• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Status
Not open for further replies.
3,630
1,710
Sup, we’re doing Universal Naruto again. Before this thread gets shut down immediately, let me make a couple of things clear. 1. These are new arguments that haven’t been discussed before, as far as I’ve checked. 2. This is only targeting the ETSB of Kaguya and Creation of All Things for characters that can use it, no one else, so I’m not upgrading any of the characters’ AP due to UES, just this one attack and hax. 3. I am not using the Boruto movie novel or Road to Ninja movie, only strictly what’s within the Naruto manga and databooks. So I ask that you all take your time to read the thread and have a proper discussion. With all said and done, let's take a stroll through hell one more time.
The first thing I'm going to discuss are the statements surrounding Kaguya’s dimensions. At the final confrontation with Naruto, we see Kaguya drag Naruto and Sasuke into a multitude of her parallel dimensions, which she begins quickly swapping between. It is during one of these dimensional swaps that we see Obito connect to one of the parallel worlds by activating his Kamui; he successfully does so, which then allows Sasuke to switch places with Sakura's vest inside the dimension that Obito and Sakura are in before the Kamui portal closes. Sasuke then remarks that although he can shift himself between spaces using his Rinnegan, he can only do so over finite distances, and the reason he managed to make it into the portal was because of both Obito's Kamui teleportation and Sakura's vest. The reason this is important is because Sasuke specifically says he can only teleport over finite distances, and had Sakura's vest not been there, he would not have been able to do so. Implying that the distance between each realm is infinite rather than finite, which is further supported later. An important factor in this is Obito's statement, when he manages to connect one of Kaguya’s dimensions to another, that it was difficult to do so because of the sheer vastness of each dimension. The reason this is impressive is because Obito himself can connect between the Kamui dimension, which has been stated on numerous occasions to be its own time-space, and the normal universe without difficulty. Not only is Obito able to transport himself between the normal universe and the Kamui, he even does so from the Pure Lands pretty easily.
Another similar argument is that Naruto and Sasuke can both perceive limbo clones: Naruto through the use of his Six Paths Mode and Sasuke through his Rinnegan. The significance of this comes from a statement in the databook discussing the limbo clones, which says that the clones actually exist in an entirely different plane and dimension, as already accepted in this wiki. Naruto and Sasuke seemingly have no trouble seeing or sensing these clones that do not even exist in the normal universe, yet when they were separated into just two of Kaguya’s dimensions, Naruto outright says he cannot sense Sasuke, which means that the distance between each of Kaguya's dimensions is even greater than the distance of both the limbo and the Kamui dimension to the normal universe. Another supporting argument for the limbo clones being outside of the universe is that Sasuke's Mangekyo Sharingan was completely incapable of perceiving the limbo clones, which may not seem impressive on the surface, but in the third databook on page 274, it is described that the Susano’o can only be used by those who have unlocked the Mangekyo Sharingan and then describes the Mangekyo as “the heavenly eyes that see all things in the universe.”. If you look farther at the page, the title of the section says, “Residing in the eyes of those who grasp the inner workings of heaven and earth is a tempestuous warrior wielding a sword and shield.”. In Japanese, the kanji “天地” commonly refers to both “heaven and earth” and "universe," which further supports their capability to perceive universal ranges. Basically, this would mean that Sasuke, who does have the Mangekyo, which can perceive all things in the universe, cannot perceive the limbo. Which means the limbo is simply outside of the universe, as supported by the databook statement mentioned earlier, and both Naruto and Sasuke, with their Sage of Six Paths powers, are capable of perceiving the limbo clones yet are completely unable to sense each other when just separated amongst two of Kaguya's dimensions.
This argument also applies to Naruto, as Naruto is able to sense the world's origin as stated in the fourth databook and the statement of Naruto having reached the peak of sensory capabilities (bottom right), which scales above the likes of the Mangekyo Sharingan's ability to perceive all things in the universe and grasp the inner workings of heaven and earth. This all pretty much goes back to the argument of Naruto being unable to detect Sasuke in another one of Kaguya’s dimensions, despite having sensory capabilities that surpass the Mangekyo Sharingan. The Truth Seeking Orb databook page also supports this idea, as it reveals that “within the orb is the power of all of creation.”. This statement is practically repeated in the Expanding Truth Seeking Orb databook page, which states that “composed of all five elements and yin-yang, it had the power to obliterate the world and return it to nothing. Composed of all chakra natures, a vast, expanding mass is filled to the brim. Created to reshape the world, it was a huge mass of chaos.” This statement proves that Kaguya was going to return the world to nothing with her ETSB, which is supported by Black Zetsu’s statement that it was going to be the beginning of a new space. All of this proves that Kaguya is going to consume and recreate the dimension or space (which is of universal size) with her ETSB.
