- 201
- 100
Kind of implied I think,but I'm not really sure.
Idk if we should just straight up disagree with author's statements though.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
The Boys discussion thread
- Thread starter Qawsedf234
- Start date
Idk if we should just straight up disagree with author's statements though.
- 13,826
- 19,643
Looks like a stretched assumption. Homelander even said "I took him to space". If he wanted to throw he could have just done it from ground.
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 6,738
- 6,135
Assume Mach 1 HL
At 2 second, he would have flown 600 meters in the air, and would have to chuck the dude the remaining 99,400m. This interpretation implies HL can chuck a person that high. If that's the case, why would he even bother to fly up instead of just chucking him?
Statements of HL being Mach 1.5 in flight speed, where A-Train is Mach 1.
- 201
- 100
Pretty much what I said.
At face value its a mach 200 feat.
You could argue against it or question it.
But yeah fair enough.
- 423
- 390
It's not impossible for Homelander to take him to the clouds then throw him. Really, either of the two could have happened. It's not stretched. It's just a shaky supporting feat. I don't subscribe to it personally, I don't take things at face value here because Powerscaling in The Boys has been very off in S5.
- 201
- 100
Eh I could agree with mach 200 ish homelander,since its getting a lot of dispute here.
All is fair to me as long as my goat Spidey still slams.
All is fair to me as long as my goat Spidey still slams.
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 6,738
- 6,135
The author's statements matter less than the story he wrote.
But that's not what was stated, and it's nonsensical to fly up 600 meters to chuck a person 100km in the air, he could've done it at ground level. You're inventing an alternate interpretation to solve for a seeming outlier.
- 2,563
- 1,132
No, but the opposite isn't stated in the verse either, All those statments that the A-Train is the fastest are just marketing hype.
In addition, just as A-Train’s speed was measured using speed-measuring devices, Homelander’s speed was also measured and found to be faster than A-Train’s top speed.
The statement that A-Train is faster than Homelander comes from a WOG and contradicts the characters’ previously stated speeds. And A-Train’s scene in Season 5 contradicts both itself and all previous statements. I think A-Train should be scaled according to his own statements and showing, and Homelander according to his own statements and showing, and we should write a note explaining why this is the case.
- 201
- 100
Even on screen feats show that Homelander us about to on par with A train.
I almost never disagree with statements,i think its a bit stupid(Except when its not from a valid source).The author is asserting the narrative with statements,and I take narrative over feats.
Still im fine with Mach 200 Homie.
- 201
- 100
He did it for aura purposes,and
Aura>Feats obv.
DarkLock92
He/Him- 1,470
- 1,021
Can't believe Sage got off Scott free
- 201
- 100
The Boys(TV) confirmed worse powerscaling than Invincible.
- 201
- 100
Basically living the dream.
- 22
- 37
The Boys has been one of my favorite shows, and I’ve been following it religiously since Season 2. Honestly, I really enjoyed the finale. At its core, this story was always about Homelander and Butcher, and we’ve been waiting years for their final confrontation—it definitely satisfied me. Butcher was even stronger than I expected, but the part that truly satisfied me the most was when their powers were gone, and Butcher ended up beating Homelander to a pulp with his bare hands
- 7,734
- 9,216
I thought the episode was fine for what it is, but it wasnt great. The pacing has been horrible since most noticeably season 4 and it doesnt really feel like a proper finale.
I think the space feat is probably MHS but trying to scale it to general physicals instead of flight speed is how you get the feat dismissed altogether so I'd be careful and not try to jump the gun on it.
I think the space feat is probably MHS but trying to scale it to general physicals instead of flight speed is how you get the feat dismissed altogether so I'd be careful and not try to jump the gun on it.
- 201
- 100
I mean time frame is 2 seconds ish.
Assuming he reached the karman line.
Mach 150.
So that is probably the lowball.
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 6,738
- 6,135
We'd have to deliberately argue that flight speed is this weird statistic that scales far above everything else when that's really not the case.
- 2,026
- 2,892
Saw the episode finally. It manages to hit the emotional beats, the problem is how it gets there makes no sense. Also Vought. Here is the thing, Homelander is not the Devil, Vought is, Homelander was just a symptom. Even the posters act like it will be the end of Vought with the destroyed Vought tower, But the real villain gets of scott free.
This was very disappointing. Gen V was wasted, the world of Supes is just relegated to Homelander only even though 98% of the supes are just as twisted and ****** up as he is (they just didn't have the power) and this doesn't even feel like a high stakes finale because it's not.
I will give props to the music though, it really elevated the scenes. But Butcher sneaking into the White house when they literally have that Iconic walk to adapt is just, wtf.
