Outerversal Madoka Question

[DrunkTerry]

Someone sent me this scan on discord saying that Madoka existed in this void and that it had no direction would mean that it would have to be either 0D or Low 1-A or higher because infinite dimensional realms have infinite different dimensional axis. (3D have 3 axis, 4D have 4 etc.) 0D have no axis but Low-1A and 1A realms transend dimensionality.

Then I'm shown this by said person saying that because she ascended, it has to be Low 1-A or higher. Basically what would your all thoughts be here since I don't really know what to say here.

 

[Greatsage13th]

Following

 

[Sniper670]

Following as well. Intriguing

 

[DrunkTerry]

Bump

 

[Iiliminal]

im like 99% sure this did not even get her to low 1-C in past threads but im too lazy to check, u should check past threads concerning her

well unless a knowledgeable member comes in and explains why this doesnt even make her low 1-c

 

[MishimaBloodline]

i believe this was discussed here

 

[Jinsye]

This is goofy but no.

First of all, this just means Madoka inherits a dimensionless space, not that she is 1-A altogether so this wouldn't even scale to AP.
Two, this isn't the 'beyond the concept of dimensions' statement that we use for 1-A. It's just 'this place has no directions' which doesn't mean anything in regards to size or whatever.

 

[ShadowWarrior1999]

Yeah lacking directions =/= transcending them altogether.

 

[Phoenks]

As Jinsye mentioned, this merely means she exists in a space without dimensions, rather than transcending them or anything of the such. The statement is vague, and nothing implies she's beyond dimensions.

Shifting to a "higher plane" doesn't necessarily invoke a higher-dimensional existence, and even if it does, it could just be 4-D, which I believe is what she currently is. I see nothing that proves she's beyond that.

There is absolutely no way that this is 1-A, and without further explanation and evidence, I would not support Low 1-C either.

 

[DrunkTerry]

Alright thanks everyone. One last thing

What would meta conceptual world mean here? It says meta-conceptual world, isn't that a world of concepts or something along those lines...?

 

[Sniper670]

Imma be real with you chief, this means..... Nothing

 

[Delta333]

Alright thanks everyone. One last thing

What would meta conceptual world mean here? It says meta-conceptual world, isn't that a world of concepts or something along those lines...?

The heaven where she resides is conceptual

 

[The_Axiom_of_Virgo]

The heaven where she resides is conceptual

IIRC Kyubey in the anime even states she's becoming a concept after making her wish and defeating KG (in terms of popular franchises PMMM is very in your face with it's CM).

Either way I believe this Q&A is resolved.