• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Percy Jackson (Riordanverse) vs Hitsugaya Toshiro (Bleach)

KinkiestSins

Messages
3,298
Reaction score
370
Inconclusive, Both of them are very experienced in swordsmanship, to the point that the fight could go either way. I'm leaning towards Percy via invunerablitiy though.
 
DMUA said:
Inconclusive, Both of them are very experienced in swordsmanship, to the point that the fight could go either way. I'm leaning towards Percy via invunerablitiy though.
Click to expand...
Well at least Toshiro can ignore durability.

I am not sure how in 10+ books (at least to my knowledge), percy has no resistances to freezing (although he can control it in a mild form)

So theres that.
 
As far as I know Percy is quite resistant to cold. At least enough to be able to swim in subzero temperatures for a good couple minutes literally unharmed. The only way for Hitsugaya to take this would be by immobilizing him with ice, but considering Percy's powers, I do not know if that would work. Even the attack hHitsugaya used against Halibel could break with a gigantic earthquake.

But Hitsugaya could just stay out of Percys Range by flying, but he could not harm Percy that way.

I go with Inconclusive.
 
Heilergott said:
As far as I know Percy is quite resistant to cold. At least enough to be able to swim in subzero temperatures for a good couple minutes literally unharmed. The only way for Hitsugaya to take this would be by immobilizing him with ice, but considering Percy's powers, I do not know if that would work. Even the attack hHitsugaya used against Halibel could break with a gigantic earthquake.
But Hitsugaya could just stay out of Percys Range by flying, but he could not harm Percy that way.

I go with Inconclusive.
Click to expand...
I dont recall this in the books, but vote counted.

Inconclusive: 2
 
Him swiming in Sub-Zero waters or causing an earthquake?
 
Pretty sure that was in Son of Neptune.
 
It was in Son of Neptune when he fell off the Glacier. He was gone for a good couple minutes. Considering how cold the water had to be and how long he was in it, he has to have some kind of resistance to cold. Otherwise he would have frozen to Death. Instead he just came out of the water completely unaffected. Im not saying it is as strong as his heatresistance, but it's there.
 
Hmmm, I believe Toshiro has the AP advantage here (12.4 Gigaton vs 63.2 Gigaton) I'm might leaning to Toshiro for now because he's 5 times stronger than Percy.
 
I will count your vote, but keep in mind Percy has Invulnerability. Honestly, Freezing is how he can win. (But I think he is Island Level+ because he froze something so I think this is fine) Inconclusive: 2 Toshiro: 1
 
Dat Dot said:
Ah I see, how his invulnerability works?
Click to expand...
Basically, any part of his body that isnt his Achilles hill (the spot above his Naval), he tanks. However, might take out the curse because apparently he resists freezing...
 
Invulnerability doesn't exactly translates to infinite dura, tho. It just means that attacks on a certain character's league simply do not harm him in any form (Except for weaknesses). That was shown in Percy's case. He wasn't really hurt by any attacks that would've insta-killed normal Percy, but Hyperion's strongest strikes did make him feel pain and knocked the air out of his lungs, and I may not recall it exactly, but I think Possessed!Luke was wounding Percy through the fight.

Really, invulnerability is just a massive durability in comparison to one's attack power. Kind of inverse Glass Cannon.

Anyway, I'm leaning towards Toshiro, since he's muuuch stronger than Percy. Invulnerability may diminish the beating Percy's taking, but Toshiro's durability will guarantee he can endure Percy's attacks very easily. Toshiro should take this with medium difficulties.
 
Yeah, I also think that Toshiro would have a chance, but realistically speaking, what has he to offer? Ice and a Sword. And none of that will harm Percy, I believe. Keep in mind, there is not a single sustained wound under the Curse of Achilles in the Riordanverse, besides Kronos, whose full divine power and essence was resting inside a mortal, touching the most powerful weapon in the entire Verse, a weapon made to kill Primordials.

That's the only wound with Curse of Achilles. And keep in mind, under the Curse of Achilles Percy trashed Hades easily. Curse of Achilles is far more than just a durability increase, It increases every single aspect of a being to it's possible maximum, including powers as it seems. Considering that Percy was easily keeping up with People ranging from 6c to 5c+ throughout the series WITHOUT the Curse, I just do not see how Hitsugaya could possibly take down Percy. In Melee, Percy should be stronger.

Besides, it stands to doubt how effective Ice even is against Percy. He is noted to have "Ice Manipulation" and considering Water cannot harm him, I do not know if being frozen will even do anything.

I've added a list of the only things seemingly able to kill someone under the Curse of Achilles. This was copied from the Percy Jackson FANDOM page on the curse of Achilles, for conveniece sake. I however have taken out the "useless" onces that will only work for the Deity's in the Riordan-Verse

  • Dehydration
  • Asphyxiation (e.g. drowning, choking)
  • Diseases (heart attack, strokes, cancer,etc.)
  • Electrocution (claimed by the Rivergods, unproven)
  • Burning (Kronos burned his hand on the molten Scythe of Gea/Gaia)
  • Starvation
  • Poison
  • Exhaustion
Since Percy is Poseidon's Son it is quite doubtable he will die by Dehidration and he can't drown. He will not die by Disease in-fight either. Hitsugaya has no way to electrocute him. Neither can he burn him with Priomordial killing Metal molten by the Flame of Olympus either. He also has no poison.

