• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

DxD 2-A Cosmology Upgrade CRT

Status
Not open for further replies.
MasqueTLDF said:
I'm not sure if people can see it or not but did I not literally just provide evidence? Is there an error or something?
Click to expand...
It’s not that. I’m saying it’s an assumption to have the size of it when we are just throwing around ideas of how big it ish There are other instances in series that had the same idea of what’s going on here but were rejected
 
BlackeJan said:
It’s not that. I’m saying it’s an assumption to have the size of it when we are just throwing around ideas of how big it ish There are other instances in series that had the same idea of what’s going on here but were rejected
Click to expand...
It's literally just stated to be perfect recreations of stars in our galaxy, what more is there to prove?
 
MasqueTLDF said:
It's literally just stated to be perfect recreations of stars in our galaxy, what more is there to prove?
Click to expand...
…..my friend is has nothing to do with that stars. I’m talking about the size of the dimension for the rating game.

EDIT: i have shit memory but where was it said that they recreation of stars?

EDIT 2: ok nvm I found it….where in the world did u get that even the stars are the same as IRL? it only says earthly material locations/things….
 
BlackeJan said:
…..my friend is has nothing to do with that stars. I’m talking about the size of the dimension for the rating game.

EDIT: i have shit memory but where was it said that they recreation of stars?

EDIT 2: ok nvm I found it….where in the world did u get that even the stars are the same as IRL? it only says earthly material locations/things….
Click to expand...
They state that everything there is an exact replication of a real place.
We see stars in them, stars exist in the real world a well.
Having a starry sky is indicative of size.
And you still haven't shown any indication or justifiable reasoning as to why they aren't real.
 
MasqueTLDF said:
They state that everything there is an exact replication of a real place.
We see stars in them, stars exist in the real world a well.
Having a starry sky is indicative of size.
And you still haven't shown any indication or justifiable reasoning as to why they aren't real.
Click to expand...
No they only said the school was an exact replica. U have to prove that even the sky is a recreation itself, for all we know only the area they take them is the small area of the recreated space but everything around them is still irl….and again for the umpteenth time….im talking more towards the size of the dimension

EDIT: if the sky was actually created they would had said “everything” but they didn’t

EDIT 2: why in the world would they even recreate space if the battle is the ground???
 
BlackeJan said:
…..my friend is has nothing to do with that stars. I’m talking about the size of the dimension for the rating game.

EDIT: i have shit memory but where was it said that they recreation of stars?

EDIT 2: ok nvm I found it….where in the world did u get that even the stars are the same as IRL? it only says earthly material locations/things….
Click to expand...
OKAY SO LET's GO THROUGH THIS AGAIN

If I create a pocket dimension, and the pocket dimension has stars in it alongside various other things, then I have created the stars, because the stars did not COME with the pocket dimension already I CREATED THEM.

In order for a pocket dimension to CONTAIN stars like that, it needs to be AT LEAST 4-A in size.

If the text says everything created in the Rating Game world is like it's real life version, then one can assume that the stars, that showed up when the rating game was created are also real, and were created as well.

How many times must we do this
 
BlackeJan said:
No they only said the school was an exact replica. U have to prove that even the sky is a recreation itself, for all we know only the area they take them is the small area of the recreated space but everything around them is still irl….and again for the umpteenth time….im talking more towards the size of the dimension

EDIT: if the sky was actually created they would had said “everything” but they didn’t

EDIT 2: why in the world would they even recreate space if the battle is the ground???
Click to expand...
There are different fields created each time a rating game was held, the first example i showed didn't have any stars, the point was showing that objects created there are replicas of things in the human world, use common sense, if the ground is real, why wouldn't the sky be? As am I.

If you'd watched or read the series, you'd know that they didn't say everything because everything wasn't recreated.

Why wouldn't they? And it's not like battles are restricted to the ground, they can go to space, there's just no reason to because combat in a smaller area is more impressive to those watching.
 
