• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

The Boys discussion thread

I’d be fine if he’s squishy but has some busted regeneration
That'd make more sense with the parasite powers too. We already saw the parasite can just open and close his chest pretty easily.

Squishy Butcher with regen + durable tentacles would be ideal imo. Durable Butcher with squishy tentacles kinda takes away the uniqueness of his powers
 
Also Ryan did burn Homelanders skin in s5 and that was clearly much less bloodlusted than against Stormfront too. It's basically the same damage as what TempV Butcher did to Homelander and he was straight up equal to Homelander in laser power.
Did he? It didn’t seem like his skin was burnt, wasn’t it just the suit?? Butcher also didn’t burn his skin unless I remember wrong
The thing is it still did absolutely no damage. For that to happen and Homelanders lasers to still be oneshot above Vicky he'd have to be holding back by like 95%.
He can hold it back enough to heat milk my guy, he wasn’t trying to harm let alone kill Vicky.
 
To be fair I see his tentacles as pure offence rather than defense.

The tentacles themselves aren't that fragile consider they tied up Bombsight.
 
Sage got arrogant thinking the video would destroy any and all growth in the relationship between SB and HL because she's so confident in her belief of how people think and act. Im 99% sure she's dead as **** next episode, especially now that HL knows she crossed her. I feel like The Boys crew showed themselves to be more stupid considering they might've had a chance to kill homelander already if kimiko and starlight had realized and communicated their lack of desire for V1 a bit earlier.

Anyways, it seems like at this point the only realistic or sensible way they can kill off homelander is if Marie rips the V1 out of his bloodstream, which for one, seems a little beyond her capabilities, and secondly it would feel like really really poor writing to have a character who hadn't appeared all season and was generally relegated to the spinoff to suddenly come in and be the one to save the day.
 
I am scared they'll ruin Homelander's death because at this point how could he even die? They have to do a random ass pull like @Valiant_Abyss said which would be pretty underwhelming.

Unless he wins... 👀
 
however intelligent sister sage is, her ego supersedes it; ashley straight up tells her about the situation with homelander and soldier boy, and she doesn't even take that into consideration in her plan. her showing soldier boy a video of homie and stormfront banging was the best she had to drive a further wedge between them? ight lol cant wait for her "this was apart of my plan" nonsense next week.
It's not JUST an ego thing.

However, I think, from what I've seen she has trouble predicting how certain people will FEEL. Like, when she was growing up, people didn't understand her, and because of that, the opposite has also applied, to an extent, and she doesn't understand certain factors that will make people act erratically. Or, to put it in other words, many people underestimated how smart she was and now she's underestimating how stupid Soldier Boy is. Both of were using the other, and I think they developed a certain degree of mutual respect, so when he did some dumb shit that's gonna get millions of people killed, that was pretty surprising for everyone.

Also, I'm ngl, she probably didn't predict that Legend would tell Homelander a random fact about a commercial he saw and Homelander would react to it, there's no way. She probably knew there WAS a tracker, but that would be crazy.
 
I am scared they'll ruin Homelander's death because at this point how could he even die? They have to do a random ass pull like @Valiant_Abyss said which would be pretty underwhelming.

Unless he wins... 👀
Random asspull WAS how he died in the comics(though I did enjoy it when I read it, even if I knew it ahead of time).

Funniest asspull I can imagine is if Butcher just gives him cancer.
 
Did he? It didn’t seem like his skin was burnt, wasn’t it just the suit?? Butcher also didn’t burn his skin unless I remember wrong
Both burned his skin but didn't go super deep or anything. Even in the most recent episode
Homelander cut through his own skin with his laser a little bit
He can hold it back enough to heat milk my guy, he wasn’t trying to harm let alone kill Vicky.
I'm not saying he can't hold it back, I'm saying if he's trying to prove she's a supe it'd be silly to make it where it basically doesn't mean anything whatsoever.
I am scared they'll ruin Homelander's death because at this point how could he even die? They have to do a random ass pull like @Valiant_Abyss said which would be pretty underwhelming.

Unless he wins... 👀
I'm honestly super glad he has V1. Losing to a ******* virus would have been super lame.

