• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Re Zero CRT - Ram Revisions & Witchy Additions

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zabazab

Username Only
2,821
3,415
This ended up being a tiny bit bigger than I expected, but it is what it is.

Ram

Shackles

Ok since 1 Shackle = 10% of Ram's power is laughably impossible and we have seen that they are exponential, I've got some actually usable statements for her Shackles.

Ram with 1 Shackle released is comparable to but weaker than Rem, and she could briefly clash with Wilhelm & Ricardo.

Q: Rem vs Ram, with both of them in peak condition, which one is stronger?

A: Rem. If you meant ‘with intact horns’, then Ram.

Normally, when working as a servant, she did everything with those shackles on.

At times there were situations of emergency, and she had no choice but to utilize magic and do away with the situation. On those instances she unfastened one shackle and allowed herself a bare minimum utilization of magic. - Arc 6 Chapter 82 "Shackle-Accompanying Battle"

As if to blow that admiration aside, the figure thrust a cane forward with an explosion of magic.

The target was the ground under Wilhelm’s feet, gouging the surface out in a circle, slowing the Sword Devil down. When Wilhelm then leaped toward his foe, slashing upward, something caught him by the chest.

“Guh…!” Wilhelm’s well-honed abdomen creaked as his body was sent flying by force unthinkable for the tiny figure’s size.
The cane’s tip was pointed at the Sword Devil as the air twisted before it.

The resulting cascade of air was about to slice deep into the Sword Devil—but a slice of steel rent it first, causing its mana to explode. - Volume 8

Ram with 2 Shackles released is more than twice as strong as Beastified Garfiel.

Q: When Ram-chi was beating up on beastform Garf, was her condition then like her power in her prime?

A: About enough that she could take him with half her strength.

And, in circumstances which could be sorted despite that, she unfastened two shackles, and though only in short decisive battles, Ram demonstrated about twenty-percent of her original strength.

That was around what she had done when she had faced and fought Garfiel in the Sanctuary, approximately a year-and-a-half prior.


Ram had confidence, that that was the maximum strength she could bring out as “hornless”, and her body would not be able to endure any further and become disabled.

Those shackles, a double-edged sword, right now, had already been unfastened that much by Ram. - Arc 6 Chapter 82 "Shackle-Accompanying Battle"

There is no actual information on how much stronger Ram is with 3 Shackles released, we just know she went from being at a disadvantage against Ley to immediately stomping him and becoming able to one-shot with just a Fula.

It is known to be greater than a >>2x boost due to coming after 2nd Shackle which is greater than a 2x boost.

Ram with 5 Shackles released is equal to half of her adult prime. An adult full-power Ram is stronger than Regulus, Sekhmet, and BotE Puck.

Whilst shedding immense blood, Batenkaitos artlessly swooped down upon her.

In greater precision, he was surely making free use of miraculous superhuman techniques. Coalescing the might of multifarious transcendental beings, from the outset, he was certainly formulating techniques impossible of being reconstructed by anyone.

That excelling blitz, specializing in all possible orientations, was shut down by Ram through outstripping violence.

She guillotined those monumental techniques of hundreds, of thousands, using might worth millions. This was what the battle had now come to be.

She sought not to even come in contact with Batenkaitos. Her condition felt well.
She had grown accustomed to it in Subaru’s absence. She had unfastened approximately two more shackles.

Probably, making up for fifty-percent of her prime―― no, since Ram had been very young in those days, aspects of her that had matured were far mightier now compared to Ram back then.


And, to not wallow in that might, was Ram’s forte. - "Conversing of What Yesterday Held"

Q: If you were to line up the characters which have appeared in the work so far in order of fighting strength, how would it look?

A: Reinhard, Ram with her horn, Regulus, Sekhmet, Serious Puck. Even though these guys are like dangos under Reinhard, each one is capable of dropping the White Whale on their own. (2nd of June 2014, Arc 4)

Tier

8-B
, higher with 2 Shackles removed, at least 8-A with 3 Shackles removed, at least 7-B with 5 Shackles removed

Attack Potency

City Block level
(Comparable to Rem), higher with 2 Shackles removed (She is more than twice as strong as transformed Garfiel), at least Multi-City Block level with 3 Shackles removed (Far more than twice as strong as before, can kill Rai Batenkaitos in a single blow), at least City level with 5 Shackles removed (Possesses half the strength of her adult prime, which is superior to Sekhmet and Puck)

Speed

Supersonic
(Comparable to Rem), Supersonic+ with 2 Shackles removed (Should be more than twice as fast as before), at least Hypersonic with 3 Shackles removed (Should be far more than twice as fast as before, totally outpaced Rai Batenkaitos), at least Relativistic+, likely FTL with 5 Shackles removed (Half as fast as her adult prime, which is superior to the likes of Sekhmet and Regulus)

Lifting Strength

Class 5
(Comparable to Rem), Class 25 with 2 Shackles removed (At least twice as strong as transformed Garfiel), higher with 3 Shackles removed (Far more than twice as strong as before), Class G with 5 Shackles removed (Possesses half the strength of her adult prime, which is superior to the likes of Sekhmet)

Striking Strength

City Block level
, higher with 2 Shackles removed, at least Multi-City Block level with 3 Shackles removed, at least City level with 5 Shackles removed

Durability

City Block level
(Comparable to Rem), higher with 2 Shackles removed (More than twice as strong as transformed Garfiel), at least Multi-City Block level with 3 Shackles removed (Far more than twice as strong as before), at least City level with 5 Shackles removed (Possesses half of the strength of her adult prime, which is superior to Sekhmet and Puck)

Intelligence

Change from Gifted to Genius

Ram is an Oni Clan prodigy, hailed as the Second Coming of the Oni God despite being a child possessing only a single horn. She is quick-witted in social settings, and a natural expert in combat, that has been referred to as a genius in the text. She is an incredibly quick learner, mastering techniques she has seen only once before, and even managed to not only copy an invisible technique with wind magic, but also improved it by a massive degree. She also learned to mimic an Authority just by experiencing it's effects.

Even a genius like Ram could only understand the surface when it came to stuff like knowledge on childbirth. However, Limrear, as the maid of the pregnant Grace, should’ve been trained in case of emergencies. Roswaal was thorough in that area. -Oni Sisters of the Hidden Village

By way of Synesthesia, Ram would share the burden levied upon her own flesh body to her sleeping younger sister.

It was in consequence of having experienced Subaru’s Authority by herself once. Having witnessed something once, Ram could materialize it identically, roughly.

What Subaru had done was an identical contrivance―― it possibly coercively connected others’ Od with his own Od, inducing a fairly arbitrary Synesthesia. Subaru’s side could possibly consign his burden over if he felt inclined to do so as well, but since Subaru was a fool, he would not do so.

Contrarily, by taking it upon himself, he endeavored to abate the burden of his allies. -Arc 6 Chapter 86 "Conversing of What Yesterday Held"

Wordlessly stretching his finger to that point, Batenkaitos observed his finger be cut.

In the empty space, was an invisible blade.

Ley: “Huh.”

That was, the same technique Batenkaitos had displayed to Ram at the spiral staircase.

The art of installing blades of invisibility in space was a legendary shinobi technique
, but it did not matter whose Memories those had been in, since he had already thrown them away.

The issue was the presence of a blade here, which Batenkaitos did not remember placing behind.

Ley: “It can’t be…”

Avoiding the blade that had slightly cut his finger, Batenkaitos attempted to advance his feet further towards the interior―― his tiptoes were blown off, and he inclined backwards whilst shrieking with an “Ahii”.

And, with the inclining back of his head also being shaved off slightly, he rigidified his face and stood still.

――He was enclosed, by invisible blades.

Ley: “…Haha, seriously?”

He had shown it to her, merely once.

Once, in the midst of battle; being an invisible technique as well, so she must not have seen it either.

Moreover, she had not ever practically even stepped foot in this place. Yet regardless, she had seized his escape route, and had stationed invisible blades in advance.
-Arc 6 Chapter 86 "Conversing of What Yesterday Held"

Optional Equipment

Add Comatose Rem for her to use Synesthesia through and achieve her 3rd Shackle and beyond.


Flow Method Users

Resistance to Extreme Temperatures


Characters who use the Flow Method are unaffected by the cold of Emilia's ice weapons, as stated by Cecilus. Untalented users of the Flow Method (Gaston) can tank the heat of an explosion with minimal damage, but still feel pain from the heating, while a more skilled user (Rai) shows no negative effects from the heat. Fights on Garfiel's level generate enough heat that blood evaporates. Fighting Spirit itself generates heat.

The ice sword had been created by Emilia. Therefore, Emilia would not feel the cold, but it might be too cold for Cecilus, who had not created them.

Come to think of it, Priscilla never said it was cold either, but…”

“Rest assured. I can make up for this inconvenience with the Flow Method, so both myself and the people in the Battalion are fine. Well, I tend to get out of my flow when the Boss and the others are involved, but it’s a fact that I’m especially special for handling it naturally!” - Arc 7 Chapter 104 "Bastions in Chaos (Part One)"

Gaston, standing firm, was unable to escape from Batenkaitos and was caught up in the magic stone’s range. As the magic stone’s glowing intensified, and the next instant, it gave rise to an explosion powerful enough to tear off the stone pavement.

Red and white light illuminated, and Felt rolled away from the explosion to the other side. Otto somehow grabbed her, and then glanced at the explosion’s span.

These magic stones were what Otto constantly carried “just in case”. Ever since the fight with Garfiel in Sanctuary, he had determined it would be better do so for his own safety.