CurrySenpai said:
OKAY SO LET's GO THROUGH THIS AGAIN

If I create a pocket dimension, and the pocket dimension has stars in it alongside various other things, then I have created the stars, because the stars did not COME with the pocket dimension already I CREATED THEM.

In order for a pocket dimension to CONTAIN stars like that, it needs to be AT LEAST 4-A in size.

If the text says everything created in the Rating Game world is like it's real life version, then one can assume that the stars, that showed up when the rating game was created are also real, and were created as well.

How many times must we do this
Click to expand...
Cool let it be known that there are a few series that literally went to the same thing (there’s a star in the dimension) that was created yet it was rejected because they don’t know the SIZE of it

I’ve already said this. We need proof to know how big it is cause again that dimension can just be as big as earth or as small as the battlefield needs to be
 
CurrySenpai said:
If the text says everything created in the Rating Game world is like it's real life version, then one can assume that the stars, that showed up when the rating game was created are also real, and were created as well.
Click to expand...
No it was said the school was created. If it was said that everything was created then Grayfia would had included it in what she said
 
BlackeJan said:
…..my friend is has nothing to do with that stars. I’m talking about the size of the dimension for the rating game.

EDIT: i have shit memory but where was it said that they recreation of stars?

EDIT 2: ok nvm I found it….where in the world did u get that even the stars are the same as IRL? it only says earthly material locations/things….
Click to expand...
If it wasn't an exact representation of the stars in our galaxies, then it wouldn't perfect to begin, wouldn't it?
 
U guys already know my stance. Grayfia said only the school and material was created she never said anything about space which also wouldn’t make sense why they would create that if the fight is on ground. Respectfully but like yall are taking what someone said and exaggeration it.

i agree on everything else except the rating game dimension
 
I misread this as DnD 2-A Cosmology upgrade and was unbelievably disappointed when I realized this is a cosmology upgrade for a booba anime and not a bump to Tier 1 for Dungeons and Dragons' 2-As
 
Vietthai96 said:
I said multiple times that you nees to prove those are actual stars bruhh, it is standard
Click to expand...
Can you point me to that standard? I never heard that before. We have to prove stars in the sky are real now?

They literally have a place for star-gazing and refer to the time it takes light to travel from stars to the world.

But like... Forget stars, there is even a scan that confirms Hell even runs on its own time. That's enough for me to say these are probably their own entire universes.

- - - -

For the blog, I can't lie it is pretty hard to go through. Some of these scans kinda suck/feel unnecessary. And the organization is pretty outdated.

I agree with the tiers of Hell and Heaven.

I don't think I agree with High 3-A Human Realm. I don't see anything about infinite size. The Touki doesn't seem to possess infinite volume.

2-A Dimensional Void doesn't really work since it's just a void between dimensions. As far as I know, it'd just be unquantifiable, even if it is infinite. Though it is possible you could scale people who affect the entire void to the amount of separate planes (space-times) it encompasses.

You also can't just assume it contains infinite-space times inside.

I would tier it as High 3-A (Due to boundless/infinite-sized timeless void), possibly 2-C (For containing all the planes mentioned in the blog)
 
Last edited:
Phoenks said:
For the blog, I can't lie it is pretty hard to go through. Some of these scans kinda suck/feel unnecessary. And the organization is pretty outdated.

I agree with the tiers of Hell and Heaven.

I don't think I agree with High 3-A Human Realm. I don't see anything about infinite size. The Touki doesn't seem to possess infinite volume.

2-A Dimensional Void doesn't really work since it's just a void between dimensions. As far as I know, it'd just be unquantifiable, even if it is infinite. Though it is possible you could scale people who affect the entire void to the amount of separate planes (space-times) it encompasses.

You also can't just assume it contains infinite-space times inside.
Click to expand...
Just wanted to cover everything, it was my second blog on the site, I apologize for its lack of depth.

Sure

If there is density, there is volume.

It isn't just a void between dimensions, it is what contains DxD. I proved qualitative superiority within the blog, and if it's infinite and possesses qualitative superiority to a 3D Realm, it would be Infinite on a 4D scale thus being 2-A.

