• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Marvel gods revision (BDE Type 2)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I disagree, we know that other versions of Eternity have their own versions of Gods (such as Thor), and the mystic realms are consistently shown as part of M-Body Earth-616, at least the larger 1-A universal structure.
Still, an argument to be made. I can easily concur one, not that it's relevant but it would need to be the full visualization of Eternity, which is a header case to argue for no doubt(I may just drop it for this one) than the M-Body representation of Eternity confining 616. Either way, I don't plan to do this too soon so there's time to reread.
 
Last edited:
Anyways since @Antvasima changed his mind with the notion that we scale the true state of divinity for 1-A. All the mods will have to “read” blog that literally affirms this not notion rather well than randomly saying it isn't because it more than makes sense with the scans in the blog.
 
Last edited:
Well, I changed my mind, but we still have to figure out how we should rationalise or explain the inconsistencies with mortals interacting with deities as equals in their own realms. 🙏
 
What is needed?
1-A Gods in their true essence as there's a scan saying they transcends dimensions entirely and they view lower beings as paintings in caves as they're in all places and unbound by time.

1

2

Or you can always read the entire blog which has over 100 scans of BDE. However, I think the first two examples are easily qualify for 1-A.
 
I think that the True Forms of the Gods can be 1-A while still being part of Universal Eternity, especially as the latter will soon be at least 3 layers into 1-A.
 
Lesser beings shadow on walls for them at their full divinity. Not to mention the scan of full divinity superseding dimensionality altogether. Also, not being confined in 616 which is 1-A embodied by Universal Eternity.
To clarify, there is a proposed second level of qualitative difference between the Elder Gods in Shadow and the Asgardians, the first being human and general gods?

With the blog in mind, the Thor and Loki we commonly see interacting with the Avengers and the like is an Avatar/Emanation of the True Thor who is in turn a shadow of Utgard Thor?

I'm looking at the blog, and the scan says that Thor creates a mystic Vortex to transport him back to Earth. However, because their dimensional axes are no longer in line, Thor could materialize from the vortex anywhere in time and space. "Materialize" might be taken out of context in this example because Thor literally leaves "presumably asgard." Was this a Thor Avatar or the True Thor trying to go to earth?
 
Last edited:
To clarify, there is a proposed second level of qualitative difference between the Elder Gods in Shadow and the Asgardians?
Yeah, Elder Gods in their true nature can rival the Abstracts.
With the blog in mind, the Thor and Loki we commonly see interacting with the Avengers and the like is an Avatar/Emanation of the True Thor who is in turn a shadow of Utgard Thor?
Something like that.
I'm looking at the blog, and the scan says that Thor creates a mystic Vortex to transport him back to Earth. However, because their dimensional axes are no longer in line, Thor could materialize from the vortex anywhere in time and space. "Materialize" might be taken out of context in this example because Thor literally leaves "presumably asgard." Was this a Thor Avatar or the True Thor trying to go to earth?
Semantics, really. “Materialize” just means appearing in form since their scared divinity is always connected to them but its inherently beyond human comprehension. They're always more or less “that” just with the touch in their natural “godly” state, they are unbound by time, space, or dimension. That's why they can casually manipulate said concept even without being in their true nature.
 
Last edited:
Semantics, really. “Materialize” just means appearing in form since their scared divinity is always connected to them but its inherently beyond human comprehension. They're always more or less “that” just with the touch in their natural “godly” state, they are unbound by time, space, or dimension. That's why they can casual manipulate said concept even without being in their true nature.
Is there an example of where True Thor is while the Avatar/Emanation is doing stuff?
 
Is there an example of where True Thor is while the Avatar/Emanation is doing stuff?
It’s indirectly notioned since Donald Blake(Up until more recent stories) is his mortal form while his Asgardian form is “Thor.” However, they're all connected with their inner essence that's not “seen” but works in tandem with the form they appear in their realms.
 
It’s indirectly notioned since Donald Blake(Up until more recent stories) is his mortal form while his Asgardian form is “Thor.” However, they're all connected with their inner essence that's not “seen” but works in tandem with the form they appear in their realms.
If I'm understanding this proposal correctly, whenever Thor is on Asgard, this is his True Form. When he travels to Earth, his True Form disappears from Asgard and "reduces" to a suitable Avatar for Earth.

To reiterate, Asgard is being proposed as a 1-A realm?
 
