Separate articles for certain Godzilla kaiju incarnations?

[Gerdkinerf]

I've noticed that the Mothra, Giga, Zilla and King Ghidorah pages have all of the incarnations (Showa, Heisei, Millennium, and IDW) all lumped together and, as a result, look very messy and unorganized. However, the different incarnations of Godzilla (With the exception of the Millennium incarnations) and Mechagodzilla all have seperate pages.

Should the different versions of Mothra, Gigan, Zilla, and King Ghidorah each be given their own individual articles or should the pages be left as they already are? Futhermore, if they are left the same, should all of the Mechagodzilla, Zilla and Godzilla pages be composited together for more consistency?

Similarly, I've also noticed that the powers listed for Godzilla (Original), Orga and Jet Jaguar include those from their non-film appearences. Should we list only their powers from their film appearences or include their non-film powers for a composite version page?

 

[ZillaJrKaijuKing]

I'd go for separate pages since the disorganization was what led to different pages for Godzilla in the first place. Non-film things could probably stay as long as it's clear they're non-film feats.

 

[ZillaJrKaijuKing]

Huh. I thought the comment I wrote a couple of days ago was posted successfully. Don't know what happened.

Different pages for each monster's incarnations sounds reasonable, but a lot of character pages already have multiple incarnations listed on the same page. Godzilla's had to be split because, like Superman, there are a lot of different Godzillas and the page was too messy to even be reasonably legible. It may not be necessary to give separate articles for the other monsters. If they're too messy, then yeah.

I think non-canon powers can stay as long as it's made clear they're non-canon.

EDIT: Something is very wrong with the comment secion of this page. My comment was replaced by something completely different from what I typed. Something glitchy's going on here.

EDIT 2: Now my first comment is showing up. What is going on here?

 

[Gerdkinerf]

I'd go for separate pages since the disorganization was what led to different pages for Godzilla in the first place. Non-film things could probably stay as long as it's clear they're non-film feats.

Alright then.

 

[TheMightyRegulator]

ðƒð¥ð╝ð¥ð│ð©ÐéðÁ ð┐ð¥ðÂð░ð╗Ðâð╣ÐüÐéð░, ÐÅ ð¢ðÁ ðÀð¢ð░ÐÄ, ð║ð░ð║ Ðâð╗ðÁÐéðÁÐéÐî ð©ðÀ Ðüð©ÐüÐéðÁð╝Ðï Skavac (Nosdron)? ð» ð┐ÐÇð©ð╗ðÁÐéð░ÐÄ Ðü ðÜð¥ÐÇð¢ðÁð╗ð©ÐâÐüð¥ð╝, Ðâð▒ð©ð▓ð░ÐÄ ð┐ð©ÐÇð░Ðéð¥ð▓, ð¥ð¢ ð▓Ðïð╗ðÁÐéð░ðÁÐé ð©ðÀ ð┐ð©ÐÇð░ÐéÐüð║ð¥ð╣ ÐüÐéð░ð¢Ðåð©ð© ð¢ð©ÐçðÁð│ð¥ ð¢ðÁ ð¥ð▒ð¢ð░ÐÇÐâðÂð©ð▓ ð© Ðâð╗ðÁÐéð░ðÁÐé, ð┐ð¥Ðéð¥ð╝ ð©ð┤ðÁÐé ð¥ð▒ÐëðÁð¢ð©ðÁ Ðü ðÜð░ð┤ð¥ÐÇð¥ð╝, ð║ð¥Ðéð¥ÐÇÐïð╣ ð┤ð░ÐæÐé ðÀð░ð┤ð░ð¢ð©ðÁ ð┐ÐÇð©ð▒ÐïÐéÐî ð▓ ð║ð░ð║ÐâÐÄ-Ðéð¥ Ðüð©ÐüÐéðÁð╝Ðâ, ð░ ð║ð░ð║ ð¥Ðé ÐéÐâð┤ð░ ð▓Ðïð▒ÐÇð░ÐéÐîÐüÐÅ ð▒ðÁðÀ ÐÇðÁÐéÐÇð░ð¢Ðüð╗ÐÅÐéð¥ÐÇð░ ÐÅ ð¢ðÁ ð┐ð¥ð¢ð©ð╝ð░ÐÄ...

What...what is the meaning of this?