It might be a means painful on his wallet, but its strength was nothing to laugh at.

Otto: “Is your companion alright!?”

Felt: “Hah, don’t underestimate my giant. He’s my armor. He won’t be hurt by a meager and soft attack.
But…”

Just when she said that much, a giant figure emerged out of the smoke. It was Gaston. With his body having taken a sooty color, he smacked his body making a desperate face.

Gaston: “Gahhhhh~! Hot! Hot! Hot hot! I’ll die!”

Otto: “Even if you may be able to take explosions, I guess you can’t stop your body from warming or cooling.”

Felt sighed, seeing the form of her attendant agonizing in high fever.
Though he had bathed in the might of the Fire Magic Stone from close proximity, Gaston’s life did not appear to be in a serious condition.

Confirming that much, Otto turned his eyes back towards to the smoke. The black fumes were rising at a reasonably good scale, so there was no way Batenkaitos, who was at its heart, had managed to defend himself. On the other side of the black smoke, was Dynas, knelt down, but he seemed to be safe.

And,

Ley: “Bennett. Calcifs. August.”

Otto: “――!?”

A whisper was heard, and all eyes turned away from the hypocenter.
There were visible the forms of three collapsed white clothes, and Batenkaitos in perfectly good health.

The youth, once again, raised his left hand’s palm saying “Lick”, and inched it closer to his mouth and licked it.
-Arc 5 Chapter 68 "Name-Eating Gourmet"

“Wow, not bad.”

Just as he let out that murmured awe, the crystal exploded. Red and yellow light swelled as the small Archbishop was swallowed up in a fiery explosion.

“—Ngh!” The blast launched Otto backward. It was Gaston who had withstood the explosion with his back and caught Otto’s tumbling body.

The improvised bomb was one of the trump cards that Otto had prepared, sewn into his clothes in preparation for if something happened. Ever since the fight with Garfiel a year ago in the Sanctuary, he had made sure to always have some sort of option like that prepared at all times. It would be best if they were never needed, but this was just the sort of occasion for it.

“That should have caught him off guard, but…” It was small, but it was an explosion of the purest crystal he had. Even if Batenkaitos survived, it should have been powerful enough to at least blow off an arm or leg. It would be best if it took his life, but—

“Ahhh, that’s so cruel. Our nice clothes are all a mess now.” Stepping out of the center of the blast zone, waving away the charred black smoke, the barefoot desecrater appeared. It was difficult to believe he was still fine after enduring that explosion at such close range.

Looking more closely, there were several indications of the effects of the explosion on Batenkaitos as he emerged from the smoke. However, it was limited to the ratty cloak he had been wearing as his body was more or less untouched. - Volume 20 Chapter 1

Garfiel: “It may be exaggeratin’ to say I’m full of life… but I’ll do just that.”

Even now, he was absorbing power through the soles of his feet planted on the earth, and through invoking healing magic with all his might, Garfiel’s body was healing at a furious pace, both inside and out.

Normally, this would be a load on the body that could potentially reduce his life span, but the events in the Watergate City had forced Garfiel to break out of his shell, both physically and mentally.

Though it had not been visible, Garfiel had tore through a shell that had certainly been present, and stood tall.

With the steam rising from his many bloody wounds, as if his body were truly blazing hot, Garfiel settled his resolve to face the Dragon in the distance. -Arc 7 Chapter 95 "Enemies on All Bastions"

He had merely touched him. He had neither struck nor slashed him. Was he just playing around? Or was he insulting him? ――No, Olbart never did things without meaning. There was always a meaning, a meaning, a meaning――

???: “――Huuh!?”

The moment his thoughts turned red-hot, an even greater heat arose on his right shoulder, where he had been touched.

Taking a glance, Olbart’s handprint stood out, having been stamped in red upon his shoulder. From the handprint blood seeped and smoke was emitted, as it attempted to burn skin, flesh, and bone.

Immediately after determining it to be poison, there was no hesitation.
Garfiel opened his mouth wide to bite off the shoulder on which the red handprint had been imprinted, tearing off the poison eating away at him. The taste of his own poisoned flesh and blood was terrible, as the bones his fangs grazed brought him unbearable pain.

However, the pain was only momentary. The deep gouge that was the shoulder wound emitted steam originating from blood, as the wound was restored by a tremendous surge of flesh―― -Arc 7 Chapter 100 "A Myriad of Changes at the Bastions"

Madelyn: “What a little girl like you thinks, is completely irrelevant to this dragon—— It’s friggin’ frustrating that that crimson woman isn’t here, but still, it’s friggin’ convenient.”

With these words, Madelyn’s body slowly began releasing steam.

In the cold air, dyed white by her exhaled breath, her body continued to heat up as it radiated her visibly rising fighting spirit.

As this visible fighting spirit began to pour over, Emilia instantly produced a pair of swords in her hands. -Arc 7 Chapter 92 "Rekindling Old Ties"


Daphne

Pain Manipulation & Madness Manipulation (Type 2? maybe 3?)


Daphne is able to send someone into a maddening frenzy of painful starvation just by looking them in the eyes with her left eye and her right eye is far more horrifying.

I'm actually unsure about the type of MM this is. There's no mention of biology being affected, nor a mention of the mind being directly altered, and I don't know if it'd fit as cognition. It just makes you really hungry when you make eye contact, to the degree of going insane. I'll guess Type 2 or 3 but if you disagree please say so, I'm leaning towards 2.

It's notable that this maddening starvation can be cured by Minerva's Authority of Wrath.

As if being penetrated by her golden pupil, Subaru remained frozen still. And then, she blinked a few times,

Daphne: “That… should be enough…"

Saying this, with the same beleaguered movements, she made her way back to her coffin. And, just as she looked like she was about to collapse, the mobile coffin gently caught her inside.

Stirring her body around, Daphne found the most comfortable position. All the while, immobilized on the spot, Subaru quietly chewed something in his mouth as he watched her, Daphne yawned and placed the blindfold back over her eyes. The fabric in the interior of the coffin slowly peeled open and wrapped her tiny body snugly inside, binding her in its grasp.

Like it wasn’t even there, her restraints operated entirely on her will.

Subaru: “What just happened… Also, why… do you…”

Daphne: “You still haven’t noticed it yet…?”

Just as Subaru was about to ask her why she would restrain herself, Daphne interrupted his question, while giving her body a wriggle inside the coffin as if to make sure the restraints were properly fastened.

The moment her words entered his ears, Subaru furrowed his brows as though he noticed something.

Subaru: “Ah, ugh…?”

Pain. It was pain.

Rising in Subaru’s waist was a pain that gave the illusion that a hole had been opened there, forcing his body to bend.

His guts wrenched as sensations of thirst and hunger protested with overwhelming starvation. Groaning, writhing in the unbearable pain, Subaru’s knees collapsed onto the grass.

Saliva drooled from the edge of his lips as he desperately tried to endure the pain. Hunger, hunger, hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger hunger.

Subaru: “Aa, aaa, AAAAAaaahh… hur…ts…”

The intense hunger sent his consciousness scattering and his thoughts into disarray as he lost all sense of reality.

Panting, writhing, he rolled back and forth on the ground. His movements only exacerbating the hunger, Subaru wriggled, convulsing like a caterpillar on the bed of grass.

Starvation, maddening starvation. Famishing. Life-threatening. A gaping hole, there’s a gaping hole in his stomach. Dying, he’s going to die, he’s going to die if he doesn’t eat. He’s going to die. He’s going to die.

Daphne: “You still haven’t noticed it yet…?"

Looking down on the writhing, suffocating Subaru―― although her eyes did not actually see him, Daphne kept a grasp of Subaru’s condition through sound and smell.

He couldn’t understand the meaning of her words. Notice what, notice what when the hunger was driving him insane? Although he understood that she was behind this, there was no room for resentment in the face of this hunger. He wouldn’t be able to bear it if he didn’t fill this hunger. Right now, the only cog holding together his sanity was the thing he had been chewing on since――

Subaru: “――――”

What, was Subaru, eating, right now?

Daphne: “You noticed iit? That’s gluttony, you know.”

Hearing Daphne’s words, Subaru noticed it―― the pinky and ring fingers on his right hand were missing.

Where did the missing fingers go? There was no need to look. He was chewing on the fragments of his pinky finger right this moment.

Profuse blood seeped from the torn-off stumps, dyeing the green grass field with red.

Watching the droplets fall, Subaru’s mind went blank. With the passing of the seconds, something slowly came to fill that blankness. An emotion, of――

――Ahh, spilling blood is such a waste.

Simply a desire to quench his thirsting throat, and the disappointment of his unsated hunger. - Arc 4 Chapter 47 "Partners with Bad Affinity"

Subaru: “I don’t wanna think of it as that kind of bloodthirsty place…! Anyway what just happened!? It was only for a short while, but… I actually went insane.”

Daphne: “That was maddening hunger… Extreme hunger can turn people into something worse than beasts. If you looked into my right eye too, it would’ve been even more interesting, you know?

Subaru: “…You’re kidding.”

A magical eye, or something of the sort.

Although Ram’s clairvoyance would also count as an eye-power, her ability didn’t really have much offensive potential, so Daphne’s was definitely way scarier.

Perhaps it could be called the Eye of Hunger or the Eye of Starvation. The moment Subaru looked into her left eye, he ate his own fingers for a hunger he wasn’t even aware of.

He was so famished that he forgot the existence of pain, and everything in sight was food to sate his insatiable hunger
. - Arc 4 Chapter 48 "Price for the Tea Party"

Enhanced Senses

She can grasp the condition of people with her blindfold on through smell & sound, and can tell someone is crying by the smell of salt.

