- 6,014
- 2,122
Well, i don't want to spend a lot of time into this since i don't care as a whole those kind of stuff so i'll be bref:
There in this thread some discussion about where all this stuff started, according to the discussion, it seem that there is some conflictual requierement for being a Type 1 abstract.
An immediat exemple of the situation, some people claim that the CT need to be Type 1 due to them embodying Time and Space and thanks to some scan such as this one which explain that Giratina lack of Concept of Time Space (since he is the Dialga/Palkia Alter) and this one who show a non physical Palkia/Dialga.
The opposite side claim that this isn't how to have type 1 AE since they don't show any of the requirement as they don't behave like the Abstract existence page said
You dont understand. We dont care if they are or are not abstractions, that is not what matters to have Abstract Existence, we care about them, as abstractions, behaving like the page says each type of abstraction behaves. Otherwise, they are abstractions but dont have Abstract Existence, because they never showed that power. Simple as that.
Basically, we need to choose the right interpretation of abstract existence, if it's the latter, some profils who are an abstraction but doesn't have the requierment will lose the Type 1 abstract (like Disembodied Thought), if it's the former, sweet! all the case (such as the CT) are now Type 1 abstract and every other case like that will be treated as such.
Good night.
There in this thread some discussion about where all this stuff started, according to the discussion, it seem that there is some conflictual requierement for being a Type 1 abstract.
An immediat exemple of the situation, some people claim that the CT need to be Type 1 due to them embodying Time and Space and thanks to some scan such as this one which explain that Giratina lack of Concept of Time Space (since he is the Dialga/Palkia Alter) and this one who show a non physical Palkia/Dialga.
The opposite side claim that this isn't how to have type 1 AE since they don't show any of the requirement as they don't behave like the Abstract existence page said
You dont understand. We dont care if they are or are not abstractions, that is not what matters to have Abstract Existence, we care about them, as abstractions, behaving like the page says each type of abstraction behaves. Otherwise, they are abstractions but dont have Abstract Existence, because they never showed that power. Simple as that.
Basically, we need to choose the right interpretation of abstract existence, if it's the latter, some profils who are an abstraction but doesn't have the requierment will lose the Type 1 abstract (like Disembodied Thought), if it's the former, sweet! all the case (such as the CT) are now Type 1 abstract and every other case like that will be treated as such.
Good night.