The Revenant Marvel Comics Discussion Thread

[Tomfer]

Sooo… while I am here. I think we need to establish some sort of exception in terms of our profile and their keys standards.

Agreed.

If we do this, I would love to at least have some reason to. Or remove the appearance limit entirely, it never really made sense anyway.

I believe we should consider a few things like if it has narrative importance, cultural/story influence, and if it has enough difference in power (like if it was different abilities, different stats, etc). A example would be Tigra's human form, or The Cat. She only had 4 actual issues, yet, she had A LOT of abilities, actual good and consistent scaling, and it's influential in the character's lore. According to our rules, it should go, but I'd disagree.

 

[NaturalDestroyer]

I'm in favor of removing the limit for characters that are either important narratively or important for scaling chains.

 

[Antvasima]

I think that we can make occasional exceptions for extremely important characters for narrative or scaling, but definitely not that we should remove the limit entirely, as we would be absolutely flooded with minor characters that are very hard to define a reliable consistency for.

 

[Tomfer]

I agree that we shouldn't remove the limit entirely as well, but we should change the wording to "around 15 issues." In exchange, maybe add other requirements like the character needing a more expanded set of abilities, so we aren't flooding characters that only has super strength in his P&A tab.

 

[MrKerf]

15 is for keys for pre-existing characters, the official requirement is 20.

So, narrative and scaling importance?

 

[Antvasima]

15 is for keys for pre-existing characters, the official requirement is 20.

So, narrative and scaling importance?

Yes. I think that we can make occasional exceptions for very prominent extreme cases.

 

[MrKerf]

Another question I ponder is why oh why does Nyx have House of Ideas in equipment and optional AP? Again, out of those 12 issues she was in the House of Ideas, what once?? This is ridiculous. I can bet every dollar I got (zero) that no one scales to her with HoI, except HoI Vision, who too was there once.

 

[NaturalDestroyer]

Another question I ponder is why oh why does Nyx have House of Ideas in equipment and optional AP? Again, out of those 12 issues she was in the House of Ideas, what once?? This is ridiculous. I can bet every dollar I got (zero) that no one scales to her with HoI, except HoI Vision, who too was there once.

Yeah that probably shouldn't be there

 

[Rgerdeena]

Another question I ponder is why oh why does Nyx have House of Ideas in equipment and optional AP? Again, out of those 12 issues she was in the House of Ideas, what once?? This is ridiculous. I can bet every dollar I got (zero) that no one scales to her with HoI, except HoI Vision, who too was there once.

yeah, that key is pretty much pointless, also come to think of it why do we have a profile for a location that has only 10 appearances(house of ideas)

 

[NaturalDestroyer]

yeah, that key is pretty much pointless, also come to think of it why do we have a profile for a location that has only 10 appearances(house of ideas)

HoI having a profile does make sense, since it's extremely important for the cosmology of Marvel as a whole

 

[Rgerdeena]

HoI having a profile does make sense, since it's extremely important for the cosmology of Marvel as a whole

Eh, I don’t care too much about whether or not we keep it, but it is kind of redundant to have a profile for a 10 appearance location that everything on it can just be mentioned in the cosmology blog and one above all’s profile