The final thing I found in regards to Kaguya and her dimensions is this statement from Kakashi, which directly says Kaguya was going to rewrite the entire world and compares it to Genjutsu. This obviously supports the databook statement earlier, which said she was going to destroy and recreate everything, and the statement from Zetsu, which said, “This is the beginning of a new space.”. The reason it's important to note the genjutsu aspect of this statement is because Kaguya also has the capability of turning genjutsu into reality, which I will shortly get into. Hagoromo also has a multitude of statements that help solidify this argument as well. The first of which is stated on the Uchiha stone tablet that Hagoromo wrote ages ago. On this tablet, it is said that the Rinnegan possesses the power of “two opposing forces that made everything in creation in the universe.”. This statement gets mistranslated a lot due to the weird use of language, but the kanji used in this statement is “森羅万象”. I have compiled multiple definitions of 森羅万象, which amounts to “all things in nature; the whole creation," “all things in the world," “all creation,” and simply "universe.”. So based upon this, we can say that most likely this kanji is referring to “the whole creation,” due to the context of the Stone Tablet statement, and seeing as Hagoromo is a master of the Rinnegan, this would mean he wields the power of all creation. To support this, in both entries with the Banshou Ten’in and the Shinra Tensei, it is stated that they are able to pull in and repel all things in creation. This entry comes from the fourth databook, which means it's likely referring to the full usage of these abilities rather than the ones we saw Nagato use. To add on to this argument even more, in the third databook on page 120, it is stated that the Rinnegan has “infinite depths of power awakened," which just makes the position way more consistent. In the third databook on page 313, Hagoromo is directly stated to be “a god of creation who subjugates the world or a god of destruction that can reduce everything to nothing,” which is very similar to the databook statement for Kaguya mentioned earlier.
As per what is accepted in the wiki, Creation of All Things is an ability that allows Hagoromo to "turn fantasy into reality" and "create form out of naught" using the power of Yin-Yang Release. Yin-Yang Release is comprised of Yin Release, which governs mental energies and imagination that can create form from naught, and Yang Release, which governs physical energies that can instill life into any form created. It's from these two individual powers that all Jutsu sprung forth into existence, and in fact, all forms of Ninjutsu are considered but mere fragments of Yin-Yang Release. This ability is also considered the parent Jutsu for Izanagi, which is nothing more than a practical application of Creation of All Things. By combining both aspects of Yin-Yang Release that the Uchiha and Senju each possessed respectively, which essentially recreates Hagoromo's original power, the Izanagi can rid the user of anything disadvantageous, such as injury or death, by casting an illusion on the user and turning their unwanted reality into a dream, illusion, or non reality; however, anything advantageous such as the user's own attacks remain "real". It's a Jutsu that ties reality and illusion together, and makes fantasy into a reality. All of this is done simply with Genjutsu, which, just like the tsukuyomi, has been shown to create incredibly vast mental worlds, such as the time Itachi used it on Yashiro in the Itachi novel, where he created infinite copies of himself to stab Yashiro. In the second databook, in the tsukuyomi entry, it describes the jutsu as “an inner hell as eternal as heaven and earth, with a grip held tightly on the principles of all of creation," a strange world of infinity unbound by the limitations of time, gravity, and space. Since this is a mental world, it would normally not be too impressive, but when taking into consideration that the users of izanagi can turn imagination and illusion into reality, this becomes much more applicable to scaling. This directly ties back to a statement mentioned earlier for Kakashi and Kaguya, as she is doing the exact same thing, “to rewrite the world in an instant and make it reality, this is just like Genjutsu.”. This means that the creation of all things, when used at their highest potential, can rewrite a universe sized dimension from nothing. This is further supported as it is stated in the fourth databook that a fragment of the god tree, the ten tails, created the universe. During this time period, the Ten Tails, Hagoromo, and Kaguya were all often conflated together in legend, but Hagoromo has the power of the God Tree and the Ten Tails regardless, as does Kaguya, so this really doesn't make much of a difference. As mentioned previously, the Ten Tails created the universe, but another important aspect of the statement is that he is also beyond imagination. Since we accept that imagination is used as an energy to create form out of naught and that the Ten Tails both created the universe and transcend imagination, this would prove that the creation of all things (COAT) is universal. Kaguya also has a direct statement of her chakra being far beyond the Ten Tails, which proves she and Hagaroma would scale to this (by using COAT), along with the fact that they're literally Ten Tails Jinchuuriki who can create god trees. And the idea that the Ten Tails are only a fraction of the god tree easily scales both Kaguya and Hagoromo with COAT above that level of power as well. In the fourth databook, under the Sage of Six Paths mode entry, it says from the ancestor of Shinobi that a divine state is gifted, touching the principles of all of creation and commanding all things in nature. This means that Naruto’s Sage of Six Paths mode, gifted to him by Hagoromo, allows him to command all things in nature; it also proves that Naruto would have an understanding of the principles of all of creation, which were previously supported by the World Origin Statement. So if anything, Naruto with COAT as well would scale to around Hagoromo’s level.
In conclusion, COAT is able to rewrite and create a dimension as big as Kaguya’s, one which I explained is likely universal in size. We know Kaguya was going to do this via her ETSB, and since the process is instant as we see from Kakashi’s statement, we can assume that the 15 year timeframe for Kaguya’s ETSB recreating the dimension would be removed and only applied to its destruction (which would still be outputting 3-B level of energy per second), as while there is a timeframe for the destruction, the creation is pretty much instant. So all users of COAT would have 3-A added to their ratings, or at the very least, a possibly 3-A rating.