I don't, I don't believe I've ever made that claim.
 
MasqueTLDF said:
If there is density, there is volume.
Click to expand...
Infinite density =/= infinite volume. There seems to be people who have infinite energy but that doesn't mean the Realm is infinite.

I don't mind saying that the Human Realm is its own space-time/universe though. I just don't think this is solid evidence for infinite size.

MasqueTLDF said:
It isn't just a void between dimensions, it is what contains DxD. I proved qualitative superiority within the blog, and if it's infinite and possesses qualitative superiority to a 3D Realm, it would be Infinite on a 4D scale thus being 2-A.
Click to expand...
The scans on the blog do not show any qualitative superiority.

It's pretty clear judging by how it is described this is just your typical void between dimensions, which is outside of time and space. It is described as being boundless nothingness that connects all the planes. It is also verifiably timeless since time stop doesn't work there.

By the way, I don't know where you got this idea, but being "infinite on a 4D scale" is not 2-A—by itself, that would only be Low 2-C. Space-time continuums themselves are already infinitely large 4D constructs. 2-A would be a structure that hosts an infinite amount of said constructs.

The most you can scale the Dimensional Gap to is the amount of space-times it is holding, hence why I suggested 2-C above.
 
Masque still seems to make sense, and besides we have 2 staff agreements, one being an admin and one being thread mod so we can apply this to the cosmology now.

Edit: Does great red even have a profile?
 
Phoenks said:
Infinite density =/= infinite volume. There seems to be people who have infinite energy but that doesn't mean the Realm is infinite.

I don't mind saying that the Human Realm is its own space-time/universe though. I just don't think this is solid evidence for infinite size.


The scans on the blog do not show any qualitative superiority.

It's pretty clear judging by how it is described this is just your typical void between dimensions, which is outside of time and space. It is described as being boundless nothingness that connects all the planes. It is also verifiably timeless since time stop doesn't work there.

By the way, I don't know where you got this idea, but being "infinite on a 4D scale" is not 2-A—by itself, that would only be Low 2-C. Space-time continuums themselves are already infinitely large 4D constructs. 2-A would be a structure that hosts an infinite amount of said constructs.

The most you can scale the Dimensional Gap to is the amount of space-times it is holding, hence why I suggested 2-C above.
Click to expand...
The density or volume wasn't the point, it's infinite mass which is a requirement for High 3-A

I wasn't making the claim that the human realm had infinite size, I made the claim that Earth contained infinite matter.

Check the Dimensional Gap section again

Contains the rest of DxD as I proved and it isn't timeless, just beyond the different space times. Not verifiably timeless,
"[After you defeated Shalba Beelzebub, you used up all your strength in the artificial dimension which was crumbling. After that, the artificial dimension collapsed completely. Great Red passed by coincidentally. Then, Ophis rode on Great Red while taking you with her. This is the Dimensional Gap. By the way, several days have passed since then.]

So, now it’s like this, huh. To meet Great Red by chance…I am really lucky. So, this is the Dimensional Gap. It’s a mysterious place…"

Finite 3D with the addition of a Temporal Dimension is Low 2-C. Very Different from an already 4D realm spatially that is then stated to be Infinite.

I disagree
 
CurrySenpai said:
Masque still seems to make sense, and besides we have 2 staff agreements, one being an admin and one being thread mod so we can apply this to the cosmology now.

Edit: Does great red even have a profile?
Click to expand...
Already applied, I'd just like the thread to be closed.

He does, profile revisions are currently in the works.

Edit: If anyone else replies, I likely wont see it for another 8-10 hours as I have work related things I need to do.
 
Shouldn't it also be important to mention there are infinite timeline statements and that the dimensonal gap surrounds the verse and is connected to those? That's pretty big.
 
MasqueTLDF said:
The density or volume wasn't the point, it's infinite mass which is a requirement for High 3-A
Click to expand...
I'm gonna drop this point since I don't think it matters in the grand scheme of things. I think the Human Realm is Low 2-C.


