- 1,250
- 370
I'm fairly certain there existed multiple threads about this topic beforehand, but here goes:
I honestly do not know why profiles for games such as these yet, some people would argue that they are 'fanmade' content and whatnot, but I say otherwise.
The idea of these games being 'fanmade content' is like saying RPG maker games like Ao Oni or Witch's House would be fanmade RPG maker content because of the fact that you use a specific program/game developing tool to make them.
Roblox is an online game creation platform that allows users to create their own games, identically to how RPG maker is a series of programs for the developing role playing games and whatnot.
There are multiple games on Roblox that are relatively popular and generally known by a huge following (Such as the following three above, for example) and are basically their own games with their own feats and whatnot, identically to how profiles for RPG maker games are essentially their own games with their own feats.
This would obviously exclude fangames for things coming from official franchises, such as this game - which is a fangame for an existing franchise. To compare this to RPG Maker standards, an Undertale fangame made in RPG maker is excluded from VSB due to it being a fan content rather than actual, canonical content made from Toby Fox.
If profiles of these are actually allowed, then they should either be their own existing verse (Or linked to the Roblox verse page, with various headers identifying which game it is from) or category, also following under the "Roblox" category. This would be identical to how profiles such as Mogeko (Which is from an RPG maker game) would have "RPG Maker" and "Mogeko Castle" (The verse it originated from) in the categories.
Of course, the creation of profiles from Roblox games would only actually extend to games that aren't very vague and have a portion of content within them to scale feats from (Which there are a decent amount of), so that wouldn't be too hard.
In short, given the fact there are profiles for games made from a program used to develop RPGs (Which have their own feats), it should be logical that there would be profiles for Roblox (A game creation platform/program) games, which also have their own feats.
I'm completely fine separating the various games into verse pages, or linking the verse pages for various games in the verse page for Roblox
I honestly do not know why profiles for games such as these yet, some people would argue that they are 'fanmade' content and whatnot, but I say otherwise.
The idea of these games being 'fanmade content' is like saying RPG maker games like Ao Oni or Witch's House would be fanmade RPG maker content because of the fact that you use a specific program/game developing tool to make them.
Roblox is an online game creation platform that allows users to create their own games, identically to how RPG maker is a series of programs for the developing role playing games and whatnot.
There are multiple games on Roblox that are relatively popular and generally known by a huge following (Such as the following three above, for example) and are basically their own games with their own feats and whatnot, identically to how profiles for RPG maker games are essentially their own games with their own feats.
This would obviously exclude fangames for things coming from official franchises, such as this game - which is a fangame for an existing franchise. To compare this to RPG Maker standards, an Undertale fangame made in RPG maker is excluded from VSB due to it being a fan content rather than actual, canonical content made from Toby Fox.
If profiles of these are actually allowed, then they should either be their own existing verse (Or linked to the Roblox verse page, with various headers identifying which game it is from) or category, also following under the "Roblox" category. This would be identical to how profiles such as Mogeko (Which is from an RPG maker game) would have "RPG Maker" and "Mogeko Castle" (The verse it originated from) in the categories.
Of course, the creation of profiles from Roblox games would only actually extend to games that aren't very vague and have a portion of content within them to scale feats from (Which there are a decent amount of), so that wouldn't be too hard.
In short, given the fact there are profiles for games made from a program used to develop RPGs (Which have their own feats), it should be logical that there would be profiles for Roblox (A game creation platform/program) games, which also have their own feats.
I'm completely fine separating the various games into verse pages, or linking the verse pages for various games in the verse page for Roblox