Madara vs LS Teleportation
So, here's the scene:
- Mabui uses a technique on Ay (Fourth raikage) and Lady Tsunade that can transport her target at Light Speed
- They travel towards the battlefield at light speed while their bodies are covered by the aura of the technique (Second scan, top part of the second to last Panel) and are aimed towards Madara (on the bottom right of the second scan, second to last panel) and Muu (Bottom left of the same panel)
- On the third and last Scan, you see that Madara was able to intercept Tsunade who was kicking her while still being covered in the aura of the technique. My assertion is that she attacked Madara while still traveling at LS (Due to Mabui's transportation technique) and Madara was able to react to it putting his reactions at Relativistic.
Most of the disagreement with this Madara feat seams to stem partly from mere conjecture that leads down a rabbit hole of more conjecture solely in order to justify Ay catching KaMuuto off guard in order to somehow prove that Ay landed before he attacked...that doesn't work.
This is what it would have looked like had they arrived directly from the sky to the ground (the top right panel)
We know exactly what it would have looked like had they arrived from the sky directly to the ground (The first scan. Right next to this paragraph)
Madara (bottom right) and Muu (who is controlled by Kabuto on the bottom left) the blue approaching streaks you see on the very top of the second to last panel are Ay and Tsunade approaching at LS
There is nothing like that happening in the picture with Madara and Muu though (second scan. Right next to this paragraph). You can clearly see Tsunade and Ay's lights (Circled in Red) rushing towards KaMuuto and Madara and not the ground. You need substantial evidence to prove that they did rush directly towards the ground in front of KaMuuto and Madara which hasn't even been shown.
Tsunade and Ay attacking from slightly above
Also, based on the angle that they attacked (From slightly above to below. Third scan, right next to this paragraph), in order for Tsuande and Ay to have landed first before attacking, the sequence of events would have to be like this:
- They land in front of Madara and Muu
- they then jump into the air and come down towards them at an angle as they lash out a punch and kick
- Ay conveniently forgets his Lightning Armor just because.
- during the process of them landing and then jumping into the air, Madara decides to just cross his arms while Muu remains dumbfounded and is caught off guard by a base Ay who, let's not forget, conveniently forgot to activate his instantaneous Lightning Armor even though he had the time to land and then jump forward for another attack...
That is the only way the scene in the panel where Ay and Tsunade are shown to attack Madara and Muu could happen. A lot more assumptions have to be make, assumptions that need to somehow be proven, assumptions that not only goes against what supplementary canon showed us, but also require you to stretch your imagination in order for this to be feasible.
Too many assumptions.
Mine, however, goes like this.
- They attacked Madara and Muu head on during the LS transports
Easy, simply, less assumptions, supported by Secondary/Tertiary canon (The anime: no idea which one it even is), coincides with Relativistic Databook statements.
Better yet, this feat ties in perfectly with the Databook statements which would put the characters at around Rel+
My rendition of events is supported by evidence to why they didn't land before attacking (Ay would have used his Lightning Cloak like he does every. Single. Time.), the anime, and Databook statements that put such high tiers around that speed.
Finally, my rendition of events requires much much less assumptions in order to justify than the opposition. Occam's Razor I think it's called.
Ay
The Databook gives us a statement for Relativistic Ay through Lariat as he moves "near the speed of light." This likewise ties in with him reacting to and launching an attack while in LS transport courtesy of Mabui. It is not at all difficult to react to something merely 2x faster than you are used to.
Sasuke
We know that with his MS and his chidori, he was able to effectively tag Ay the Raikage. Even if you find the increase amount of perception given by the Mangekyō Sharingan to be not enough, you also have the fact that the chidori gives an unquantifiable increase in speed to the user. So much so that they develop tunnel vision if they don't have the sharingan to supplement them.
Additionally, Sasuke has dodged Lariat, a technique requiring the user to move close to the SoL.
Mifune
For him it's only his attack speed. Databook states that he attacks at light speed, supported by the above scaling since he attack and was countered by Sasuke who we have established to be Relativistic according to the Databook entries. Each statement seems to fit in perfectly with the next with little inconsistency between them and not much dissonance with the character scaling.
Finishing Thoughts
In such a situation where the statements of feats perfectly coincide with each other and work within the context of the story, I think it should be acceptable for the Databook statements to be used.
We have made sure that the statements from the Databook that we are considering (As noted in the OP of thread 1) are not hyperbolic and actually make sense when considering character scaling. There is a reason no one is considering LS Haku.
As a little tidbit, this thread should under no way violate the discussion rules of Naruto threads.
- We aren't claiming that characters are LS or FTL, only that they are Relativistic.
- The Databook descriptions presented are non-hyperbolic statements and fit within the story while also scaling well to other individual feats that are also stated to be Relativistic.