  • Naruto: At least 6-C, likely 5-C, higher with Rasengan Barrage, 5-C with Six Paths Sage Mode, higher with Kurama Six Paths Sage Mode, far higher when amplified by Bijū, even higher with Rasengan Variants, even higher when enraged, even higher with Asura Avatar and Majestic Attire Susano'o, 5-C with Six Paths Chibaku Tensei, 3-A with Creation of All Things
  • Hagoromo: 5-C, higher with Six Paths Chibaku Tensei, Low 5-B with Telekinesis, 3-A with Creation of All Things
  • Kaguya: 5-C, 3-B, up to 3-A overtime with Expansive Truth Seeker Orb, 3-A with Creation of All Things
 
Since we accept that imagination is used as an energy to create form out of naught and that the Ten Tails both created the universe and transcend imagination, this would prove that the creation of all things (COAT) is universal.

But the Ten Tails didn't create the Universe...?

Don't rely on hyperbolic text in the databook that is unsupported by the manga itself.
 
Amenotejikara and Kamui
Sasuke's Rinnegan teleportation technique swaps him and an object HE CAN SEE. So obviously, unless Obito opens a portal such that Sasuke CAN SEE into the other dimension, he's not going to be able to swap himself with something. So, no this doesn't mean Kaguya's dimensions are infinite.

Secondly, being a time space doesn't inherently mean you're an entire space time continuum whatsoever. I'm not going to bother explaining why, since 1) a look in the dictionary can do that for you, and 2) you can check out our site standards for pocket dimension sizes.

Limbo Clones and MS
The limbo realm overlaps the physical universe of Naruto. Hence why the Limbo clones are standing on the planet (not literally on the planet but you get what I mean).

Being able to see all things on heaven and earth does not at all inherently equate to all things in the physical universe whatsoever. You have to prove that the context is that heaven and earth is in context of the entire universe, instead of just referring to being able to see things related to the physical and spiritual world. Like how the MS can perceive with high acuity spiritual and physical things.

None of these statements mean anything about some kind of physical distance.

Naruto's Senses
This predicates itself on your prior section being correct. Since I disagree that your prior section is correct whatsoever, there's no point in addressing this section.

The Rest
Neither Hagoromo nor the Ten Tails (the one we see in the story, aka Kaguya) created the universe. We just know that for a fact lmao, the universe existed prior to Hagoromo being born and existed before Kaguya as well. So no, Hagoromo's COAT didn't create the universe, nor being able to create all things the same as being capable of creating the entire universe in an instant.

Edit: stop watching Noodles videos
 
The first thing I'm going to discuss are the statements surrounding Kaguya’s dimensions. At the final confrontation with Naruto, we see Kaguya drag Naruto and Sasuke into a multitude of her parallel dimensions, which she begins quickly swapping between. It is during one of these dimensional swaps that we see Obito connect to one of the parallel worlds by activating his Kamui; he successfully does so, which then allows Sasuke to switch places with Sakura's vest inside the dimension that Obito and Sakura are in before the Kamui portal closes. Sasuke then remarks that although he can shift himself between spaces using his Rinnegan, he can only do so over finite distances,
Sasuke says he can do more across a finite distance, not any finite distance, there's a big difference there.

