• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Resident Evil Remakes Canonicity

Apex_Predator_GX

Apex_Predator_GX

7,095
3,855
As we know the RE remakes are No-canon cause they were stated to be from alternative universes.

Therefore porfiles like William Birkin should have info from the canon games to the story aka the originals.

In the remake Sherry is free of the G virus, but she was never free if the g virus, this is a contradiction with RE6, It is Annette who states this fact looking at the monitor with the results of Sherry's exam.

Ada NEVER fell off the platform, her continuity in the franchise is from Leon B where she saves Leon from the T-103 and has her continuity in UC Deaths door.

Another minor example, The file Leon and Ada in RE6 describs the the events from the original RE2, Sherry tells Jake that Leon saved her, he indeed saved her because he was the one who takes Sherry out of the lab and put her in train. This didn't happen in the Reimaginin, Leon only meets Sherry when she was already inside the train.

In RE6 when Ada is about to save Sherry and Jake she She sarcastically says "I'm going to return the kindness your parents gave me"

Of course, Annette almost killed her by shooting her , and William almost ripped her head off in the Cable Car and almost ripped her arm off in the train.

this doesn't happen in Reimagining, Ada doesn't even meet William. There are a lot more details but RE:2 has continuity problems , the events don't fit the continuity of the franchise and so it's not canon, this is exactly what was said especiallyby Pete the producer, it's a Re-imagining, and revisiting is the same as reimagining , RE: 2 does the same as Shattered Memories did.

Biohazard RE:2 IS NOT CANON and doesn't fit the main plot. Biohazard 2 with Its events is the Canon game with Claire A / Leon B for the closest canon with some additional information.
 
If the remakes are stated to take place in an alternate timeline, there could be different versions of some of those various characters if it's different enough.
 
I concur, the remakes are too different in so many regards, almost entirely new things in some cases.
 
They aré definitely NOT the same timeline as the original games but also they are a re-interpretation (Stated by Capcom himself) of the canon events so we should go with Profiles for the main timeline characters.
 
This seems to probably be fine.
 
Not really sure if feats would get affected by this at all TBH. They'd still scale to the feats done in RE4 and later.
 
So have enough people accepted this?
 
We are separating different versions of a character due to the different canon.

RE2 ramake is no canon to the main continuity
 
I know but RE1 Remake is not canon to the following entires in the saga at difference with the original RE which is the true canon fisrt part.
 
Apex PredatorX said:
I know but RE1 Remake is not canon to the following entires in the saga at difference with the original RE which is the true canon fisrt part.
Click to expand...
So the feats of the Remake are to be considered invalid or put in a different key?
 
Then i guess we would have to make different keys.

And about RE0, since the RE1 Remake is going to count as an alternative version then the same would be applied with the former, RE0 does had more plot/character similiarities with the Remake rather than the Original, especially if we are going to still consider the Umbrella Chronicles (or at least certain parts) as canon to the Remakes.

I mean, in the Original Rebecca in RE1 did say that she has take refuge to the Mansion right after the helicopter had landed, when in RE0 Bravo Team split in search of evidence.
 
Different keys may be a good idea.
 
It makes sense also yes UC is canon to the remakes.

The problem Is the scaling chain For example Némesis from Original RE3 is Small Building level scaling from feats of the RE2 Remake
 
Apex PredatorX said:
It makes sense also yes UC is canon to the remakes.
The problem Is the scaling chain For example Némesis from Original RE3 is Small Building level scaling from feats of the RE2 Remake
Click to expand...
Like it was say before, Nemesis and other characters will get a key for their Remake counterpart.
 
We should start revising the Tyrants.

T-002
T-002 bashes through multiple feet of solid stone and concrete to reach the surface.

6087066-nemesis feat strength (1)


T-103
T-103 smashes through a building floor. minute 10:13

Resident Evil 2 Cutscenes 720P HD
Resident Evil 2 Cutscenes 720P HD


T-Nemesis
Nemesis punches through the solid granite walls of a cathedral.

6087099-nemesis feat strength (8)
 
Willian Birki

Second form Birkin punches through the steel side of the train with his claw arm

6088553-birkin strength (3)


Fifth form Birkin is fully able to pulls its mass, which is the size of a train cart.

6088589-birkin strength (10)


Fifth form Birkin's tentacles rip through the train.

6088579-birkin strength (11)
 
Shouldnt OG speed be looked at first? Since the supersonic speed comes from the first REmake.


though I'm curious about dismissing that as non canon since I do believe nothing is contradicted and only Re2 make was stated to be a reimagining.
 
So what should we do here?
 
I agree. Remakes always supplant the originals unless they are directly stated to be separate continuities. This also applies to FFVII Remake. It makes less sense for RE than FF, but whatever, if that's what Capcom wants.
 
Sera EX said:
I agree. Remakes always supplant the originals unless they are directly stated to be separate continuities. This also applies to FFVII Remake. It makes less sense for RE than FF, but whatever, if that's what Capcom wants.
Click to expand...
Which one are you agreeing with here doe
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

AnonymousStandUser
Resident Evil AP and Speed upgrades
Replies
12
Views
3K
AnonymousStandUser
AnonymousStandUser
Pyro9278
  • Article
Some general updates
Replies
16
Views
2K
AnonymousStandUser
AnonymousStandUser
Employe
Resident Evil CRT
Replies
27
Views
3K
Employe
Employe
Renitr
Resident Evil: Movies (aka an attempt to resurrect this verse from the dead). Some massive reworks and additions for Alice profile part 1
Replies
4
Views
1K
XSOULOFCINDERX
XSOULOFCINDERX
Random-Helper323
She-Hulk vs Leon S Kennedy
Replies
8
Views
1K
XxZetsuxX
XxZetsuxX
Back
Top