Looking down on the writhing, suffocating Subaru―― although her eyes did not actually see him, Daphne kept a grasp of Subaru’s condition through sound and smell.- Arc 4 Chapter 47 "Pair with Bad Affinity"

Daphne: “…Aaaaaaaah, really? Sorry… Anyway… Sniiiff~ sniiiff~, I smell something salty… is someone crying? Is it Neru-Neru?” -Arc 4 Chapter 78 "These Sounds to Make You Shed Tears"

Resistance to Disease Manipulation, Petrification, and Poison Manipulation

Daphne can eat the Black Serpent, despite it being poisonous, casting 100 diseases at a touch, and even causing petrification.

Q: Do the snake’s diseases combine in any number of ways?

A: It can cause petrification and rotting away, and it leaves behind viruses in the land as it moves. - Three Great Witchbeasts Q&A

Q: So perhaps Daphne could eat the whale, rabbit, and snake?

A: She could eat them, yeah? - Three Great Witchbeasts Q&A

Q: So the fact that she could eat the snake means that Daphne wouldn’t become sick?

A: Look at her. She’s sick no matter how you look at it. - Three Great Witchbeasts Q&A

Q: It’s been said that mabeasts will follow the creature that breaks their horns, but would the White Whale and Great Rabbit (did they have horns?) follow the creature that breaks their horns?

A: The White Whale, Great Rabbit, and Black Snake, too, have already had their horns and hearts broken by Daphne. - Three Great Witchbeasts Q&A


Minerva

I'd rather avoid resorting to Unknown for a stat unless completely necessary, so I suggest rating Minerva as City level based on her power to rupture a mountain, snd generally being considered a physical powerhouse, scaling her to the high tiers.

Her Attack Potency should be something along the lines of City level environmental destruction (Minerva's Authority transforms any action she causes into healing, no matter what she does to someone- directly or indirectly- it will heal them, effectively giving her zero actual attack potency)

Her Speed should be changed from Unknown to at least Supersonic, as Minerva is stated to pierce the sound barrier.

Her Lifting Strength should be changed from Unknown to at least Class 5, as Minerva is considered to possess the power to "overwhelm all others" and is portrayed as possessing superhuman strength, and thus should be at least comparable to if not stronger than superhumans such as Emilia or Garfiel

Her Durability should match her AP due to Newton's 3rd Law.

Her Striking Strength should match her AP as she is a physical "fighter".

Minerva: “Do you realize what it feels like to be ignored, when it’s been so long――!?”

The ground exploded, instantly annihilating the distance between them.

Minerva charged forward leaving a cloud of dust in her wake as she twisted her body to punch with all her might. Piercing the air, breaking through the sound barrier with a thunderous clap, the strike continued towards the Witch’s head, drilling towards the shadow obscuring her visage, and―― - Arc 4 Chapter 76 "≠Satella"

And when she realized, she began wishing for something else. Raw power.

To obtain power that would let her throw all away, that would let her overwhelm all others, she struggled to her limits and ran, heading towards the power she so desired.

To stop exactly that, she solely desired for power. Training herself, she endured all pains to finally obtain an iron-clad will.

Eventually, she found the end of her path. The pinnacle of strength where none else could reach.

Standing on the battlefield, she shouted to stop the fight.

To overwhelm all other powers with her own, to crush all grief, shatter all malice and to stop the endless stream of tears before her, she struggled to her utmost.

Punching those who brandished their swords, kicking those who flung magic, breaking those who bared their fangs, she pulverized all and any who came to seek battle.

But, the more the woman fought, the stronger became the swordsmen, the mages and the bearer of fangs, ever increasing their numbers.

As if she had entered a never-ending spiral of violence.

No one knew how to save themselves other than to answer violence with violence. That was why, no one knew of a way to save themselves aside from victory in battle.

Woman: “Why――!!”

In the end, the woman herself, despite knowing this, also answered with violence. Lowering her fist that dripped crimson, she turned her blood-smeared face to the sky, and wailed.

People called that emotion Fury―― no, they called it Wrath.

Towards this world that forced others to tears, towards those who refused to stop fighting, towards the absurd unfairness that was the end of life.

――Let them, have a taste of my iron fists.

At some point, she stood up, wiped the dirt off her knees, and took off running.

Diving into the fray of the still-ongoing battle, she punched everyone’s faces whilst shouting.

Stop fighting. Look at the sky. Feel the breeze. Smell the flowers. Live, with your families and loved ones.

For the first time, the woman’s voice swept unrest throughout the battlefield.

Fists that could break apart the very earth, kicks that could cause the heavens to roar, all only to let others live. - Arc 4 Chapter 24 "Wicked Examiner"

The ground caved in beneath her single step as Minerva’s fist pierced through the wind, driving towards Typhon’s face.

The shrieking fist advanced with enough force to rupture a mountain, but the moment it connects with a living being, the destruction would transform into healing.

For comparison, even Rem is considered to be "not that strong"

Q: Please tell me one character Frederica is stronger than, and one character she is weaker than.

A: She's about the same as Rem. In other words, not that strong.

Causality Manipulation

Minerva's healing functions by twisting cause & effect.

Minerva’s healing attacks could bring lifeforms back from the brink of death―― But to think that this Authority was all-powerful would be a mistake.

The healing power triggered by her fists was the result of a mechanism which forcibly twisted cause and effect, expending incredible amounts of Mana to activate. The Mana required far exceeded the capacity of humans, and, even for a Witch, Minerva could not possibly manage it alone.

In that case, where did the Mana for her strikes come from? ――The answer is simple. It was stolen from the very Nexus of the world. - Arc 4 Intermission II "The Guest of Honor Has Left"


Typhon

Change Speed from Below Average Human level to Supersonic

Typhon intercepted Minerva in the Castle of Dreams

Minerva: “That, idiot――!”

The instant she noticed Subaru’s attempted suicide, Minerva rolled up her sleeves and jolted forward, hurrying to punch Subaru to heal him. But, cutting in front of her was Typhon, who had been standing at Subaru’s side.

The small Witch stretched out her little body, blocking Minerva’s path.

Typhon: “Baru made his own choice! Nerva, no interrupting!”

Minerva: “Self-harm or suicide or injury or murder, I won’t allow any of it under my watch! I don’t care what kind of anguish is going on inside! I can’t do a thing about wounds that I can’t see! That’s why! There’s no way I could ever overlook a wound that I can see!”

The ground caved in beneath her single step as Minerva’s fist pierced through the wind, driving towards Typhon’s face.

The shrieking fist advanced with enough force to rupture a mountain
, but the moment it connects with a living being, the destruction would transform into healing. Although, the shockwave of the impact would still be transferred to the recipient of the strike.

Pain Manipulation

Typhon's Authority of Pride will cause pain when shattering a victim if the victim is a bad person, but will shatter them painlessly if they are a good person.

Typhon: “――Onlythroughpainandsufferingcantheguiltybecleansedofsin.”

Subaru: “Hah?”

Suddenly, the little girl quickly muttered something in a whisper.

Unable to understand, Subaru’s raised up one of his brows, and felt a light impact. As if his arm had been lightly tugged, there was then a strangely liberating sensation, as if being released from a heavy burden.

Wondering what had happened, Subaru turned his head to look all around him. Everything was just like it was before, and nothing changed in the world. The space that permitted Subaru and the little girl to sit facing each other was still without wind or sound or sensation of any kind.

Sitting in the chair in front of him, was still only the little girl swinging her legs.

Only, in her hand, she was holding a man’s severed arm―― Subaru: “――!?”

Typhon: “Doesn’t hurt soo, you’re not a bad maaan, I’m so relieveeed.

Noticing the abnormal turn of events, Subaru looked at his own right arm ― at the right side of his body where is arm should be, he saw the reality of the exposed cross-section of his shoulder where his arm had been twisted off.

Pain, blood, none of it was there, before he noticed the deed. The bone and arteries wrapped in pink meat, all exposed in the cross section, reminded him of the edible meat lined up in a butcher’s shop.

That is, aside from the unacceptable surreal reality that it was happening to his own right shoulder.

Subaru: “Oo, aaaaaaaaah!!!! A-arm… My arm aaaah!?”

Typhon: “It doesn’t hurt riiight, don’t yell so loooud. If you flail around too much, we won’t be able to put it baaack.”


Carmilla

Death Manipulation


Carmilla's Faceless Bride forces others to become entranced by her, causing them to forget to breathe and eventually stops the beating of their heart. There were very few rumours around Carmilla due to nearly everyone she met dying.

That instant, Subaru heard a voice whispering into his ear, pulling him back to his senses.

The very same moment, the pain of being deprived of oxygen up to the point of asphyxiation struck him, along with the dry soreness of his continually wide-open eyes.

“Aah―― A, aah?”

“These were drastic measures, but I’m glad to see you back―― When facing Carmilla, Lust’s Faceless Bride, people tend to forget to breathe. Ultimately, even their hearts stop beating.”

“Egh, haaa, guh, tch… Haaaaa, haaaaaaaaa.”

Spitting out the choking saliva, having fallen to his hands and knees, Subaru’s consciousness was strobing. - Arc 4 Chapter 73 "Where Weakness Lies"

Q: Carmilla’s deadly sin is lust; did she not get angry about damage to her reputation because of that? Together with the ability to charm those who look at her, it seems like she’d be called a demon of desire.

