Is this One Piece calculation Mathematically Correct?

[GodlyCharmander]

First off, here's the source.

So basically, he used the Anime to calculate the KE from Roger and Whitebeard's Clash, which is fine, Oda has been involved in the anime's extended fights since Zou, it seems. And the Wiki does accept the Anime as secondary canon.

But the methodology seems to be far too stretched to be true, if someone does have the time, could you check the calculation in the video?

 

[DemonGodMitchAubin]

IdeaShock is a gross One Piece wanker who calc stacks and makes me lose hope in humanity

So no, it is not valid

 

[GodlyCharmander]

IdeaShock is a gross One Piece wanker who calc stacks and makes me lose hope in humanity

So no, it is not valid

While I recognized some leaps in logic, which I might be wrong about, I believe there is no calc stacking in this particular video.

Btw, this is not really priority, so It's not like I'm demanding someone to go debunk his calculation, I don't mean to sound rude or bossy. But, I would like a second or third opinion from the more knowledgeable members about the methodology, math and "assumptions" made in the video.

 

[KingTempest]

First off, here's the source.

So basically, he used the Anime to calculate the KE from Roger and Whitebeard's Clash, which is fine, Oda has been involved in the anime's extended fights since Zou, it seems. And the Wiki does accept the Anime as secondary canon.

Oda has not been involved with the anime since Zou. He was involved with the anime only in Zou. It's only secondary canon if it shares a scene in the manga, which this does not.

But the methodology seems to be far too stretched to be true, if someone does have the time, could you check the calculation in the video?

I've seen this video. Wanked incorrect calc.

Idek how he managed to use OP's animals as irl animals then wanked the size to 2700 acres. It's irritating.

 

[GodlyCharmander]

I've seen this video. Wanked incorrect calc.

Idek how he managed to use OP's animals as irl animals then wanked the size to 2700 acres. It's irritating.

I see. This was one of the things I noticed too. The clearly cartoon-ey looking animals being scaled to irl animals was some bullshit, and I don't think he gave any sources to the formula at the end.

 

[GodlyCharmander]

Anyway, thank you for your attention, sir.

 

[KingTempest]

I see. This was one of the things I noticed too. The clearly cartoon-ey looking animals being scaled to irl animals was some bullshit,

Ex-actly.

and I don't think he gave any sources to the formula at the end.

He never does. He calculated whitebeard cracking the air at 6-B when it's nothing above tier 8.

Anyway, thank you for your attention, sir.

If you need help with anything involving OP, lmk

 

[FluffyCreatureZ]

BTW this is the same guy that claims that luffy is 32 zettatons, MFTL+, hits on the molecular level and can beat naruto LMAO.

 

[theultimate5105]

BTW this is the same guy that claims that luffy is 32 zettatons, MFTL+, hits on the molecular level and can beat naruto LMAO.

yes

 

[KingTempest]

OP has been answered