One Piece Book Scaling.

[PsychoWarper]

This is literally an Outlier, regardless of literally anything else said in this thread and no matter if this feat is considered legit or not its still a massive outlier that wont be accepted.

Also Jinbe literally just set a book on fire, that just seems... yeah thats no much if a feat since they are seemingly made of paper so he basically just set a large book on fire.

 

[Overlord775]

Is there any proof that the worlds are real and the ability doesn't just turn the characters into fictional beings inside a fictional world (AKA 11-A) ?

 

[Shyouu]

Also here: burning through this infinite universe.

Nothing indicates that they are infinite in size.
The Japanese scan says the following.

"本の世界は想像力の広さ無限じゃ"

Translating that gives us

"The world of books is infinite in imagination"

Imagination itself is not infinite as it has limits. We cannot imagine things such as the 4th spatial dimension or omnipotence. It's limited to our knowledge.

Furthermore, the argument is that 異世界 (isekai) means they're a different spacetime continuum. As with Kaguya's space-times, assuming they're immediately universal in size is a rash assumption. Especially given that no One Piece character has been able to come close to producing enough energy to create a universe-sized spacetime continuum. As per Sagan's Razor, "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" and claiming a mid-high tier like Mont D'Or producing High Universe levels of energy is an extraordinary claim indeed.

Credits to seraph

 

[GodlyCharmander]

The size of a pocket dimension is unrelated to AP when the actual book can be destroyed easily. It doesn't scale to AP, nor does it scale to any other devil fruit, this isn't Dragon Ball, abilities are not raw power.

Unrelated, but I think Luffy is stronger than Ace by scaling above Jinbe-

 

[LordGinSama]

tbh this is a better feat of hax more than anything, totally forgot about the Buku Buku.

High 3-A is a total no go, and by the way the Yami Yami no Mi isn't the strongest fruit in the series, it's the most dangerous due to it's ability to steal and nullify DF's. The strongest and most destructive would be Whitebeard's Gura Gura no Mi so this wouldn't scale to Blackbeard or Ace even if this were legitimate.


Edit: **** didn't even know he had a profile lmao.

 

[Damage3245]

This can absolutely be closed now.

The consensus is to completely reject this from what I'm seeing.

Happy April Fools, I guess.