>High 2-A Mario
I had a feeling this was coming sadly if anyone from that Character Stats and Profile Wiki would find this page considering everyone who is a self-proclaimed Mario expert from there seems to think that Mario for whatever reason is High 2-A even though the reasoning is completely nonsensical and about as logical as having Universal DiC Sonic.
Real World feats should be taken with a grain of salt.
Mr. Mxyzptlk, for example,
can enter the Real World and affect it by even talking to the writers, but you don't see Mxy getting a special tier because, by the logic we're using right now, he should be above the Writer for the fact The Real World > DC Comics' as a fictional story.
Tier -1 Mxy confirmed OvO. There is a similar case for
Archie Sonic where
he interacts with the Real World where he is considered mere fiction to humans, but it doesn't affect his tier as well. Or is Mickey Mouse at a new special tier for
entering the Human World like Mario? Real Worlds in fiction obviously view copyrighted material stories as mere fiction. All Mario is doing here is getting some of the best
4th Wall Breaking that a character can get in fiction this doesn't justify him being High 2-A. Not remotely when his best feats involve him doing something 4 infinities below what you are suggesting him at.
The feats you are showing don't put them at a quantifiable tier since they are quite literally the definition of
4th Wall Breaking and nothing beyond it with you both even giving the context that it is. Even if
4th Wall Breaking of this level isn't all that common in fiction, a variety of characters including the ones mentioned above along with
Bugs Bunny,
Popeye, etc. have all done the exact same thing. We can't give Mario special treatment if we treat feats like the ones above as just really good 4th Wall Breaking with the exact same realistic implications you are just mentioning here. The only thing you have given us is the degree of his broken
Toon Force,
4th Wall Breaking, and some
Plot Manipulation. Also, even if there were 4D feats, that wouldn't justify them being at 5D.
Also, regarding the sun feat. It burnt down a forest which is usually treated as a Town level feat. That is why
Slenderma, for example, has a 7-C key on his profile, not a 7-B feat. In general, having the idea of "Mario's True Power" sounds like a bad idea like an "Unrestricted Pucca" because there are inconsistent feats but are somehow justified with ideas like these by fans. It doesn't work when you scale characters to one of Mario's lower feats but say his "true power" (which is something that is never even confirmed as a canon thing) is 4 infinities greater for no rhyme or reason. Also, we really don't need two keys like that, to begin with. There is a reason Saitama doesn't have a "Restricted" and "Unrestricted" key to his profile anymore.
I think our current keys for the page are fine right now as well. Diving into a High 2-A Mario is going to derail the thread past what we're focusing on which is making the pages. Even if you don't disagree with the current reason, would you rather not like to have a page then make a content revision for Mario ratings later? It makes this easier considering we don't need to debate this out until one of you does a Content Revision Thread when the page is made. You would effectively negate the purpose of this thread and cause an unwanted debate for the moment considering we're still just trying to get even keys and stuff organized. Jumping 4 infinities from where we are rating them right now is a mess.