So the only points on the list are Choking, Exhaustion and Starvation.

I'm doubting if any of that will happen. Percy is extremely able in Melee-Combat, so I doubt Hitsugaya will choke him to Death. That, also, would be out of Character for him. He either uses his ice or his sword.

While Percy can die of Exhaustion, he is extremely Tenacious und his Stamina is rechargable in water -or, if you want to look at it from another side, in water, he has nigh-infinite stamina. And considering Percy tends to run around with Ambrosia and Nectar, he probably will not die from either starvation OR exhaustion.

If someone had an idea how Hitsugaya could do anything against all this, feel free to share.

EDIT: Tried to fix Spelling Errors.
 
Toshiro wins. Percy is an impressive swordsman, but Toshiro is a Soul Reaper Captain, with way more expierience in comparison to Percy. Toshiro can also manipulate water easier than Percy. Also, the Curse of Achilles won't help Percy that much. Toshiro is much faster than Percy, and will resort to rush around him, continuously attacking with his sword and ice blasts. He would eventually hit Percy in the back.
 
Do you even Read the Comments and Rules? Speed is equalized -ergo Toshiro will not do anything like dancing around Percy. Considering that Percy can keep up with the God of War (ergo around the maximum of sword skill) it is extremely unlikely he will be defeated like that. Not even to mention that it would be OOC for Toshiro to fight like that.

Toshiro cannot manipulate water at all - besides turning it into ice. If you read above, this is of questionable use.
 
Ok, fine, speed is equalized. But Ares in the Riodanverse is actually garbage in terms of power, and he was toying with Percy during that fight. Also, once he freezes Percy's water, he can manipulate that ice to his liking. He also has much more expierience in comparison to Percy, there's no arguing there. Percy spends his days between each Percy Jackson book at school, while Toshiro in his 6-C days was continuously honing his Bankai.
 
@Mickey

Percy can control ice too. Just saying.

As for experience, Percy clashed evenly with warriors thousands of years old and was the best swordsman to come out of Camp Half-Blood in 300 years.

Experience might not be your best bet here.
 
Riordanverse Ares is not garbage. He is one of the strongest mythological iterations out there, given his 5-C rating. Don't know where you got that from.
 
This smells criminally like someone that does not know the PJ Series. As for Hitsugaya - as far as I know, he has never shown the Ablity to manipualte preexisting ice. Just generate it.
 
Then he slammed Riptide into the ice at his feet. The entire glacier shuddered. Ghosts fell to their knees. Behind Percy, a wave surged up from the bay—a wall of gray water even taller than the glacier. Water shot from the chasms and crevices in the ice. As the wave hit, the back half of thecamp crumbled. The entire edge of the glacier peeled away, cascading into the void—carrying buildings, ghosts, and Percy Jackson over the edge.
Edit: Ignore my previous comments. I was worked up over something and wasn't in the right mindset and misread things.
 
It seems like Percy is manipulating the solid water inside the glacier. Which hilariously still counts as Ice Manipulation.

Reppuzan is right.
 
@Reppuzan

However, it seems like Heiler was talking about Hitsugaya not being able to generate ice, not Percy. And he also seemed to be talking about Mickey, not you.
 
I'll be even more generous, here are some more quotes:

I got to my feet and willed the entire creek to rise. It swirled up, hundreds of gallons of water in a massive icy funnel cloud.
~ The Titan's Curse​
Percy was fighting like a whirlwind. In fact...he was a whirlwind. A miniature hurricane of water and ice vapor churned around him as he wadedthrough the enemy, knocking Roman ghosts away, deflecting arrows and spears. Since when did he have that power?
~ The Son of Neptune​
 
As it seems to have been confusing: I meant Hitsugaya. Toshiro has never displayed the ability to manipualte already formed ice. I already knew Percy is very much able to manipualte ice.

As to Repuzan - I always thought he turned the Ice INSIDE the Glacier into water and used it to burst the Ice.
 
I'll swap to Percy for reasons above.
 
@Heilergott

He's used half-frozen water as well as ice, converting the latter into vapor in order to generate a hurricane.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Robo432343
Toshiro Hitsugaya vs. Byakuya Kuchiki
Replies
16
Views
957
Robo432343
Robo432343
SheevShezarrine
Magical Teenage Fugitive vs Magical Teenage Fed
Replies
4
Views
2K
SheevShezarrine
SheevShezarrine
Topaz404
Minamitsu Murasa vs Percy Jackson (Riordianverse) (0-0-0)
Replies
12
Views
1K
Topaz404
Topaz404
ReaperAndBlues
Getting Hot? Here's a Fight to Cool You Off.
Replies
31
Views
2K
ReaperAndBlues
ReaperAndBlues
GraveDigger84
Added abilities for Percy Jackson
Replies
39
Views
2K
GraveDigger84
GraveDigger84
Back
Top