characters provide explanations for how Chihiro is countering Banquet, including Chihiro himself, and they never say a single other thing than “strengthening the inner ear”. I do not think one panel of the effect being over his eye is remotely strong enough proof. You’re going too far with your interpretation of what that means without any strong confirmation from Hokazono.

I’m not sure how the rest of this reply really matters, could you explain that to me?


It came from Banquets showings ?
Why are you acting like these aren't all in like 2-3 chapters which can easily be picked up on, just scan through chapter 75-76
Cause of the memory manipulation. Calm down lad.


Chihiro never says how Banquet works, he only says his way of countering it.
The inner ear deals with Balance, which asides from its stated Illusory Effects via Status inducement is the second most prominent effect Banquet gives its victims
Yeah it explains the balance part and not the other parts that well, but the problem is by all accounts Hokazono just portrays doing that thing as making Chihiro totally immune. I guess you can explain it by saying that whatever propagates banquet takes a path through the ears to the brain idk. You’ve got to be conservative with chucking powers onto things. The fact that it could only be resolved by a specific counter and not by “Nishiki’s general ability to shunt off supernatural influence” means it’s not supposed to be a generalised resistance. I mean, hell, you think the specific counter is by enhancing his senses. That’s not really a resistance per se is it?



Another issue I have is giving things layers. Lot of shit in One Piece, Dragon Ball and Jujutsu Kaisen we’d give layers to that nobody gives layers to here if we applied the same standard of “well if a character has hax and then pumps up the output of some energy to affect someone they couldn’t before (or a person could pump up the hax more than somebody else could) then it’s layered hax and if someone resists it they have layered resistance”.
 
If that’s what you count it as that’s fine, idrc, just as long as it’s not used to say characters resist a kind of memory manipulation where memories themselves are actually affected.
Why act oblivious to the fact Memory Manipulation can be applied in a variety of ways
Two times characters provide explanations for how Chihiro is countering Banquet, including Chihiro himself, and they never say a single other thing than “strengthening the inner ear”. I do not think one panel of the effect being over his eye is remotely strong enough proof. You’re going too far with your interpretation of what that means without any strong confirmation from Hokazono.
Explanations for Countering Banquet's effects , not how it works.
It's plainly stated that it induces illlusory effects and alters the victims states by Narration and Hiruhiko
We know for a fact it does not only affect the inner ear (responsible for balance), it manifests illusions and manipulates the senses
This is a Manga for a reason, we get to see actions of what characters are doing not only read the words on the page, Chihiro uses Nishiki to strengthen his perception and counters Banquet at its Maximum Output, Hiruhiko directly references that specific instance too
I’m not sure how the rest of this reply really matters, could you explain that to me?
Strengthening Inner Ears is a priority to be mentioned because without it you lack the ability to defend yourself properly, we see this with the Masumi, Iori and Samura
We already know Nishiki Enhances his perception, he uses this to the max to react to Samura, telling us that Nishiki enhances Chihiro senses at this point would be spoonfeeding
Yeah it explains the balance part and not the other parts that well, but the problem is by all accounts Hokazono just portrays doing that thing as making Chihiro totally immune. I guess you can explain it by saying that whatever propagates banquet takes a path through the ears to the brain idk.
What are you saying man, it's a Spell that causes everyone within its set range to fall under its effects, you're going beyond to attribute what's not there, there is no propagation
It's Status Effect inducement over ten-hundreds of meters
You’ve got to be conservative with chucking powers onto things. The fact that it could only be resolved by a specific counter and not by “Nishiki’s general ability to shunt off supernatural influence” means it’s not supposed to be a generalised resistance. I mean, hell, you think the specific counter is by enhancing his senses. That’s not really a resistance per se is it?
That is a resistance tho?
While using Nishiki he can protect himself from all it's effects.

