- 108
- 56
Calculations: https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:GodlyCharmander/One_Piece:_Crocodile_Pulverization_feats
Both of these calculations contain many flaws within them.
The size of the castle: OP assumes that the red line is 2.5 kilometers in order to claim that the castle is a almost kilometer in diameter. Yet we know that's not true as the castle is consistently seen being much smaller than this. And I do mean consistently.
Either the red line isn't 2.5 kilometers or the buildings on this page are not meant to scale, as by this logic the random buildings that are seen being small would be hundreds of meters wide, the small pathway we see Luffy and Crocodile being comparable to would be about a hundred meters, and random windows would be dozens to a hundred meters wide. Which any reasonable person can tell isn't the case as seen on the scans. This alone invalidates both calculations. But we can keep going.
The Desert Spada calculation: Aside from the size being wrong, the value of the calculation is totally off. This is because the green line they used represents the depth of the cut. Which is 107 meters according to the calc. OP used that value to calculate the volume, and then multiplied it by the pulverization value for rock to get the energy. For this to work we must assume that the whole volume must be filled with solid rock. This isn't the case as we know that the green line contains a lot of empty spaces, given how there are literally windows within it, meaning there are rooms. And obviously a room has a ton of empty space. The calculation does not account for that, and is thus invalid.
Ground Death: This calculation assumes Crocodile pulverized over 657834698852 cubic centimeters of rock, which is based on the assumption that he pulverized the entirity of the floor at a depth of 1.04 meters. There is 0 basis for this being the case, and this is thus a headcanon. In fact, in the manga we see that he didn't pulverize the entire floor itself, but only the things ON the floor, such as tiles, statues and trees. This is further demonstrated when Luffy jumps up to avoid the sand only to fall back down on that same floor the calculation assumes was destroyed, demonstrating that the floor itself is intact. No damage of the extend assumed was ever shown.
The calculations are wrong both in terms of size and in terms of the assumptions made regarding the volume. Therefore this calls for a removal of these calculations.
Agree: @Damage3245
Neutral:
Disagree:
Both of these calculations contain many flaws within them.
The size of the castle: OP assumes that the red line is 2.5 kilometers in order to claim that the castle is a almost kilometer in diameter. Yet we know that's not true as the castle is consistently seen being much smaller than this. And I do mean consistently.
Either the red line isn't 2.5 kilometers or the buildings on this page are not meant to scale, as by this logic the random buildings that are seen being small would be hundreds of meters wide, the small pathway we see Luffy and Crocodile being comparable to would be about a hundred meters, and random windows would be dozens to a hundred meters wide. Which any reasonable person can tell isn't the case as seen on the scans. This alone invalidates both calculations. But we can keep going.
The Desert Spada calculation: Aside from the size being wrong, the value of the calculation is totally off. This is because the green line they used represents the depth of the cut. Which is 107 meters according to the calc. OP used that value to calculate the volume, and then multiplied it by the pulverization value for rock to get the energy. For this to work we must assume that the whole volume must be filled with solid rock. This isn't the case as we know that the green line contains a lot of empty spaces, given how there are literally windows within it, meaning there are rooms. And obviously a room has a ton of empty space. The calculation does not account for that, and is thus invalid.
Ground Death: This calculation assumes Crocodile pulverized over 657834698852 cubic centimeters of rock, which is based on the assumption that he pulverized the entirity of the floor at a depth of 1.04 meters. There is 0 basis for this being the case, and this is thus a headcanon. In fact, in the manga we see that he didn't pulverize the entire floor itself, but only the things ON the floor, such as tiles, statues and trees. This is further demonstrated when Luffy jumps up to avoid the sand only to fall back down on that same floor the calculation assumes was destroyed, demonstrating that the floor itself is intact. No damage of the extend assumed was ever shown.
The calculations are wrong both in terms of size and in terms of the assumptions made regarding the volume. Therefore this calls for a removal of these calculations.
Agree: @Damage3245
Neutral:
Disagree:
Last edited:
I'm simply not going to waste my time going back and forth in useless debates that will end up going in circles