A: People who see her generally die, so there’s not much chance for rumors to spread, wouldn’t you say? - Old Witches Q&A

Q: When trying to capture the six witches besides Satella, which one would be the most difficult to capture? Please let us know, both in terms of abilities, and personality.

A: If, by abilities, you mean combat, you’re likely to die just from approaching both Typhon and Carmilla, so in terms of abilities, their difficulty would be high. In terms of personality, I think the hateful Carmilla that everyone adores would be the most difficult woman to capture. You’d fall for her right away. - Archbishops & Witches Q&A


All Witches of Sin

Madness Manipulation (Type 3)


A Witch's Miasma is known to cause fear in others even when being suppressed by the Witch- and when it is intentionally exuded by the Witch it will cause such terror that anyone around them who cannot resist the Miasma will immediately go mad and kill themself.

“I’m glad. My proposal is simple. 30 seconds is all I need. I’ll go with you without fighting back if you are able to stand in front of me for 30 seconds without anything happening to you. Since it seems interesting too.”

“Ha. What’s up with that? Do you think something like that will be enough to scare us…?”

“—Well then, the 30 second countdown begins now.”

The moment she perceived that they had accepted her terms, Echidna stroked her long-white hair, narrowed her dark eyes, and glared at the men.

“───”

All of the men looked like they had no idea what had just happened. In their eyes, it must have looked like the child in front of them who looked to be around 10 years old had suddenly turned into a beautiful girl with white hair. However, before the men could get an answer to their question, they started succumbing to the abnormality that assaulted them one after another.

“Kah…ku.”

The man holding the machete fell to his knees. His eyes darted around all over the place, not focusing on any one thing, and then began foaming at the mouth. A similar phenomenon occurred not only to him, but to all the men surrounding her as well. The eighteen men in Echidna’s line of sight were unable to resist her Witch’s Miasma and thus were in great agony.

The men scratched and tore at their necks, rolled their eyes back into their heads, blew foam out of their mouths, convulsed, choked on their tongues, split their own heads open with their weapons, buried their heads in the snow, and died in agony in various other ways.

“—Exactly thirty seconds.”

Having finished counting the 30 seconds she’d promised them, Echidna looked around. There was nothing but men lying motionless in their own blood and vomit. Unfortunately, there hadn’t been any among them who could endure the thirty seconds of hell and qualify to be the Sage that could reign over the six Witches.

Echidna looked back at the fallen men, then closed her eyes and thought of the boy with black hair, of the boy who remained unaffected while being surrounded by the Witches covered in Miasma—though he probably didn’t even realize how abnormal it was to be able to do that. - The Witches After Tea Party


All Witch Factor Holders (or at least all Witches + Subaru)

Resistance to Madness Manipulation (Type 3)


It's likely that a Witch Factor grants resistence to a Witch's madness-inducing miasma just as it grants resistance to Fear, as seen with the Witches themselves standing in each others presence and Subaru who was bathed in the miasma of all the Witches of Sin with no negative effect. Q&A answers not mentioning fear or death from Miasma when speaking of Bishops and Witches interacting suggests this as well.

Echidna looked back at the fallen men, then closed her eyes and thought of the boy with black hair, of the boy who remained unaffected while being surrounded by the Witches covered in Miasma—though he probably didn’t even realize how abnormal it was to be able to do that. - The Witches After Tea Party


Sirius Romanée-Conti

Change Immortality (Type 1) to Longevity, likely Immortality (Type 1)

The scan that's used for Sirius' immortality states that she, Regulus, and Petelgeuse have long lives. I don't believe this is enough for definite immortality even though Regulus and Petelgeuse are immortal. She has been alive for at least a century it seems, and it is possible a likely rating is due as she is compared to two immortals.

Temperature Manipulation

Sirius specializes in Fire Magic, which doesn't just create fire, but also controls temperature.

Limited(?) Resistance to Analytical Prediction

Sirius' chains follow no standard logic and trace unpredictable paths. This might be considered limited as it is only her chains that are unpredictable and not Sirius herself.

As Liliana watched with eyes peeled, Priscilla began a life-and-death sword dance with Sirius.

Sirius’s irregular chains didn’t follow any standard sort of logic and traced an unpredictable path while Priscilla quite literally danced with her sword as she cut her way through the incoming attacks.

Liliana had seen Priscilla’s amazing sword skills several times already during their circuit of the city. And seeing it on display once more made her realize all over again just how impressive it was as she didn’t yield even a step against Sirius. - Re:Zero Volume 19, Chapter 2, Section 4

That's it for this CRT.
 
Last edited:
Throw in heat resistance as well as cold for flow method. Examples like Ley being immune to the heat of fire crystals and Gaston not are obvious. Fights at Garfield's level generate so much heat passively that it instantly evaporates any blood.

I'll get to the rest at some point later.
 
Madness Manipulation (Type 2)

A Witch's Miasma is known to cause fear in others even when being suppressed by the Witch- and when it is intentionally exuded by the Witch it will cause such terror that anyone around them who cannot resist the Miasma will immediately go mad and kill themself.
Will respond to the other stuff later but this should be Type 3 because it's just a side effect of the miasma.
 
Personally I'm a bit iffy on Garfiel's blood evaporating being evidence of heat resistance, I think it could just be heat generated from his rapid regeneration, and idk if that would require heat resistance.
 
Personally I'm a bit iffy on Garfiel's blood evaporating being evidence of heat resistance, I think it could just be heat generated from his rapid regeneration, and idk if that would require heat resistance.
It's not just from his regen. And even then Garfiel would still have to resist it
Block, deflect, avoid, evade, duck, kick aside, meet head-on―—!

Fists clashed, generating shock waves that caused the sweat dripping from the two to evaporate.

Powerful arm and sturdy arm facing off in collision, the staggering sound making it difficult to believe that this was flesh on flesh. The pair’s bodies were unable to withstand this, flying outward in opposite directions. - Arc 5 chapter 62
This would only get much more severe at higher levels like Cecilus and Wilhelm. In fact Cecilus is dodging and weaving through Arakiya's fire magic all the time. He even was grazed by it once.

Not to mention Sirius's flames melting concrete and Priscilla being in close quarters with them.

In my opinion with these examples, and them being able to resist cold it is fairly obvious they resist heat as well.
 
Ram

Shackles

Ok since 1 Shackle = 10% of Ram's power is laughably impossible and we have seen that they are exponential, I've got some actually usable statements for her Shackles.

Ram with 1 Shackle released is comparable to but weaker than Rem.
How the heck you can be comparable, but weaker than someone? The statement just say Rem is stronger, how Ram is comparable?
Ram with 2 Shackles released is more than twice as strong as Beastified Garfiel.
I actually have a question about this, but after eating a cookie, i forgot what it was.
Gonna put a hold on this.
There is no actual information on how much stronger Ram is with 3 Shackles released, we just know she went from being at a disadvantage against Ley to immediately stomping him and becoming able to one-shot with just a Fula.
Considering the nature of Fula, makes sense.
Tier

8-B
, higher with 2 Shackles removed, at least 8-A with 3 Shackles removed,
Why 8-A exactly? I don't remember just being able to one-shot people make you jump a tier. Also, can you post the scan of her beating up Ley?
Optional Equipment

Add Comatose Rem for her to use Synesthesia through and achieve her 3rd Shackle and beyond.
Wow, you really proposing this, i trought you are joking lmao

Ok, giving Ram a comatose Rem don't make any sense, that happens like once on the novels, until it happens again giving her a Rem as equipament that she rarely uses makes zero sense. Rem is also not a thing, so being labelled as equipament don't make any sense.

Like, Goku here can fuse with other people to became more powerfull, but we don't give him Vegeta as a equipament. Probally have more examples of this on the wiki.

Like, makes more sense to create a new key to Ram of arc 6, and Rem being a equipament there.

Like, you can give her this new tier, but put a note saying she can't access this power without outside help. Indexing this power increase she can't even use normally is kinda... something.

You can team up with people in versus match, so giving Ram a equipament based on that is reduntant. Is not even that good, because the opponent gonna just attack Rem, if they are smart enough.
Daphne

Madness Manipulation (Type 2? 3?)
I trought this was webnovel only, did the youtuber i watched lied to me?
Minerva

I'd rather avoid resorting to Unknown for a stat unless completely necessary, so while I don't think her AP or Durability can be rated anything but unknown yet, I do think that her

A) Speed should be changed from Unknown to at least Supersonic, as Minerva was a very formidable fighter in the past and is capable of breaking the wind (i.e making a shockwave) with her speed, and
Is a shockwave trought? "Because breaking the wind" should't mean supersonic.
Or you could be, if so, i actually i agree with this.
B) Lifting Strength should be changed from Unknown to at least Class 5, as Minerva is considered to possess the power to "overwhelm all others" and is portrayed as possessing superhuman strength, and thus should be at least comparable to if not stronger than superhumans such as Emilia or Garfiel
Why? It said she is super strong, why would that mean she is comparable to Emilia or Garfiel? Does the story stated that she is? Superhuman makes more sense actually.
Carmilla

Death Manipulation


Carmilla's Faceless Bride forces others to become entranced by her, causing them to forget to breathe and eventually stops the beating of their heart. There were very few rumours around Carmilla due to nearly everyone she met dying.
That's not Death manipulation at all, people look at her and they forgot to breath, that is not her causing direct death to the person.
All Witches of Sin

Madness Manipulation (Type 2)


A Witch's Miasma is known to cause fear in others even when being suppressed by the Witch- and when it is intentionally exuded by the Witch it will cause such terror that anyone around them who cannot resist the Miasma will immediately go mad and kill themself.
First of all, this.