But I also have no idea how they'll kill him. If the V1 also made him much stronger which the uncontrollable laser blast and Butchers "run" seems to imply, even Marie probably no longer has the potential to match him.
 
Anyways here's a list of major remaining members and casualties/losses on each side for fun since the start of this season (I know some may not be aligned entirely in terms of their internal thoughts but I just put who is currently aligned with who at least to the public):
  • Homelander
  • Soldier Boy
  • The Deep
  • Ashley and Bashly
  • Oh Father
  • Sister Sage (switched sides)
  • New Noir (killed by the Deep)
  • Firecracker (killed by Homelander)
[*]8 main members to start, 5 remaining, 2 dead.

  • Butcher
  • Hughie
  • Starlight
  • Ryan*** (got ass whooped by Homelander and does NOT wanna run it back)
  • MM
  • Frenchie
  • Kimiko
  • Sister Sage
  • A-Train (Killed by Homelander)
  • Stan Edgar (In Vought custody)
  • Newman's husband (quit)
  • Gen V crew*** (Irrelevant and/or absent)
  • 11 members to start, 9 remaining, 1 dead, 2 MIA
 
Also, I'm ngl, she probably didn't predict that Legend would tell Homelander a random fact about a commercial he saw and Homelander would react to it, there's no way. She probably knew there WAS a tracker, but that would be crazy.
No I think she did anticipate he'd show up, or just be okay with him showing up. She didn't seem surprised by the fact that he was there, only that Soldier Boy handed it to him.
 
Bombsight is like the 3rd strongest physically in the verse
If we're talking purely physicals, I think him and Soldier Boy are even, SB just has more skill or whatever. I'd put Maeve up there too if it weren't for the fact that she mainly held her own because Homelander was so ass at fighting compared to her.
 
No I think she did anticipate he'd show up, or just be okay with him showing up. She didn't seem surprised by the fact that he was there, only that Soldier Boy handed it to him.
Yeah, I guess she must've just assumed he'd get told about the tracker by one of his coworkers or something.
 
Anyways here's a list of major remaining members and casualties/losses on each side for fun since the start of this season (I know some may not be aligned entirely in terms of their internal thoughts but I just put who is currently aligned with who at least to the public):
  • Homelander
  • Soldier Boy
  • The Deep
  • Ashley and Bashly
  • Oh Father
  • Sister Sage (switched sides)
  • New Noir (killed by the Deep)
  • Firecracker (killed by Homelander)
[*]8 main members to start, 5 remaining, 2 dead.

  • Butcher
  • Hughie
  • Starlight
  • Ryan*** (got ass whooped by Homelander and does NOT wanna run it back)
  • MM
  • Frenchie
  • Kimiko
  • Sister Sage
  • A-Train (Killed by Homelander)
  • Stan Edgar (In Vought custody)
  • Newman's husband (quit)
  • Gen V crew*** (Irrelevant and/or absent)
  • 11 members to start, 9 remaining, 1 dead, 2 MIA
Here's who I think is dying and how:

Definitely dying:
-Butcher: Killed by cancer or Homelander, but outlives him. Possibly has to be killed by Hughie.
-Homelander: Idfk. Presumably killed by getting jumped.
-Soldier Boy: Killed by Homelander or The Boys
-Oh-Father: Killed by Homelander or one of his allies, possibly after sacrificing himself, or killed by The Boys normally, or accidentally kills himself.

Probably Dying:
-The Deep: Killed by Homelander, virus, or fish betrayal. Possibly killed by Starlight, unlikely. MIGHT just get condemned to live underwater forever.
-Kimiko: They had the whole mortality thing for her earlier. She'll probably sacrifice herself and get hit by something, maybe the virus, idk.
-Frenchie: Dies with Kimiko if she dies.
-Sage: Killed by Homelander

50/50:
-Ashley: If she dies, it'll be someone else's fault. Presumably a Supe kills her.
-MM: If he's killed, it'll be by Soldier Boy or Butcher, maybe Homelander
-Stan Edgar: If he dies, it'll be MM or Homelander that kills him.


Definitely not dying:
Hughie
Annie
Ryan: If he dies, it's from Homelander. 1% chance tho.
Neuman's family



Gen V crew might show up, but probably not. I wish they would, they'd be very helpful rn.
 
Homelander is gonna kill SB to prove he has no humanity left, his human father. Write this down
 
I actually really liked Bombsight. Like he genuinely seems like not that bad of a Supe fr

Like actually wanna see more of him in Vought Rising now
Which is ironic, given how much of a piece of work he is in Teen Wolf and Stranger Things
 
My takeaways from this episode:

Sister Sage is such a terribly written character. Her whole personality is "I predicted that." "People are so predictable." but never actually showing how she comes to any of her conclusions about anything or anyone. And now, when it matters the most, and literally anyone with 80 IQ could've seen it coming, she flops on the most basic prediction ever despite having a literal mind reader give her elite comms. What a joke, dude. I never liked her in the first place, but this is seriously sad.

Why can't we have a single smart character in this show?

Starlight is embarrassingly weak. How are you getting no-diffed by loud voice man. God damn it, she and Hughie have felt sooo useless this season...

I think I'm getting tired of the weird sexual stuff this show has. Like, why is a dude's power just swinging his balls around? We already had the Sausage guy...

Realistically, Homelander simply wins and ends the series right after V1 unless he passes out or something. I guess they're gonna have to BS something, though..

Black Noir just ******* sucks in this show, no matter what iteration of him, I guess.
 
If we're talking purely physicals, I think him and Soldier Boy are even, SB just has more skill or whatever. I'd put Maeve up there too if it weren't for the fact that she mainly held her own because Homelander was so ass at fighting compared to her.
I disagree I think they are relative in skill but the difference is lifting strength another notable thing is that SB hurt his hand punching him
 
Last edited:
Stormfront, Vicky, and even both temp V and cancer butcher damn near no-sold the laser. Sure for Vicky you could say he was purposely not going at full power, but with both Stormfront and both Butcher versions it was pretty clearly a direct feat of durability. Homelanders laser was pretty clearly also equally to TempV Butchers and Homelander basically no sold those too.

I also think the balancing is kinda dumb. I'd much prefer Butchers body being vulnerable to the lasers but his tentacles tanking them than the opposite. That way Butcher would be at a constant threat from Homelander lasering him but still not completely outclassed if he manages to block the beams.
Dude homelander can control the intensity of his beams. He was 100% holding back the entire scene with Stormfront and she did not no sell it either as she got a third degree burn the finale wouldn't even make any sense if that was the case. The literal same goes goes Neuman lmao do you seriously think homelander was trying to kill her on live television? He was just trying to expose her powers. Cancer butcher is the only one where I'm convinced he wasn't holding back and even that isn't a no sell at all.
 
Both burned his skin but didn't go super deep or anything. Even in the most recent episode
Homelander cut through his own skin with his laser a little bit

I'm not saying he can't hold it back, I'm saying if he's trying to prove she's a supe it'd be silly to make it where it basically doesn't mean anything whatsoever.
No it wouldn't he would simply be baiting her to react to the beam being fired at her or would lower it to a level where it would Possibly matter TO HER.
 
Starlight is embarrassingly weak. How are you getting no-diffed by loud voice man. God damn it, she and Hughie have felt sooo useless this season...
Ok, I was talking about this yesterday, but an attack coming in at the speed of sound that produces enough force to send you flying is NOT a weak power.

For the record, the balls thing is just a bit about old dudes that's been around for a couple centuries but doesn't come up that often because we don't talk about senior citizen testicles that much. For instance, I remember a comic with a bit playing off that where someone was like "where do you think grandfather clocks got their name?" and yknow it went as expected.
 
Ok, I was talking about this yesterday, but an attack coming in at the speed of sound that produces enough force to send you flying is NOT a weak power.

For the record, the balls thing is just a bit about old dudes that's been around for a couple centuries but doesn't come up that often because we don't talk about senior citizen testicles that much. For instance, I remember a comic with a bit playing off that where someone was like "where do you think grandfather clocks got their name?" and yknow it went as expected.
also ain't sound Supe's weakness?
 
Oh father’s sound also could potentially be giving Homelander his hallucinations. Of course, I don’t think that’s confirmed. But if it is, then that mean he’s definitely one of the stronger supes, and him beating starlight entirely makes sense
 
YES! You get it. I didn't bring it up because I was just talking generally, but Supes ARE weak to many sound attacks due to their hearing, and sound ALREADY has some disorienting capabilities.
Like we literally see Annie holding her head in pain like Mark Grayson after getting his ass blasted by Sonic attacks
 
Soldier Boy really got retconned hard though. In S3 we are told that the only woman he cared about was Crimson Countess.

He not only kept her in mind throughout decades of imprisonment and torture. The first person he tries to find is her and even weeps after killing her.

It's not like the topic of Stormfront never came up. He gives a throwaway line that shows Stormfront was nothing more than a good **** in Herogasm.

And now somehow she is the important person in his life.

It's baffling how bad the writing quality is, just to promote a spin off.
 
I think were ignoring the fact that only one vial of V1 existed.So if the boys got it we would have a dilemma of who would take it,Kimiko or Annie.
 
Can someone calculate two destructive feats from episode 6? I'm talking about scenes there bombsight flew through a concrete ceiling and destroyed a concrete structure upon landing, and bombsight formed a crater in the ground upon landing. I think it will be a good supporting 9-A/8-C feats.
 
I think were ignoring the fact that only one vial of V1 existed.So if the boys got it we would have a dilemma of who would take it,Kimiko or Annie.
Couldn’t Frenchie replicate it after they got it? The formula was the problem right
 
I think were ignoring the fact that only one vial of V1 existed.So if the boys got it we would have a dilemma of who would take it,Kimiko or Annie.
No, if they had it, Frenchie could probably replicate it. The only reason Sage wasn't succeeding in making it was she didn't have a sample.
It's not like the topic of Stormfront never came up. He gives a throwaway line that shows Stormfront was nothing more than a good **** in Herogasm.
All else aside, that's not what he says. He says she was another Supe, since he thinks they wouldn't know who she was, because he's talking to like, Butcher and Hughie, not anyone he'd really be emptying the contents of his heart to. But what he says after that is "Man, was she a firecracker." Now, in the way he uses it, that's meant to be a compliment, and it's not just "does sex good," it refers to someone having a strong, "fiery" personality, which the speaker enjoys. Nowhere does that say "I only cared about this person for sex."
 
But what he says after that is "Man, was she a firecracker." Now, in the way he uses it, that's meant to be a compliment, and it's not just "does sex good," it refers to someone having a strong, "fiery" personality, which the speaker enjoys. Nowhere does that say "I only cared about this person for sex."
Yeah sure. still doesn't matter because Crimson countess exists. It's clearly a retcon no matter how many pages and books you write defending it. Soldier would be looking for Liberty if she was the love of his life, rather than Crimson countess. Instead she is a throwaway reference to show that these two character attended previous herogasms.
 
Can someone calculate two destructive feats from episode 6? I'm talking about scenes there bombsight flew through a concrete ceiling and destroyed a concrete structure upon landing, and bombsight formed a crater in the ground upon landing. I think it will be a good supporting 9-A/8-C feats.
I mean Bombsight clearly scales to Soldier Boy so it’d be pointless
 
I think this statement (which comes from a deleted scene) should no longer be used on her page, because Maeve clearly wasn't the second most powerful Supe on Earth, given that there was Rock Hard and Bombsight.
I’d also note this was before the lore about Soldier Boy being “nearly as strong” as Homelander and the whole thing about Supes levelling up via training.
 
Did he? It didn’t seem like his skin was burnt, wasn’t it just the suit?? Butcher also didn’t burn his skin unless I remember wrong.
I think that's because HV has like "two modes"
Pure heat version, with little to no force behind it.
Then there's the concussive one, mainly use to push or destroy stuff and people, though it does have some heat.
I think this statement (which comes from a deleted scene) should no longer be used on her page, because Maeve clearly wasn't the second most powerful Supe on Earth, given that there was Rock Hard and Bombsight.
I mean, while it kinda suffers retroactively, it would still apply towards the supes known at S1.
 
Back
Top