Trinity seven Revision — Gods Love Change!

[Vietthai96]

Is this immutable because God transcend causal system?. Because simply being immutable, unchanging isn't enough for Aca 5. Immutable, unchanging is a broad word, it could mean and be used in a lot of scenarios, not exclusively for Aca 5 immutable. You could say a guy with eternal youth, unchanging appearance an immutable existence and obviously that dude isn't an aca 5 guy

 

[Grabbing_dragon]

Is this immutable because God transcend causal system?. Because simply being immutable, unchanging isn't enough for Aca 5. Immutable, unchanging is a broad word, it could mean and be used in a lot of scenarios, not exclusively for Aca 5 immutable. You could say a guy with eternal youth, unchanging appearance an immutable existence and obviously that dude isn't an aca 5 guy

Yes. They are immutable in their existence in every way because of what they are, and their existence itself does not participate in causality. Their existence is unaffected by everything to beings that cannot interact with them. The example you gave doesn't really work since they aren't physical beings. So the argument is that their changeless existence would include causality as one of the things it transcends.

 

[Grabbing_dragon]

You could say a guy with eternal youth, unchanging appearance an immutable existence

I don’t see how those examples really translate to existential or ontological immutability. I don’t see how appearance equals a being’s existence. Something can look unchanging while still changing internally or fundamentally in existence. The same goes for the eternal youth part; it doesn’t translate to ontology like it does in my scans, so it’s a category error.