If I'm understanding this proposal correctly, whenever Thor is on Asgard, this is his True Form. When he travels to Earth, his True Form disappears from Asgard and "reduces" to a suitable Avatar for Earth.

To reiterate, Asgard is being proposed as a 1-A realm?
Well, given that regular superheroes and mortals have repeatedly been there and interacted with its citizens as if it is a regular environment, we also need to somehow address that inconsistency. 🙏
 
Well, given that regular superheroes and mortals have repeatedly been there and interacted with its citizens as if it is a regular environment, we also need to somehow address that inconsistency. 🙏
It's gonna be hard to explain this
P9NmYI0.jpeg
 
I don't think we've ever actually seen any examples of a "True Form"/Avatar split for Asgardians. The two examples in the blog don't show that at all, one is about teleportation and one is about astral projection, which is a different thing entirely. If we are going to go with this idea, we are going to need better proof.

That being said, that one scan gives an indication that Thor's divine powers are higher dimensional (or Outerversal) in scope, but that they inhabit a physical body, and that that physical body can become higher dimensional (or Outerversal) like his divine power.

As for average Asgardians are we even sure they count as "gods?" I don't necessarily think its inconsistent for 3D beings to live in a realm that is higher dimensional. I don't like Mephisto's minions are pan-dimensional or infinitely transcendent like his realm is. Likewise, I think non-higher dimensional characters are shown capable of interacting with Mephisto's realm in the same way they are Asgard, so I think this is just a case of Marvel lore being somewhat incongruent with VSBW standards. In Marvel, it seems like there is no in-universe contradiction of normal people interacting relatively normally with an "infinitely transcendent" or "beyond mortal comprehension" realm.
 
Last edited:
If I'm understanding this proposal correctly, whenever Thor is on Asgard, this is his True Form. When he travels to Earth, his True Form disappears from Asgard and "reduces" to a suitable Avatar for Earth.
Yeah, Donald Blake for the longest time was his “avatar.” However, the gods portion shouldn't really be that confusing, they're literal stories, legends, and myths that are given sustenance through the Demiurge and shaped by humans collective conscious.
To reiterate, Asgard is being proposed as a 1-A realm?
Yeah, there's a good reason why since their god essence and the realm from which they came are very much related.
 
Well, given that regular superheroes and mortals have repeatedly been there and interacted with its citizens as if it is a regular environment, we also need to somehow address that inconsistency. 🙏
I've already addressed this, it doesn't happen as often as you think it does. I've already stated there's somewhat different interpretation of how they appear throughout the story, but at its most consistent basis it’s beyond dimensional existence. If it were such an issue, I rather we upgrade said beings trough amps rather than count it as some sort of anti-feat.


I don't think we've ever actually seen any examples of a "True Form"/Avatar split for Asgardians. The two examples in the blog don't show that at all, one is about teleportation and one is about astral projection, which is a different thing entirely. If we are going to go with this idea, we are going to need better proof.
Like I said it really doesn't matter. I've already reticy when the “avatar” things should be used. My proposal within the blog hardly matter since they're seen differently throughout humans belief can count as their avatar that's distinct from their true essence. As long as their not in their full divinity, then counting it as avatars or direct expression more or less means the same thing.
That being said, that one scan gives an indication that Thor's divine powers are higher dimensional (or Outerversal) in scope, but that they inhabit a physical body, and that that physical body can become higher dimensional (or Outerversal) like his divine power.
Literally means the same thing, whether they're reincarnated in a body or their essence is within a physical body literally counts as a definition of an avatar.
As for average Asgardians are we even sure they count as "gods?" I don't necessarily think its inconsistent for 3D beings to live in a realm that is higher dimensional. I don't like Mephisto's minions are pan-dimensional or infinitely transcendent like his realm is. Likewise, I think non-higher dimensional characters are shown capable of interacting with Mephisto's realm in the same way they are Asgard, so I think this is just a case of Marvel lore being somewhat incongruent with VSBW standards. In Marvel, it seems like there is no in-universe contradiction of normal people interacting relatively normally with an "infinitely transcendent" or "beyond mortal comprehension" realm.
It’s not just Marvel, we’re being way too picky despite the information given. There's bound to be somewhat of a sore area that will have to come as something that'll happen with various interpretations between writers.
 
I've already addressed this, it doesn't happen as often as you think it does. I've already stated there's somewhat different interpretation of how they appear throughout the story, but at its most consistent basis it’s beyond dimensional existence. If it were such an issue, I rather we upgrade said beings trough amps rather than count it as some sort of anti-feat.
Yeah... so.... whose gonna tell him about Strange's academy field trip to Asgard?
 
