Madness manipulation vs Mad people

PaChi2

VS Battles

Retired

20,720

3,668

• Jul 17, 2019

• #1

For example:

Carnage (Marvel Comics) has madness manipulation because by sharing his own twisted thoughts he drives people insane. In other words, he is already mad enough to make others mad.

Which leads me to believe he should have resistance to madness manipulation to some deegree.

Any other cases you can think of? Is being mad/crazy enough to resist Madness Manipulation, albeit to an unknown deegree?

 

PaChi2

VS Battles

Retired

20,720

3,668

• Jul 17, 2019

• Thread starter
• #2

Someone please move this to the General Discussion board. This does not belong here, thanks.

 

The_King_of_Prudence

10,645

1,589

• Jul 17, 2019

• #3

This is why we need more people who can cure madness.

 

Iapitus_The_Impaler

16,606

1,785

• Jul 17, 2019

• #4

Not exactly the same thing, but I recall that in bird box those that are already insane are not forced to suicide by whatever the monster shows

 

Dienomite22

7,897

3,856

• Aug 16, 2019

• #5

bump

 

TriforcePower1

8,373

3,043

• Aug 19, 2019

• #6

PaChi2 said:

Someone please move this to the General Discussion board. This does not belong here, thanks.

Click to expand...

 

Elizhaa

VS Battles

Administrator

15,711

7,686

• Aug 20, 2019

• #7

^^

It has been done.

 

PaChi2

VS Battles

Retired

20,720

3,668

• Aug 20, 2019

• Thread starter
• #8

Thanks!

Now... Can I have input regarding this? Pls

 

KnightOfSunlight

2,486

872

• Aug 20, 2019

• #9

Well, this seems like one of the things that depends.

There's multiple forms of "Madness" in the real world. None of them are even remotely required to be similar, aside from a functional lack of normal thought. Things like Psychosis are entirely different from things like Schizophrenia.

So... it depends. If the two types of madness are similar, then the character that already suffers from it should be immune to madness manip that introduces that madness (A character suffering from schizophrenia can't get double schizophrenia, now can they?). Meanwhile, if they are not similar, they shouldn't be immune because it's a different type of mental instability (Someone with Schizophrenia certainly ca get Psychosis from madness manip)

Overall, I'd say it depends, and the best way to determine is to look at the symptoms and determine what they have.

...Which doesn't always work in fiction. Shit.

 

Elizhaa

VS Battles

Administrator

15,711

7,686

• Aug 21, 2019

• #10

PaChi2 said:

Thanks!
Now... Can I have input regarding this? Pls

Click to expand...

Glad to help!

I agree with @KnightOfSunlight's point. I think the best characters could get is Limited Resistance to Madness Manipulatrion since they are already mad.

 

Epsilon_R

He/Him

6,262

1,276

• Aug 23, 2019

• #11

Question

Can a possessed character that can only feel hatred be affected by madness manipulation ?