TheTenno07
He/Him- 541
- 316
shouldn't he have multiple selves?hi. Pretty much everything is in the profile I think
BestMGQScalerEver/Maleldil
vsbattles.fandom.com
I think the evidence is rather strong and simple but we'll see.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Tier 0 Space Narnia (Space Trilogy)
- Thread starter FriendOfTheTeaParty
- Start date
-
- Tags
- maleldil space trilogy
- Status
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #42
No.
TheTenno07
He/Him- 541
- 316
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #44
Because its not multiple minds or souls inhabiting anything. They're distinct persons (not different selves) who possess a single essence/being in which even individually are wholely it.
TheTenno07
He/Him- 541
- 316
Well, it is based on the christian trinity and that concept has God as 1 mind but 3 distinct consciousness/persons, that (excepting the name of the type) sounds pretty much like the type 1
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #46
No. That is not how it works. Personhood isn't referring to being conscious (they're relational hypostases), there's only 1 intellect/consciousness in the trinity.
TheTenno07
He/Him- 541
- 316
With consciousness I mean self-awareness
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #48
I also asked Ultima about it off-site and that this type of stuff also wouldn't be multiple selves. He'll probably give his evaluation of the thread later I think.
TheTenno07
He/Him- 541
- 316
- 3,675
- 5,681
There’s one center of willing, but they could still be considered different selves since they’re not each other. Each person has distinct relational roles, and different underlying realities of their rational nature along with being different subjects.
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #51
I can get that in a way they can be considered "selves" but not in a way that qualifies for the ability. Although I think there might be some issues or nitpicks with your description but it's not too important for the thread
Last edited:
- 15,331
- 22,662
The "selves" are different expressions the a wholly individual if i'm not wrong
- 3,675
- 5,681
Yeah you’re right:
Multiple Selves is the ability which allows to have several different entities existing within one being. They can either be minds, souls, living organisms or even combinations of these types. This ability has a number of advantages and a number of shortcomings.
It says different entities whether it be minds or souls existing in one being that would contradict the trinity where all the hypostases share the same exact will, mind, etc. In the trinity there’s no distinction when it comes to ontology, and they are all materially identical. So yeah I don’t think the trinity qualifies for this tbh.
are you talking about the hypostases in the trinity or the multiple selves ability?
- 15,331
- 22,662
The former
- 3,675
- 5,681
They’re real distinctions not just forms of expression.
Re5yh
He/Him- 1,568
- 716
I agree with MGQscalierever, God with multiple selves is a very deep question in religion
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #58
Ultima isn't gonna be coming to this thread it seems, he's been aware of the thread since 3rd of this month, and said he'd do it "tomorrow" like 2 days ago (it's been more than tomorrow), so I'll just make the profile since 2 admin 2 thread mod votes is enough.
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #59
TheTenno07
He/Him- 541
- 316
Amazing job
- 177,777
- 90,818
- 6,386
- 17,776
Yeah, finally got to this. Have to say that these books have some of the most ecstatic writing I've ever read. Amazing stuff. But anyhow: Yeah, I think Tier 0 here is fairly straightforward. In point of fact I took the liberty to write up my own justification for the tier, to replace the rather barebones one currently in the sandbox. Fill it with the scans as needed:
Though I will say, also, that the second key is pretty needless. It adds absolutely nothing to the profile's justification really and is pretty much only there for show, so I suggest it gets removed (Also it doesn't even prettify the profile on account of the fact that only two of the three persons would be getting keys).
Though I will say, also, that the second key is pretty needless. It adds absolutely nothing to the profile's justification really and is pretty much only there for show, so I suggest it gets removed (Also it doesn't even prettify the profile on account of the fact that only two of the three persons would be getting keys).
Last edited:
- 177,777
- 90,818
Thank you very much for helping out. 
Is somebody willing to modify this wiki page with Ultima's text and the associated scan links if I unlock the page for you?
vsbattles.fandom.com
Is somebody willing to modify this wiki page with Ultima's text and the associated scan links if I unlock the page for you?
Maleldil
Maleldil is the Son of the Old One, the lord of all Eldila, and is the one true ruler of the universe, who has once incarnated on Earth. Maleldil barely makes any appearance himself within the novel, existing mostly as an unseen and indirect guide, but has revealed himself to Ransom in the form...
vsbattles.fandom.com
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #64
I have one prepared.Thank you very much for helping out.
Is somebody willing to modify this wiki page with Ultima's text and the associated scan links if I unlock the page for you?
Maleldil
Maleldil is the Son of the Old One, the lord of all Eldila, and is the one true ruler of the universe, who has once incarnated on Earth. Maleldil barely makes any appearance himself within the novel, existing mostly as an unseen and indirect guide, but has revealed himself to Ransom in the form...
- 7,784
- 9,314
- Thread starter
- #65
this can be closed. edits are done
- 15,331
- 22,662
Closing
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