Besides we already know the fixed limit of Sasuke's Amenotejikara by this point because of his interaction with Madara and it's definitely a fixed distance.
An important factor in this is Obito's statement, when he manages to connect one of Kaguya’s dimensions to another, that it was difficult to do so because of the sheer vastness of each dimension.
vast ≠ Infinite
 
also, all these "see, sense, feel, touch, smell all things in this universe" statements are pm irrelevant to anything AP-related without proof it isnt hyperbolic.

Another similar argument is that Naruto and Sasuke can both perceive limbo clones: Naruto through the use of his Six Paths Mode and Sasuke through his Rinnegan. The significance of this comes from a statement in the databook discussing the limbo clones, which says that the clones actually exist in an entirely different plane and dimension, as already accepted in this wiki. Naruto and Sasuke seemingly have no trouble seeing or sensing these clones that do not even exist in the normal universe, yet when they were separated into just two of Kaguya’s dimensions, Naruto outright says he cannot sense Sasuke,
Naruto's clone is the one that can't sense Sasuke.

The real Naruto never had that issue.
 
But the Ten Tails didn't create the Universe...?

Don't rely on hyperbolic text in the databook that is unsupported by the manga itself.
It was meant to be a supporting evidence hence the 'this is further supported' before I got into it, but if you say this argument contradicts the manga, I accept that, I should've double checked it. My original argument was still Kaguya's COAT rewriting her whole dimension which I argued to be of universal size.
Amenotejikara and Kamui
Sasuke's Rinnegan teleportation technique swaps him and an object HE CAN SEE. So obviously, unless Obito opens a portal such that Sasuke CAN SEE into the other dimension, he's not going to be able to swap himself with something. So, no this doesn't mean Kaguya's dimensions are infinite.
This still proves he can't see the dimensions or what is within other dimensions without the aid of Obito's portal while being in one of the dimensions because the dimensions themselves are that far.
Secondly, being a time space doesn't inherently mean you're an entire space time continuum whatsoever. I'm not going to bother explaining why, since 1) a look in the dictionary can do that for you, and 2) you can check out our site standards for pocket dimension sizes.
I never said it was a space time continuum, just that Obito can easily go in and out of the Naruto universe and Kamui, but can't do the same for Kaguya's dimension due to the size difference.
Limbo Clones and MS
The limbo realm overlaps the physical universe of Naruto. Hence why the Limbo clones are standing on the planet (not literally on the planet but you get what I mean).

Being able to see all things on heaven and earth does not at all inherently equate to all things in the physical universe whatsoever. You have to prove that the context is that heaven and earth is in context of the entire universe, instead of just referring to being able to see things related to the physical and spiritual world. Like how the MS can perceive with high acuity spiritual and physical things.

None of these statements mean anything about some kind of physical distance.
Heaven and Earth is used in the title section of the databook, while below it, it outright says "heavenly eyes that see all things in the universe: Amaterasu, representing the light of the material world. Tsukuyomi, the nightmare realm, representing the world of mind and darkness". Also the Hagoromo statement later on proves that Heaven and Earth refers to all things in creations when they were talking about
Naruto's Senses
This predicates itself on your prior section being correct. Since I disagree that your prior section is correct whatsoever, there's no point in addressing this section.
See above
The Rest
Neither Hagoromo nor the Ten Tails (the one we see in the story, aka Kaguya) created the universe. We just know that for a fact lmao, the universe existed prior to Hagoromo being born and existed before Kaguya as well. So no, Hagoromo's COAT didn't create the universe, nor being able to create all things the same as being capable of creating the entire universe in an instant.
I'll concede on the Ten Tails creating the universe since Damage also addressed this. However, this was only a supporting argument, since my original argument was Kaguya rewriting her dimensions in an instant
Edit: stop watching Noodles videos
I didn't use his multiversal or Road to Ninja or Boruto movie novel or UES arguments. Not saying I didn't watch his stuff, but the CRT is not a copy paste of his video.
 