Second, why you so sure this translation is more accurate?

Third, even with this new scan, is still said that is a combination of all the 6 witches, nowhere says that can be done individually.
That's it for this CRT.
I think this a fine 6.5/10 CRT, because the rest is mostly fine. I gonna read a fanfic now, see you soon.
 
Last edited:
Shackles

Ok since 1 Shackle = 10% of Ram's power is laughably impossible and we have seen that they are exponential, I've got some actually usable statements for her Shackles.

Ram with 1 Shackle released is comparable to but weaker than Rem.
Yeah, percentages in fiction shouldn't be trusted too much to really work as they are supposed, so I'm all out to rate them differently based on their feats/scaling. That said however, I'm not really seeing from those quotes that 1 shackle Ram is comparable to Rem, after all the first one just mention that with her horns instact before the incident she was stronger and the second just state that with one shackle she can minimally use magic, nothing really says 1 shackle = Rem.
Ram with 2 Shackles released is more than twice as strong as Beastified Garfiel.
Why the novel says that's 20% of her original strength but the author straight up says it's half? At least be consistent author.

Is fine to scale 2 shackled to Garfiel.
Ram with 5 Shackles released is equal to half of her adult prime. An adult full-power Ram is stronger than Regulus, Sekhmet, and BotE Puck.
Technically it says that she is currently far mightier than back then but I guess is fine to scale it to half her prime. Is also fine the full strength scaling.
Intelligence

Change from Gifted to Genius
This is fine, although just asking, she already have power mimicry? Because if not she should get it from being able to copy things after see them.
Optional Equipment

Add Comatose Rem for her to use Synesthesia through and achieve her 3rd Shackle and beyond.
Bruh, adding a comatose person as equipment is so wrong.
Flow Method Users

Resistance to Extreme Temperatures
Fine.
Daphne

Madness Manipulation (Type 2? 3?)
It's indeed something of a weird ability, however based on the scene of Subaru getting affected it seems as if the ability do something akin to the phantom pain brains experience when someone lose a limb, but in this case instead of being simple pain is a phantom hunger that reach a level of pain and hunger that the victim go insane, so based on that I feel that pain manip and madness type 2 would be more fitting for this.
Enhanced Senses

She can grasp the condition of people with her blindfold on through smell & sound, and can tell someone is crying by the smell of salt.
The enhanced smell sense is fine but not really the enhanced hearing, and that's because when someone is violently rolling, chewing and complaining from pain one don't need super hearing to know the direction from where those sounds come.
Resistance to Disease Manipulation, Petrification, and Poison Manipulation

Daphne can eat the Black Serpent, despite it being poisonous, casting 100 diseases at a touch, and even causing petrification.
This is fine.
Minerva

I'd rather avoid resorting to Unknown for a stat unless completely necessary, so while I don't think her AP or Durability can be rated anything but unknown yet, I do think that her

A) Speed should be changed from Unknown to at least Supersonic, as Minerva was a very formidable fighter in the past and is capable of breaking the wind (i.e making a shockwave) with her speed, and

B) Lifting Strength should be changed from Unknown to at least Class 5, as Minerva is considered to possess the power to "overwhelm all others" and is portrayed as possessing superhuman strength, and thus should be at least comparable to if not stronger than superhumans such as Emilia or Garfiel
Seem reasonable.
Causality Manipulation

Minerva's healing functions by twisting cause & effect.
Good.
Typhon

Change Speed from Below Average Human level to Supersonic

Typhon intercepted Minerva in the Castle of Dreams
Fine, although based on the mountain part shouldn't Minerva be rated as 7-B like other high tiers?
Pain Manipulation

Typhon's Authority of Pride will cause pain when shattering a victim if the victim is a bad person, but will shatter them painlessly if they are a good person.
This is fine.
Carmilla

Death Manipulation


Carmilla's Faceless Bride forces others to become entranced by her, causing them to forget to breathe and eventually stops the beating of their heart. There were very few rumours around Carmilla due to nearly everyone she met dying.
Good.
All Witches of Sin

Madness Manipulation (Type 2)


A Witch's Miasma is known to cause fear in others even when being suppressed by the Witch- and when it is intentionally exuded by the Witch it will cause such terror that anyone around them who cannot resist the Miasma will immediately go mad and kill themself.
All Witch Factor Holders (or at least all Witches + Subaru)

Resistance to Madness Manipulation (Type 2)
As mentioned by Phoenks this is type 3, and the resistance is fine.
Sirius Romanée-Conti

Change Immortality (Type 1) to Longevity

The scan that's used for Sirius' immortality states that she, Regulus, and Petelgeuse have long lives. I don't believe this is enough for immortality even though Regulus and Petelgeuse are immortal. She has been alive for at least a century it seems.
I mean, if she is compared with other two characters who are immortal it seems logical to assume that she would also be immortal. At worst I can see a compromise like 'At least Longevity, likely Immortality (Type 1)', but even that feels a bit unnecessary.
Temperature Manipulation

Sirius specializes in Fire Magic, which doesn't just create fire, but also controls temperature.
No problem with this.
Limited(?) Resistance to Analytical Prediction

Sirius' chains follow no standard logic and trace unpredictable paths. This might be considered limited as it is only her chains that are unpredictable and not Sirius herself.
Ehhh, I don't really think that's resistance to analytical prediction, even more when is directly show how someone with analytical prediction could clash with the chains without problem. I could see other believing is a resistance to analytica prediction though, so if staff accept it I guess is fine.
 
How the heck you can be comparable, but weaker than someone? The statement just say Rem is stronger, how Ram is comparable?
Being stronger does not mean incomparable, Wilhelm or Rem are obviously stronger but 1st Shackle Ram still downscales, which is why she is currently listed as 8-B. In fact Garfiel is considered overwhelmingly more powerful than Rem and would defeat her easily, and they are listed as compararable in some regard.


Why 8-A exactly? I don't remember just being able to one-shot people make you jump a tier. Also, can you post the scan of her beating up Ley?
It's an exponential multiplier from Ram's >2x boost from 2nd Shackle. By third Shackle she'd be at least >100 tons.

Here's the quotes

Henceforth――

Ram: “Kindly endure with the intent to die, Barusu―― Rem will cry, otherwise.”

Thus, hurling those inaudible words, Ram unfastened her third shackle, after an interval of ten years. - Arc 6 Chapter 82 "Shackle-Accompanying Battle"


――Enhancement overflowing with the sensation of boiling blood, she had despised that ever since she was a child.

Omnipotence which seemed as if she could govern all things in this world.

Had the time of her being intoxicated with that hallucination continued, no matter how firm a spirituality she may have been blessed with, time would have unquestionably made her err in her path.

She was aware that she surpassed others. However, she did not lay too much trust in that.

She also made mistakes. Simply by possessing a will to not make mistakes, and a stance to correct mistakes.

The reason why she had been able to embrace that will, was also thanks to her not being intoxicated with omnipotence and acting like a fool. - Arc 6 Chapter 82 "Shackle-Accompanying Battle"


Ram: “What a Barusu-like thing to say―― It’d help if you’d stop this tug of war.”

Batenkaitos was surprised, and having jumped through the air faster than his ascent, Ram looked below towards his creepy face.

And, she mercilessly drove in the bottom of her shoe towards that face, with an opened mouth lined up with sharp fangs.

Ley: “Buh.” Ram: “Alright, let us see how many times you will be able to get a taste of Ram’s shoe until you fall below.” With his snout crushed, Batenkaitos’s petite frame rolled over midair.

With the vigor of his ascent killed off, this time Gluttony was made to fall directly below due to the strength of Ram’s kick at the same pace.

Pursuing him, Ram raised both of her hands towards the heavens, yielding wind in her palms and swiftly, towards the falling Batenkaitos’s face, hammered a second kick downwards―― no, a third, a fourth, and continued hammering kicks in.

Mercilessly, Ram’s heel kicked into his nose, his teeth, his chin, his forehead with each shot.
She had found that sneering face, and that mouth which time and again had called Ram “Nee-sama” to be unpleasant.

She intended to spoil them both, as their descent yet resumed. Incidentally――

Ram: “It is not Ram’s fault even if you get hit by the traps you laid. You reap what you sow.”

Ley: “Gih! Gya! Higihh ~tsu!”

Enroute to fall by the kick, the invisible blades he had laid in the atmosphere cleaved Batenkaitos’s body.

He was bleeding, and it seemed a few of the wounds had gouged his flesh as well, but Ram would not ignore them.

Ram, did not like to go out of her way and go as far as to make her opponent suffer and agonize.
However, that applied to the cases where her opponent had sympathetic qualities, and if her opponent was a detested enemy of hers, she would not falter in making them squeal like a pig.

Ram: “So? Do you regret it?”

Skillfully halting her body in the air, Ram enquired with her legs remaining on the opponent’s face and chest.
With his face polluted by thick blood, Batenkaitos did not respond to the question, but instead raised the daggers on both of his hands overhead.

In that juncture, both of Ram’s hands, used as swords, struck the opponent’s shoulders, coercively dislocating the shoulder joints.

Ley: “――Aoh.”

Ram: “So? Do you regret it?”

No matter how excellent a technique he wielded, with dislocated shoulders, his arms would not swing.

Whilst looking downwards onto the surprised face with eyes widened, Ram once again repeated the same question.

Ram: “――――”

As Batenkaitos gazed at Ram, she tried to search for fright being born in his eyes.

Her motive was to etch in. Fright, anguish, an indefinable sense of defeat. For the purpose of revenge―― no, not something trivial of that kind.

