Novels? (Nard revision)

[AlternativePrinciple]

Generally avoid bumping threads until 24 hours had passed since last post.

K, I'll be careful next time

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump X3

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump X3

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump X5

 

[RanaProGamer]

Kind of wish Arc gave his input here

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump X6

 

[RanaProGamer]

Bump X5

I think you meant X6

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

I think you meant X6

Me bad

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump X7

 

[KaydeeX]

Bump X6

Nuh uh, it’s X7

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Nuh uh, it’s X7

Guess I am living 1 day behind

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump X5

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

bump

 

[Apollonir.Scale]

It was forgotten like other Naruto CRTs.

 

[HelloThere1089]

It was forgotten like other Naruto CRTs.

There are only few Naruto supporter mods left who want anything to do with this verse (can't say I blame them). Unless it's a huge upgrade thread, I don't see CRTs like this getting much traction.

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Bump X10

 

[RanaProGamer]

Bump X10

Any chance you can contact more thread mods?

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Any chance you can contact more thread mods?

Dont know any and someone already posted this thread to the mods thread

 

[Apollonir.Scale]

Now, how is the result determined when 2 mods say they agree and 2 mods say they disagree? If Mod 5, who will express his opinion, says he agrees, will the recommendations in the CRT be implemented? On the contrary, will it be closed even if he says he disagrees?

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Now, how is the result determined when 2 mods say they agree and 2 mods say they disagree? If Mod 5, who will express his opinion, says he agrees, will the recommendations in the CRT be implemented? On the contrary, will it be closed even if he says he disagrees?

need one more vote for either side. If a mod agrees then this thread gets accepted, but if they disagree then the thread gets closed

 

[Sasukesama0492]

Bump..

 

[UchihaSlayer96]

I'm kind of inclined to agree with Shadow here.

The movie was adapted from a script written by Kishi and the novel was written by Kodachi, who wrote the first half of the Boruto manga. The point is, these two products had heavy involvement from the main writers of the series, and are recognized as part of the official timeline by the parent company.

That being said, assuming this goes through, the manga will still take precedence as the primary canon source. So the novel would only be useful as a tertiary source that's really only good for clarification or giving additional information/context not present in the other adaptations, provided they cause no contradictions ofc. Essentially the exact role the anime currently serves, but obviously a bit diminished because the novel doesn't have the plethora of "this is canon to the manga continuity" statements that the anime has. But I disgress.

 

[RanaProGamer]

And there’s our last vote, after many months. We’ve finally reached a conclusion.

 

[HelloThere1089]

I'm kind of inclined to agree with Shadow here.

The movie was adapted from a script written by Kishi and the novel was written by Kodachi, who wrote the first half of the Boruto manga. The point is, these two products had heavy involvement from the main writers of the series, and are recognized as part of the official timeline by the parent company.

That being said, assuming this goes through, the manga will still take precedence as the primary canon source. So the novel would only be useful as a tertiary source that's really only good for clarification or giving additional information/context not present in the other adaptations, provided they cause no contradictions ofc. Essentially the exact role the anime currently serves, but obviously a bit diminished because the novel doesn't have the plethora of "this is canon to the manga continuity" statements that the anime has. But I disgress.

Btw, do you mind drafting a discussion rule? Or is it not required the same way we don't have a discussion rule for the anime being secondary canon?

 

[UchihaSlayer96]

Btw, do you mind drafting a discussion rule? Or is it not required the same way we don't have a discussion rule for the anime being secondary canon?

I think a note explaining the situation on the Verse Page will suffice and be more appropriate imo.

 

[HelloThere1089]

I think a note explaining the situation on the Verse Page will suffice and be more appropriate imo.

"The manga is treated as the primary source material while the anime and novels are considered secondary and tertiary source materials respectively. The tertiary canon status of the Boruto movie novelization was agreed upon in this thread." Sumn like this? Or do you think I should add something like "Information from the tertiary canon can only be used if the specific information doesn't contradict the primary and the secondary canon"

 

[Godernet]

the verse page I have in the works has a section outlining canon content with notes that explain the part they play in the canon.

I can add it to that if anything that way you don't make a new section just for it to get replaced soon after

 

[HelloThere1089]

the verse page I have in the works has a section outlining canon content with notes that explain the part they play in the canon.

I can add it to that if anything that way you don't make a new section just for it to get replaced soon after

Yeah. That would be great.

 

[UchihaSlayer96]

"The manga is treated as the primary source material while the anime and novels are considered secondary and tertiary source materials respectively. The tertiary canon status of the novels was agreed upon in this thread." Sumn like this? Or do you think I should add something like "Information from the tertiary canon can only be used if the specific information doesn't contradict the primary and the secondary canon"

Yeah something like this would do the trick.

the verse page I have in the works has a section outlining canon content with notes that explain the part they play in the canon.

I can add it to that if anything that way you don't make a new section just for it to get replaced soon after

Great idea, Bubba. Thanks.

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

Then this thread can be closed now

 

[HelloThere1089]

Then this thread can be closed now

The discussion rule needs to be removed first.

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

The discussion rule needs to be removed first.

how me do that?

 

[HelloThere1089]

how me do that?

Bubba.

Slayer do you mind helping Alt here.

 

[UchihaSlayer96]

Slayer do you mind helping Alt here.

I think that's a job for an Admin or content mod. That page is locked.

 

[AlternativePrinciple]

I think that's a job for an Admin or content mod. That page is locked.

should i go to the all purpose thread and ask them to remove it?

 

[HelloThere1089]

Isn't Shadow a content mod? You can ask Shadow in the general thread.

 

[UchihaSlayer96]

Both options work.