This still proves he can't see the dimensions or what is within other dimensions without the aid of Obito's portal while being in one of the dimensions because the dimensions themselves are that far.
I never said it was a space time continuum, just that Obito can easily go in and out of the Naruto universe and Kamui, but can't do the same for Kaguya's dimension due to the size difference.
Obito can't go anywhere in the Naruto universe, he only travels on the planet. None of those proves anything here is 3-A.

Heaven and Earth is used in the title section of the databook, while below it, it outright says "heavenly eyes that see all things in the universe: Amaterasu, representing the light of the material world. Tsukuyomi, the nightmare realm, representing the world of mind and darkness". Also the Hagoromo statement later on proves that Heaven and Earth refers to all things in creations when they were talking about
Seeing all things in the Naruto universe, would only mean that whatever isn't seen isn't inherently in the Naruto main universe. Has no barring on the size of things, since dimensions can overlap and not be connected.

Nothing in your response defends the stance that any of these characters have 3-A techniques.
 
The final thing I found in regards to Kaguya and her dimensions is this statement from Kakashi, which directly says Kaguya was going to rewrite the entire world and compares it to Genjutsu.
Kakashi is observing based on what he's experiencing, not making an in-depth analysis of the mechanics of Kaguya's Jutsu.

All he's saying is that the world around them is being transformed the same way genjutsu can "transform the world around you"

We even know this is what he meant because when he's initially transported, he immediately inquires and tests if it's Genjutsu.
This obviously supports the databook statement earlier, which said she was going to destroy and recreate everything, and the statement from Zetsu, which said, “This is the beginning of a new space.”
It doesn't,

In Kakashi's case, he's just saying the effects of Kaguya's Jutsu feel like a GJ.

Strong Occular GJ(which Kakashi is very familiar with) are basically mental BFRs.

Given that complete Area shifting is something he's never encountered before, it makes sense that he would associate it with an ability he is familiar with.
. The reason it's important to note the genjutsu aspect of this statement is because Kaguya also has the capability of turning genjutsu into reality, which I will shortly get into. Hagoromo also has a multitude of statements that help solidify this argument as well. The first of which is stated on the Uchiha stone tablet that Hagoromo wrote ages ago. On this tablet, it is said that the Rinnegan possesses the power of “two opposing forces that made everything in creation in the universe.”. This statement gets mistranslated a lot due to the weird use of language, but the kanji used in this statement is “森羅万象”. I have compiled multiple definitions of 森羅万象, which amounts to “all things in nature; the whole creation," “all things in the world," “all creation,” and simply "universe.”. So based upon this, we can say that most likely this kanji is referring to “the whole creation,” due to the context of the Stone Tablet statement, and seeing as Hagoromo is a master of the Rinnegan, this would mean he wields the power of all creation.
For one, the stone tablet is a largely unreliable source, considering Zetsu actively tampered with it.

Not to mention, "all things in this universe/world/creation." isn't a 3-A statement.

all that means is that he can create things within the universe, not the universe itself.

It's no different from Madara saying he can "smash all things in this Universe" with his Susano'o.

all it amounts to is a hyperbolic statement with many charitable interpretations. in which case context matters more than anything.

And context does not support 3-A.
 
Sasuke says he can do more across a finite distance, not any finite distance, there's a big difference there.

Besides we already know the fixed limit of Sasuke's Amenotejikara by this point because of his interaction with Madara and it's definitely a fixed distance.

vast ≠ Infinite
Ngl, I didn’t even know that panel existed, but wasn’t this early on before the whole Kaguya fight, I remember a statement during Naruto and Sasuke’s final battle that even after all their fights, Sasuke said he was still getting used to using all the abilities, so if anything, his abilities could have improved between the Madara and Kaguya fight. Also I’m aware that vast ≠ infinite, the argument was that it’s vast compared to Kamui.
also, all these "see, sense, feel, touch, smell all things in this universe" statements are pm irrelevant to anything AP-related without proof it isnt hyperbolic.
Which argument are you referring to exactly? I’ve listed this multiple times
Fair, I didn’t catch this detail
 
Not to mention, "all things in this universe/world/creation." isn't a 3-A statement.
Yes it's not 3-A, especially if there is a time continuity in the verse, this statement is directly Low 2-C. There is no need to brain exercise.

There are many characters that default to Low 2-C from phrases like all of existence or the universe, all that is required is that there be a time continuum in the verse
 
Ngl, I didn’t even know that panel existed, but wasn’t this early on before the whole Kaguya fight, I remember a statement during Naruto and Sasuke’s final battle that even after all their fights, Sasuke said he was still getting used to using all the abilities, so if anything, his abilities could have improved between the Madara and Kaguya fight.
It was during the Madara fight, but I don't think Kishi would involve a range limit and then scrap it 10 chapters later, nothing implies his range grew all that much from a few minutes ago.

