- 16,980
- 22,783
Intro
A follow up of this thread. Where I will discuss a final alternative to settling the Toneri issue I talked to Damage about maybe half a year ago or sumn lol.
Discussion
So, from the conclusions of the thread linked in the introduction, this calc is accepted as a possibly. Which basically means by our own standards the interpretation for the 5-C+ calc is valid but not inherently more objective than the alternative interpretation (which nets it like a 6-B calc).
Now in a lot of accepted calcs here, in which there are size discrepancies in the pixel scaling with no clear objective depiction to scale from, we often average the pixel scales to obtain a happy compromise that accounts for all visuals of the feat. Essentially, what I'm wondering here is, in this case would it be better to keep the two interpretations of the feat separate, or should we average the moon halves separation and recalc the split using an average separation, since there was no significantly superior interpretation regarding the split?
Votes
Keep it as is now:
Average it: Damage (worth considering), M3X, Kay Laugh Out Loud
A follow up of this thread. Where I will discuss a final alternative to settling the Toneri issue I talked to Damage about maybe half a year ago or sumn lol.
Discussion
So, from the conclusions of the thread linked in the introduction, this calc is accepted as a possibly. Which basically means by our own standards the interpretation for the 5-C+ calc is valid but not inherently more objective than the alternative interpretation (which nets it like a 6-B calc).
Now in a lot of accepted calcs here, in which there are size discrepancies in the pixel scaling with no clear objective depiction to scale from, we often average the pixel scales to obtain a happy compromise that accounts for all visuals of the feat. Essentially, what I'm wondering here is, in this case would it be better to keep the two interpretations of the feat separate, or should we average the moon halves separation and recalc the split using an average separation, since there was no significantly superior interpretation regarding the split?
Votes
Keep it as is now:
Average it: Damage (worth considering), M3X, Kay Laugh Out Loud
Last edited:
