Spongebob Squarepants Discussion Thread

[Psychomaster35]

So starting with Spongebob:

-Upgrade his regeneration to High (After he turned himself into bubbles and got popped, he presumably regenerated afterwards)

That’s still Mid-High. To reach High regeneration, you would need to be reduced to a few dust particles, and what he regenerated from was vapor.

-Resistance to Plot Manipulation (Burger Beard redefined the fate of Spongebob in the magic book yet Spongebob wasn’t affected by it. Burger Beard couldn’t even read Bubbles The Dolphins’ existence in the story and unaffected by your show being taken off the air

Remove the first justification. Burger Beard was only forced to continue the story because the seagulls convinced him to.

Everything else in Spongebob’s section looks fine, but please fix your grammar. I understand you may be a non-English person possibly using a translator, though.

 

[Psychomaster35]

Continuing on, the changes for Squidward, Patrick, and Plankton look fine. As for Mr. Krabs:

-Immortality (Type 1 and 5) (He cannot die, instead it is necessary for the Flying Dutchman to fetch him and lock him in Dave Jones' closet, in the episode "Money Speaks" he says he is immortal and he lived so long his first coin is a stone)

Eh, I’m kinda skeptical on Type 5. Nothing really states he can’t die, and just because the Flying Dutchman had to seal him into Davy Jone’s Locker doesn’t imply he can’t die. In fact, the deleted scene for Clams would’ve confirmed that Krabs’ parents are dead. Type 1 is okay, though.

Everything else on the changes for Krabs looks fine.

 

[Psychomaster35]

The changes for Gary, Larry, The Flying Dutchman, King Neptune, Sandy, and Dennis look fine (Although Sandy healed her head, not her suit). As for Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy:

- Empowerment and reality distortion (with the power of friendship)

- Age manipulation (with the power of friendship Mermaid Man returns to his prime)

I believe you are referring to Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy V? If I’m right, then I don’t recall that happening. All it was was Barnacle Boy helping Mermaid Man back up when he decided to return to the side of justice. Acausality is fine.

As a side note: I don’t think you should be including game or show spinoff feats in the changes since they aren’t canon to the main show.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

I have a say in Psycho's análisis myself, so stayed tuned for that when I get back.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

- Upgrade his regeneration to High (After he turned himself into bubbles and got popped, he presumably regenerated afterwards)

That’s still Mid-High. To reach High regeneration, you would need to be reduced to a few dust particles, and what he regenerated from was vapor.

I can see your point here.

But okay, let me at least add that SB in actuality could be Low-Godly: He was unfazed from the string erasures as he was literally laughing it off, where as everybody else when THEY get erased it's in a snap and even then SB would still be able to spawn back his body from absolutely nowhere into it's own self as seen here and here (There is surprisingly more examples of this).

- Resistance to Plot Manipulation (Burger Beard redefined the fate of Spongebob in the magic book yet Spongebob wasn’t affected by it. Burger Beard couldn’t even read Bubbles The Dolphins’ existence in the story and unaffected by his show being taken off the air

Remove the first justification. Burger Beard was only forced to continue the story because the seagulls convinced him to.

When Burger Beard redefined the Plot, everyone else went mad, yet this didn't seemingly effect SB as fully. But if these count - (Burger Beard couldn’t even read Bubbles The Dolphins’ existence in the story and unaffected by his show being taken off the air) then ok

Everything else in Spongebob’s section looks fine, but please fix your grammar. I understand you may be a non-English person possibly using a translator, though.

I can help for now, just say the word.

- Immortality (Type 1 and 5) (He cannot die, instead it is necessary for the Flying Dutchman to fetch him and lock him in Dave Jones' closet, in the episode "Money Speaks" he says he is immortal and he lived so long his first coin is a stone)

Eh, I’m kinda skeptical on Type 5. Nothing really states he can’t die, and just because the Flying Dutchman had to seal him into Davy Jone’s Locker doesn’t imply he can’t die. In fact, the deleted scene for Clams would’ve confirmed that Krabs’ parents are dead. Type 1 is okay, though.

I too am baffled with Type 5. Everything else is up to bar, Type 5 doesn’t seem to matter much when you can function normally as a Ghost tho.

As for Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy:

- Empowerment and reality distortion (with the power of friendship)

- Age manipulation (with the power of friendship Mermaid Man returns to his prime)

I believe you are referring to Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy V? If I’m right, then I don’t recall that happening. All it was was Barnacle Boy helping Mermaid Man back up when he decided to return to the side of justice.

All of this was in the comics, I remember vividly and it's legit. We just have to find it again.

As a side note: I don’t think you should be including game or show spinoff feats in the changes since they aren’t canon to the main show.

There are reasons in doing this actually, but I'll let them have a say in it first.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

You also forgot to add the Eternity EXP part for both SB, Squid, Krabs, and Plankton. There's something much bigger going on with Frenchy as well. Let's take this into consideration first:

Frenchy is now something else entierly, and he has literally meant the time of eternity, just as easy as peering into 2000 years in the future would... Yet despite these stats Frenchie has, the characters have effected him anyways which should say something more. This is immensely solid with all things considered.

They are as old as eternity itself...

Holy **** SB is actually beyond cracked on EXP, considering they worked for a literal eternity doing lots of the other crazy adventures surely XD.

I'm convinced with the eternity exp/age, given the author will NOT LIE with what he says.
When he says eternity, IT'S LITERAL FOREVER/ETERNITY... Actually, there is more to it then that come to think of it, Frenchie IS that said narrator. Frenchie can instantly tell/reach these said unknowable periods (Note: Other examples are in "Spongehenge", Frenchie somehow knows where The Flying Dutchman had the crew in the void, and many MANY more)

And you want to know the best part from this??... SB amongst others have literally bypassed/mocked the guy XD:





Here they even run him over, dude is clearly fazed by them.

 

[Psychomaster35]

I’ve looked through everything else, and aside from the feats that come from games/spinoffs (IE. Dream Manipulation in the games and the Black Hole surviving feat in the Patrick Star Show), they look fine. Though you need to update the calculations list with my new string calculation as well as Flashlight’s 3 Spongebob calculations.

But okay, let me at least add that SB in actuality could be Low-Godly: He was unfazed from the string erasures as he was literally laughing it off, where as everybody else when THEY get erased it's in a snap and even then SB would still be able to spawn back his body from absolutely nowhere into it's own self as seen here and here (There is surprisingly more examples of this).

Him coming back from being erased by the string is fine, although the last 2 scans still have visible parts of him.

There are reasons in doing this actually, but I'll let them have a say in it first.

If this was because of Prawn’s appearance in a recent episode, then that’s not enough. They would have to be making past references to the games themselves. And while the crossover event confirms all 3 Spongebob shows are in the same multiverse, they are still different universes.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

I’ve looked through everything else, and aside from the feats that come from games/spinoffs (IE. Dream Manipulation in the games and the Black Hole surviving feat in the Patrick Star Show), they look fine.

Alright, I know how dubious you feel about it, but I'll let them (Pugao, Almighty, Coolgohan, etc.) have a say in this too anyways. As I said, I too have been off the loop on the SB verse and I need a refresher.

Though you need to update the calculations list with my new string calculation as well as Flashlight’s 3 Spongebob calculations.

OK, I'll leave them with any suggestions in these as well, but thank you for contributing anyways.

Him coming back from being erased by the string is fine, although the last 2 scans still have visible parts of him.

The confetti doesn't really mean anything considering he clearly didn't directly spawn from the said confetti... SB still came from nothing else entierly, not the confetti. Likely the same with the second clip, we not only hear his voice when Ms. Puff looked behind, it was understood that SpongeBob by now was there being the radio... Despite there being no actual parts to regenerate from in the said exact spot of the radio...

So, as I said, SB's Regen should still be like this to not cause confusion:
"Regeneration (At least Low-Godly. Unfazed from erasures and can bring back his body from nothingness several times)".

If this was because of Prawn’s appearance in a recent episode, then that’s not enough. They would have to be making past references to the games themselves.

I mean he also makes appearances in the Comics as well.

Others here could name a couple more examples if they can, I mean Prawn originated from BFBB first, but I'm certain there have been some nods.

And while the crossover event confirms all 3 Spongebob shows are in the same multiverse, they are still different universes.

I'll leave them with their own suggestions as well for now.

 

[Pugao_03]

So starting with Spongebob:

-Upgrade his regeneration to High (After he turned himself into bubbles and got popped, he presumably regenerated afterwards)

That’s still Mid-High. To reach High regeneration, you would need to be reduced to a few dust particles, and what he regenerated from was vapor.

-Resistance to Plot Manipulation (Burger Beard redefined the fate of Spongebob in the magic book yet Spongebob wasn’t affected by it. Burger Beard couldn’t even read Bubbles The Dolphins’ existence in the story and unaffected by your show being taken off the air

Remove the first justification. Burger Beard was only forced to continue the story because the seagulls convinced him to.

Everything else in Spongebob’s section looks fine, but please fix your grammar. I understand you may be a non-English person possibly using a translator, though.

ok, it turns out that in the justification of Barba burguer it was shown that a page of the book even after being ripped out still affected the world around.
And it turns out that Burguer Beard wasn't shown putting the story on.
So possibly? Though it shouldn't affect too much.

But it seems ok to remove the high regeneration, but sorry for the english mistakes, it's just that I'm not fluent in that language.

 

[Pugao_03]

Continuing on, the changes for Squidward, Patrick, and Plankton look fine. As for Mr. Krabs:

-Immortality (Type 1 and 5) (He cannot die, instead it is necessary for the Flying Dutchman to fetch him and lock him in Dave Jones' closet, in the episode "Money Speaks" he says he is immortal and he lived so long his first coin is a stone)

Eh, I’m kinda skeptical on Type 5. Nothing really states he can’t die, and just because the Flying Dutchman had to seal him into Davy Jone’s Locker doesn’t imply he can’t die. In fact, the deleted scene for Clams would’ve confirmed that Krabs’ parents are dead. Type 1 is okay, though.

Everything else on the changes for Krabs looks fine.

I understand that it is strange, because it is very difficult to classify this because in this case the doctor's scene implies that Mr Krabs would have died so much that he is terrified, From what the doctor told SpongeBob and Squidward implies that as squidward says "Mr krabs won't come back" because of the hospital results, But we see that he is physically alive and well, unlike other characters who die naturally Mr Krabs had to be escorted by the flying Dutchman

Possibly type 5 would work?
(not to mention he doesn't seem to be a living dead in the scene or anything like that)

 

[Pugao_03]

The changes for Gary, Larry, The Flying Dutchman, King Neptune, Sandy, and Dennis look fine (Although Sandy healed her head, not her suit). As for Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy:

- Empowerment and reality distortion (with the power of friendship)

- Age manipulation (with the power of friendship Mermaid Man returns to his prime)

I believe you are referring to Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy V? If I’m right, then I don’t recall that happening. All it was was Barnacle Boy helping Mermaid Man back up when he decided to return to the side of justice. Acausality is fine.

As a side note: I don’t think you should be including game or show spinoff feats in the changes since they aren’t canon to the main show.

I forgot to put the links sorry, it was in a HQ they were facing a villain that was a mini tsunami and with the power of friendship they distorted the HQ to look like a comic, This while the heroes returned to their prime.

 

[Pugao_03]

But about the games, BFBB (Battle for Bikini Bottom) I believe it would be canonical, in addition to one of the villains of this game appearing in the regular series, in the game we have several things and references to the cartoon.
The spin offs like Kamp Coral have an episode where Sandy from the current cartoon communicates with Kamp Coral saying she is from the "future".
it also has the quote from one of the show's writers saying that SpongeBob never had an "Canon".

 

[Pugao_03]

but I think that for the things of the show the age of the characters would be quite absurd.
and thanks Psychomaster35 for rating everything

 

[Pugao_03]

I’ve looked through everything else, and aside from the feats that come from games/spinoffs (IE. Dream Manipulation in the games and the Black Hole surviving feat in the Patrick Star Show), they look fine. Though you need to update the calculations list with my new string calculation as well as Flashlight’s 3 Spongebob calculations.


Him coming back from being erased by the string is fine, although the last 2 scans still have visible parts of him.

Okay, I'll update everything later, but this being erased would make him have regeneration of what kind? For apparently the rope has erased everyone in the universe which includes souls like the flying Dutchman.

and is it okay to experience a whole eternity?

 

[Psychomaster35]

I understand that it is strange, because it is very difficult to classify this because in this case the doctor's scene implies that Mr Krabs would have died so much that he is terrified, From what the doctor told SpongeBob and Squidward implies that as squidward says "Mr krabs won't come back" because of the hospital results, But we see that he is physically alive and well, unlike other characters who die naturally Mr Krabs had to be escorted by the flying Dutchman

Possibly type 5 would work?
(not to mention he doesn't seem to be a living dead in the scene or anything like that)

Still doesn’t imply anything, and not even a possibly works in that case.

But about the games, BFBB (Battle for Bikini Bottom) I believe it would be canonical, in addition to one of the villains of this game appearing in the regular series, in the game we have several things and references to the cartoon.
The spin offs like Kamp Coral have an episode where Sandy from the current cartoon communicates with Kamp Coral saying she is from the "future".
it also has the quote from one of the show's writers saying that SpongeBob never had an "Canon".

Once again, that hardly changes anything. If anything, the games referencing things that happened in the show make it feel like a one-sided canon while the show doesn’t mention any references to the games outside of small cameos.

The part where past Sandy went to Kamp Koral to stop Plankton from stealing the formula as instructed by present Sandy has issues in itself. Mainly, if Sandy and Spongebob met at Kamp Koral because present Sandy convinced her past self to go there to preserve the timeline, then why didn’t Spongebob recognize Sandy when they met in Tea at the Treedome? If anything, I consider the 2 shows 2 different alternate realities. And even if they were part of the same timeline, the same can’t be said about The Patrick Star Show which makes it very clear in the 3-way crossover special that it’s a completely different alternate reality despite all 3 shows taking place in the same multiverse.

Source about Spongebob not having any canon?

 

[Pugao_03]

Still doesn’t imply anything, and not even a possibly works in that case.

if not immortality what do you think it would be? everyone implies that mr krabs is dead, but he is shown to be alive, Flying Dutchman went to the hospital to get him, as Mr Krabs was a very bad person in life with his destination being Davy Jones' closet, as the Flying Dutchman is like "a reaper"
In the context of the episode he is dead, but the only way he can get out of the world of the living is if the flying Dutchman picks him up.

The part where past Sandy went to Kamp Koral to stop Plankton from stealing the formula as instructed by present Sandy has issues in itself. Mainly, if Sandy and Spongebob met at Kamp Koral because present Sandy convinced her past self to go there to preserve the timeline, then why didn’t Spongebob recognize Sandy when they met in Tea at the Treedome? If anything, I consider the 2 shows 2 different alternate realities. And even if they were part of the same timeline, the same can’t be said about The Patrick Star Show which makes it very clear in the 3-way crossover special that it’s a completely different alternate reality despite all 3 shows taking place in the same multiverse.

Source about Spongebob not having any canon?

If you say so, because in the game we see characters that are only featured in the series like SpongeBob's bubble friend and other things that only exist in the series.
not to mention that both in the comics and in the cartoon the BFBB villain appears, it's kind of strange not to consider the game as part of the show when it doesn't bring any contradiction

About this would be due to a lack of official Chronological on the show, as quoted by one of the show's writers.
It's one of the explanations for the show's lack of continuity.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

Okay, I'll update everything later, but this being erased would make him have regeneration of what kind? For apparently the rope has erased everyone in the universe which includes souls like the flying Dutchman.

Oh yeah, most of these souls are also shown to be buried of course. So SB Regeneration would be Mid-Godly as (Aside appearing from nothing already) he laughed off the erasure that erased literal undead/souls.

and is it okay to experience a whole eternity?

It should. Frenchy has already done insane stuff himself, from peering into futures, voids, etc. So none of it is an exaggeration surprisingly (Beating/mocking Frenchie alone should say something more as well too).

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

but I think that for the things of the show the age of the characters would be quite absurd.
and thanks Psychomaster35 for rating everything

Also we REALLY need to redefine Spongebob’s current "sTaNdArD tAcTiCtS" depictions. SB is surprisingly far more then what he lets on then that.

 

[Pugao_03]

Although Patrick star show is another universe, I'm not sure Kamp koral would be due to Sandy's own quotes about being about the future.

But I think I found a scale between the Shows maybe? Although SpongeBob had been crushed by Patrick's grandfather, the opening hand of the episode that faced one of Plankton's robots dominated him.
Being that he was one of the characters that survived the explosion of the Earth that created a black hole


9:42



besides that on another occasion Mr Krabs dominated the
opening hand 1:33
In addition to being able to defend against it of course

 

[Psychomaster35]

So SB Regeneration would be Mid-Godly as (Aside appearing from nothing already) he laughed off the erasure that erased literal undead/souls.

Proof? I’ve watched the entire episode and we never see any souls affected by the string.

if not immortality what do you think it would be? everyone implies that mr krabs is dead, but he is shown to be alive, Flying Dutchman went to the hospital to get him, as Mr Krabs was a very bad person in life with his destination being Davy Jones' closet, as the Flying Dutchman is like "a reaper"
In the context of the episode he is dead, but the only way he can get out of the world of the living is if the flying Dutchman picks him up.

No ability. Plus, they were wrong about Mr. Krabs being dead because he was clearly still alive.

Although Patrick star show is another universe, I'm not sure Kamp koral would be due to Sandy's own quotes about being about the future.

There’s still the contradiction in the continuity about Spongebob meeting Sandy which implies these are really just alternate realities that are both canon at the same time.

But I think I found a scale between the Shows maybe? Although SpongeBob had been crushed by Patrick's grandfather, the opening hand of the episode that faced one of Plankton's robots dominated him.
Being that he was one of the characters that survived the explosion of the Earth that created a black hole

Are you sure that’s even the same Hans from the main Spongebob universe? Because all of the characters in the Patrick Star show are blatantly completely separate characters from their main show counterparts outside of having the same personalities and bodies.

Nonetheless, even by disregarding the black hole feat that happens in a spin-off show not canon to the main series, the main show should scale to 4-A or 3-B based on imagination/dreams constantly becoming a reality to the point where they are interactable where it’s possible to destroy them.

 

[Pugao_03]

No ability. Plus, they were wrong about Mr. Krabs being dead because he was clearly still alive.

Flying Dutchman says his time has come Squidward says Mr Krabs is dead
SpongeBob is sad to hear that he died
Mr krabs' doctor freaks out when he sees his diagnosis when Mr krabs asks if everything is ok
The Flying Dutchman mentions that Mr Krabs due to his greed would go to Davy Jones' closet
All this because Mr Krabs died of poisoning with a hamburger, we even see him going to the hospital in a bad way

Honestly, the whole episode revolves around the fact that Mr Krabs was supposedly dead and because he was greedy in life the Flying Dutchman personally went to get him for eternal suffering
To say that everyone was wrong including the very being who is in charge of reaping the souls of bad people from the bottom of the sea is dishonest, not to mention that this is the main theme of the episode, Having been affirmed by several characters, so much so that Mr Krabs was given a second chance after he begged to live again.

Proof? I’ve watched the entire episode and we never see any souls affected by the string.

The ghosts that are souls were affected, as the rope left nothing behind.

Are you sure that’s even the same Hans from the main Spongebob universe? Because all of the characters in the Patrick Star show are blatantly completely separate characters from their main show counterparts outside of having the same personalities and bodies.

Yeah, it was the same as the opening of the show's original universe.

on the issue of contradiction, welcome to spongebob a cartoon that has no official timeline.

 

[Pugao_03]

Nonetheless, even by disregarding the black hole feat that happens in a spin-off show not canon to the main series, the main show should scale to 4-A or 3-B based on imagination/dreams constantly becoming a reality to the point where they are interactable where it’s possible to destroy them.

Really, but one question... Should his reaction speed scale to rope? It seems that while he was undoing the universe he followed the rope in motion and they said something about him having to pull it very quickly

 

[Pugao_03]

I don't know if this could be a feat of speed, but a robotic version of Gary can move fast enough to catch a laser without it disappearing
1:38

 

[Pugao_03]

Also we REALLY need to redefine Spongebob’s current "sTaNdArD tAcTiCtS" depictions. SB is surprisingly far more then what he lets on then that.

I think there could have been better specified that he only uses karate against characters of the same size, but his preferred method of attack is bubble manipulation, even in hero form.
If overwhelmed or cornered he usually uses Broadway force which comes with reality distortion and a few other things.

 

[Psychomaster35]

Flying Dutchman says his time has come Squidward says Mr Krabs is dead
SpongeBob is sad to hear that he died
Mr krabs' doctor freaks out when he sees his diagnosis when Mr krabs asks if everything is ok
The Flying Dutchman mentions that Mr Krabs due to his greed would go to Davy Jones' closet
All this because Mr Krabs died of poisoning with a hamburger, we even see him going to the hospital in a bad way

Again, just because the Flying Dutchman needed to lock him into Davy Jone’s locker doesn’t imply Krabs is immortal. He was most likely going to torture him up until his death.

The ghosts that are souls were affected, as the rope left nothing behind.

Again, proof the ghosts were even affected? We never even see any ghosts on-screen that have been affected by it.

Yeah, it was the same as the opening of the show's original universe.

on the issue of contradiction, welcome to spongebob a cartoon that has no official timeline.

Except the crossover blatantly shows all 3 shows are different continuities. Stop saying they are just because there’s no canon in the show since that’s just for the main series only.

Really, but one question... Should his reaction speed scale to rope? It seems that while he was undoing the universe he followed the rope in motion and they said something about him having to pull it very quickly

Definitely, and this is even consistent with his other FTL feats

 

[Pugao_03]

Again, just because the Flying Dutchman needed to lock him into Davy Jone’s locker doesn’t imply Krabs is immortal. He was most likely going to torture him up until his death.

this is headcanon, at no time is it mentioned that he would do this and there are several quotes and implications that mr krabs died coming from a medical diagnosis and the flying dutchman himself
The only reason the Flying Dutchman went there is that Mr Krabs died of poisoning.
So much so that Mr Krabs needed another chance to restart his life

Although the episode does not imply that he is "immortal" it does show that instead of Mr Krabs dying in the conventional way when he dies it is necessary for the Flying Dutchman to come get him when he dies.
But thanks to Spongebob, the Dutchman doesn't even want to look for Mr Krabs' soul anymore.

Again, proof the ghosts were even affected? We never even see any ghosts on-screen that have been affected by it.

If they hadn't been affected, the moment SpongeBob erases the milky way from existence we'd see ghosts like the flying Dutchman in the erased location don't you think? Not to mention that there are characters who, when they die, become ghosts and even after being erased by the rope, they do not become ghosts.

Except the crossover blatantly shows all 3 shows are different continuities. Stop saying they are just because there’s no canon in the show since that’s just for the main series only

Patrick's grandfather appearing in Kamp koral doesn't necessarily prove that Kamp koral is from a different universe than the original show as it was quoted to be the same timeline by Sandy, It is possible that he went to the past of that timeline.
The biggest problem between both being from the same timeline seems to be the fact that in one episode they meet in a different way, But this is explained by one of the writers and there is a quote from Sandy about being in the same timeline.
Not to mention that the cartoon has moments of lack of continuity, in the normal cartoon in the episode where Patrick helps Plankton to attract clients the villain says the following "I've never seen you in all my life" Although I've known him several episodes before and even trained him.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

I think there could have been better specified that he only uses karate against characters of the same size, but his preferred method of attack is bubble manipulation, even in hero form.
If overwhelmed or cornered he usually uses Broadway force which comes with reality distortion and a few other things.

Kind of. What I mean is that he still uses more potent hax on display then the ones mentioned thus far as well.

Proof? I’ve watched the entire episode and we never see any souls affected by the string.

This describes my thoughts about it:

If they hadn't been affected, the moment SpongeBob erases the milky way from existence we'd see ghosts like the flying Dutchman in the erased location don't you think? Not to mention that there are characters who, when they die, become ghosts and even after being erased by the rope, they do not become ghosts.

Basically in many episodes they come back as Ghosts, but none of them appeared in ghost forms as they permanently were erased, yet SB is unfazed by this therefore Mid-Godly is still well acquainted.

Patrick's grandfather appearing in Kamp koral doesn't necessarily prove that Kamp koral is from a different universe than the original show as it was quoted to be the same timeline by Sandy, It is possible that he went to the past of that timeline.
The biggest problem between both being from the same timeline seems to be the fact that in one episode they meet in a different way, But this is explained by one of the writers and there is a quote from Sandy about being in the same timeline.
Not to mention that the cartoon has moments of lack of continuity, in the normal cartoon in the episode where Patrick helps Plankton to attract clients the villain says the following "I've never seen you in all my life" Although I've known him several episodes before and even trained him.

Which is why I let people have their suggestions first, as stuff like this can be a miss.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

this is headcanon, at no time is it mentioned that he would do this and there are several quotes and implications that mr krabs died coming from a medical diagnosis and the flying dutchman himself
The only reason the Flying Dutchman went there is that Mr Krabs died of poisoning.
So much so that Mr Krabs needed another chance to restart his life

Although the episode does not imply that he is "immortal" it does show that instead of Mr Krabs dying in the conventional way when he dies it is necessary for the Flying Dutchman to come get him when he dies.
But thanks to Spongebob, the Dutchman doesn't even want to look for Mr Krabs' soul anymore.

Ok I understand now, clearly there is more going on if the professional doctors themselves have the diagnostics that Eugene should be dead, THEN THAT is where the Dutchman comes in to retrieve his soul, hell many others have consistently stated that he's dead from the news so what gives?
Though here is the most interesting thing as it's not only the 52 cents gag, SpongeBob in one occasion sold his soul to many other ghosts/demons, so technically aside Soul Manipulation resistance, shouldn't SB have Type 5 Immortality as well???

 

[Pugao_03]

Ok I understand now, clearly there is more going on if the professional doctors themselves have the diagnostics that Eugene should be dead, THEN THAT is where the Dutchman comes in to retrieve his soul, hell many others have consistently stated that he's dead from the news so what gives?
Though here is the most interesting thing as it's not only the 52 cents gag, SpongeBob in one occasion sold his soul to many other ghosts/demons, so technically aside Soul Manipulation resistance, shouldn't SB have Type 5 Immortality as well???

I mean, I had seen somewhere that if "death" or the person responsible for guiding the souls of the dead to the next world gives up on taking said person's soul, that would provide him with immortality type 5.
Flying Dutchman in this episode is "the one responsible for taking the souls of bad people to the other world" which in the case of Mr Krabs would be Davy Jones' closet.
In these cases, the Dutchman appears in person to take people away, but in the case of Mr Krabs he gave up and he couldn't stand to spend 45 seconds with the Soul of SpongeBob, So much so that he said later that his soul wasn't even worth it and that it was Mr Krabs' problem.

 

[Psychomaster35]

I’m pretty sure that we’ve had soulless characters before yet that isn’t enough to qualify for Type 5 Immortality.

From what I’ve been convinced in regards to the string, seems like I agree with Mid-Godly, especially since Spongebob is implied to have sold his soul at one point. Though, if everyone was capable of coming back in the next episode, doesn’t that mean they all (minus Patrick since he was unaffected by the string) get Mid-Godly regenration?

 

[Pugao_03]

I’m pretty sure that we’ve had soulless characters before yet that isn’t enough to qualify for Type 5 Immortality.

From what I’ve been convinced in regards to the string, seems like I agree with Mid-Godly, especially since Spongebob is implied to have sold his soul at one point. Though, if everyone was capable of coming back in the next episode, doesn’t that mean they all (minus Patrick since he was unaffected by the string) get Mid-Godly regenration?

the reason for type 5 immortality does not come from him "not having a soul", but from the "reaper" in the verse not accepting his soul in the next world, it is as if he is banished from death.
Some examples could include the Lobo from the DC comics, who due to wreaking havoc in heaven and hell none of them accept the wolf soul there which makes it remain on the plane in which the story takes place.
Flying Dutchman doesn't want Mr Krabs or SpongeBob's soul to fall into his hands

Well... it's a good question, I think so, but for the other characters apart from Spongebob it would be something over time.

 

[Psychomaster35]

the reason for type 5 immortality does not come from him "not having a soul", but from the "reaper" in the verse not accepting his soul in the next world, it is as if he is banished from death.
Some examples could include the Lobo from the DC comics, who due to wreaking havoc in heaven and hell none of them accept the wolf soul there which makes it remain on the plane in which the story takes place.
Flying Dutchman doesn't want Mr Krabs or SpongeBob's soul to fall into his hands

Sure, I may as well agree with this then.

 

[Pugao_03]

Alright, later I'll update everything and check for spelling mistakes (feel free to point them out) and if you could list the things to be added in an organized way it would help a lot when I gotta organize.

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

Alright, later I'll update everything and check for spelling mistakes (feel free to point them out) and if you could list the things to be added in an organized way it would help a lot when I gotta organize.

So are Type 5 Immortality for Krabs + SpongeBob AND Mid-Godly regen are in agreement then?

 

[Psychomaster35]

Yeah.

When will the CRT for the new tiers and abilities be made now that I have evaluated everything?

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

Alright, later I'll update everything and check for spelling mistakes (feel free to point them out) and if you could list the things to be added in an organized way it would help a lot when I gotta organize.

Yeah.

When will the CRT for the new tiers and abilities be made now that I have evaluated everything?

I'll wait to see what Pug has a say in this first...
OH, let's not forget about the eternal EXP + the fact Frenchy is actually not human, but something else entierly:

Mind you - It's even more impressive that the characters have bypassed/mocked/effected Frenchy since the beginning, who already shows insane feats, yet as I said despite his borderline eldritch nature, many of them have effected Frenchy (Via the examples I have given regarding him).

 

[Psychomaster35]

Eh, mocking/bypassing the French Narrator doesn’t really warrant any ability for them outside of maybe breaking the fourth wall, although we do see that the inside of the French Narrator has an entire starry sky within him, so this could be some form of Abstract Existence.

 

[The_Almighty_Wholesome]

Wow been completely absent for a few weeks and come back to a whole bunch of new abilities and revisions!

Overall agree with everything Psycomaster said and the other revisions mentioned. I think we need to finally make a CRT with this massive overhaul with the new tiering, speed feats, abilities, etc as I can’t think of anything that hasn’t been discussed. it’s just a matter of who wants to make this massive CRT lol……

 

[Pugao_03]

I realized that it makes sense that everyone in the verse has medium-divine regeneration considering that even the souls in the verse can regenerate

 

[Anomalous_N_I_W_D_E]

I realized that it makes sense that everyone in the verse has medium-divine regeneration considering that even the souls in the verse can regenerate

Oh shit you're right. Actually come to think of it: This would also mean SB has Regen Negation at the Mid-Godly level, even resistance to it, given he did literally laugh it off! XD.
Wonder if it scales to Neptune, considering he's the "Strongest" in the SB Verse (Aside the eldritch entities in the SB Verse so it is debatible regarding Neptune), but even then SB is unfazed by the Regeneration Negation from him.