Ram: “Rem――”

It was for the purpose, of recovering her. The ginormous number of victims, who had been met by the tragedy of Gluttony until now. For the purpose of recovering the masses who had gotten their Name and Memories plundered and the history they had come in contact with, usurped.

If killing was all that was required, then Ram was capable of doing that even right now.

All she had to do was to have her feet wear a blade of wind and decapitate him with the same toil as when she had kicked his face in. Even if he was a Witch Cultist, renowned for being living foulness, if his neck and body were to be sundered, he would effectually die.

With a process of retribution, by one who was from the village of the Oni Clan which had been burnt to the ground, onto those who had brought about the village’s destruction.

After all, she was aware that the character of the Witch Cult was merely repugnant, being a horde of weak buffoons.

Thus she questioned, in order to kill his heart prior to his life. - Arc 6 Chapter 82 "Shackle-Accompanying Battle"


Wow, you really proposing this, i trought you are joking lmao
She's optional equipment and not standard, I don't believe Arc 6+ Ram is different enough to warrant a new key.


I trought this was webnovel only, did the youtuber i watched lied to me?
It is, but the existence of this ability does not contradict LN canon, especially since she wears a blindfold and Echidna still warns not to make eye contact.


Why? It said she is super strong, why would that mean she is comparable to Emilia or Garfiel? Does the story stated that she is? Superhuman makes more sense actually.
Minerva is overwhelmingly strong in the context of the Re:Zero world. I even added the statement that Rem- who is class 5- is not that strong.


That's not Death manipulation at all, people look at her and they forgot to breath, that is not her causing direct death to the person.
"The direct cessation of biological functions" is considered a form of death manipulation. Minerva's Authority captivates you and stops your heart, killing you.

Second, why you so sure this translation is more accurate?

Third, even with this new scan, is still said that is a combination of all the 6 witches, nowhere says that can be done individually.
It's more accurate bc Emminent is the goat. But also because this one specifically mentions Echidna's Miasma as driving the men insane, not some "aura of wickedness" which suggests to me that the previous translation was of lower quality.

There is also no mention of the miasma that kills these men being anyone other than Echidna's. "They were unable to resist her Witches miasma". We also already know she can't use the other 5 Witches powers, and considering the fact that Echidna being in Omega form prevents her miasma's release, I highly doubt that the Witch souls in a Pyroxene crystal are radiating miasma without bring projected (which they may not even be able to do).
 
nothing really says 1 shackle = Rem
Her base stats currently on her profile are 1st Shackle. She also is able to keep up with someone like Frederica who is Rem's level, if she is using 1st Shackle, but is still weaker than her.

This is fine, although just asking, she already have power mimicry?
Yes she does, she's a little genius.

Fine, although based on the mountain part shouldn't Minerva be rated as 7-B like other high tiers?
She easily could be 7-B, or even far higher, but due to her Authority giving her negative AP it's hard to say what level she should be at.
 
Pretty much agree with @Expectro2000xxx

In terms of some specifics:
Yeah, percentages in fiction shouldn't be trusted too much to really work as they are supposed, so I'm all out to rate them differently based on their feats/scaling. That said however, I'm not really seeing from those quotes that 1 shackle Ram is comparable to Rem, after all the first one just mention that with her horns instact before the incident she was stronger and the second just state that with one shackle she can minimally use magic, nothing really says 1 shackle = Rem.

Ram with 1 shackle is what she normally operates at, 2 shackles can only be maintained for a short period of time excluding external factors like Subaru taking the recoil for her, and Ram using Rem as her horn. These 2 stuff happens in arc 6, arc 4 is the first time in years Ram used 2 shackles, against Garfiel. In arc 3 we see her briefly clash with people like Wilhelm and Ricardo, so while weaker, she downscales.

This is fine, although just asking, she already have power mimicry? Because if not she should get it from being able to copy things after see them.

Could have sworn i already added power mimicry to her profile.

Bruh, adding a comatose person as equipment is so wrong.

It's very weird...


It's indeed something of a weird ability, however based on the scene of Subaru getting affected it seems as if the ability do something akin to the phantom pain brains experience when someone lose a limb, but in this case instead of being simple pain is a phantom hunger that reach a level of pain and hunger that the victim go insane, so based on that I feel that pain manip and madness type 2 would be more fitting for this.

Agree

Fine, although based on the mountain part shouldn't Minerva be rated as 7-B like other high tiers?

She was like Low 7-B years ago, but was removed a while back due to nature of how her ability works, she can't harm anything, so you get this statement about destroying mountains, but it does absolutely nothing to anyone, not to mention it wasn't in the LN, and my mindset before was if something isn't in the LN, it can't be used. More lenient there now, as long as it doesn't contradict anything the WN is fair game imo.


I mean, if she is compared with other two characters who are immortal it seems logical to assume that she would also be immortal. At worst I can see a compromise like 'At least Longevity, likely Immortality (Type 1)', but even that feels a bit unnecessary.

At least Longevity, likely Immortality (Type 1) might work, though idk how Sirus authority could allow for immortality, her ability is based around forming connections with others such as senses, souls, minds etc, meanwhile Regulus doesn't experience changed, and Petelguese body hops and is a spirit which are immortal.

Ehhh, I don't really think that's resistance to analytical prediction, even more when is directly show how someone with analytical prediction could clash with the chains without problem. I could see other believing is a resistance to analytica prediction though, so if staff accept it I guess is fine.

Also don't think it qualifies.
 
Speed should be changed from Unknown to at least Supersonic, as Minerva was a very formidable fighter in the past and is capable of breaking the wind (i.e making a shockwave) with her speed, and

Breaking the wind is? Idk, does that qualify? Maybe it does, but I could have sworn there was also an explicit statement that Minerva surpasses the speed of sound around the Witches Tea Party, but it's been years since i read this portion of the WN, and don't feel like hunting it down, it's certainty not in the LN though.
 
Being stronger does not mean incomparable, Wilhelm or Rem are obviously stronger but 1st Shackle Ram still downscales, which is why she is currently listed as 8-B. In fact Garfiel is considered overwhelmingly more powerful than Rem and would defeat her easily, and they are listed as compararable in some regard.
They should't be, because if Rem is stronger than Ram, that means they are not comparable at all.
It's an exponential multiplier from Ram's >2x boost from 2nd Shackle. By third Shackle she'd be at least >100 tons.
Well, she downscale for the value of the TNT, so i don't think the math actually checks out.
Here's the quotes
Cool, Ram here increase her power a little, and is able to land various combos of kicks on Ley, i see see...
The one-shot thing makes zero sense trought, like yeah if she cuts his neck, he gonna die, that's not a one-shot. Fure blades are cutting attacks.
She's optional equipment and not standard, I don't believe Arc 6+ Ram is different enough to warrant a new key.
Ok, so no Key 6 to Ram.

Still, giving Rem in comatose state as any form of equipament don't make much sense, she probally can use in versus duo matches trought, but for equipament, nah.
It is, but the existence of this ability does not contradict LN canon, especially since she wears a blindfold and Echidna still warns not to make eye contact.
Ah.
If that's the case until we have confirmation on what her eyes does, giving her this ability is a no for me. Still needs comfirmation.
The most you can give is a likely rating, not a full one because is not canon yet.
Minerva is overwhelmingly strong in the context of the Re:Zero world. I even added the statement that Rem- who is class 5- is not that strong.
Rem should downscale actually.

I still think if Minerva is not direct stated to scale to anyone, giving this rating is a bit iffy, but ok is fine.

Btw, what about the speed point, does is actually a shockwave?
"The direct cessation of biological functions" is considered a form of death manipulation. Minerva's Authority captivates you and stops your heart, killing you.
I mean yeah, she makes you forgot how to breath, and even you hearth stop, i don't think that is directly causing death to someone.
It's more accurate bc Emminent is the goat. But also because this one specifically mentions Echidna's Miasma as driving the men insane, not some "aura of wickedness" which suggests to me that the previous translation was of lower quality.
Can you confirm trought that is more accurate? Whats the actual japanese text said?
There is also no mention of the miasma that kills these men being anyone other than Echidna's. "They were unable to resist her Witches miasma".
We also already know she can't use the other 5 Witches powers, and considering the fact that Echidna being in Omega form prevents her miasma's release, I highly doubt that the Witch souls in a Pyroxene crystal are radiating miasma without bring projected (which they may not even be able to do).
I gonna quote myself:
But nothing in the scan says that all the witches have this ability, or why they should have this ability. The line "there does not seem to be any human being who is able to endure thirty seconds of hell and to meet the six witches." don't prove that each individual Witch can do this alone, the scan says that Omega, currently caring the six withes on her pocket, as able to kill everyone on her vicinity because of a combination of all of them.
The scan also says "The eighteen men in Echidna’s line of sight were unable to resist her Witch’s Miasma and thus were in great agony." so there you go, this makes clear that is a Echidna ability, not a general thing about witches.
Also, the scan imply that this is passive? If so...
 
At least Longevity, likely Immortality (Type 1) might work, though idk how Sirus authority could allow for immortality, her ability is based around forming connections with others such as senses, souls, minds etc, meanwhile Regulus doesn't experience changed, and Petelguese body hops and is a spirit which are immortal.
That particular Q&A is a weird one because Tappei is just wrong about Petelgeuse's immortality, which is due to his race not Authority. I'm fine with a likely/possibly rating until her elven heritage is revealed.

