- 15,332
- 7,563
Relevant:
1. https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Assaltwaffle/Stars:_Standards_and_GBE
2. https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/1269115
Basically, we had a whole discussion about this and decided some of the stuff in the Tier 4, from Small Star to Large Star level, was incorrect.
For example, the GBE of the Sun, which is listed as the baseline for the 4-C tier. Except the GBE of the Sun is only 2.277146e+40 joules; which is a far-cry from the value listed in the profile. It would only fall under Low 4-C.
Furthermore, according to our Gravitational Binding Energy page, the GBE of the Earth and the Sun were calculated with a more precise formula than the one we always use. This is also false; the supposed "more precise formula' is actually identical to the formula we use, the order of the letters is just different, and the results with that are identical down to the fourth decimal.
Also, according to one of our members, the values listed on the Wikipedia page aren't even present on the alleged sources for them, which makes it even worse.
In other words, the GBE of the Sun is nowhere near the value listed even with the "better formula". We should thus downgrade the standards for 4-C to the new value calculated above; 2.277164x10^41 joules.
Now, onto the second issue.
This one may not be as important, but it is still one. With the new information, the "Dwarf", "Small" and "Large" names are incorrect and redundant. A large star is actually much easier to destroy than the Sun, for example, and red dwarfs are actually the "large" stars here, with their GBEs being well within the High 4-C range.
To sum it up, the largest star in the universe, UY Scuti, has poor density, and as such, its GBE is very tiny. It only comes off to Dwarf Star level+; except it is not a dwarf star, it is the largest star ever. As such, Assaltwaffle believes they should be removed and renamed.
To what, we don't know. Perhaps "Low Star", "Star", and "High Star level". I'm personally not into this suggestion, but still, opinions are needed.
Summary
NOTE: STAFF ONLY
1. https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Assaltwaffle/Stars:_Standards_and_GBE
2. https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/1269115
Basically, we had a whole discussion about this and decided some of the stuff in the Tier 4, from Small Star to Large Star level, was incorrect.
For example, the GBE of the Sun, which is listed as the baseline for the 4-C tier. Except the GBE of the Sun is only 2.277146e+40 joules; which is a far-cry from the value listed in the profile. It would only fall under Low 4-C.
Furthermore, according to our Gravitational Binding Energy page, the GBE of the Earth and the Sun were calculated with a more precise formula than the one we always use. This is also false; the supposed "more precise formula' is actually identical to the formula we use, the order of the letters is just different, and the results with that are identical down to the fourth decimal.
Also, according to one of our members, the values listed on the Wikipedia page aren't even present on the alleged sources for them, which makes it even worse.
In other words, the GBE of the Sun is nowhere near the value listed even with the "better formula". We should thus downgrade the standards for 4-C to the new value calculated above; 2.277164x10^41 joules.
Now, onto the second issue.
This one may not be as important, but it is still one. With the new information, the "Dwarf", "Small" and "Large" names are incorrect and redundant. A large star is actually much easier to destroy than the Sun, for example, and red dwarfs are actually the "large" stars here, with their GBEs being well within the High 4-C range.
To sum it up, the largest star in the universe, UY Scuti, has poor density, and as such, its GBE is very tiny. It only comes off to Dwarf Star level+; except it is not a dwarf star, it is the largest star ever. As such, Assaltwaffle believes they should be removed and renamed.
To what, we don't know. Perhaps "Low Star", "Star", and "High Star level". I'm personally not into this suggestion, but still, opinions are needed.
Summary
- Change 1: Change the standard for 4-C to 2.277164x10^40 joules. This would widen the gap between it and High 4-C.
- Change 2: Rename the tier 4 components due to the fact that dwarf and small stars are harder to destroy. It may not be necessary, but we are open to suggestions here.
NOTE: STAFF ONLY
