Garnet vs Whitebeard

[WeeklyBattles]

That's right, it's back. In character (But garnet is ok with fighting Whitebeard), all powers and abilities, no prior knowledge or prep time, victory by KO or death. Who wins?

Whitebeard - 0

Garnet - 8

 

[Cropfist]

Garnet by having thousands of years of combat experience.

 

[The_real_cal_howard]

This is a difficult one.

For one, Whitebeard is stronger, but by not a lot (318 gigs vs 336 gigs). Most of their other abilites cancel out. Haki with Future vision, and most of their resistances are the same. Garnet is also 2X faster at Mach 500. Whitebeard is somewhere in the 200s. Airquakes and Rocket Gauntlets both give range. However, there's one difference: the Regenerationn and immortality. With those, and also the much larger combat experience, and electrokinesis to boot, Garnet should get the win.

 

[Grudgeman1706]

Garnet for both reasons above^^^

 

[CrossverseCrisis]

So is the scenerio more of WB going "wanna fight" and Garnet just shrugging and going" sure, why not"? Cause that's how i picture both getting into a fight here. ^^;

Jking aside, Cal pretty much said it all. Whitebeard is stronger than Garnet but it isn't by a whole lot tho. They have abilities that can cancel each other out like Garnet's future vision countered by WB's precog haki. And they just about the same level of resistance towards a certain thing or two here (ex. heat). Garnet does have the speed advantage here but WB has a bit more in the durability level in that he's at least Large Island (meaning he could take a bit more hits than Garnet). Garnet has her electrokinesis ability to likely boost her offensive attacks, but WB can do the same with his haki but also like use it defensively (as what he did with his weapon that Akainu was not able to melt upon on).

Seems like a really close and even match up to me. Garnet has the regen, speed, and much larger combat experience, while Whitebeard has the (albeit) slight AP and likely Dura advantage here.

 

[Fllflourine]

Garnet, due to her vastly greater experience, regen, speed, immortality, and slight power advantage.

 

[CrossverseCrisis]

Actually FIl, Whitebeard's the one with the slight power advantage.

However i think that this can lead to Garnet's victory. She does have the regen ability whereas WB doesn't. WB is also slower in comparison to Garnet. Not to mention the Gem Fusion likely having a lot of combat experience. WB in comparison has a slight power and likely dura advantage and for him, he could be winning more just by hitting Garnet with a lot of his Quake powers. But given Garnet's slight advantages, i say she takes this but with some high diff.

It'll likely be a close match up still...

 

[Fllflourine]

By power I meant powers and abilities, tho

 

[CrossverseCrisis]

By power I meant powers and abilities, tho

Oh oh, okay~

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Boop, Garnet 5 Whitebeard 0

 

[Jinx666]

Yeah Garnet

Future Vision and Faster speed make her hard to hit as well as to dodge.

Even if she splits, she can immediately reform again

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Bump, Garnet 6, Whitebeard 0

 

[Der_Purple_Ist_Dank]

Poor Whitebeard, Garnet should take this due to faster speed and precog. I feel like this is kinda a stomp.

 

[Grudgeman1706]

So that settles it, garnet wins

 

[Battlemania]

I wouldn't consider it a stomp since, like cross said, he also has precog, stronger slightly, and more durable. Going with Garnet for reasons above

 

[WeeklyBattles]

Alright, since there are no objections i'll add this (Well, technically re-add it...)