Maybe it does, but I could have sworn there was also an explicit statement that Minerva surpasses the speed of sound around the Witches Tea Party
You've got a good memory

Minerva: “Do you realize what it feels like to be ignored, when it’s been so long――!?”

The ground exploded, instantly annihilating the distance between them.

Minerva charged forward leaving a cloud of dust in her wake as she twisted her body to punch with all her might. Piercing the air, breaking through the sound barrier with a thunderous clap, the strike continued towards the Witch’s head, drilling towards the shadow obscuring her visage, and―― - Arc 4 Chapter 76 "≠Satella"
 
Well, she downscale for the value of the TNT, so i don't think the math actually checks out.
Ram is twice as strong as Beastified Garfiel, who himself is >= 27.66 tons. Her boost from 1st to 2nd Shackle is already >2x, and 3rd Shackle is an even greater boost due to being exponential.

Still, giving Rem in comatose state as any form of equipament don't make much sense
Beatrice and Puck are listed as both characters and equipment, so I see no why unconscious Rem can't be.

Ah.
If that's the case until we have confirmation on what her eyes does, giving her this ability is a no for me. Still needs comfirmation.
The most you can give is a likely rating, not a full one because is not canon yet.
I have a similar view to Pegasus that the WN is basically secondary canon. Usable unless it's contradictory. I think your opinion is valid but I disagree.

I mean yeah, she makes you forgot how to breath, and even you hearth stop, i don't think that is directly causing death to someone.
Ok, what does stopping a person's heart do?

Can you confirm trought that is more accurate? Whats the actual japanese text said?
I do not have the raws no, but I do believe Emminent to be a reliable translator, and the fact that this translation mentions Miasma- an actual concept in the series- I am inclined to believe it more.

Your own quote contradicts itself, you both say that Omega is using the power of the other 5 Witches (no proof) and then also claim it's an ability exclusive to Echidna.

The scan is actually saying that Echidna's miasma was enough to drive all 18 men to madness and suicide, and then later says that Subaru is remarkable for standing in the presence of all the Witches of Sin who are all covered in miasma.

This ability is/isn't passive I guess... most Witches actively suppress it which reduces it to merely causing fear/vomitting, but if they chose to actively do nothing it'd cause madness.
 
Her base stats currently on her profile are 1st Shackle. She also is able to keep up with someone like Frederica who is Rem's level, if she is using 1st Shackle, but is still weaker than her.
Ok, I don't doubt that, I really don't, however your argument was 1 shackle ≅ Rem, so I pointed how the quotes in the op supporting that part didn't show anything like that, so is better if you were to change them with something actually showing the 1 shackle ≅ Rem, like by posting her being comparable to Priscilla who is said by the author to be comparable to Rem.
She easily could be 7-B, or even far higher, but due to her Authority giving her negative AP it's hard to say what level she should be at.
I mean, if you look at the quote it says:
The ground caved in beneath her single step as Minerva’s fist pierced through the wind, driving towards Typhon’s face.

The shrieking fist advanced with enough force to rupture a mountain
, but the moment it connects with a living being, the destruction would transform into healing. Although, the shockwave of the impact would still be transferred to the recipient of the strike.
It states that the impact it's still transferred to the other side through the shockwave, on top of the ground also getting damaged with her step, so she can certainly be rated.
Ram with 1 shackle is what she normally operates at, 2 shackles can only be maintained for a short period of time excluding external factors like Subaru taking the recoil for her, and Ram using Rem as her horn. These 2 stuff happens in arc 6, arc 4 is the first time in years Ram used 2 shackles, against Garfiel. In arc 3 we see her briefly clash with people like Wilhelm and Ricardo, so while weaker, she downscales.

Could have sworn i already added power mimicry to her profile.
Like I said previously, I only contested those quotes as proof of 1 shackle ≅ Rem, if they are changed for things that actually prove that then everything is fine.

Based on @Zabazab previous response it seems that she already have it.
She was like Low 7-B years ago, but was removed a while back due to nature of how her ability works, she can't harm anything, so you get this statement about destroying mountains, but it does absolutely nothing to anyone, not to mention it wasn't in the LN, and my mindset before was if something isn't in the LN, it can't be used. More lenient there now, as long as it doesn't contradict anything the WN is fair game imo.

At least Longevity, likely Immortality (Type 1) might work, though idk how Sirus authority could allow for immortality, her ability is based around forming connections with others such as senses, souls, minds etc, meanwhile Regulus doesn't experience changed, and Petelguese body hops and is a spirit which are immortal.
I get that, however as I pointed above the effects of her AP still can be felt even with her ability restoring things afterwards.

Don't know, I don't follow the series so I didn't even knew her power, however if the author did say that then it should be for a reason.
Breaking the wind is? Idk, does that qualify? Maybe it does, but I could have sworn there was also an explicit statement that Minerva surpasses the speed of sound around the Witches Tea Party, but it's been years since i read this portion of the WN, and don't feel like hunting it down, it's certainty not in the LN though.
I also honestly think it's weird, but I supposed it was in reference to the sound barrier, hence why I didn't really said anything. Although that other quote you mention is far better, that can be used as the main feat and the wind breaking part could be a supporting feat.
 
Ram is twice as strong as Beastified Garfiel, who himself is >= 27.66 tons. Her boost from 1st to 2nd Shackle is already >2x, and 3rd Shackle is an even greater boost due to being exponential.
I see.
Beatrice and Puck are listed as both characters and equipment, so I see no why unconscious Rem can't be.
I mean, Puck and Beatrice are characters that actually fought with they contractors, and they gain new powers with them.
Rem is something that happen once, and she is not even comatose anymore.
I have a similar view to Pegasus that the WN is basically secondary canon. Usable unless it's contradictory. I think your opinion is valid but I disagree.
Okay. Not like my opinions matters anyway.
Ok, what does stopping a person's heart do?
Death.
But her authority does this indirectly, by making them not able to breath anymore.
I do not have the raws no, but I do believe Emminent to be a reliable translator, and the fact that this translation mentions Miasma- an actual concept in the series- I am inclined to believe it more.
Okay, i still not too sure, but okay.
The old translation is made by the witch cult translations i think, do you think they are realiable?
Your own quote contradicts itself, you both say that Omega is using the power of the other 5 Witches (no proof) and then also claim it's an ability exclusive to Echidna.
I mean, is either one of the two, she is using the witches, or is exclusive to Echidna, that's what i meant.
The scan is actually saying that Echidna's miasma was enough to drive all 18 men to madness and suicide, and then later says that Subaru is remarkable for standing in the presence of all the Witches of Sin who are all covered in miasma.
That still would't imply every one of them have MM trought, since Echidna miasma could still be interpreted different for them.
This ability is/isn't passive I guess... most Witches actively suppress it which reduces it to merely causing fear/vomitting, but if they chose to actively do nothing it'd cause madness.
When is stated that they can surpress they miasma?
 
Ok, I don't doubt that, I really don't, however your argument was 1 shackle ≅ Rem, so I pointed how the quotes in the op supporting that part didn't show anything like that, so is better if you were to change them with something actually showing the 1 shackle ≅ Rem, like by posting her being comparable to Priscilla who is said by the author to be comparable to Rem.

Here's the evidence for her current rating, she goes toe-to-toe with Old Wilhelm.
As if to blow that admiration aside, the figure thrust a cane forward with an explosion of magic. The target was the ground under Wilhelm’s feet, gouging the surface out in a circle, slowing the Sword Devil down. When Wilhelm then leaped toward his foe, slashing upward, something caught him by the chest. “Guh…!” Wilhelm’s well-honed abdomen creaked as his body was sent flying by force unthinkable for the tiny figure’s size. The cane’s tip was pointed at the Sword Devil as the air twisted before it. The resulting cascade of air was about to slice deep into the Sword Devil—but a slice of steel rent it first, causing its mana to explode.


It states that the impact it's still transferred to the other side through the shockwave, on top of the ground also getting damaged with her step, so she can certainly be rated.
At most she can cause environmental destruction- Minerva's Authority of Wrath basically turns any action she performs into healing. She can kick someone through a mountain, twist their neck like a wet towel, stab them, drop a boulder on them, no matter what she does it will heal.

The only way she can cause harm is by like digging a hole and letting someone walk into it, but she'd never try to harm anyone.


I mean, Puck and Beatrice are characters that actually fought with they contractors, and they gain new powers with them.
Rem is something that happen once, and she is not even comatose anymore.
Ram gains new power from Rem, but the fact that they only use it once is why I decided optional equipment to be more appropriate than standard equipment.


Okay. Not like my opinions matters anyway.
Neither do mine, but we can make them matter by persuading others.


Okay, i still not too sure, but okay.
The old translation is made by the witch cult translations i think, do you think they are realiable?
I don't know who translated it before, but Eminent's is what is linked on the WCT site.


Death.
But her authority does this indirectly, by making them not able to breath anymore.
You can maybe argue that for breathing, but your heart cannot actually stop by being entranced by something. The heart is stopped by supernatural means.


That still would't imply every one of them have MM trought, since Echidna miasma could still be interpreted different for them.
There is no stated difference in miasma, only quantity of it. The more miasma the greater the effect. There is no reason to believe that Echidna has unique miasma, and it was stated that all Witches together would have an even greater effect.


When is stated that they can surpress they miasma?
Omega herself is a prime example, and so is the fact that most people don't just go mad and die in Echidna's presence- they merely vomit and feel terror.
 
Last edited:
At most she can cause environmental destruction- Minerva's Authority of Wrath basically turns any action she performs into healing. She can kick someone through a mountain, twist their neck like a wet towel, stab them, drop a boulder on them, no matter what she does it will heal.