 

[Gerdkinerf]

ðƒð¥ð╝ð¥ð│ð©ÐéðÁ ð┐ð¥ðÂð░ð╗Ðâð╣ÐüÐéð░, ÐÅ ð¢ðÁ ðÀð¢ð░ÐÄ, ð║ð░ð║ Ðâð╗ðÁÐéðÁÐéÐî ð©ðÀ Ðüð©ÐüÐéðÁð╝Ðï Skavac (Nosdron)? ð» ð┐ÐÇð©ð╗ðÁÐéð░ÐÄ Ðü ðÜð¥ÐÇð¢ðÁð╗ð©ÐâÐüð¥ð╝, Ðâð▒ð©ð▓ð░ÐÄ ð┐ð©ÐÇð░Ðéð¥ð▓, ð¥ð¢ ð▓Ðïð╗ðÁÐéð░ðÁÐé ð©ðÀ ð┐ð©ÐÇð░ÐéÐüð║ð¥ð╣ ÐüÐéð░ð¢Ðåð©ð© ð¢ð©ÐçðÁð│ð¥ ð¢ðÁ ð¥ð▒ð¢ð░ÐÇÐâðÂð©ð▓ ð© Ðâð╗ðÁÐéð░ðÁÐé, ð┐ð¥Ðéð¥ð╝ ð©ð┤ðÁÐé ð¥ð▒ÐëðÁð¢ð©ðÁ Ðü ðÜð░ð┤ð¥ÐÇð¥ð╝, ð║ð¥Ðéð¥ÐÇÐïð╣ ð┤ð░ÐæÐé ðÀð░ð┤ð░ð¢ð©ðÁ ð┐ÐÇð©ð▒ÐïÐéÐî ð▓ ð║ð░ð║ÐâÐÄ-Ðéð¥ Ðüð©ÐüÐéðÁð╝Ðâ, ð░ ð║ð░ð║ ð¥Ðé ÐéÐâð┤ð░ ð▓Ðïð▒ÐÇð░ÐéÐîÐüÐÅ ð▒ðÁðÀ ÐÇðÁÐéÐÇð░ð¢Ðüð╗ÐÅÐéð¥ÐÇð░ ÐÅ ð¢ðÁ ð┐ð¥ð¢ð©ð╝ð░ÐÄ...

What...what is the meaning of this?

I don't get it either.

 

[ZillaJrKaijuKing]

Something's wrong with this comment section. That is not what I typed. I don't even know what language that is. It looked normal when I posted it. My first comment also briefly disappeared, hence the second comment.

I'm not 100% on the separate pages anymore, either. A lot of character articles have multiple incarnations listed on the same page. Godzilla was like Superman in that there were too many and it was too messy. I'd say go for it if the messiness is too problematic.

 

[Antvasima]

I don't really have an opinion regarding the issue, but too many Godzilla pages can look even more cluttered for the wiki as a whole.

 

[HYPERGODZILLA]

I've noticed that the Mothra, Giga, Zilla and King Ghidorah pages have all of the incarnations (Showa, Heisei, Millennium, and IDW) all lumped together and, as a result, look very messy and unorganized. However, the different incarnations of Godzilla (With the exception of the Millennium incarnations) and Mechagodzilla all have seperate pages.
Should the different versions of Mothra, Gigan, Zilla, and King Ghidorah each be given their own individual articles or should the pages be left as they already are? Futhermore, if they are left the same, should all of the Mechagodzilla, Zilla and Godzilla pages be composited together for more consistency?

Yeah but for diferent Kaijus from Godzilla would be a even greater disorder for the wiki. But for example about the millennium Godzillas if looks like a a big disorder in only a page in that case it would be great to have those incarnations separate in diferents profiles.

 

[ConsumingFire]

The lumped together profiles look sloppy especially since the different incarnations' powers are lumped together on those same pages which makes the disorganization even worse. We should really just separate the incarnations and organize them on the verse page by what timeline (Showa, Heisei, Millennium) that they appear in.

 

[Gallavant]

The lumped together profiles look sloppy especially since the different incarnations' powers are lumped together on those same pages which makes the disorganization even worse. We should really just separate the incarnations and organize them on the verse page by what timeline (Showa, Heisei, Millennium) that they appear in.

Especially since when some of those incarnations have some different powerups/forms themselves

 

[Antvasima]

Okay then. Feel free to separate them as you deem appropriate Gallavant.

 

[HYPERGODZILLA]

Especially since when some of those incarnations have some different powerups/forms themselves

Agree. It is a complete mess! to separate them is the best idea.