This was very disappointing. Gen V was wasted, the world of Supes is just relegated to Homelander only even though 98% of the supes are just as twisted and ****** up as he is (they just didn't have the power) and this doesn't even feel like a high stakes finale because it's not.
I will give props to the music though, it really elevated the scenes. But Butcher sneaking into the White house when they literally have that Iconic walk to adapt is just, wtf.
- 423
- 390
Agreed. The show tells you time and time again Homelander is the way he is because of Vought being comically evil and turning a child into a product. Yet Stan isn't punished despite overseeing the project that was dedicated to torturing saidchild. It genuinely annoys me how the fanbase glazes Stan Edgar as this "Stoic, Stone-Faced Sigma with aura" when he is legit a piece of shit he deserved a fate worse than death, but people gloss over this fact cause "aura bro".
This is another reason why I think it's a very poorly written finale, not just scale or stakes. Where's Stan's punishment?
- 2,026
- 2,892
On the scaling side, it's all over the place. Can fly to space in less than a second, but can't escape a room. Oh Father's scream should have popped MM's shoulder's out given he was holding the strap.
Butcher can keep up and throw around Homelander, but got absolutely stomped out by Bombsight, because Jensen needed the screen time to himself. Kimiko can take a laser beam and not be cut in half which implies her durability is now way way higher, except it isn't since we saw bullets pierce her. Oh and the big point of SCORCHED EARTH MY ASS,
Butcher can keep up and throw around Homelander, but got absolutely stomped out by Bombsight, because Jensen needed the screen time to himself. Kimiko can take a laser beam and not be cut in half which implies her durability is now way way higher, except it isn't since we saw bullets pierce her. Oh and the big point of SCORCHED EARTH MY ASS,
DarkLock92
He/Him- 1,470
- 1,021
Funny how Kingpin got a bigger crashout than Homelander
- 201
- 100
Marie is the potential woman of The Boys.
Now official.
Tapkmiz
He/Him- 145
- 136
I don't really get the separation in this case. We do know the Homelander - even as a young inexperienced Supe - has super speed on foot, as shown in Diabolical when he disarms the people in his first save. I think you'd have to go through a lot of hoops to argue Homelander physically moving his own body through space doesn't require some degree of reactions comparable to the speeds at which he's moving.
- 201
- 100
This is a problem that has a fairly easy solution.
Butcher reacts to Homelanders flight speed,and Homelander can keep up with Butcher in combat.
But Butcher got Blitzed by bombsight.
What is this scaling oh my god.
- 2,026
- 2,892
Deep's death is so contrived. You are telling me that on a Random coast, all these animals (who don't appear in shallows unless hunting seals or something) were just waiting for Deep somehow ? Also what tf do you mean for Ambrosia ? You are a shark, you literally eat her species. You eat anything that can fit in your mouth.
Why is a Deep sea Giant Squid on the shore (the live in abysal zone and only come up if they are dead or dying) and since when can a squid crush and go through a normal ass human much less a supe ?
So this confirms a Bear is 100% bodying 99% of all supes.
Why is a Deep sea Giant Squid on the shore (the live in abysal zone and only come up if they are dead or dying) and since when can a squid crush and go through a normal ass human much less a supe ?
So this confirms a Bear is 100% bodying 99% of all supes.
- 174
- 77
Didn't pop Ashley's shoulder when she was using it on him. Although a much weaker strap.
- 174
- 77
In S2 Deep takes a sperm whale to the shore
- 2,026
- 2,892
She is a supe. Ashley strapped it, did kinky stuff and then he screamed. MM was holding the strap behind his head. He would literally be flung into Oh Father's back.
- 2,026
- 2,892
"TAKES" It was given orders too. The Sharks had no way of knowing Deep would be there. He dropped in randomly and they just happened to be there.
- 388
- 266
True. But he didn’t really have any reason to. Mister Marathon was already proven to be lying. So him having traveled all that distance could’ve easily been just another lie
- 201
- 100
Kinkscaling?
- 423
- 390
I'm like 90% sure the way Deep died was a parallel to Adam Bourke's death and he died through his bum, which would bypass his hard exterior. That's just what I thought.
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 6,738
- 6,135
Fallacy of association. Homelander lied about being a morally sound super-hero, so all his statements are lies!
Of course that's silly, but it's spiritually the same argument you're making.
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 6,738
- 6,135
Also, all these characters know how fast Marathon is, if that was an outlandish claim, it would've been called out.
- 388
- 266
That’s actually a fair point, that he could’ve thrown him
- 2,026
- 2,892
It makes sense for Mr Marathon though since he was trying to butter up Soldier boy.
- 201
- 100
Soldier boy didn't know shit about MrMarathon and Homelander was sitting in a corner waiting for the V1,he has no reason to stand up and call MrM out, because he simply didn't care if he lied or not.
Similar threads