MasqueTLDF said:
Check the Dimensional Gap section again

Contains the rest of DxD as I proved and it isn't timeless, just beyond the different space times. Not verifiably timeless,
"[After you defeated Shalba Beelzebub, you used up all your strength in the artificial dimension which was crumbling. After that, the artificial dimension collapsed completely. Great Red passed by coincidentally. Then, Ophis rode on Great Red while taking you with her. This is the Dimensional Gap. By the way, several days have passed since then.]

So, now it’s like this, huh. To meet Great Red by chance…I am really lucky. So, this is the Dimensional Gap. It’s a mysterious place…"

Finite 3D with the addition of a Temporal Dimension is Low 2-C. Very Different from an already 4D realm spatially that is then stated to be Infinite.
Click to expand...
"Several days" can just be in reference to that person's perception of time.

Being "beyond" space-time doesn't necessarily mean it transcends space-time, especially when you pair it with the context that it is:
1. Between/Outside of dimensions (Space-times)
2. An infinite Void/Emptiness
3. Timeless

It makes more sense to me that this is just an infinite unquantifiable realm between/encompassing the dimensions in the multiverse.

So it would just scale to the amount of space-times it holds.

I would urge staff to recheck this.
 
Human Realm is just Earth the planet, having infinite touki, touki is just ki, energy doesn't mean Earth or Human Realm is infinite

Phoenks said:
But like... Forget stars, there is even a scan that confirms Hell even runs on its own time. That's enough for me to say these are probably their own entire universes.
Click to expand...
Even of we talking about literal stars, it is Multi-Solar at most??, having time doesn't mean it is an entire universe on it own, like, pocket space-time is a thing. Beside Ultima still not really change Low 2-C standard yet


CurrySenpai said:
Does great red even have a profile?
Click to expand...
There is a LN profile
CurrySenpai said:
infinite timeline statements
Click to expand...
???, i don't remember such a thing in novel, also infinite timeline isn't matter, cause timeline contain dimensional gap, mythology realms, Earth, etc.....so you can scale anything to it, no one ever affect these amount of timeline
 
Phoenks said:
"Several days" can just be in reference to that person's perception of time.

Being "beyond" space-time doesn't necessarily mean it transcends space-time, especially when you pair it with the context that it is:
1. Between/Outside of dimensions (Space-times)
2. An infinite Void/Emptiness
3. Timeless

It makes more sense to me that this is just an infinite unquantifiable realm between/encompassing the dimensions in the multiverse.

So it would just scale to the amount of space-times it holds.

I would urge staff to recheck this.
Click to expand...
The person who was in control of the Dimensional Gap for the longest known period of time, who is also the most knowledgeable of it making the statement begs to differ.

"Beyond" was just phrasing used so that I wouldn't have to copy and paste every single quote.
*Surrounds every world, a realm where time and space are irrelevant
*Correct/Empty in the same way Space is, the realms are still contained within it as well as the Land of Oz, the rating game arenas, Gogmagogs, etc
*Again, it isn't Timeless

Not unquantifiable

I disagree

Right after it gets accepted? You couldn't have proposed this argument during the weeks this CRT was active? Given this and your unfaithful arguments, I'd think you'd have some sort of bias. (If it isn't out of place for me to say this)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

MasqueTLDF
  • Locked
DxD Issei AP Revision 4
Replies
18
Views
2K
UchihaSlayer96
UchihaSlayer96
MasqueTLDF
  • Locked
DxD Cosmology 2.0
Replies
33
Views
3K
MasqueTLDF
MasqueTLDF
MasqueTLDF
  • Locked
(Staff Needed) DxD Cast Stat Revision 1
2 3 4
Replies
124
Views
7K
BlackeJan
BlackeJan
MasqueTLDF
  • Locked
DxD God Tiers
Replies
31
Views
3K
LephyrTheRevanchist
LephyrTheRevanchist
MasqueTLDF
  • Locked
DxD Issei AP Revision 1
Replies
7
Views
1K
MasqueTLDF
MasqueTLDF
Back
Top