Sasuke stating it to be a fixed finite range rather than capable of working on any finite range still implies it's nowhere near the range you are arguing for in the OP.
Which argument are you referring to exactly? I’ve listed this multiple times
pm all of them,

you're using these statements as support but there is no argument that you've brought up where the only conclusion that can be drawn is 3-A hax. just a lot of 50/50 interpretation-based statements where the in-story feats and lore don't support anything close to Universal.
 
Sasuke then remarks that although he can shift himself between spaces using his Rinnegan, he can only do so over finite distances, and the reason he managed to make it into the portal was because of both Obito's Kamui teleportation and Sakura's vest. The reason this is important is because Sasuke specifically says he can only teleport over finite distances, and had Sakura's vest not been there, he would not have been able to do so. Implying that the distance between each realm is infinite rather than finite
No, he needs the sakuras vest because he needs an object to switch his position with and not because the distance is infinite and also he needs obitos kamui to use his ability is because he was trying to switch his position with an object in another dimension and in order to switch his rinnegan has to be able to see the object (obviously, it’s a dojustu) and inorder to do that without obitos kamui it needs to have the ability to see through dimensions which is something a rinnegan can’t do and is the ability of the jougan. Hence he can’t use his shift ability across dimensions. Think of it as like the two rooms of the and you are trying to see through them using a telescope. The telescope will fail to do so because it doesn’t have the ability to see through walls. Take the two rooms to be the two dimensions and the telescope to be the rinnegan and the wall to be the dimensional barrier. Obitos kamui acted as like a hole in the wall using which the rinnegan was able to see to the other side and use the shift ability.
 
Obito can't go anywhere in the Naruto universe, he only travels on the planet. None of those proves anything here is 3-A.


Seeing all things in the Naruto universe, would only mean that whatever isn't seen isn't inherently in the Naruto main universe. Has no barring on the size of things, since dimensions can overlap and not be connected.

Nothing in your response defends the stance that any of these characters have 3-A techniques.
Kakashi is observing based on what he's experiencing, not making an in-depth analysis of the mechanics of Kaguya's Jutsu.

All he's saying is that the world around them is being transformed the same way genjutsu can "transform the world around you"

We even know this is what he meant because when he's initially transported, he immediately inquires and tests if it's Genjutsu.

It doesn't,

In Kakashi's case, he's just saying the effects of Kaguya's Jutsu feel like a GJ.

Strong Occular GJ(which Kakashi is very familiar with) are basically mental BFRs.

Given that complete Area shifting is something he's never encountered before, it makes sense that he would associate it with an ability he is familiar with.

For one, the stone tablet is a largely unreliable source, considering Zetsu actively tampered with it.

Not to mention, "all things in this universe/world/creation." isn't a 3-A statement.

all that means is that he can create things within the universe, not the universe itself.

It's no different from Madara saying he can "smash all things in this Universe" with his Susano'o.

all it amounts to is a hyperbolic statement with many charitable interpretations. in which case context matters more than anything.

And context does not support 3-A.
It was during the Madara fight, but I don't think Kishi would involve a range limit and then scrap it 10 chapters later, nothing implies his range grew all that much from a few minutes ago.

Sasuke stating it to be a fixed finite range rather than capable of working on any finite range still implies it's nowhere near the range you are arguing for in the OP.

pm all of them,

you're using these statements as support but there is no argument that you've brought up where the only conclusion that can be drawn is 3-A hax. just a lot of 50/50 interpretation-based statements where the in-story feats and lore don't support anything close to Universal.
No, he needs the sakuras vest because he needs an object to switch his position with and not because the distance is infinite and also he needs obitos kamui to use his ability is because he was trying to switch his position with an object in another dimension and in order to switch his rinnegan has to be able to see the object (obviously, it’s a dojustu) and inorder to do that without obitos kamui it needs to have the ability to see through dimensions which is something a rinnegan can’t do and is the ability of the jougan. Hence he can’t use his shift ability across dimensions. Think of it as like the two rooms of the and you are trying to see through them using a telescope. The telescope will fail to do so because it doesn’t have the ability to see through walls. Take the two rooms to be the two dimensions and the telescope to be the rinnegan and the wall to be the dimensional barrier. Obitos kamui acted as like a hole in the wall using which the rinnegan was able to see to the other side and use the shift ability.
I guess the 3-A dimension arguments don't seem to be that strong. The only argument left to tackle is that COAT can turn Genjutsu into reality including Tsukuyomi which can create universe sized mental worlds. We know that Izanagi, which is inferior to COAT can rewrite the world.
 