You seem to be ignoring the fact that when Hiruhiko noted that Chihiro was only strengthening his ears, he straight up stated that Chihiro was holding back on using his full power to kill him since Samura is his real opp
Chihiro wasn't specifically only strengthening his senses because he needed to but because he wasn't bothered enough to go all out against Hiruhiko, Samura was his real target
Another issue I have is giving things layers. Lot of shit in One Piece, Dragon Ball and Jujutsu Kaisen we’d give layers to that nobody gives layers to here if we applied the same standard of “well if a character has hax and then pumps up the output of some energy to affect someone they couldn’t before (or a person could pump up the hax more than somebody else could) then it’s layered hax and if someone resists it they have layered resistance”.
That's how it works tho?
It affects him in Base
Nishiki stops it from doing so
Hiruhiko raises his output to the max it overcomes his resistance
Turbocharged Nishiki completely neutralizes it once more

This isn't greater output = overcome layers, he's overcoming a resistance with greater output, that's textbook layering. And Banquet doesn't use magnitudinal abilities

"Layering is the ability to break through resistances to one's ability/hax. Successfully using an ability against a resistant character means that the ability is "layered." Further, resisting a layered ability is an indication of layered resistance, so on and so forth. An ability becoming stronger does not automatically mean it is layered unless it is shown to overcome a resistance."

Also I'll take this as a no and I'll make the profiles myself
 
You can’t use one panel of the effect seemingly coming off Chihiro’s eyes and develop an entirely new interpretation of how the effect is supposed to work when Nishiki enhancing things in that way has never been seen (only shown to increase stats). You can disagree 100% but I think it’s just silly and both you and Daleseab are stuck to oddly specific interpretations of what’s happening and ignore any way the text could be trying to say something else (in Dalsean’s case especially even ignoring wgat I say in this conversation).


There’s all the implications to say it is “magnitudinal” btw.
 
You can’t use one panel of the effect seemingly coming off Chihiro’s eyes and develop an entirely new interpretation of how the effect is supposed to work when Nishiki enhancing things in that way has never been seen (only shown to increase stats). You can disagree 100% but I think it’s just silly and both you and Daleseab are stuck to oddly specific interpretations of what’s happening and ignore any way the text could be trying to say something else (in Dalsean’s case especially even ignoring wgat I say in this conversation).


There’s all the implications to say it is “magnitudinal” btw.
No one ignored a thing btw, you just outright refused the answers I gave

You actually sat here and said sunlight ≠ heat

After something like that there's just no point in talking about it with you and the whole convection point is goofy as well of course its not impossible there was some heat transferred through owl but its ultimately pointless to speculate since we don't know its material properties being that its construct made of spirit energy and the fact that any heat transferred through woild be ultimatel negligible as its gonna be X amounts of watts over (the entire landmass of japan) and sunlight ain't exactly concentrated enough that it'd be strong enough for any kind of rating or "feat" as you're wanting
 
Last edited:
No one ignored a thing btw, you just outright refused the answers I gave

You actually sat here and said sunlight ≠ heat

After something like that there's just no point in talking about it with you and the whole convection point is goofy as well of course its not impossible there was some heat transferred through owl but its ultimately pointless to speculate since we don't know its material properties
You’re saying “we don’t know its material properties” while also asserting we shouldn’t treat it as a material at all, just some more or less only visual effect. My stance is simply that you should count it as a mass of feathers since that is how all of Samura’s powers work.


My argument was that if you think the changes in weather were due to a heat gradient then owl would still have to be a physical object which you could calc the GPE of or the KE to spread.
 
You’re saying “we don’t know its material properties” while also asserting we shouldn’t treat it as a material at all, just some more or less only visual effect. My stance is simply that you should count it as a mass of feathers since that is how all of Samura’s powers work.
I never said it was just a visual effect, not a single time did I claim it was an illusion. You genuinely actually just yap without comprehension just for agendas. I told you from the beginning that owl is not made of feathers like you kept asserting, Its obviously physical it blocks freaking sunlight. You keep asserting that it is made out of feathers which is a baseless assumption when its literally just a spirit energy construct made to cover an area for detection. Samura does not have creation, the feathers as well as all his abilities are spirit energy he is not making real feathers (real as in material property wise the same as a real birds) they are composed of spirit energy. You're trying to assume a material where there is nothing irl that is spirit energy substitute.

My argument was that if you think the changes in weather were due to a heat gradient then owl would still have to be a physical object which you could calc the GPE of or the KE to spread
Great never said or implied it was not a physical object hope this helps🙏❤️


KE is invalid because once again you're assuming a travel time where there is none, he literally spawned it in and despawned as he pleased, the owl ability having a travel time is entirely your own headcanon and never stated or implied and when we see it disappear its in an instant it doesn't compress inwards nor did it expand outwards and he certainly isn't pushing any mass to do so. GPE doesn't work again because its made from his spirit energy he does not have creation
 
Back
Top