- 671
- 739
- Thread starter
- #41
This will be edited as we go along
Scales To Weakened Morgoth (at least 4-A, possibly 3-B): Fingolfin (by feat), Feanor (author statement of being stronger than Fingolfin), Sauron (author statement of second age Sauron being greater than end of FIrst Age Morgoth, author statement of the strongest Maiar being well-nigh as great as the Valar), Thorondor (by feat. Strongest servant of Manwe), Luthien (by feat. Only via hax, probably not combat applicable). The Silmarils (by feat. Burned 4-A/3-B Morgoth). Melian (her dimensional Girdle eluded him and his generals, Sauron was implied to be unable to pierce it. She also counteracted the Sleep of Yavanna over Beleriand). Gothmog (killed Feanor, with help). All the Balrogs combined drove off Ungoliant.
Scales To Silmarils (at least 4-A): Carcharoth (literally held one in his stomach and absorbed its power). Huan (stomped Sauron and killed Silmaril Carcharoth). Feanor, obviously. He created them. Ancalagon (it took Silmaril-amped Earendil 24 hours to kill him, even with the assistance of Thorondor).
Scales to Sauron (at least 4-A, possibly 3-B): All members of the White Council. Galadriel destroyed Dol Guldur in The Hobbit timeframe, Gandalf the Grey drove off weakened Sauron before The Hobbit began, Gandalf the White stalemated Sauron during TTT, Saruman is superior to Gandalf the Grey, Elrond should be comparable to Galadriel). Glorfindel (killed a Balrog). Gil-Galad and Elendil (combined killed full power Sauron). Huan again (absolutely destroyed Sauron in the First Age). Balrogs scale to weakened Sauron.
Unknown: Glaurung (Gurthang could kill pretty much anything in the verse), the Ringwraiths (more inconsistent than Dragon Ball Super Goku).
Scales To Weakened Morgoth (at least 4-A, possibly 3-B): Fingolfin (by feat), Feanor (author statement of being stronger than Fingolfin), Sauron (author statement of second age Sauron being greater than end of FIrst Age Morgoth, author statement of the strongest Maiar being well-nigh as great as the Valar), Thorondor (by feat. Strongest servant of Manwe), Luthien (by feat. Only via hax, probably not combat applicable). The Silmarils (by feat. Burned 4-A/3-B Morgoth). Melian (her dimensional Girdle eluded him and his generals, Sauron was implied to be unable to pierce it. She also counteracted the Sleep of Yavanna over Beleriand). Gothmog (killed Feanor, with help). All the Balrogs combined drove off Ungoliant.
Scales To Silmarils (at least 4-A): Carcharoth (literally held one in his stomach and absorbed its power). Huan (stomped Sauron and killed Silmaril Carcharoth). Feanor, obviously. He created them. Ancalagon (it took Silmaril-amped Earendil 24 hours to kill him, even with the assistance of Thorondor).
Scales to Sauron (at least 4-A, possibly 3-B): All members of the White Council. Galadriel destroyed Dol Guldur in The Hobbit timeframe, Gandalf the Grey drove off weakened Sauron before The Hobbit began, Gandalf the White stalemated Sauron during TTT, Saruman is superior to Gandalf the Grey, Elrond should be comparable to Galadriel). Glorfindel (killed a Balrog). Gil-Galad and Elendil (combined killed full power Sauron). Huan again (absolutely destroyed Sauron in the First Age). Balrogs scale to weakened Sauron.
Unknown: Glaurung (Gurthang could kill pretty much anything in the verse), the Ringwraiths (more inconsistent than Dragon Ball Super Goku).