I guess the 3-A dimension arguments don't seem to be that strong. The only argument left to tackle is that COAT can turn Genjutsu into reality including Tsukuyomi which can create universe sized mental worlds. We know that Izanagi, which is inferior to COAT can rewrite the world.
"Universe sized mental worlds" Why exactly should this be tiered? It's just a genjutsu which create illusions inside your mind, this wouldn't even upscale COAT, it's just a nothing argument.
 
"Universe sized mental worlds" Why exactly should this be tiered? It's just a genjutsu which create illusions inside your mind, this wouldn't even upscale COAT, it's just a nothing argument.
COAT turns Genjutsu to reality, we know this cuz Izanagi, a much weaker variant of COAT, turns the Genjutsu of the user into reality, thus rewriting the world they are in
 
COAT turns Genjutsu to reality, we know this cuz Izanagi, a much weaker variant of COAT, turns the Genjutsu of the user into reality, thus rewriting the world they are in
That's nowhere near Universal in effects though.... Izanagi has only really be seen to avoid lethal injuries. Not to reality warp the whole world, let alone the Universe.
 
That's nowhere near Universal in effects though.... Izanagi has only really be seen to avoid lethal injuries. Not to reality warp the whole world, let alone the Universe.
The ETSB is stated to contain COAT on both the scans of the TSB I provided, the fact that it was going to recreate the dimension means that it does have the power to create a dimension at least of the size of Kaguya's dimension
 
The first of which is stated on the Uchiha stone tablet that Hagoromo wrote ages ago. On this tablet, it is said that the Rinnegan possesses the power of “two opposing forces that made everything in creation in the universe.”. This statement gets mistranslated a lot due to the weird use of language, but the kanji used in this statement is “森羅万象”. I have compiled multiple definitions of 森羅万象, which amounts to “all things in nature; the whole creation," “all things in the world," “all creation,” and simply "universe.”. So based upon this, we can say that most likely this kanji is referring to “the whole creation,” due to the context of the Stone Tablet statement, and seeing as Hagoromo is a master of the Rinnegan, this would mean he wields the power of all creation.
The Stone Tablet is unreliable for many reasons but Shibai and Omnipotence's existence kinda negs this idea that Hagaromo had this much power.
this is the context of the Rinnegan during the middle point of Naruto, where it seems like a godlike ability only the savior of the world can have.

until we learn soon after that it's actually a genetic trait that can be evolved from the Sharingan or a descendant of the Otsutsuki, who are beings that are practically irrelevant compared to a true Otsutsuki God.

The GJ statements are more 50/50 interpretation statements, but considering Shibai required countless millennia of devouring worlds to ascend to godhood and "create the current world" with his Shinjutsu which is described as being something entirely different level from Sage Abilities and Ninjutsu (which COAT, Izanagi, and ETSO all fall under.) the argument that COAT is universal really has no support.
 
The Stone Tablet is unreliable for many reasons but Shibai and Omnipotence's existence kinda negs this idea that Hagaromo had this much power.

this is the context of the Rinnegan during the middle point of Naruto, where it seems like a godlike ability only the savior of the world can have.

until we learn soon after that it's actually a genetic trait that can be evolved from the Sharingan or a descendant of the Otsutsuki, who are beings that are practically irrelevant compared to a true Otsutsuki God.

The GJ statements are more 50/50 interpretation statements, but considering Shibai required countless millennia of devouring worlds to ascend to godhood and "create the current world" with his Shinjutsu which is described as being something entirely different level from Sage Abilities and Ninjutsu (which COAT, Izanagi, and ETSO all fall under.) the argument that COAT is universal really has no support.
The ETSB is stated to contain COAT on both the scans of the TSB I provided, the fact that it was going to recreate the dimension means that it does have the power to create a dimension at least of the size of Kaguya's dimension
What do you think about ETSB remaking Kaguya's dimension using COAT, that's clear cut
 
What do you think about ETSB remaking Kaguya's dimension using COAT, that's clear cut
It scales to planet, we have no idea how that would of even looked, and besides, the ETSB was going to remake the space specifically, with the "space" in this context being the planet they were standing on, since that's all that's implied for kaguyas spaces to be. Like in multiple data book pages all that is really elaborated on is how kaguyas spaces are the planets of ice, hypergravity, sand, acid, and lava. And what would you even get out of this? It's not like the "dimension" is 3-A anyway, max rating you can scale the ETSB to is what the current ratings already are, which is star level. There are no upgrades to be had here.
 
