The Everlasting Quest for Proper Evaluation of Instant Death (verse)

[Dark_Soul20189]

Soooo, here we are again...

So in the Instant Death series, we have a magic type called instant Death magic.

Now why do I bring it up?

First of the scan talks about, how it doesn't work against stronger opponents, and requires an enormous amount of energy, to the point all other magics are considered more efficient. Hell, there are even "numerous ways to resist it". Hell, the end of it speaks about how there is no way to guarantee a 100% chance it will even work.

Now why do I bring this up?

Death Manipulation (Everyone with the system can resist the effects of instant death magic as long as they are stronger than the user[8])

All Instant Death characters have this resistance.

Now what is the problem?

As mentioned above, the scan says anyone stronger than it, won't work it, There are numerous ways to resist it, and lastly, It is never a 100% success rate... Only to then proceed to say any other way to deal with the weaker party would be far more effective.

This basically makes the ability useless against anyone stronger than the caster. This does not grant them a "resistance" since they are not technically resisting an ability but rather are just naturally not affected by it, it would be no different than us humans being unaffected by a virus that only affects dogs.

So all beings who have resistance to Death manipulation for this reason should have it removed.

Agree -
Disagree -
Neutral -

 

[NARONG_SUVAN]

Disagreed “numerous methods of resisting have been developed” meaning failing again higher level opponents isn’t inherently how instant death magic work people need to learn how to counter its.

 

[Dark_Soul20189]

Disagreed “numerous methods of resisting have been developed” meaning failing again higher level opponents isn’t inherently how instant death magic work people need to learn how to counter its.

I think you are misunderstanding something, "numerous ways of resisting it has been developed" not for people stronger than the user, but weaker users. You are also ignoring the fact it was stated to never have a 100% success rate, hell we don't even know how that magic works.

 

[Grabbing_dragon]

perfectly agree

 

[NARONG_SUVAN]

I think you are misunderstanding something, "numerous ways of resisting it has been developed" not for people stronger than the user, but weaker users. You are also ignoring the fact it was stated to never have a 100% success rate, hell we don't even know how that magic works.

Hmmm you rights i agreed with OP