• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Charlotte Montd'Or Tier and Hax Revision

Messages
3,182
Reaction score
1,107
Big Mom's Pirates are known for their formidable abilities. Montd'Or in question could be a villain of his own arc.

The proposals are:

Power and abilities

Information Analysis: When Montd'Or traps a target—be it an animal or a person—inside his book, we can see that the page where the target is imprisoned displays text containing names and additional information such as description, storyline, and location of the target.

Creation, Pocket Reality Manipulation, and Reality Warping: His Devil Fruit allows him to create books containing alternate dimensions, within which Montd'Or can freely manipulate the battlefield according to his imagination. [Check comments]

• Swap Illusion Creation to Perception Manipulation: In this scene, Montd'Or is not creating an illusion, but rather altering Luffy’s actual perception by inserting his senses into the world of books. If it were just an illusion:

1- It would have no effect on Luffy due to his Kenbunshoku Haki and mental resistance.

2- Even if we assumed it was an illusion that bypasses Haki, there would be no reason for Luffy to keep seeing Nami, who was in the real world, unless Luffy's perception of reality itself had been changed.

Fear Manipulation: Could transform his dimension into a alternate space described as a "nightmare-like world that confuses enemies". According to the Fear Manipulation page, interacting with nightmares may fall under this ability. [Check comments]

• Non Combat-Applicable Time Manipulation: There is no flow of time in the dimensions of the book so everything is eternally ageless.

• Non Combat-Applicable Spatial Manipulation: There are pages in the book that contain entire prisons that are much larger on the inside than on the outside, and can only be accessed by special bookmarks which distort them.

Fire Manipulation: Can freely create fire in the world of books, or on the pages.

Death Manipulation: If the book containing sealed people is destroyed with the pages open, it is possible to escape; but if the book is closed, then the people on it will be destroyed along with the book.

Paralysis Induction: Can keep targets completely immobile while sealed in pages.

Tier

He should be scaled to High 6-C for a few reasons:

1. He possesses a high level of authority within Lilin's crew, being responsible for giving direct orders to Lower-ranking members, such as Opera and Baron Tamago. For comparison, Opera was able to injure base Luffy and Tamago had a direct confrontation with Pedro.

2. He is recognized as a dangerous fighter by the Vinsmoke family, receiving prominence along with Amande and Bobbin. For comparison, Bobbin withstood a kick from base Sanji and Amande cut through a candy wall from Perospero casually.

This would also put him above Opera, since he was not recognized by the Vinsmoke even though he was on the front lines.

3. He was aware of the Vinsmoke family's execution plan, and therefore should have been confident in being able to kill Vinsmoke Ichiji with a shot to the head.
 
Last edited:
I can't upload it to imgur so I'll do it here:
Scan 1

Shydu4p.jpeg


Japanese:

本の世界へ引きずり込んだら、そこはモンドールの独壇場。自らの想像のままに有利な状況を創造できる。
---
Hon no sekai e hikizurikondara, soko wa Mondōru no dokudanjō. Mizukara no sōzō no mama ni yūri na jōkyō o sōzō dekiru.
---
English:

If you're dragged into the world of the book, it's Mondor's domain. He can create advantageous situations exactly as he imagines them.

Scan 2

EqPcPl8.jpeg

Japanese:
ブクブクの実を食べたシャーロット家19男。想像力で生み出した異世界や本自体に対象を閉じ込め、場を作る、作戦や戦況の使い方は多岐に及ぶ。クラッカーの仇討ちでは先陣を切り、お茶会を既に走したルフィ達の追跡時にも素早く指揮を執る、参謀的役割を担っている。現在、兄妹と共にワノ国近海で母の踊りを待つ。

English:
User of the "Buku Buku no Mi", Charlotte Mont-d'Or, 19th son of the Charlotte family. With his imagination, he can create alternate worlds and trap targets inside books or within those fictional worlds. He can set up battlefields — his ability has a wide range of tactical uses. During Cracker's revenge, he took the lead and quickly commanded the pursuit of Luffy and his crew who had already fled the tea party. He plays a strategic role as a commander. Currently, along with his siblings, he awaits his mother’s arrival near the seas of Wano.


Fear Manipulation: Could transform his dimension into a alternate space described as a "nightmare-like world that confuses enemies". According to the Fear Manipulation page, interacting with nightmares may fall under this ability.

Scan

Japanese:

幻想的異空間は、敵を困惑させる悪夢の様な世界だ!!

Rōmaji:
Gensō-teki ikūkan wa, teki o konwaku saseru akumu no yō na sekai da!!

English:
"The fantastical alternate space is a nightmare-like world that confuses the enemy!!"
 
Last edited:
1. He possesses a high level of authority within Lilin's crew, being responsible for giving direct orders to Lower-ranking members, such as Opera and Baron Tamago. For comparison, Opera was able to injure base Luffy and Tamago had a direct confrontation with Pedro.

2. He is recognized as a dangerous fighter by the Vinsmoke family, receiving prominence along with Amande and Bobbin. For comparison, Bobbin withstood a kick from base Sanji and Amande cut through a candy wall from Perospero casually.
These aren't good AP justifications for him as far as I can tell.

High authority does not necessarily mean high AP.

3. He was aware of the Vinsmoke family's execution plan, and therefore should have been confident in being able to kill Vinsmoke Ichiji with a shot to the head.
Using a special bullet to do the job, not his own personal AP.
 
I disagree with Mont-d'or's AP scaling for the same reason as Damage. Also a bit iffy on fear manipulation and fire manipulation since they seem to be subsets of perception manipulation. Everything else looks fine.
 
I'm fine with the abilities save for fire and fear manip. Fear can definitely be produced in illusions but I'm not sure this is supernatural fear and not just "ahhhhhh".
The AP isn't the best. High 6-C with the bullets is fine, but overall Ap justifications, no.
D'or really isn't a fighter like Amande or Opera or sum, he's just a Devil fruit merchant.
 
These aren't good AP justifications for him as far as I can tell.

High authority does not necessarily mean high AP.
Fair. Btw, what about the vinsmoke putting him on the same Power group as Amande and Bobbin?

Using a special bullet to do the job, not his own personal AP.
It was a special pistol made to penetrate the Vinsmoke skin. But since this is part of his arsenal, shouldn't he be High 6-C with Walker?
 
Also a bit iffy on fear manipulation and fire manipulation since they seem to be subsets of perception manipulation.
In this case, he was in the world of books when he put Luffy's senses there. Btw another piece of evidence that he can create fire is that he created some light candles on Luffy and Nami's saddle.
Everything else looks fine.
Thanks.
 
Back
Top