Pure conjecture and nothing more. Kaguya’s dimension isn’t 3-A anyway.
How would it be conjecture? Even if we say Kaguya's dimension isn't 3-A and stick with 4-C, both TSB databook scans acknowledge that TSB is comprised of all 5 elements (which we know aren't capable of creation, likely only destruction) and COAT (which we know is capable of creation), which would only make COAT the only viable option for ETSB's ability of creation.
 
How would it be conjecture? Even if we say Kaguya's dimension isn't 3-A and stick with 4-C, both TSB databook scans acknowledge that TSB is comprised of all 5 elements (which we know aren't capable of creation, likely only destruction) and COAT (which we know is capable of creation), which would only make COAT the only viable option for ETSB's ability of creation.
Not at all. ETSB can have its own ability of creation, given that it's just flat out stated that Kaguya's ETSB was the start of a new space. You're linking two things that don't have any good reason to be linked.
 
It scales to planet, we have no idea how that would of even looked, and besides, the ETSB was going to remake the space specifically, with the "space" in this context being the planet they were standing on, since that's all that's implied for kaguyas spaces to be. Like in multiple data book pages all that is really elaborated on is how kaguyas spaces are the planets of ice, hypergravity, sand, acid, and lava. And what would you even get out of this? It's not like the "dimension" is 3-A anyway, max rating you can scale the ETSB to is what the current ratings already are, which is star level. There are no upgrades to be had here.
It doesn't scale to just the planet. It scales to the whole dimension containing the star as well since that is what is accepted in the wiki. The upgrades would be that Hagoromo and Naruto would also have 4-C added via COAT
 
How would it be conjecture? Even if we say Kaguya's dimension isn't 3-A and stick with 4-C, both TSB databook scans acknowledge that TSB is comprised of all 5 elements (which we know aren't capable of creation, likely only destruction)
TSO and ETSO are comprised of the five basic elements plus Yin-Yang Release. They can transmute things as well as erase things.

COAT is a Yin-Yang Release Jutsu Hags uses to shape Reality from Imagination.

All that would have to be true here is that the combination of all 7 elements can cause various effects such as creation or destruction.
and COAT (which we know is capable of creation), which would only make COAT the only viable option for ETSB's ability of creation.
The “only viable” option doesn’t have to exist.

Many facets of chakra are still being explored, such as how everyone’s mind is connected in someway via chakra which is how Otsutsuki Gods can manipulate an entire populace at once.

In fact what’s more likely is that Yin Yang release just has creative properties

Which makes sense considering Yin by itself can create mental worlds and Yang can create life.

And COAT has no reason scaling to the already accepted 4C rating of ETSO given its an unquantifiable overtime feat used by the strongest character in the verse(at the time) utilizing an entire planet worth of people’s chakra.

Let alone the self admittedly inferior Hagaromo with COAT
 
Last edited:
Not at all. ETSB can have its own ability of creation, given that it's just flat out stated that Kaguya's ETSB was the start of a new space. You're linking two things that don't have any good reason to be linked.
TSO and ETSO are comprised of the five basically elements plus Yin-Yang Release. They can transmute things as well as erase things.

COAT is a Yin-Yang Release Jutsu Hags uses to shape Reality from Imagination.

All that would have to be true here is that the combination of all 7 elements can cause various effects such as creation or destruction.

The “only viable” option doesn’t have to exist.

Many facets of chakra are still being explored, such as how everyone’s mind is connected in someway via chakra which is how Otsutsuki Gods can manipulate an entire populace at once.

In fact what’s more likely is that Yin Yang release just has creative properties

Which makes sense considering Yin by itself can create mental worlds and Yang can create life.

And COAT has no reason scaling to the already accepted 4C rating of ETSO given its an unquantifiable overtime feat used by the strongest character in the verse(at the time) utilizing an entire planet worth of people’s chakra.

Let alone the self admittedly inferior Hagaromo with COAT
I guess this all makes sense, this can be closed then
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top