Yeah... so.... whose gonna tell him about Strange's academy field trip to Asgard?
Hardly normal beings. Plus, magic and mysticism is very much connected. I don't think this example is as bad as some others.

Plus, I wanna address the mods and more serious statements. Save these comments for later.
 
Hardly normal beings. Plus, magic and mysticism is very much connected. I don't think this example is as bad as some others.
About that, one of the kids is a completely normal human with a magic jacket, the teacher there with the glasses is a completely and totally normal human without magic at all
Plus, I wanna address the mods and more serious statements. Save these comments for later.
Sure I'm not gonna keep this up either, I barely understand tier 1 anyways
 
I've already addressed this, it doesn't happen as often as you think it does. I've already stated there's somewhat different interpretation of how they appear throughout the story, but at its most consistent basis it’s beyond dimensional existence. If it were such an issue, I rather we upgrade said beings trough amps rather than count it as some sort of anti-feat.
Over the years of Marvel Comics, do we have scans that Midgard Travel/interaction with Asgard or other Godly Realms is independently caused by actions from those higher realms? As in, it is impossible for the mortal realm to initiate contact with the godly realms due to their alleged 1-A status?
 
Last edited:
Over the years of Marvel Comics, do we have scans that Midgard Travel/interaction with Asgard or other Godly Realms is independently caused by actions from those higher realms? As in, it is impossible for the mortal realm to initiate contact with the godly realms due to their alleged 1-A status?
No some of the cases just happen to be for plot conveniences. It just doesn't happen often enough until then story demands it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So you're saying a scan mentioning what I said does exist?
If by that you mean Asgardians in question teleport them to the realm as we’ve seen throughout the stories on multiple occasions then yes there's the independent cause. Typically, they don't randomly go there by accident and it rarely without some sort of connection with beings who can access the realm or a form of transportation.
 
Every single time I have seen mortals, including low-level superhumans or unpowered humans, visit Asgard or Olympus in Marvel comic books, no mention has been made of that they are elevated to a much higher state of existence, and the regular superheroes who visit there usually quite easily physically kick around the regular Asgardians.

Meaning, if we go with your approach, we would have to state that the deity realms have lower physical manifestations, with their higher essences unapproachable by lower existences. 🙏
 
Every single time I have seen mortals, including low-level superhumans or unpowered humans, visit Asgard or Olympus in Marvel comic books, no mention has been made of that they are elevated to a much higher state of existence, and the regular superheroes who visit there usually quite easily physically kick around the regular Asgardians.
Are you going in circles? I've already said a lot of the times this involves the plot, not whether they had a boost or not.
Meaning, if we go with your approach, we would have to state that the deity realms have lower physical manifestations, with their higher essences unapproachable by lower existences. 🙏
Yeah, I'm fine with that.
 
Last edited:
So you are proposing that they are basically like the New Gods of DC where they have the weaker emanation and a higher essence/Godhead form?

The Asgard that mortals interact with is also an emanation of the True Asgard?
Yeah, its clear that their divinity is still beyond time, space, and dimensions and they are stories and legends at their core.
 
Meaning, if we go with your approach, we would have to state that the deity realms have lower physical manifestations, with their higher essences unapproachable by lower existences. 🙏
Yeah, I'm fine with that.
So you are proposing that they are basically like the New Gods of DC where they have the weaker emanation and a higher essence/Godhead form?

The Asgard that mortals interact with is also an emanation of the True Asgard?
Yeah, its clear that their divinity is still beyond time, space, and dimensions and they are stories and legends at their core.
Thank you. I am personally fine with that then, but are there any stories that directly state this? 🙏
So If I understood this correctly then a construction worker that is trying to make a living from asgard is tier 1? It reminds of that guy from Agents of shield with his beserker staff.
If I understand correctly, then the construction workers would only interact with a lower physical manifestation of Asgard. 🙏
 
Thank you. I am personally fine with that then, but are there any stories that directly state this? 🙏
Its in my thread but you can check the page we have now:


It’s under AE.
 
If I understand correctly, then the construction workers would only interact with a lower physical manifestation of Asgard. 🙏
Now I'm confused, wasn't the tier 1 to apply to any asgardian while in Asgard? Or are the actual gods the only ones who will be tier 1?
I was starting to feel good about myself believing that even a tier 1 guy was struggling to make a living
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top