The only way she can cause harm is by like digging a hole and letting someone walk into it, but she'd never try to harm anyone.
He attacks still possess energy and force, those things are needed to clash against others, to block their attacks and any such combat related action which she need to fight at all. The damage she do could be healed, yes, that however don't mean she isn't generating that energy/force to begin with it (is actually the other way around, because she generated those things is that people get injuried and thus can be healed), so her stats should reflect by all means her actual statistics (which seem to be of 7-B level).
 
He attacks still possess energy and force, those things are needed to clash against others, to block their attacks and any such combat related action which she need to fight at all. The damage she do could be healed, yes, that however don't mean she isn't generating that energy/force to begin with it (is actually the other way around, because she generated those things is that people get injuried and thus can be healed), so her stats should reflect by all means her actual statistics (which seem to be of 7-B level).

I still disagree with rating her attack potency, since the potency of her attacks are nil. All she can do is destroy the environment or cause knockback, but it's not like she deals damage which heals- the damage becomes healing before it is even applied. Ants don't even get crushed under her feet, they just feel better.

Striking strength and durability might deserve a rating, but I think that'd probably be up to Pegasus.
 
I still disagree with rating her attack potency, since the potency of her attacks are nil. All she can do is destroy the environment or cause knockback, but it's not like she deals damage which heals- the damage becomes healing before it is even applied. Ants don't even get crushed under her feet, they just feel better.

Striking strength and durability might deserve a rating, but I think that'd probably be up to Pegasus.
Why not give her an attack potency for environmental damage? Either way she can't be used in a fight since she can't deal any damage. It just makes her profile more detailed and accurate.
 
Ram gains new power from Rem, but the fact that they only use it once is why I decided optional equipment to be more appropriate than standard equipment.
I don't think that's enough to warrant giving Ram a equipament bases on Rem while she is in coma.
Just scrap the optimal equipament, and put a note saying that she can only use this power while team up with Subaru or Rem, giving her a optimal equipament bases on that one time is kinda unscessary.
I don't know who translated it before, but Eminent's is what is linked on the WCT site.
Is the Witch cult translation that translate before.
You can maybe argue that for breathing, but your heart cannot actually stop by being entranced by something. The heart is stopped by supernatural means.
I am saying she make people so entrance with her, that they forgot how to breath and then they hearth stop beating because of the lack of oxygen.
Her power just make people simp for her so hard, that they forgot how to breath, saying she is causing direct death to someone is not really the case here.
There is no stated difference in miasma, only quantity of it. The more miasma the greater the effect. There is no reason to believe that Echidna has unique miasma, and it was stated that all Witches together would have an even greater effect.
Is by showings trought, Echidna miasma os shown to make people mad and kill themself, the other witches don't have any showings of these effects, the statement about "Witches covered in miasma" still doesnt mean they would have this ability, since they Miasma still cause extreme fear on people, and a great ammount of Miasma in one place would cause people to Go insane, so Subaru able to stand around them is in fact impressive.

I just want more statement that they can also do that.
Omega herself is a prime example, and so is the fact that most people don't just go mad and die in Echidna's presence- they merely vomit and feel terror.
Not really, that would just imply that Echidna can control her Miasma, not the other witches.

I still hold the opinion that they don't have this Miasma that cause people mad until more statement, until now just seems Echidna can do that and her alone.
 
I don't think that's enough to warrant giving Ram a equipament bases on Rem while she is in coma.
It'd give her the option of accessing her higher Shackles without needing to team up, especially when no conscious version of Rem has ever provided mana to Ram via Synesthesia. It'd be more reflective of the canon.

I am saying she make people so entrance with her, that they forgot how to breath and then they hearth stop beating because of the lack of oxygen.
Her power just make people simp for her so hard, that they forgot how to breath, saying she is causing direct death to someone is not really the case here.
Are you misunderstanding Faceless Bride? It literally stops your heart, it doesn't just suffocate you, it prevents your heart from beating. This is textbook death manipulation, it's like writing "heart attack" in the death note.

Is by showings trought, Echidna miasma os shown to make people mad and kill themself, the other witches don't have any showings of these effects, the statement about "Witches covered in miasma" still doesnt mean they would have this ability, since they Miasma still cause extreme fear on people, and a great ammount of Miasma in one place would cause people to Go insane, so Subaru able to stand around them is in fact impressive.
The burden of proof is on you to show that Echidna's Miasma is inexplicably different from the other 5 Witches Miasma.

The text states that Echidna's Witch Miasma killed the men. It then says that Subaru is remarkable for withstanding the Miasma of all Witches at once. This is directly telling us that all the Witches normally have the same effect when releasing Miasma.

Not really, that would just imply that Echidna can control her Miasma, not the other witches.

I still hold the opinion that they don't have this Miasma that cause people mad until more statement, until now just seems Echidna can do that and her alone.
The other Witches also conversate with people, except for Carmilla and Envy. Minerva goes around healing people so obviously she isn't miasma bombing them. Daphne, when not cannibalizing people, is a great listener. Sekhmet is a rational person who even lived in a town for a while.

This is the sidestory we have that explains Miasma = Madness, and it says that all the Witches have this ability. There's not gonna be much more for side characters only due to reappear in the finale.

The eighteen men in Echidna’s line of sight were unable to resist her Witch’s Miasma and thus were in great agony.
Echidna looked back at the fallen men, then closed her eyes and thought of the boy with black hair, of the boy who remained unaffected while being surrounded by the Witches covered in miasma—though he probably didn’t even realize how abnormal it was to be able to do that.
 
It'd give her the option of accessing her higher Shackles without needing to team up, especially when no conscious version of Rem has ever provided mana to Ram via Synesthesia. It'd be more reflective of the canon.
That's kinda unescessary, there's no need to give Ram a optimal equipament based on Rem.
Just a put a note saying that she need to team up with Subaru on Tem to acess her tier.
Are you misunderstanding Faceless Bride?
No, just saying that If you stop breathing, eventualy you heart stop beating too.
The burden of proof is on you to show that Echidna's Miasma is inexplicably different from the other 5 Witches Miasma.
Echidna Miasma is shown to make people go mad.
The others witches are never shown have this Miasma making people go mad.
There you go.
The text states that Echidna's Witch Miasma killed the men. It then says that Subaru is remarkable for withstanding the Miasma of all Witches at once. This is directly telling us that all the Witches normally have the same effect when releasing Miasma.
Not really, because that Six witches are three, the amount of Miasma is also greater, making that If someone is around them, would face more Miasma If they face onlybone Witch,
That don't exactly mean which individual Witch have this effect on they own, just when they are combined.
The other Witches also conversate with people, except for Carmilla and Envy. Minerva goes around healing people so obviously she isn't miasma bombing them. Daphne, when not cannibalizing people, is a great listener. Sekhmet is a rational person who even lived in a town for a while.
Well, you could interpret that is not exactly they surpressing, as much they don't have this effect on they Miasma, so there's no need to surpress anything.
 
Ok so the equipment thing is purely a difference of opinion, you've misunderstood what Faceless Bride really does, and you've just repeated your already refuted points about Miasma.

Regarding the miasma, it's simply a case of occams razor to believe all Witch's miasma has the same effect. You have to jump through logistical hoops to argue they don't, when the text is telling us that they do in fact have the same effect since it stacks.
 
Ok so the equipment thing is purely a difference of opinion,
Yeah
you've misunderstood what Faceless Bride really does
Not really
, and you've just repeated your already refuted points about Miasma.
You din't refute my points about Miasma, so i repeat then.

Anyway, we kinda going in circles, and even trought i could mention Subaru in the dunes to make my argument, i think i gonna drop this argument.

I just disagree with four things in this CRT.
Regarding the miasma, it's simply a case of occams razor to believe all Witch's miasma has the same effect. You have to jump through logistical hoops to argue they don't, when the text is telling us that they do in fact have the same effect since it stacks.
Okay i guess makes sense, but i still disagree trought.
 
I also agree with comatose Rem being optional equipment as it would be way more fun to have fights with that Ram
Also the fact that this is probably the most useful thing she has done since arc 3
Not really
No, i agree with zabazab on this
You din't refute my points about Miasma, so i repeat then.

Anyway, we kinda going in circles, and even trought i could mention Subaru in the dunes to make my argument, i think i gonna drop this argument.

I just disagree with four things in this CRT.

Okay i guess makes sense, but i still disagree trought.
The miasma point is kind of obvious if you look at it from the authors pov and also what his intent was with it. It did be pretty weird for tappei to call it "witch's miasma" and then not have all the witches have it
 
Gave another quick look to things and after read again the eyes of starvation part I remember a scene in Arifureta where the protagonist was turning crazy from phantom hunger (as in, his body didn't had to actually eat due to effects of a magic but regardless he felt immense hunger), so I'm more confident in my previous conclusion and analogy.

I also still stand in my opinion about the other things, including the miasma part as I don't really agree with the previous discussion about it not applying to the witches in general despite the clear statements.
 
I'll call staff. Surprisingly, there is not many staff for Re:Zero on this wiki, despite it's popularity.
The fate of most if not all novels in the wiki, noy many get interested in give them a look unless they already are readers of them, part of the motive of why I tried to give my input in the previous and this crt is to help a bit with that.
 
Thank you.

Also, if anyone has time I'd appreciate if you could add the extreme temperatures resistance to the profiles of characters that use the Flow Method, since there's so many that do.

It's already been added to Sirius's profile so you can just copypaste, I'll do them all eventually but the help would be nice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top