"This entire premise is under the notion that getting accepted into Beacon is automatically qualifies one as a prodigy. Again, we have seen characters canonically being referred to as prodigies within the RWBY-verse and none of that was because of them getting accepted into Beacon. The only thing we know about Beacon is that their students are unquantifiably ahead of the norm. Saying that ALL students in Beacon are prodigies would directly invalidate Ozpin and Pyrrha's status as actual prodigies."
Its almost like every named character in the series is a highly skilled fighter but there are people who are more skilled than others. Theres a whole skill-scaling chain for RWBY with the baseline being a small handful of people in the world who are veritable combat masters.
"I also specifically mentioned within combat, as the in-combat and out-of-combat uses varies greatly. I said that they work similar in practice, not that their properties are the same. In combat her illusions are more akin to an advanced version of Blake's (which you directly referred to as an afterimage aswell) So i once again draw attention to this:"
No, they do not. Look at any of her fights in the show or the novels, she has made herself completely invisible, created clones, manipulated the environment, used illusions to conceal others, all in combat. Please show where Goku has done any of that.
"2. illusion creation is directly defined as "The ability to create false images" so saying that the technique that is literally called "afterimage" is completely incomparable is disingenuous at best. They both acomplish the same end-result of misleading and disorienting, which is what Yang canonically lost against as she spent half the fight against Neo wondering how she randomely got hit. So again, regardless of how comparable the Afterimage is towards Neo, you cannot prove that Yang resists it, and you cannot prove that she is a fighting-prodigy as she was never stated as one, nor has she been implied to be one, nor does she scale towards one."
The ability to create false images to confuse and manipulate opponents. A very versatile ability, illusions can vary greatly in strength and effects, ranging from small and virtually harmless, nothing more than distractions, to incredibly complex. The most powerful illusions can distort a...
vsbattles.fandom.com
An afterimage is an artistic effect where a character appears to leave faint silhouettes behind them, which are often transparent, like a ghost. These are usually used to emphasize fast movement, and are often used in combat to mislead opponents as to the actual location of the user. It...
vsbattles.fandom.com
Theyre literally listed as two vastly different powers. If you want to make a CRT to try to give Goku illusion creation then go for it, but until then you cannot just claim that he has illusion creation based on afterimages.
So again, no, Goku does not have anything comparable to Neo's illusions. His afterimages are comparable to Blake's which Yang has no issue keeping track of. She does not need to be stated to be a fighting prodigy, her combat feats and background more than support her being one.